Contraception with two levonorgestrel rod implants. A 5-year study in the United States and Dominican Republic.

A 5-year trial of a two-rod contraceptive implant, which releases the progestin levonorgestrel (LNG rod), was conducted at four clinics with 594 women. Mean age and weight at admission were 25.5 years and 62.4 kg, respectively. Consent to continue through 5 years was sought and obtained when the 3-year cumulative pregnancy rate proved to be 0.8 per 100. No pregnancies occurred in the fourth or fifth years. The 5-year cumulative pregnancy rate was, therefore, 0.8 per 100 with an annual average pregnancy rate below 2 per 1000 women. Prolonged bleeding/spotting (8.2% of subjects) and irregular bleeding (5.6%) were the most frequently cited medical reasons for removal. Removals for headache (4.7%) and weight change (4.0%) were the next most frequent medical reasons. Between 1% and 2% of subjects during the 5-year trial sought removals for each of the following conditions: mood changes, lower abdominal pain, depression, or pain at the implant site. The mean annual continuation rate during the study was 77 per 100. Use per woman averaged 2.96 years. Mean removal time was 5.9 +/- 0.6 min. These data indicate that, for a 5-year period, the two LNG rod implants are equivalent to the six Norplant capsule implants with respect to safety and efficacy parameters, but permit easier and more rapid implant removal.

PIP: The newly developed 2-rod levonorgestrel (LNG) implant system has a surface area only 44% that of Norplant yet provides LNG release rates and blood levels similar to the 6-capsule Norplant system. Clinical trials of the 2-rod implant system initiated in 1990 demonstrated an exceptionally low cumulative pregnancy rate (0.8/100) in the first 3 years of use. This paper reports on an extension of the original study for an additional 2 years. 594 women at 4 study sites in the US and the Dominican Republic completed 5 years of method use. No pregnancies occurred in the fourth and fifth years of use. Thus, the 5-year cumulative pregnancy rate was 0.8/100, with an average annual pregnancy rate below 2/1000 women. The mean annual continuation rate during the 5-year study period was 77/100 women, with an average duration of use of 2.96 years. The most frequent reasons for medical removal were prolonged bleeding/spotting (8.2% of women), irregular bleeding (5.6%), headache (4.7%), and weight gain (4.0%). Mean removal time was 5.9 minutes and complications occurred in only 2.3% of removals. Overall, these findings confirm that the 2-rod LNG implant contraceptive has an effectiveness equivalent to the 6-capsule implant for a 5-year period, with good acceptability and a substantially improved ease of removal.

Clinical performance of a new two-rod levonorgestrel contraceptive implant: a three-year randomized study with Norplant implants as controls.

In a randomized three-year clinical trial at seven clinics, the performance of levonorgestrel rod (LNG ROD) implants used by 600 women was compared with that of soft tubing NORPLANT implants used by 598 women. No pregnancies occurred in either group of women and, accordingly, body weight did not affect the efficacy of either type of implant. There were neither statistically significant nor important differences in termination rates for any reason over the three years. Complaint and illness rates during use of either of the two implant types were statistically indistinguishable and were attributable to the same set of conditions. Seventy-one per 100 of the women using each implant regimen continued to the three-year point, for an average annual continuation rate of 89 per 100. Removals of LNG ROD implants were accomplished in about half the time required for removal of Norplant capsule implants (p < 0.001).

Safety, efficacy, and acceptability of medical abortion in China, Cuba, and India: a comparative trial of mifepristone-misoprostol versus surgical abortion.

OBJECTIVE: We investigated safety, efficacy, and acceptability of an oral regimen of medical abortion compared with surgical abortion in three developing countries. STUDY DESIGN: Women (n = 1373) with amenorrhea < or = 56 days chose either surgical abortion (as provided routinely) or 600 mg of mifepristone followed after 48 hours by 400 micrograms of misoprostol. This is the appropriate design for studying safety, efficacy, and acceptability among women selecting medical abortion over available surgical services. RESULTS: The medical regimen had more side effects, particularly bleeding, than did surgical abortion but very few serious side effects. Failure rates for medical abortion, although low, exceeded those for surgical abortion: 8.6% versus 0.4% (China), 16.0% versus 4.0% (Cuba), and 5.2% versus 0% (India). Nearly half of failures among medical clients were not true drug failures, however, but surgical interventions not medically necessary (acceptability failures or misdiagnoses). Women were satisfied with either method, but more preferred medical abortion. CONCLUSION: Medical abortion can be safe, efficacious, and acceptable in developing countries.

PIP: A multi-center comparative study of medical compared to surgical abortion confirmed that medical abortion can be safe, effective, and acceptable in developing countries. A total of 1373 women from medical centers in China, Cuba, and India with pregnancies of 56 days' gestation or less were given the choice of surgical abortion or 600 mg of mifepristone followed after 48 hours by 400 mcg of misoprostol. Since the majority selected medical abortion, researchers in China and Cuba assigned some of these women to the surgical group to equalize the size of the two groups. The surgical abortion failure rates in China, Cuba, and India were 0.4%, 4%, and 0%, respectively, while the failure rates for medical abortion were 8.6%, 16.0%, and 5.2%, respectively. In all sites, both medical failures (an adverse effect resulting in a medically indicated surgical intervention) and acceptability failures (failure to complete the entire regimen) contributed substantially to the gross failure rates for medical abortion. Medical abortion failure rates increased with gestational age. Although cramping, nausea, and vomiting were more frequent among women in the medical abortion group and bleeding was heavier, general assessments of well-being reported at exit interviews did not differ between the two treatment groups at any site. Regardless of abortion method, the majority of women were either satisfied or highly satisfied with the procedure. In all countries, a higher number of medical than surgical abortion patients indicated they would opt again for the same procedure. Neither the bleeding pattern nor the higher failure rate associated with medical abortion justify withholding this option from women in developing countries.

Clinical assessment of treatments for prolonged bleeding in users of Norplant implants.

The effectiveness of three drugs in controlling prolonged bleeding in the first year of NORPLANT implants use was tested. The drugs were levonorgestrel (L-Ng, 0.03 mg twice a day for 20 days), ethinylestradiol (EE, 0.05 mg per day for 20 days) and ibuprofen (Ib, 800 mg three times a day for 5 days) and were given orally. A control group received a placebo (PL, one pill of lactose for 20 days). Treatment should start each time a woman experienced eight consecutive days of bleeding or spotting. The 183 volunteers were not aware of the drug administered. A daily record of bleeding and spotting and of treatment intake was maintained. One-hundred-forty women completed the study period; 60 never used the prescribed treatment. Women treated with the three test drugs had significantly fewer bleeding and spotting days during the treated month and also throughout the study year than women using the placebo. The mean number of bleeding plus spotting days per actually treated subject in the first year was 77, 94, 101 and 129 days for the EE, Ib, L-Ng and PL groups, respectively. The administration of EE might help in the management of prolonged bleeding during the first year of NORPLANT implants use.

Two-year prospective study in Colombia of Norplant implants.

A clinical trial of levonorgestrel-releasing Norplant implants used for contraception was undertaken in two cities in Colombia. Through two years in which 389 women had accumulated 594 years of use, there were no pregnancies. In a comparison group of copper intrauterine device acceptors, the one-year pregnancy rate was 1.1 per 100. Menstrual disturbances associated with progestin-only administration were the principal side-effects, and the major reason for cessation of use. Continuation among users of the implants was at the same or at a higher rate than observed among users of the intrauterine device. Advantages and disadvantages of alternate sites for implant placement are discussed.

Long-term experience with Norplant implants in international clinical trials.

Norplant subdermal implants containing levonorgestrel were used for contraception and compared with the Copper T, Model T Cu 200, during 42 months of use in an open study in Chile, the Dominican Republic, and Finland. Among 324 women enrolled for the implant regimen, there were no pregnancies in the 1st 2.5 years, and 2 by the end of 42 months. 1st segment net and gross cumulative pregnancy rates were 0.7 and 1.2/100 respectively, at 3.5 years. Cumulative pregnancy rates for the T Cu 200 group were 2.9, net and 3.5/100, gross at 42 months. More than 1/2 of the implant acceptors, 51.6/100 were continuing use at 3.5 years, somewhat above the continuation rate of the T Cu acceptors, 43.5/100, but not significantly so.

Lipoprotein patterns in women in Santo Domingo using a levonorgestrel/estradiol contraceptive ring.

Ten healthy, normally menstruating women attending a family planning clinic in Santo Domingo Participated in a study to determine the effects on plasma lipid levels of levonorgestrel and estradiol released from a contraceptive ring. A schedule of 21 days of use followed by 7 days of non-use was followed for 6 cycles. During the first two cycles of use, concentrations of cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, triglycerides and LDL cholesterol declined significantly from control levels, up to 25% for cholesterol, 28% for HDL cholesterol, 45% for friglycerides and 24% for LDL cholesterol. There were no subsequent changes with continued use. These declines are similar in direction but of lesser magnitude than those reported from clinics in other countries where pretreatment plasma levels of the same lipids are considerably higher. There was no significant change in the total cholesterol to HDL cholesterol ratio during treatment.

A randomized double blind study of two oral contraceptives.

To study the question of whether one brand of oral contraceptives may be as acceptable as another for use of publicly-assisted family planning programs, a double blind study of two well-known brands, Ovral and Norinyl, was undertaken in Costa Rica and Trinidad. The pills were randomly assigned to 1,200 women. Common side effects - nausea, dizziness, vomiting, headaches - were associated with both Norinyl and Ovral. Differences in event rates for these conditions were much more marked by country than by the pill used. Ovral was associated with increases in skin problems, notably chloasma, in Cost Rica. A higher percentage of women using Norinyl reported intermenstrual bleeding and spotting in both countries. In Costa Rica continuation rates for Norinyl were adversely affected by this. With these exceptions there appear to be no important differences between the brands that would affect their use in family planning programs.

PIP: A double-blind study of 2 well-known brands of contraceptives, Ovral and Norinyl, was performed in Trinidad and Costa Rica to determine if 1 brand of oral contraceptive were as acceptable as another. Differences in race and ethnic origin were large between the 2 study populations. There were no significant differences in reporting of gastrointestinal side effects for the 2 formulations. Women using Ovral in Costa Rica reported acne and chloasma in significantly greater (P .001) numbers than did women using Norinyl. Participants in Trinidad were virtually free of such complaints. Overall in both study populations, Ovral affected significantly more users (P .05) both with regard to chloasma and all skin conditions than did Norinyl. A moderate excess of cervicitis and cervical erosion among Ovral users in Trinidad was seen; in Costa Rica, cervical erosion occurred in 13% of users of either drug, whereas cervicitis was noted in 3% of each group. Both brands reduced the average number of days of menstrual bleeding in the 2 countries, and both formulations effected a reduction in the % of women reporting relatively heavy menstrual flow. Intermenstrual spotting or bleeding was strongly (P .001 overall) associated with the use of Norinyl; in both countries, the % of women using Norinyl reporting intermenstrual bleeding was at least 2 times that of Ovral users. In Costa Rica, continuation rates for Norinyl were badly affected by the frequency of intermenstrual bleeding (27.9 for Norinyl and 8.2 for Ovral). Otherwise, it is concluded that there were no important differences between the 2 formulations.

A comparison of the copper T-200 and the Lippes Loop in four countries.

A comparative field trial of the Copper TCu-200 and the Lippes loop was conducted in Colombia, Iran, Korea, and Thailand from 1971 to 1973. The study, involving 7,400 women, provided two-year first segment continuation and termination rates. In three countries, TCu-200 expulsion rates were significantly below Lippes loop expulsion rates. For women with three or fewer living children, TCu-200 expulsion rates were markedly below Lippes loop rates in all four countries. The comparative advantage accruing to the TCu-200 in this characteristic did not extend to the two-year continuation rates.

The effectiveness of the Copper-T intrauterine device: a collaborative study in five countries.

PIP: Investigators in 5 countries collaborated with the Population Council to study the use-effectiveness of a new intrauterine contraceptive -- a T-shaped inert plastic device modified to bear 200 mm of exposed copper surface. After clinical trials in Santiago, Chile, the TCu-200 was tested on a total of 6257 women in the U.S.A., Colombia, Iran, Korea, Taiwan, and Thailand from May to November 1971. Postacceptance data are available for 95.3%, most of whom were interviewed at home 6 to 13 months after the initial insertion. For women with 1,2, or 3 living children at the time of acceptance, copper-T had higher continuation rates than Lippes Loop acceptors in the same countries. For women with 4 or more living children at the time of acceptance, continuation rates for the T device were only slightly higher, or the same, as those for the Lippes Loop. Pregnancy and expulsion rates for the copper-T were below those for the loop. Because of the uncertainty of the effective life of the copper, it is currently recommended that the device be replaced every 2 years, which would seem to limit it as a preferred device in mass family planning programs. However, recent evidence indicates that the antifertility effect of the copper-T device may last longer than 2 years.^ieng