Defining carbohydrate antigens as HIV vaccine candidates.

The induction of high affinity antibodies capable of broad neutralization and protection against infection and/or disease is a major goal in the development of a vaccine for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Insights into the structure and function of the envelope (Env) protein of HIV-1 suggest that the virus is under strong selection pressure by the immune response leading to constant mutations in the Env protein including the N-glycosylation sites. Initially considered a shield against the immune system, the heavily glycosylated outer surface of the HIV Env protein has drawn attention lately as a legitimate target. The dense cluster of high mannose glycans and the great variety of complex glycans present epitopes that might impact on disease progression. Indeed a number of mannose binding proteins and at least one human anti-mannose antibody--2G12, are broadly neutralizing. Due to the low immunogenicity of carbohydrates, these targets on HIV are of limited value unless new powerful immunogens are found. One approach would be the molecular design of peptide carbohydrate mimotopes that can elicit neutralizing antibodies by recruiting optimal T cell help. Here we review existing data on carbohydrate interactions and HIV immunogenicity that serves as a basis for structural concepts and approaches used for vaccine design targeting HIV associated carbohydrate antigens. In particular, the value and the limitations of chemical (peptide libraries), structural and immunological information is illustrated.

Carbohydrate mimotopes in the rational design of cancer vaccines.

The task of rationally designing vaccines that can effectively impact on the survival of cancer patients remains challenging. Monoclonal antibodies and T cell receptors have proven to be viable templates for the application of pharmacophore design principles to develop antigens and immunogens as these immune system molecules recognize a variety of sequentially and structurally unrelated ligands. This structural information combined with immunological assessment has contributed to the development of strategies to elicit effective humoral and cellular responses to cancer cells. Understanding the structural requirements for antibody and T cell recognition provides a basis for identifying potentially new sets of immunogens that may have both fundamental immunological and clinical value. Here we review the structural concepts and approaches used in vaccine design applications that illustrate the value and limitations of using chemical (peptide libraries) and immunological information to define novel peptide immunogens that function as mimotopes to generate immune responses targeting tumor associated carbohydrate antigens.

Antigenic properties of peptide mimotopes of HIV-1-associated carbohydrate antigens.

The glycan shield of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) envelope protein presents many potential epitopes for vaccine development. To augment immune responses to HIV, type 1 (HIV-1), envelope-associated carbohydrate antigens, we are defining peptide mimics of HIV-associated carbohydrate antigens that function as antigen mimotopes that upon immunization will induce antibodies cross-reactive with carbohydrate antigens. We have previously defined peptides with a putative sequence tract RYRY that mimic concanavalin A-binding glycans. To imitate the multivalent binding of carbohydrates, we compared the avidity of a linear (911) and cyclic peptide (D002) reactive with concanavalin A presented in a multiple antigen peptide (MAP) format. The affinity of the MAP-D002 peptide was higher than that of the peptide MAP-911, whereas the avidity of D002 peptide was lower than that of 911. Serum from mice immunized with MAP-911 had lower titer for oligomannose-9 than those elicited by MAP-D002 under the same conditions, but both immunogens elicited antibodies that can block the binding of GP120 to dendritic cells. Antibodies that bind to the studied MAPs were found in a preparation of normal human immunoglobulin for intravenous use. Those that were purified on 911 bound back to 911 and D002, whereas anti-D002 antibodies were specific only for D002. Human antibodies reactive with both mimotopes and with a mannosyl preparation were observed to bind to envelope protein. These results suggested the potential to fine-tune the antibody response to carbohydrate antigens by modifying structural features of peptide mimotope-based immunogens.

Concanavalin A binding to HIV envelope protein is less sensitive to mutations in glycosylation sites than monoclonal antibody 2G12.

Many mannose-binding proteins inhibit divergent strains of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) in in vitro models of viral infectivity, suggesting that targeting mannose residues in vaccine applications might offset the strain restriction typically observed in antibody responses to HIV vaccine preparations. Concanavalin A (ConA) behaves like neutralizing antibodies that do not interfere with CD4 binding of gp120 but rather with later events in virus entry. The design of mannose-based vaccines, therefore, depends on understanding the mode of binding of ConA to the envelope protein in comparison with other mannose-binding proteins. Here, we further compare the binding affinity and fine specificity of ConA for the envelope protein to that of the human antibody 2G12. The 2G12 antibody is of unusual structure recognizing a cluster of 12 linked mannose residues associated with Man9GlcNAc2. Molecular structure comparison for Man9GlcNAc2 recognition by ConA and 2G12 indicates that 2G12 has a more restricted specificity to high mannose glycans of gp120 which correlates with kinetic analysis assessed by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and ConA inhibits 2G12 binding to gp120 but 2G12 does not inhibit ConA binding to gp120. ConA binding to Env proteins from four different HIV strains proves significantly less sensitive to mutations in the glycosylation sites than 2G12 binding to the proteins. Thus, antibodies directed toward mannose epitopes reactive with ConA may prove to be more effective in the long run to thwart HIV infection and transmission.