Assays to predict the genotoxicity of the chromosomal mutagen etoposide -- focussing on the best assay.

The topoisomerase II inhibitor etoposide is used routinely to treat a variety of cancers in patients of all ages. As a result of its extensive use in the clinic and its association with secondary malignancies it has become a compound of great interest with regard to its genotoxic activity in vivo. This paper describes a series of assays that were employed to determine the in vivo genotoxicity of etoposide in a murine model system. The alkaline comet assay detected DNA damage in the bone marrow mononuclear compartment over the dose range of 10--100mg/kg and was associated with a large and dose dependent rise in the proportion of cells with severely damaged DNA. In contrast, the bone marrow micronucleus assay was found to be sensitive to genotoxic damage between the doses of 0.1--1mg/kg without any corresponding increases in cytotoxicity. An increase in the mutant frequency was undetectable at the Hprt locus at administered doses of 1 and 10mg/kg of etoposide, however, an increase in the mutant frequency was seen at the Aprt locus at these doses. We conclude that the BMMN assay is a good short-term predictor of the clastogenicity of etoposide at doses that do not result in cytotoxic activity, giving an indication of potential mutagenic effects. Moreover, the detection of mutants at the Aprt locus gives an indication of the potential of etoposide to cause chromosomal mutations that may lead to secondary malignancy.

The effects of dose, route of administration, drug scheduling and MDR-1 gene transfer on the genotoxicity of etoposide in bone marrow.

We have used the bone marrow micronucleus assay (BMMN) as a measure of clastogenicity, in response to etoposide exposure in murine bone marrow. Oral delivery of etoposide resulted in a reduced number of micronucleated polychromatic erythrocytes (MPE) relative to the same dose delivered intraperitoneally (P < 0.001). Daily fractionation of the oral schedule of etoposide led to a more than six-fold increase in cumulative MPE frequency over that observed with the same total, unfractionated dose, with the potency of the response increasing with serial exposure (r = 0.79). Retrovirally-mediated expression of MDR1 in murine bone marrow resulted in partial protection against the clastogenic activity of etoposide relative to mock transduced control mice. The model system developed has indicated a variety of factors able to influence the genotoxicity of etoposide. It should now be possible to further exploit this model in order to define other factors governing haemopoietic sensitivity to etoposide.

Engineering drug resistance in human cells.

Many of the problems with current anti-tumour therapies stem from a lack of specificity for tumour as opposed to normal tissues. To address the problem of collateral toxicity during anti-tumour chemotherapy we have been developing a gene therapy approach to protect normal tissues from the toxic and potentially mutagenic effects of chemotherapeutic agents. As a paradigm for this we have been examining the potential of the DNA repair protein O6-alkylguanine-DNA-alkyltransferase (ATase) to confer genetic chemoprotection to the bone marrow. By transfer and expression of a mutant form of this protein, which is resistant to inactivation by the tumour sensitising agent O6-benzylguanine (O6-beG), we have been able to demonstrate protection of murine bone marrow in vitro from the cytotoxic and clastogenic effects of O6-beG in combination with the anti-tumour agent temozolomide. This protection is seen in multiple lineages, including erythroid and granulocyte/macrophage progenitors, as well as more primitive cells. Importantly, significant protection of the platelet lineage is also seen, with faster recovery of platelets. The multi-lineage protection seen has encouraged us to take this approach forward to clinical trial in the near future.

Role of O6-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase in the resistance of mouse spermatogenic cells to O6-alkylating agents.

The O(6)-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase inactivator O(6)-benzylguanine was administered to BALB/c mice either alone or before exposure to 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea to study the role of the DNA repair protein O(6)-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase in the protection of the testis against anti-cancer O(6)-alkylating agents. Exposure of the mice to 1, 3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea or O(6)-benzylguanine alone did not produce any marked testicular toxicity at the times studied. Testicular O(6)-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase concentrations were assayed between 0 and 240 min after O(6)-benzylguanine treatment and were shown to be > 95% depleted 15 min after treatment with O(6)-benzylguanine and remained at > 95% at all the times assayed. Histological examination, the reduction in testicular mass and the induction of spermatogenic cell apoptosis showed that this depletion significantly potentiated 1, 3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea-induced testicular damage after treatment. Major histological damage was apparent 42 days after treatment, demonstrating that the stem spermatogonia were significantly affected by the combination. These results demonstrate that O(6)-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase plays a significant role in protecting the spermatogenic cells from damage caused by DNA alkylation and indicate that the observed toxicity may result from damage to stem spermatogonia.

The expression of full length Gp91-phox protein is associated with reduced amphotropic retroviral production.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: As a single gene defect in mature bone marrow cells, chronic granulomatous disease (X-CGD) represents a disorder which may be amenable to gene therapy by the transfer of the missing subunit into hemopoietic stem cells. In the majority of cases lack of Gp91-phox causes the disease. So far, studies involving transfer of Gp91-phox cDNA, including a phase I clinical trial, have yielded disappointing results. Most often, low titers of virus have been reported. In the present study we investigated the possible reasons for low titer amphotropic viral production. DESIGN AND METHODS: To investigate the effect of Gp91 cDNA on the efficiency of retroviral production from the packaging cell line, GP+envAm12, we constructed vectors containing either the native cDNA, truncated versions of the cDNA or a mutated form (LATG) in which the natural translational start codon was changed to a stop codon. Following derivation of clonal packaging cell lines, these were assessed for viral titer by RNA slot blot and analyzed by non-parametrical statistical analysis (Whitney-Mann U-test). RESULTS: An improvement in viral titer of just over two-fold was found in packaging cells containing the start-codon mutant of Gp91 and no evidence of truncated viral RNA was seen in these cells. Further analysis revealed the presence of rearranged forms of the provirus in Gp91-expressing cells, and the production of truncated, unpackaged viral RNA. Protein analysis revealed that LATG-transduced cells did not express full-length Gp91-phox, whereas those containing the wild-type cDNA did. However, a truncated protein was seen in ATG-transduced cells which was also present in wild type cells. No evidence for the presence of a negative transcriptional regulatory element was found from studies with the deletion mutants. INTERPRETATION AND CONCLUSIONS: A statistically significant effect of protein production on the production of virus from Gp91-expressing cells was found. Our data point to a need to restrict expression of the Gp91-phox protein and its derivatives in order to enhance retroviral production and suggest that improvements in current vectors for CGD gene therapy may need to include controlled, directed expression only in mature neutrophils.

Enhancing hemopoietic drug resistance: a rationale for reconsidering the clinical use of mitozolomide.

Retroviral gene transfer was used to achieve expression in mouse bone marrow of a mutant form of the DNA repair protein O6-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase (hATPA/GA), which exhibits resistance to inactivation by O6-benzylguanine (O6-beG). After reconstitution of mice with transduced bone marrow, approximately 50% of the bipotent granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming cell (GM-CFC) and multipotent spleen colony-forming unit (CFU-S) hemopoietic populations showed expression of the transgene; this expression was associated with resistance to either mitozolomide or to a combination of O6-beG and mitozolomide, relative to mock-transduced controls. Thus, at a dose of mitozolomide in vivo that allowed only 70% and 62% survival of mock-transduced GM-CFC and CFU-S, respectively, the hATPA/GA CFC were totally resistant to the same dose of mitozolomide (P < .05 and .001, respectively). In the presence of O6-beG, the toxicity of mitozolomide was greatly potentiated. Only 24% and 18%, respectively, of mock-transduced GM-CFC and CFU-S survived combination treatment, whereas 45% (P < .05) and 37% (P < .01) of GM-CFC and CFU-S, respectively, from hATPA/GA mice survived the same combination of doses. Furthermore, as a result of transgene expression, the number of micronucleated polychromatic erythrocytes induced by mitozolomide was significantly reduced (P < .05) by 40% relative to mock-transduced controls, indicating the potential of this approach to reduce the frequency of mutation associated with chemotherapy exposure. The protection against the toxic and clastogenic effects of mitozolomide in both primitive and more mature hemopoietic cells suggests that the severe myelosuppression that halted further clinical investigation of this drug could be substantially ameliorated by the exogenous expression of O6-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase. Therefore, these data raise the prospect for the reinvestigation of mitozolomide and other proscribed drugs in the context of genetically protected hemopoiesis.

A novel dual function retrovirus expressing multidrug resistance 1 and O6-alkylguanine-DNA-alkyltransferase for engineering resistance of haemopoietic progenitor cells to multiple chemotherapeutic agents.

Following transduction with a retrovirus (SF1MIH) expressing both the multidrug resistance 1 (MDR1) and O6-alkylguanine-DNA-alkyltransferase (ATase) proteins, human erythroleukaemic progenitor (K562) cells were isolated which were resistant to killing by the MDR1 substrate, colchicine. In colony-forming survival assays, K562-SF1MIH cells exhibited resistance to colchicine and doxorubicin, as well as to the O6-alkylating agents N-Methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU) and temozolomide. Furthermore, the resistance to doxorubicin was abolished by preincubation with the MDR1 inhibitor verapamil while resistance to MNU was ablated by the specific ATase inactivator, O6-benzylguanine (O6-beG) confirming that resistance to doxorubicin and MNU was conferred by MDR1 and ATase, respectively. When K562-SF1MIH were exposed to combinations of colchicine and MNU or doxorubicin and temozolomide, simultaneous resistance to these agents was observed. Thus, transduction of K562 with SF1MIH conferred dual resistance to these cells. These data offer the prospect of designing vectors that will confer resistance to entire regimens of chemotherapy rather than just to individual components of such drug cocktails, thereby substantially increasing the efficacy of therapy. Furthermore, the use of such dual expression constructs is likely to be highly informative for the design of effective in vivo selection protocols, an issue likely to make a major impact in a clinical context in gene therapy in the near future.

Genotoxicity studies on the azo dye Direct Red 2 using the in vivo mouse bone marrow micronucleus test.

The clastogenicity of the azo dye Direct Red 2 (DR2) has been investigated using the murine bone marrow micronucleus assay. A potent dose-dependent response was observed following oral gavage of DR2 up to 4 mg/kg, after which significant toxicity to the erythroid compartment was observed. The route of administration had a significant effect on the frequency of micronucleus formation: intraperitoneal injection was approximately two-fold less clastogenic than the equivalent dose delivered orally (p<0.05). The requirement for activation of DR2 by intestinal microflora was indicated by the fact that mice given acid-treated water prior to administration of DR2 showed a significant reduction (40%; p<0.001) in micronucleated polychromatic erythrocyte formation. The implications of these findings for the health and safety of occupationally exposed workers are discussed.

Expression levels of the DNA repair enzyme HAP1 do not correlate with the radiosensitivities of human or HAP1-transfected rat cell lines.

Apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites in DNA are potentially lethal and mutagenic. They can arise spontaneously or following DNA damage from reactive oxygen species or alkylating agents, and they constitute a significant product of DNA damage following cellular exposure to ionizing radiation. The major AP endonuclease responsible for initiating the repair of these and other DNA lesions in human cells is HAP1, which also possesses a redox function. We have determined the cellular levels of this enzyme in 11 human tumour and fibroblast cell lines in relation to clonogenic survival following ionizing radiation. Cellular HAP1 levels and surviving fraction at 2 Gy (SF2) varied five- and tenfold respectively. However, no correlation was found between these two parameters following exposure to gamma-irradiation at low (1.1 cGy per min) or high (108 cGy per min) dose rates. To examine this further, wild-type and mutant versions of HAP1 were overexpressed, using an inducible HAP1 cDNA expression vector system, in the rat C6 glioma cell line which has low endogenous AP endonuclease activity. Induction of wild-type HAP1 expression caused a > fivefold increase in the capacity of cellular extracts to cleave an oligonucleotide substrate containing a single abasic site, but increased expression did not confer increased resistance to gamma-irradiation at high- or low-dose rates, or to the methylating agent methyl methanesulphonate (MMS). Expression in C6 cell lines of mutant forms of HAP1 deleted for either the redox activator or DNA repair functions displayed no apparent titrational or dominant negative effects. These studies suggest that the levels of endogenous AP endonuclease activities in the various cell lines examined are not limiting for efficient repair in cells following exposure to ionizing radiation or MMS. This contrasts with the correlation we have found between HAP1 levels and radiosensitivity in cervix carcinomas (Herring et al (1998) Br J Cancer 78: 1128-1133), indicating that HAP1 levels in this case assume a critical survival role and hence that established cell lines might not be a suitable model for such studies.

Influence of O6-benzylguanine on the anti-tumour activity and normal tissue toxicity of 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea and molecular combinations of 5-fluorouracil and 2-chloroethyl-1-nitrosourea in mice.

Previous studies have demonstrated that novel molecular combinations of 5-fluorouracil (5FU) and 2-chloroethyl-1-nitrosourea (CNU) have good preclinical activity and may exert less myelotoxicity than the clinically used nitrosoureas such as 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea (BCNU). This study examined the effect of O6-alkylguanine-DNA-alkyltransferase (ATase) depletion by the pseudosubstrate O6-benzylguanine (BG) on the anti-tumour activity and normal tissue toxicity in mice of three such molecular combinations, in comparison with BCNU. When used as single agents at their maximum tolerated dose, all three novel compounds produced a significant growth retardation of BCNU-resistant murine colon and human breast xenografts. This in vivo anti-tumour effect was potentiated by BG, but was accompanied by severe myelotoxicity as judged by spleen colony forming assays. However, while tumour resistance to BCNU was overcome using BG, this was at the expense of enhanced bone marrow, gut and liver toxicity. Therefore, although this ATase-depletion approach resulted in improved anti-tumour activity for all three 5-FU:CNU molecular combinations, the potentiated toxicities in already dose-limiting tissues indicate that these types of agents offer no therapeutic advantage over BCNU when they are used together with BG.