Dynamic self-assembly of DNA minor groove-binding ligand DB921 into nanotubes triggered by an alkali halide.

We describe a novel self-assembling supramolecular nanotube system formed by a heterocyclic cationic molecule which was originally designed for its potential as an antiparasitic and DNA sequence recognition agent. Our structural characterisation work indicates that the nanotubes form via a hierarchical assembly mechanism that can be triggered and tuned by well-defined concentrations of simple alkali halide salts in water. The nanotubes assembled in NaCl have inner and outer diameters of ca. 22 nm and 26 nm respectively, with lengths that reach into several microns. Our results suggest the tubes consist of DB921 molecules stacked along the direction of the nanotube long axis. The tubes are stabilised by face-to-face π-π stacking and ionic interactions between the charged amidinium groups of the ligand and the negative halide ions. The assembly process of the nanotubes was followed using small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering, transmission electron microscopy and ultraviolet/visible spectroscopy. Our data demonstrate that assembly occurs through the formation of intermediate ribbon-like structures that in turn form helices that tighten and compact to form the final stable filament. This assembly process was tested using different alkali-metal salts, showing a strong preference for chloride or bromide anions and with little dependency on the type of cation. Our data further demonstrates the existence of a critical anion concentration above which the rate of self-assembly is greatly enhanced.

Synthesis and biological evaluation of hybrid acridine-HSP90 ligand conjugates as telomerase inhibitors.

The synthesis and biological evaluation of a series of bifunctional acridine-HSP90 inhibitor ligands as telomerase inhibitors is herein described. Four hybrid acridine-HSP90 inhibitor conjugates were prepared using a click-chemistry approach, and subsequently shown to display comparable results to the established telomerase inhibitor BRACO-19 in the TRAP-LIG telomerase assay. The conjugates also demonstrated significant cyctotoxity against a number of cancer cell lines, in the sub-µM range.

Developing and paying for medicines for orphan indications in oncology: utilitarian regulation vs equitable care?

Despite 'orphan drug' legislation, bringing new medicines for rare diseases to market and securing funding for their provision is sometimes both costly and problematic, even in the case of medicines for very rare 'ultra orphan' oncological indications. In this paper difficulties surrounding the introduction of a new treatment for osteosarcoma exemplify the challenges that innovators can face. The implications of current policy debate on 'value-based' medicines pricing in Europe, North America and elsewhere are also explored in the context of sustaining research into and facilitating cancer patient access to medicines for low-prevalence indications. Tensions exist between utilitarian strategies aimed at optimising the welfare of the majority in the society and minority-interest-focused approaches to equitable care provision. Current regulatory and pricing strategies should be revisited with the objective of facilitating fair and timely drug supply to patients without sacrificing safety or overall affordability. Failures effectively to tackle the problems considered here could undermine public interests in developing better therapies for cancer patients.

Mechanistic and anti-proliferative studies of two novel, biologically active bis-benzimidazoles.

We have previously synthesised a number of novel head-to-head bis-benzimidazole derivatives that are structurally related to the fluorochrome, Hoechst 33258, and which possess strong affinity for A:T sites in the minor groove of duplex DNA. Initial studies revealed these compounds to exhibit potent antiproliferative activity against a range of ovarian cell lines and to inhibit transcription in an in vitro setting. In this study, we have examined their cellular behaviour in detail and have shown that two of these compounds (ABA13 and ABA833) potently inhibit the proliferation of a range of human tumour cell lines, and show some specificity towards breast carcinoma cell lines. In most of the cell lines investigated, ABA833 was the more potent of the two compounds. Flow cytometric analysis revealed that ABA13 and ABA833 (50-500 nM) induced an S phase block and increased the pre-G1 population in MCF-7 and MDA 468 human breast cancer cells. An increase in the pre-G1 population of RKO colon carcinoma cells was seen only at 500 nM with ABA833, reflecting the reduced sensitivity of this cell line to the bis-benzimidazoles in comparison to the breast cancer cell lines. Mechanistic studies revealed that neither ABA13 or ABA833 act as topoisomerase I (topo I) or topoisomerase II (topo II) poisons in plasmid or kinetoplast DNA (kDNA) relaxation assays, but both compounds do inhibit the catalytic activity of these enzymes. Drug uptake studies showed that reduced sensitivity of MCF-7adr and RKO cells compared with MCF-7 to both ABA13 and ABA833 correlated with a markedly reduced intracellular drug accumulation.

Inhibition of the Bloom's and Werner's syndrome helicases by G-quadruplex interacting ligands.

G-Quadruplex DNAs are folded, non-Watson-Crick structures that can form within guanine-rich DNA sequences such as telomeric repeats. Previous studies have identified a series of trisubstituted acridine derivatives that are potent and selective ligands for G-quadruplex DNA. These ligands have been shown previously to inhibit the activity of telomerase, the specialized reverse transcriptase that regulates telomere length. The RecQ family of DNA helicases, which includes the Bloom's (BLM) and Werner's (WRN) syndrome gene products, are apparently unique among cellular helicases in their ability to efficiently disrupt G-quadruplex DNA. This property may be relevant to telomere maintenance, since it is known that the sole budding yeast RecQ helicase, Sgs1p, is required for a telomerase-independent telomere lengthening pathway reminiscent of the "ALT" pathway in human cells. Here, we show that trisubstituted acridine ligands are potent inhibitors of the helicase activity of the BLM and WRN proteins on both G-quadruplex and B-form DNA substrates. Inhibition of helicase activity is associated with both a reduction in the level of binding of the helicase to G-quadruplex DNA and a reduction in the degree to which the G-quadruplex DNA can support DNA-dependent ATPase activity. We discuss these results in the context of the possible utility of trisubstituted acridines as antitumor agents for the disruption of both telomerase-dependent and telomerase-independent telomere maintenance.

Stabilisation of TG- and AG-containing antiparallel DNA triplexes by triplex-binding ligands.

We have used DNase I footprinting to examine the interaction of several triplex-binding ligands with antiparallel TG- and AG-containing triplexes. We find that although a 17mer TG-containing oligonucleotide on its own fails to produce a footprint at concentrations as high as 30 microM, this interaction can be stabilised by several ligands. Within a series of disubstituted amidoanthraquinones we find that the 2,7- regioisomer affords the best stabilisation of this TG triplex, though the 1,8- isomer also stabilises this interaction to some extent. By contrast the 1,5- and 2,6- regioisomers show no interaction with TG triplexes. Similar studies with a 13mer AG-containing oligonucleotide show the opposite pattern of stabilisation: the 2,6- and 1,5- isomers stabilise this triplex, but the 2,7- and 1,8-compounds do not. The polycyclic compound BePI strongly stabilises TG- but not AG-containing triplexes, while a substituted naphthylquinoline interacts with both antiparallel triplex motifs.

Structure-based design of selective and potent G quadruplex-mediated telomerase inhibitors.

The telomerase enzyme is a potential therapeutic target in many human cancers. A series of potent inhibitors has been designed by computer modeling, which exploit the unique structural features of quadruplex DNA. These 3,6,9-trisubstituted acridine inhibitors are predicted to interact selectively with the human DNA quadruplex structure, as a means of specifically inhibiting the action of human telomerase in extending the length of single-stranded telomeric DNA. The anilino substituent at the 9-position of the acridine chromophore is predicted to lie in a third groove of the quadruplex. Calculated relative binding energies predict enhanced selectivity compared with earlier 3,6-disubstituted compounds, as a result of this substituent. The ranking order of energies is in accord with equilibrium binding constants for quadruplex measured by surface plasmon resonance techniques, which also show reduced duplex binding compared with the disubstituted compounds. The 3,6,9-trisubstututed acridines have potent in vitro inhibitory activity against human telomerase, with EC(50) values of up to 60 nM.

A new class of symmetric bisbenzimidazole-based DNA minor groove-binding agents showing antitumor activity.

The synthesis and evaluation of the novel head-to-head bisbenzimidazole compound 2,2-bis[4'-(3' '-dimethylamino-1' '-propyloxy)phenyl]-5,5-bi-1H-benzimidazole is described. An X-ray crystallographic study of a complex with the DNA dodecanucleotide sequence d(CGCGAATTCGCG) shows the compound bound in the A/T minor groove region of a B-DNA duplex and that the head-to-head bisbenzimidazole motif hydrogen-bonds to the edges of all four consecutive A:T base pairs. The compound showed potent growth inhibition with a mean IC(50) across an ovarian carcinoma cell line panel of 0.31 microM, with no significant cross-resistance in two acquired cisplatin-resistant cell lines and a low level of cross-resistance in the P-glycoprotein overexpressing acquired doxorubicin-resistant cell line. Studies with the hollow fiber assay and in vivo tumor xenografts showed some evidence of antitumor activity.

DNA minor groove interactions and the biological activity of 2,5-bis.

2,5-Bis-[4-(N-cyclobutyl-amidino)phenyl] furan and 2,5-bis-[4-(N-cyclohexyl-amidino)phenyl] furan have activity against Pneumocystis carinii and also show cytotoxicity against several tumour cell lines. These activities are correlated with DNA-binding abilities; the crystal structures of complexes with the DNA sequence d(CGCGAATTCGCG) is reported here. Interactions with, and effects on, the DNA minor groove, are found to be factors in the biological properties of these compounds.

Structural characterization of a guanine-quadruplex ligand complex.

The inhibition of telomerase by molecules such as disubstituted amidoanthraquinones is believed to be due to their stabilization of guanine-quadruplex complexes. The characterization is reported of a complex with the intermolecular parallel quadruplex formed from the sequence TGGGGT and a 1,4-bis-piperidino amidoanthraquinone. Crystals obtained did not give single-crystal diffraction; the fiber-like pattern has been interpreted in terms of a repeating unit with four guanine-quartets and two stacked/intercalated ligand molecules. The two categories of possible structures for the complex consistent with this interpretation have been examined by molecular dynamics simulations, with fully solvated environments and 1000 ps simulation times. The two central guanine-quartets in the intercalation model rapidly became highly distorted, whereas the two types of models with ligand stacked externally on the ends of the quadruplex remained very stable. It was concluded that the externally bound ligand complexes best represent the structure of this quadruplex complex, in agreement with earlier NMR results on related systems.

Crystal structure of FMN-dependent nitroreductase from Escherichia coli B: a prodrug-activating enzyme.

The FMN-dependent flavoprotein nitroreductase from Escherichia coli B (NTR) is used in cancer chemotherapy to activate a range of prodrugs. The crystal structure of this enzyme has been determined, using molecular replacement methods and refined at 2.06 A resolution. The recombinant 24-kDa enzyme was crystallized in the tetragonal space group P4(1)2(1)2, with unit cell dimensions of a = b = 57.74 A and c = 275.51 A and two molecules in the asymmetric unit. The structure has a final R factor of 20.3% (R(free) = 26.7%), for all data between the resolution ranges of 10-2.06 A, and includes 4453 protein atoms, 230 water molecules, and 2 flavin mononucleotide (FMN) molecules. The functional unit is a homodimer, which forms the asymmetric unit in the crystal structure. The tertiary structures of these two monomers and their subunit interactions are nearly identical. The molecular replacement search model, the crystal structure of the major NAD(P)H:FMN oxidoreductase of Vibrio fisheri (FRase 1), was selected on the basis of its high sequence identity to that of NTR. The final superposition of these two enzymes revealed a very similar overall fold, with variation in the structures focused around surface loops and helices near the FMN cofactor. Helix G is implicated in substrate specificity and is better resolved in the present NTR structure than in the previously reported FRase 1 structure. The FMN binding pocket is also well-resolved, showing the presence of two channels leading into the active site. The amino acid side chains and main chain atoms interacting with the FMN are well-ordered. The structure of the substrate binding pocket has been used to examine substrate specificity and enzyme kinetics for prodrugs used in antibody-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (ADEPT) and gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (GDEPT).

Stability of DNA triplexes on shuttle vector plasmids in the replication pool in mammalian cells.

Triple helix-forming oligonucleotides may be useful as gene-targeting reagents in vivo, for applications such as gene knockout. One important property of these complexes is their often remarkable stability, as demonstrated in solution and in cells following transfection. Although encouraging, these measurements do not necessarily report triplex stability in cellular compartments that support DNA functions such as replication and mutagenesis. We have devised a shuttle vector plasmid assay that reports the stability of triplexes on DNA that undergoes replication and mutagenesis. The assay is based on plasmids with novel variant supF tRNA genes containing embedded sequences for triplex formation and psoralen cross-linking. Triple helix-forming oligonucleotides were linked to psoralen and used to form triplexes on the plasmids. At various times after introduction into cells, the psoralen was activated by exposure to long wave ultraviolet light (UVA). After time for replication and mutagenesis, progeny plasmids were recovered and the frequency of plasmids with mutations in the supF gene determined. Site-specific mutagenesis by psoralen cross-links was dependent on precise placement of the psoralen by the triple helix-forming oligonucleotide at the time of UVA treatment. The results indicated that both pyrimidine and purine motif triplexes were much less stable on replicated DNA than on DNA in vitro or in total transfected DNA. Incubation of cells with amidoanthraquinone-based triplex stabilizing compounds enhanced the stability of the pyrimidine triplex.

A novel inhibitor of human telomerase derived from 10H-indolo[3,2-b]quinoline.

The bis-dimethylaminoethyl derivative of quindoline (10H-indolo[3,2-b]quinoline), an alkaloid from the West African shrub Cryptolepis sanguinolenta, has been synthesised. This has been shown to have modest cytotoxicity, as well as inhibitory activity against the telomerase enzyme. It is hypothesised that the latter activity is due to stabilisation of an intermediate guanine-quadruplex complex, in accordance with computer modelling.

A DNA-porphyrin minor-groove complex at atomic resolution: the structural consequences of porphyrin ruffling.

The crystal structure of a B-type DNA hexanucleotide duplex complexed with the porphyrin molecule nickel-[tetra-N-methyl-pyridyl] porphyrin has been solved by multiwavelength anomalous diffraction phasing and refined to an R factor of 11.5% at a resolution of 0.9 A. The structure has been solved and refined as two crystallographically independent duplexes, stacked end to end. Contrary to expectation, the porphyrin molecule is not intercalated into the duplex but is stacked onto the ends of the two-duplex stack. The porphyrin molecule is highly buckled as a consequence of the nickel coordination, which produces large changes in local DNA structure. A second mode of porphyrin binding is apparent as a consequence of crystal packing, which places the ligand in the minor groove of an adjacent duplex. This structure thus provides, to our knowledge, the first atomic visualization of minor-groove binding for a porphyrin molecule. The geometry of groove binding provides a ready explanation for porphyrin-induced DNA strand cleavage at deoxyribose residues.

A new crystal form for the dodecamer C-G-C-G-A-A-T-T-C-G-C-G: symmetry effects on sequence-dependent DNA structure.

The dodecanucleotide d(CGCGAATTCGCG) has been crystallised in the space group P3(2)12, representing a new crystal form for this sequence. The structure has been solved by molecular replacement and refined at 1.8 A resolution. The present structure contrasts with previous ones for this sequence since it is situated on a crystallographic 2-fold axis, and the crystal symmetry reflects the palindromic nature of this sequence. Some features accord with previous observations, notably that the minor groove is hydrated with a continuous spine of solvent. There is no evidence of alkali metal ions within this spine. The minor groove retains its narrow width, although it is now symmetric and extends over the A/T tract. Various base and base-pair morphological parameters have been examined. Their values do not show significant correlations with earlier reports, suggesting that crystal packing effects on them are more dominant than has been hitherto realised.

A thermodynamic and structural analysis of DNA minor-groove complex formation.

As part of an effort to develop a better understanding of the structural and thermodynamic principles of DNA minor groove recognition, we have investigated complexes of three diphenylfuran dications with the d(CGCGAATTCGCG)(2) duplex. The parent compound, furamidine (DB75), has two amidine substituents while DB244 has cyclopentyl amidine substituents and DB226 has 3-pentyl amidines. The structure for the DB244-DNA complex is reported here and is compared to the structure of the DB75 complex. Crystals were not obtained with DB226 but information from the DB75 and DB244 structures as well as previous NMR results on DB226 indicate that all three compounds bind in the minor groove at the AATT site of the duplex. DB244 and DB75 penetrate to the floor of the groove and form hydrogen bonds with T8 on one strand and T20 on the opposite strand while DB226 forms a complex with fewer interactions. Binding studies by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) yield -delta G degrees values in the order DB244>DB75>DB226 that are relatively constant with temperature. The equilibrium binding constants for DB244 are 10-20 times greater than that for DB226. Isothermal titration calorimetric (ITC) experiments indicate that, in contrast to delta G degrees, delta H degrees varies considerably with temperature to yield large negative delta Cp degrees values. The thermodynamic results, analyzed in terms of structures of the DNA complexes, provide an explanation of why DB244 binds more strongly to DNA than DB75, while DB266 binds more weakly. All three compounds have a major contribution to binding from hydrophobic interactions but the hydrophobic term is most favorable for DB244. DB244 also has strong contributions from molecular interactions in its DNA complex and all of these factors combine to give it the largest-delta G degrees for binding. Although the factors that influence the energetics of minor groove interactions are varied and complex, results from the literature coupled with those on the furan derivatives indicate that there are some common characteristics for minor groove recognition by unfused heterocyclic cations that can be used in molecular design.

Structure-activity relationships among guanine-quadruplex telomerase inhibitors.

The ribonucleoprotein telomerase is responsible for maintaining the length of telomeric ends of chromosomes in tumour cells. It is activated in over 85% of the tumour cells, and is emerging as a major target for cancer chemotherapy. A range of molecules containing tricyclic and tetracyclic aromatic chromophores has been shown to inhibit the telomerase enzyme system at the micromolar level. There is evidence that they do so via stabilisation of a guanine-quadruplex structure, which provides a stop signal for further telomere elongation. The known structure-activity relationships for these compounds are summarised, and pointers for the development of future molecules with enhanced selectivity are described.

G-quadruplexes as therapeutic targets.

The ends of chromosomes (telomeres) consist of tandem repeats of guanine-rich sequences. In eukaryotics, telomeric DNA is single stranded for the final few hundred bases. These single-stranded sequences can fold into a variety of four-stranded structures (quadruplexes) held together by quartets of hydrogen-bonded guanine bases. The reverse transcriptase enzyme telomerase is responsible for maintaining telomeric DNA length in over 85% of cancer cells by catalyzing the synthesis of further telomeric repeats. Its substrate is the single-stranded 3'-telomeric end. Inhibition of telomere maintenance can be achieved by stabilization of a quadruplex structure for the telomere end. A variety of small molecules have been devised to achieve this, ranging from anthraquinones to porphyrins, acridines, and complex polycyclic systems. Structural and mechanistic aspects of these quadruplex complexes are reviewed here, together with a discussion of the issues of selectivity/potency for quadruplex DNAs vs duplex DNA.