The European Federation for Medicinal Chemistry and Chemical Biology (EFMC) Best Practice Initiative: Hit Generation.

Hit generation is a crucial step in drug discovery that will determine the speed and chance of success of identifying drug candidates. Many strategies are now available to identify chemical starting points, or hits, and each biological target warrants a tailored approach. In this set of best practices, we detail the essential approaches for target centric hit generation and the opportunities and challenges they come with. We then provide guidance on how to validate hits to ensure medicinal chemistry is only performed on compounds and scaffolds that engage the target of interest and have the desired mode of action. Finally, we discuss the design of integrated hit generation strategies that combine several approaches to maximize the chance of identifying high quality starting points to ensure a successful drug discovery campaign.

The European Federation for Medicinal Chemistry and Chemical Biology (EFMC) Best Practice Initiative: Phenotypic Drug Discovery.

Phenotypic drug discovery has a long track record of delivering innovative drugs and has received renewed attention in the last few years. The promise of this approach, however, comes with several challenges that should be addressed to avoid wasting time and resources on drugs with undesired modes of action or, worse, false-positive hits. In this set of best practices, we go over the essential steps of phenotypic drug discovery and provide guidance on how to increase the chance of success in identifying validated and relevant chemical starting points for optimization: selecting the right assay, selecting the right compound screening library and developing appropriate hit validation assays. Then, we highlight the importance of initiating studies to determine the mode of action of the identified hits early and present the current state of the art.

Optimization of the In Vivo Potency of Pyrazolopyrimidine MALT1 Protease Inhibitors by Reducing Metabolism and Increasing Potency in Whole Blood.

The paracaspase MALT1 has gained increasing interest as a target for the treatment of subsets of lymphomas as well as autoimmune diseases, and there is a need for suitable compounds to explore the therapeutic potential of this target. Here, we report the optimization of the in vivo potency of pyrazolopyrimidines, a class of highly selective allosteric MALT1 inhibitors. High doses of the initial lead compound led to tumor stasis in an activated B-cell-like (ABC) diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) xenograft model, but this compound suffered from a short in vivo half-life and suboptimal potency in whole blood. Guided by metabolism studies, we identified compounds with reduced metabolic clearance and increased in vivo half-life. In the second optimization step, masking one of the hydrogen-bond donors of the central urea moiety through an intramolecular interaction led to improved potency in whole blood. This was associated with improved in vivo potency in a mechanistic model of B cell activation. The optimized compound led to tumor regression in a CARD11 mutant ABC-DLBCL lymphoma xenograft model.

Discovery of Potent, Highly Selective, and In Vivo Efficacious, Allosteric MALT1 Inhibitors by Iterative Scaffold Morphing.

MALT1 plays a central role in immune cell activation by transducing NF-κB signaling, and its proteolytic activity represents a key node for therapeutic intervention. Two cycles of scaffold morphing of a high-throughput biochemical screening hit resulted in the discovery of MLT-231, which enabled the successful pharmacological validation of MALT1 allosteric inhibition in preclinical models of humoral immune responses and B-cell lymphomas. Herein, we report the structural activity relationships (SARs) and analysis of the physicochemical properties of a pyrazolopyrimidine-derived compound series. In human T-cells and B-cell lymphoma lines, MLT-231 potently and selectively inhibits the proteolytic activity of MALT1 in NF-κB-dependent assays. Both in vitro and in vivo profiling of MLT-231 support further optimization of this in vivo tool compound toward preclinical characterization.

The European Federation for Medicinal Chemistry (EFMC) Best Practice Initiative: Validating Chemical Probes.

As part of an initiative aimed to share best practices in Medicinal Chemistry, the European Federation for Medicinal Chemistry (EFMC) is preparing a series of webinars and slide sets focused on the early phase of drug discovery. This educational material is freely accessible through the EFMC. The main target audiences are students or early career scientists and we also believe it will be valuable for experienced practitioners. The first of the series is focused on the generation and validation of high-quality chemical probes, which are critical for drug discovery and more broadly to further our understanding of human biology and disease.

Pharmacological Inhibition of MALT1 Protease Leads to a Progressive IPEX-Like Pathology.

Genetic disruption or short-term pharmacological inhibition of MALT1 protease is effective in several preclinical models of autoimmunity and B cell malignancies. Despite these protective effects, the severe reduction in regulatory T cells (Tregs) and the associated IPEX-like pathology occurring upon congenital disruption of the MALT1 protease in mice has raised concerns about the long-term safety of MALT1 inhibition. Here we describe the results of a series of toxicology studies in rat and dog species using MLT-943, a novel potent and selective MALT1 protease inhibitor. While MLT-943 effectively prevented T cell-dependent B cell immune responses and reduced joint inflammation in the collagen-induced arthritis rat pharmacology model, in both preclinical species, pharmacological inhibition of MALT1 was associated with a rapid and dose-dependent reduction in Tregs and resulted in the progressive appearance of immune abnormalities and clinical signs of an IPEX-like pathology. At the 13-week time point, rats displayed severe intestinal inflammation associated with mast cell activation, high serum IgE levels, systemic T cell activation and mononuclear cell infiltration in multiple tissues. Importantly, using thymectomized rats we demonstrated that MALT1 protease inhibition affects peripheral Treg frequency independently of effects on thymic Treg output and development. Our data confirm the therapeutic potential of MALT1 protease inhibitors but highlight the safety risks and challenges to consider before potential application of such inhibitors into the clinic.

Requirement of Mucosa-Associated Lymphoid Tissue Lymphoma Translocation Protein 1 Protease Activity for Fcγ Receptor-Induced Arthritis, but Not Fcγ Receptor-Mediated Platelet Elimination, in Mice.

OBJECTIVE: Fcγ receptors (FcγR) play important roles in both protective and pathogenic immune responses. The assembly of the CBM signalosome encompassing caspase recruitment domain-containing protein 9, B cell CLL/lymphoma 10, and mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphoma translocation protein 1 (MALT-1) is required for optimal FcγR-induced canonical NF-κB activation and proinflammatory cytokine release. This study was undertaken to clarify the relevance of MALT-1 protease activity in FcγR-driven events and evaluate the therapeutic potential of selective MALT-1 protease inhibitors in FcγR-mediated diseases. METHODS: Using genetic and pharmacologic disruption of MALT-1 scaffolding and enzymatic activity, we assessed the relevance of MALT-1 function in murine and human primary myeloid cells upon stimulation with immune complexes (ICs) and in murine models of autoantibody-driven arthritis and immune thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP). RESULTS: MALT-1 protease function is essential for optimal FcγR-induced production of proinflammatory cytokines by various murine and human myeloid cells stimulated with ICs. In contrast, MALT-1 protease inhibition did not affect the Syk-dependent, FcγR-mediated production of reactive oxygen species or leukotriene B4 . Notably, pharmacologic MALT-1 protease inhibition in vivo reduced joint inflammation in the murine K/BxN serum-induced arthritis model (mean area under the curve for paw swelling of 45.42% versus 100% in control mice; P = 0.0007) but did not affect platelet depletion in a passive model of ITP. CONCLUSION: Our findings indicate a specific contribution of MALT-1 protease activity to FcγR-mediated events and suggest that MALT-1 protease inhibitors have therapeutic potential in a subset of FcγR-driven inflammatory disorders.

An allosteric MALT1 inhibitor is a molecular corrector rescuing function in an immunodeficient patient.

MALT1 paracaspase is central for lymphocyte antigen-dependent responses including NF-κB activation. We discovered nanomolar, selective allosteric inhibitors of MALT1 that bind by displacing the side chain of Trp580, locking the protease in an inactive conformation. Interestingly, we had previously identified a patient homozygous for a MALT1 Trp580-to-serine mutation who suffered from combined immunodeficiency. We show that the loss of tryptophan weakened interactions between the paracaspase and C-terminal immunoglobulin MALT1 domains resulting in protein instability, reduced protein levels and functions. Upon binding of allosteric inhibitors of increasing potency, we found proportionate increased stabilization of MALT1-W580S to reach that of wild-type MALT1. With restored levels of stable MALT1 protein, the most potent of the allosteric inhibitors rescued NF-κB and JNK signaling in patient lymphocytes. Following compound washout, MALT1 substrate cleavage was partly recovered. Thus, a molecular corrector rescues an enzyme deficiency by substituting for the mutated residue, inspiring new potential precision therapies to increase mutant enzyme activity in other deficiencies.

N-aryl-piperidine-4-carboxamides as a novel class of potent inhibitors of MALT1 proteolytic activity.

Starting from a weak screening hit, potent and selective inhibitors of the MALT1 protease function were elaborated. Advanced compounds displayed high potency in biochemical and cellular assays. Compounds showed activity in a mechanistic Jurkat T cell activation assay as well as in the B-cell lymphoma line OCI-Ly3, which suggests potential use of MALT1 inhibitors in the treatment of autoimmune diseases as well as B-cell lymphomas with a dysregulated NF-κB pathway. Initially, rat pharmacokinetic properties of this compound series were dominated by very high clearance which could be linked to amide cleavage. Using a rat hepatocyte assay a good in vitro-in vivo correlation could be established which led to the identification of compounds with improved PK properties.

The T-cell fingerprint of MALT1 paracaspase revealed by selective inhibition.

Mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphoma translocation protein 1 (MALT1) is essential for immune responses triggered by antigen receptors but the contribution of its paracaspase activity is not fully understood. Here, we studied how MALT1 proteolytic function regulates T-cell activation and fate after engagement of the T-cell receptor pathway. We show that MLT-827, a potent and selective MALT1 paracaspase inhibitor, does not prevent the initial phase of T-cell activation, in contrast to the pan-protein kinase C inhibitor AEB071. However, MLT-827 strongly impacted cell expansion after activation. We demonstrate this is the consequence of profound inhibition of IL-2 production as well as reduced expression of the IL-2 receptor alpha subunit (CD25), resulting from defective canonical NF-κB activation and accelerated mRNA turnover mechanisms. Accordingly, MLT-827 revealed a unique transcriptional fingerprint of MALT1 protease activity, providing evidence for broad control of T-cell signaling pathways. Altogether, this first report with a potent and selective inhibitor elucidates how MALT1 paracaspase activity integrates several T-cell activation pathways and indirectly controls gamma-chain receptor dependent survival, to impact on T-cell expansion.

Azaindoles as Zinc-Binding Small-Molecule Inhibitors of the JAMM Protease CSN5.

CSN5 is the zinc metalloprotease subunit of the COP9 signalosome (CSN), which is an important regulator of cullin-RING E3 ubiquitin ligases (CRLs). CSN5 is responsible for the cleavage of NEDD8 from CRLs, and blocking deconjugation of NEDD8 traps the CRLs in a hyperactive state, thereby leading to auto-ubiquitination and ultimately degradation of the substrate recognition subunits. Herein, we describe the discovery of azaindoles as a new class of CSN5 inhibitors, which interact with the active-site zinc ion of CSN5 through an unprecedented binding mode. The best compounds inhibited CSN5 with nanomolar potency, led to degradation of the substrate recognition subunit Skp2 in cells, and reduced the viability of HCT116 cells.

Pathophysiological Consequences of a Break in S1P1-Dependent Homeostasis of Vascular Permeability Revealed by S1P1 Competitive Antagonism.

RATIONAL: Homeostasis of vascular barriers depends upon sphingosine 1-phosphate (S1P) signaling via the S1P1 receptor. Accordingly, S1P1 competitive antagonism is known to reduce vascular barrier integrity with still unclear pathophysiological consequences. This was explored in the present study using NIBR-0213, a potent and selective S1P1 competitive antagonist. RESULTS: NIBR-0213 was tolerated at the efficacious oral dose of 30 mg/kg BID in the rat adjuvant-induced arthritis (AiA) model, with no sign of labored breathing. However, it induced dose-dependent acute vascular pulmonary leakage and pleural effusion that fully resolved within 3-4 days, as evidenced by MRI monitoring. At the supra-maximal oral dose of 300 mg/kg QD, NIBR-0213 impaired lung function (with increased breathing rate and reduced tidal volume) within the first 24 hrs. Two weeks of NIBR-0213 oral dosing at 30, 100 and 300 mg/kg QD induced moderate pulmonary changes, characterized by alveolar wall thickening, macrophage accumulation, fibrosis, micro-hemorrhage, edema and necrosis. In addition to this picture of chronic inflammation, perivascular edema and myofiber degeneration observed in the heart were also indicative of vascular leakage and its consequences. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, these observations suggest that, in the rat, the lung is the main target organ for the S1P1 competitive antagonism-induced acute vascular leakage, which appears first as transient and asymptomatic but could lead, upon chronic dosing, to lung remodeling with functional impairments. Hence, this not only raises the question of organ specificity in the homeostasis of vascular barriers, but also provides insight into the pre-clinical evaluation of a potential safety window for S1P1 competitive antagonists as drug candidates.

Targeted inhibition of the COP9 signalosome for treatment of cancer.

The COP9 signalosome (CSN) is a central component of the activation and remodelling cycle of cullin-RING E3 ubiquitin ligases (CRLs), the largest enzyme family of the ubiquitin-proteasome system in humans. CRLs are implicated in the regulation of numerous cellular processes, including cell cycle progression and apoptosis, and aberrant CRL activity is frequently associated with cancer. Remodelling of CRLs is initiated by CSN-catalysed cleavage of the ubiquitin-like activator NEDD8 from CRLs. Here we describe CSN5i-3, a potent, selective and orally available inhibitor of CSN5, the proteolytic subunit of CSN. The compound traps CRLs in the neddylated state, which leads to inactivation of a subset of CRLs by inducing degradation of their substrate recognition module. CSN5i-3 differentially affects the viability of tumour cell lines and suppresses growth of a human xenograft in mice. Our results provide insights into how CSN regulates CRLs and suggest that CSN5 inhibition has potential for anti-tumour therapy.

An oral sphingosine 1-phosphate receptor 1 (S1P(1)) antagonist prodrug with efficacy in vivo: discovery, synthesis, and evaluation.

A prodrug approach to optimize the oral exposure of a series of sphingosine 1-phosphate receptor 1 (S1P(1)) antagonists for chronic efficacy studies led to the discovery of (S)-2-{[3'-(4-chloro-2,5-dimethylphenylsulfonylamino)-3,5-dimethylbiphenyl-4-carbonyl]methylamino}-4-dimethylaminobutyric acid methyl ester 14. Methyl ester prodrug 14 is hydrolyzed in vivo to the corresponding carboxylic acid 15, a potent and selective S1P(1) antagonist. Oral administration of the prodrug 14 induces sustained peripheral blood lymphocyte reduction in rats. In a rat cardiac transplantation model coadministration of a nonefficacious dose of prodrug 14 with a nonefficacious dose of sotrastaurin (19), a protein kinase C inhibitor, or everolimus (20), an mTOR inhibitor, effectively prolonged the survival time of rat cardiac allografts. This demonstrates that clinically useful immunomodulation mediated by the S1P(1) receptor can be achieved with an S1P(1) antagonist generated in vivo after oral administration of its prodrug.

A potent and selective S1P(1) antagonist with efficacy in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis.

Lymphocyte trafficking is critically regulated by the Sphingosine 1-phosphate receptor-1 (S1P(1)), a G protein-coupled receptor that has been highlighted as a promising therapeutic target in autoimmunity. Fingolimod (FTY720, Gilenya) is a S1P(1) receptor agonist that has recently been approved for the treatment of multiple sclerosis (MS). Here, we report the discovery of NIBR-0213, a potent and selective S1P(1) antagonist that induces long-lasting reduction of peripheral blood lymphocyte counts after oral dosing. NIBR-0213 showed comparable therapeutic efficacy to fingolimod in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), a model of human MS. These data provide convincing evidence that S1P(1) antagonists are effective in EAE. In addition, the profile of NIBR-0213 makes it an attractive candidate to further study the consequences of S1P(1) receptor antagonism and to differentiate the effects from those of S1P(1) agonists.

A lead discovery strategy driven by a comprehensive analysis of proteases in the peptide substrate space.

We present here a comprehensive analysis of proteases in the peptide substrate space and demonstrate its applicability for lead discovery. Aligned octapeptide substrates of 498 proteases taken from the MEROPS peptidase database were used for the in silico analysis. A multiple-category naïve Bayes model, trained on the two-dimensional chemical features of the substrates, was able to classify the substrates of 365 (73%) proteases and elucidate statistically significant chemical features for each of their specific substrate positions. The positional awareness of the method allows us to identify the most similar substrate positions between proteases. Our analysis reveals that proteases from different families, based on the traditional classification (aspartic, cysteine, serine, and metallo), could have substrates that differ at the cleavage site (P1-P1') but are similar away from it. Caspase-3 (cysteine protease) and granzyme B (serine protease) are previously known examples of cross-family neighbors identified by this method. To assess whether peptide substrate similarity between unrelated proteases could reliably translate into the discovery of low molecular weight synthetic inhibitors, a lead discovery strategy was tested on two other cross-family neighbors--namely cathepsin L2 and matrix metallo proteinase 9, and calpain 1 and pepsin A. For both these pairs, a naïve Bayes classifier model trained on inhibitors of one protease could successfully enrich those of its neighbor from a different family and vice versa, indicating that this approach could be prospectively applied to lead discovery for a novel protease target with no known synthetic inhibitors.

Palladium-catalyzed enantioselective C-3 allylation of 3-substituted-1H-indoles using trialkylboranes.

We have developed a new enantioselective C-3 allylation of 3-substituted indoles using allyl alcohol and trialkylboranes. Asymmetric syntheses of 3,3-disubstituted indolines and indolenines in enantiomeric excesses up to 90% have been achieved using the bulky borane 9-BBN-C6H13 as the promoter of the reaction. The dependence of the selectivity on the nature of the borane suggests that the boron reagent has a role beyond promoting ionization of the allyl alcohol. A protocol for oxidation of indolenines to oxindoles has also been developed and led to a formal synthesis of (-)-phenserine.

Conformational analysis of the C-terminal Gly-Leu-Met-NH2 tripeptide of substance P bound to the NK-1 receptor.

We examined the effect of simultaneously incorporating proline or proline-amino acid chimeras in positions 9, 10, and/or 11 of substance P, on the affinity for the two NK-1 binding sites and on second-messenger activation. Because these 3-substituted prolines constrain not only the (phi,psi) values of the peptide backbone, but also the chi space of the amino acid side chain, we were able to gather data on the structural requirements for high-affinity binding to the NK-1 receptor. We were able to confirm that this C-terminal component is crucial and that it should adopt an extended conformation close to a polyproline II structure when bound to the receptor. The partial additivity of these constraints, more specifically, for the NK-1M site, suggests that the peptide backbone flexibility around the hinge-point residue Gly9 is essential to subtly position crucial side chains.

Asymmetric synthesis of 3-substituted proline chimeras bearing polar side chains of proteinogenic amino acids.

The amino-zinc-ene-enolate cyclization reaction is a straightforward route to the synthesis of 3-substituted prolines. Herein we report the application of this reaction to the syntheses of proline chimeras of lysine, glutamic acid, glutamine, arginine, and serine. All these compounds were obtained in enantiomerically pure form and suitably protected for peptide synthesis.