RESUMO
Initial medical certificate is a descriptive medical and legal document whose purpose is to prove the existence of a damage and to enable the victim to access his or her right. The purpose of our study was to study the content and to evaluate the writing quality of initial medical certificates. We conducted a retrospective and descriptive study over an 18-month period, from January 2017 to June 2018. We collected data from 450 initial medical certificates at the Forensic Medicine Department of the Charles Nicolle University Hospital in Tunis. The quality of the initial medical certificates was assessed using a template that allowed to assign them a score out of 30. A mean score was mainly assigned to initial medical certificates Template scores ranged between 9.5 and 27.5/30 with an mean of 18.59/30. General practitioners and specialist physicians, such as ophthalmologists, neurosurgeons and doctors using the support provided by the Ministry of Health wrote better certificates. Similarly, we noted better quality of writing when certificates dealt with intentional assaults and injuries. Our study shows that the majority of initial medical certificates does not conform to editorial guidelines. These shortcomings are probably related to the fact that doctors have never received adequate medical-legal training.
Assuntos
Medicina Legal , Clínicos Gerais , Feminino , Instalações de Saúde , Humanos , Masculino , Estudos Retrospectivos , TunísiaRESUMO
Neck paragangliomas are relatively rare neuroendocrine nonsecretory tumors. They are mainly observed among adults and are often asymptomatic, causing a frequent delay in diagnosis. In pediatric cases, neck paragangliomas can be associated with adrenergic symptoms that may lead to complications.A report of a sudden death due to a carotid paraganglioma in a young girl is reported. Autopsy revealed a thoracic arotic dissection and a 4-cm jugulocarotidian mass in the absence of traumatic injuries. Histology showed no evidence of underlying aortic disease, including signs of Marfan syndrome, and a paraganglioma. Postmortem biochemistry analysis showed blood metanephrines levels 100 times higher than normal range. The cause of death was an aortic dissection complicating a neck paraganglioma. The manner of death was concluded as natural.Our case highlighted the importance for forensic pathologist to consider the diagnosis of paraganglioma in case of sudden hypertensive complications, especially among young people.