Noradrenergic cardiac denervation is associated with gait velocity in Parkinson disease: a dual ligand PET study.

PURPOSE: Preliminary data suggest that gait abnormalities in Parkinson disease (PD) may be associated with sympathetic cardiac denervation. No kinematic gait studies were performed to confirm this observation. We aimed to correlate spatiotemporal kinematic gait parameters with cardiac sympathetic denervation as determined by cardiac [11C]HED PET in PD. METHODS: Retrospective database analysis of 27 PD patients with cardiac sympathetic denervation. All patients underwent spatiotemporal kinematic gait assessment (medication 'off' state), cardiac [11C]HED and dopaminergic brain [11C]DTBZ PET scans. We employed a hierarchical regression approach to examine associations between the extent of cardiac denervation, dopaminergic nigrostriatal neurodegeneration, and three gait parameters - velocity, step length and cadence. RESULTS: More extensive cardiac denervation was associated with slower velocity (estimate: -1.034, 95% CI [-1.65, -0.42], p = 0.002), shorter step length (estimate: -0.818, 95% CI [-1.43, -0.21], p = 0.011) and lower cadence (estimate: -0.752, 95% CI [-1.28, -0.23], p = 0.007) explaining alone 30% (Adjusted-R²: 0.297), 20% (Adjusted-R²: 0.202) and 23% (Adjusted-R²: 0.227) of the variability, respecivetly. These associations remained independent of striatal dopaminergic impairment and confounding factors such as age, Hoehn and Yahr (HY) stages, peripheral neuropathy, cognition, and autonomic symptoms. In contrast, striatal dopaminergic denervation was significantly associated with step length (estimate: 0.883, 95% CI [0.29, 1.48], p = 0.005), explaining about 24% of the variability but was dependent of HY stage. CONCLUSIONS: More severe cardiac noradrenergic denervation was associated with lower gait velocity, independent of striatal dopaminergic denervation and HY stage, impacting both step length and cadence. These results suggest independent contributions of the peripheral autonomic system degeneration on gait dynsfunction in PD.

Cardiac sympathetic denervation and anxiety in Parkinson disease.

BACKGROUND: Anxiety in Parkinson disease (PD) negatively impacts quality of life. While research predominantly focuses on central nervous system changes, some evidence suggests a connection between peripheral autonomic dysfunctions and PD-related anxiety. The role of the peripheral autonomic nervous system in this context may be overlooked. OBJECTIVES: This study explores the link between anxiety symptoms and cardiac sympathetic denervation in PD using 11C-meta-hydroxyephedrine ([11C]HED) PET cardiac imaging. METHODS: We studied 34 non-demented PD subjects, assessing anxiety levels through the Spielberg Anxiety State-Trait test trait section (STAI-T). Patients underwent comprehensive assessments along with [11C]HED cardiac and [11C]DTBZ brain PET. To identify subdimensions of STAI-T, we employed principal components analysis (PCA). We examined associations between the anxiety subdimensions and two measures of cardiac sympathetic denervation from [11C]HED PET. We utilized correlation and linear regression models for these analyses. RESULTS: PCA revealed two STAI-T results components: anxiety-depressive and pure anxiety subcomponents. Only pure anxiety significantly correlated with measures of cardiac sympathetic denervation (rhos -0.40, p = 0.018; 0.35, p = 0.043). Regression models confirmed a significant association, with cardiac sympathetic denervation explaining ∼20 % of pure anxiety variance, independent of sex, dopaminergic impairment, and anxiolytic treatments. DISCUSSION: This study provides preliminary evidence of peripheral autonomic nervous system abnormalities contributing to PD-related anxiety, suggesting dysregulation in peripheral autonomic functions influencing anxiety perception.

Predicting Progression from Normal to MCI and from MCI to AD Using Clinical Variables in the National Alzheimer's Coordinating Center Uniform Data Set Version 3: Application of Machine Learning Models and a Probability Calculator.

Clinical trials are increasingly focused on pre-manifest and early Alzheimer's disease (AD). Accurately predicting clinical progressions from normal to MCI or from MCI to dementia/AD versus non-progression is challenging. Accurate identification of symptomatic progressors is important to avoid unnecessary treatment and improve trial efficiency. Due to large inter-individual variability, biomarker positivity and comorbidity information are often insufficient to identify those destined to have symptomatic progressions. Using only clinical variables, we aimed to predict clinical progressions, estimating probabilities of progressions with a small set of variables selected by machine learning approaches. This work updates our previous work that was applied to the National Alzheimer's Coordinating Center (NACC) Uniform Data Set Version 2 (V2), by using the most recent version (V3) with additional analyses. We generated a user-friendly conversion probability calculator which can be used for effectively pre-screening trial participants.

Impaired contrast sensitivity is associated with more severe cognitive impairment in Parkinson disease.

OBJECTIVES: Dopaminergic degeneration affects both nigrostriatal projection neurons and retinal amacrine cells in Parkinson disease (PD). Parkinsonian retinopathy is associated with impaired color discrimination and contrast sensitivity. Some prior studies described associations between color discrimination deficits and cognitive deficits in PD, suggesting that contrast discrimination deficits are due, at least in part, to cognitive deficits in PD. We investigated the relationship between cognitive deficits and impaired contrast sensitivity in PD. METHODS: PD subjects, n = 43; 15F/28M; mean age 66.5 ± 8.2, Hoehn and Yahr stage 2.6 ± 0.6, and duration of disease of 6.2 ± 5.0 years underwent neuropsychological and Rabin contrast sensitivity testing. RESULTS: Mean Rabin contrast sensitivity score was 1.34 ± 0.40. Bivariate analyses showed significant correlation between Rabin contrast sensitivity scores and global cognitive z-scores (R = 0.54, P = 0.0002). Cognitive domain Z-score post hoc analysis demonstrated most robust correlation between Rabin scores and executive functions (R = 0.49, P = 0.0009), followed by verbal learning (R = 0.44, P = 0.0028), visuospatial (R = 0.39, P = 0.001) and attention z-scores (R = 0.32, P = 0.036). CONCLUSIONS: Impaired contrast sensitivity in PD is robustly associated with cognitive deficits, particularly executive function deficits. These results suggest that contrast sensitivity may be a useful biomarker for cognitive changes in PD and may have implications for driving safety evaluations in PD.

The p75 neurotrophin receptor augments survival signaling in the striatum of pre-symptomatic Q175(WT/HD) mice.

Huntington's disease (HD) is a dominantly inherited neurodegenerative disorder characterized by a constellation of motor, cognitive, and psychiatric features. Striatal medium spiny neurons, one of the most affected populations, are dependent on brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) anterogradely transported from the cortex for proper function and survival. Recent studies suggest both receptors for BDNF, TrkB and p75 neurotrophin receptor (p75), are improperly regulated in the striata of HD patients and mouse models of HD. While BDNF-TrkB signaling almost exclusively promotes survival and metabolic function, p75 signaling is able to induce survival or apoptosis depending on the available ligand and associated co-receptor. We investigated the role of p75 in the Q175 knock-in mouse model of HD by examining the levels and activation of downstream signaling molecules, and subsequently examining Hdh(+/Q175);p75(-/-) mice to determine if p75 represents a promising therapeutic target. In Hdh(+/Q175);p75(+/+) mice, we observed enhanced survival signaling as evidenced by an increase in phosphorylation and activation of Akt and the p65 subunit of NFκB in the striatum at 5 months of age and an increase in XIAP expression compared to Hdh(+/+);p75(+/+) mice; this increase was lost in Hdh(+/Q175);p75(-/-) mice. Hdh(+/Q175);p75(-/-) mice also showed a decrease in Bcl-XL expression by immunoblotting compared to Hdh(+/Q175);p75(+/+) and Hdh(+/+);p75(+/+) littermates. Consistent with diminished survival signaling, DARPP-32 expression decreased both by immunoblotting and by immunohistochemistry in Hdh(+/Q175);p75(-/-) mice compared to Hdh(+/+);p75(+/+), Hdh(+/Q175);p75(+/+), and Hdh(+/+);p75(-/-) littermates. Additionally, striatal volume declined to a greater extent in Hdh(+/Q175);p75(-/-) when compared to Hdh(+/Q175);p75(+/+) littermates at 12 months, indicating a more aggressive onset of degeneration. These data suggest that p75 signaling plays an early role in augmenting pro-survival signaling in the striatum and that disruption of p75 signaling at a pre-symptomatic age may exacerbate pathologic changes in Hdh(+/Q175) mice.

Diabetes, Gray Matter Loss, and Cognition in the Setting of Parkinson Disease.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Parkinson disease (PD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder affecting motor and cognitive functions. Prior studies showed that patients with PD and diabetes (DM) demonstrate worse clinical outcomes compared to nondiabetic subjects with PD. Our study aimed at defining the relationship between DM, gray matter volume, and cognition in patients with PD. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This study included 36 subjects with PD (12 with DM, 24 without DM, mean age = 66). Subjects underwent high-resolution T1-weighted brain magnetic resonance imaging, [(11)C]dihydrotetrabenazine positron emission tomography imaging to quantify nigrostriatal dopaminergic denervation, clinical, and cognitive assessments. Magnetic resonance images were postprocessed to determine total and lobar cortical gray matter volumes. Cognitive testing scores were converted to z-scores for specific cognitive domains and a composite global cognitive z-score based on normative data computed. Analysis of covariance, accounting for effects of age, gender, intracranial volume, and striatal [(11)C]dihydrotetrabenazine binding, was used to test the relationship between DM and gray matter volumes. RESULTS: Impact of DM on total gray matter volume was significant (P = 0.02). Post hoc analyses of lobar cortical gray matter volumes revealed that DM was more selectively associated with lower gray matter volumes in the frontal regions (P = 0.01). Cognitive post hoc analyses showed that interaction of total gray matter volume and DM status was significantly associated with composite (P = 0.007), executive (P = 0.02), and visuospatial domain cognitive z-scores (P = 0.005). These associations were also significant for the frontal cortical gray matter. CONCLUSION: DM may exacerbate brain atrophy and cognitive functions in PD with greater vulnerability in the frontal lobes. Given the high prevalence of DM in the elderly, delineating its effects on patient outcomes in the PD population is of importance.

GFAP mutations, age at onset, and clinical subtypes in Alexander disease.

OBJECTIVE: To characterize Alexander disease (AxD) phenotypes and determine correlations with age at onset (AAO) and genetic mutation. AxD is an astrogliopathy usually characterized on MRI by leukodystrophy and caused by glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) mutations. METHODS: We present 30 new cases of AxD and reviewed 185 previously reported cases. We conducted Wilcoxon rank sum tests to identify variables scaling with AAO, survival analysis to identify predictors of mortality, and χ(2) tests to assess the effects of common GFAP mutations. Finally, we performed latent class analysis (LCA) to statistically define AxD subtypes. RESULTS: LCA identified 2 classes of AxD. Type I is characterized by early onset, seizures, macrocephaly, motor delay, encephalopathy, failure to thrive, paroxysmal deterioration, and typical MRI features. Type II is characterized by later onset, autonomic dysfunction, ocular movement abnormalities, bulbar symptoms, and atypical MRI features. Survival analysis predicted a nearly 2-fold increase in mortality among patients with type I AxD relative to those with type II. R79 and R239 GFAP mutations were most common (16.6% and 20.3% of all cases, respectively). These common mutations predicted distinct clinical outcomes, with R239 predicting the most aggressive course. CONCLUSIONS: AAO and the GFAP mutation site are important clinical predictors in AxD, with clear correlations to defined patterns of phenotypic expression. We propose revised AxD subtypes, type I and type II, based on analysis of statistically defined patient groups.

[Digestive disorders in Parkinson's disease: dysphagia and sialorrhea]. / Trastornos digestivos en la enfermedad de Parkinson: disfagia y sialorrea.

INTRODUCTION: The non-motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease are a frequent and often under-diagnosed disorder. Two of the most significant non-motor symptoms are perhaps dysphagia and sialorrhea (which are relatively common in advanced stages of the disease) owing to their important functional repercussions and to the associated comorbidity. DEVELOPMENT AND CONCLUSIONS: In recent years, different evaluation scales have been developed for clinical use and in screening the aforementioned symptoms. Of the different therapeutic options available, botulinum toxin represents the preferred treatment for sialorrhea. In contrast, speech therapy and an optimisation of the antiparkinsonian therapy are generally useful measures to treat dysphagia, percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy being reserved for patients suffering from Parkinson who have severe dysphagia.

History of falls in Parkinson disease is associated with reduced cholinergic activity.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the relationships between history of falls and cholinergic vs dopaminergic denervation in patients with Parkinson disease (PD). BACKGROUND: There is a need to explore nondopaminergic mechanisms of gait control as the majority of motor impairments associated with falls in PD are resistant to dopaminergic treatment. Alterations in cholinergic neurotransmission in PD may be implicated because of evidence that gait control depends on cholinergic system-mediated higher-level cortical and subcortical processing, including pedunculopontine nucleus (PPN) function. METHODS: In this cross-sectional study, 44 patients with PD (Hoehn & Yahr stages I-III) without dementia and 15 control subjects underwent a clinical assessment and [(11)C]methyl-4-piperidinyl propionate (PMP) acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and [(11)C]dihydrotetrabenazine (DTBZ) vesicular monoamine transporter type 2 (VMAT2) brain PET imaging. RESULTS: Seventeen patients (38.6%) reported a history of falls and 27 patients had no falls. Analysis of covariance of the cortical AChE hydrolysis rates demonstrated reduced cortical AChE in the PD fallers group (-12.3%) followed by the PD nonfallers (-6.6%) compared to control subjects (F = 7.22, p = 0.0004). Thalamic AChE activity was lower only in the PD fallers group (-11.8%; F = 4.36, p = 0.008). There was no significant difference in nigrostriatal dopaminergic activity between PD fallers and nonfallers. CONCLUSIONS: Unlike nigrostriatal dopaminergic denervation, cholinergic hypofunction is associated with fall status in Parkinson disease (PD). Thalamic AChE activity in part represents cholinergic output of the pedunculopontine nucleus (PPN), a key node for gait control. Our results are consistent with other data indicating that PPN degeneration is a major factor leading to impaired postural control and gait dysfunction in PD.

Striatal [11C]dihydrotetrabenazine and [11C]methylphenidate binding in Tourette syndrome.

OBJECTIVE: Tourette syndrome (TS) is a common neurodevelopmental disorder marked by tics and behavioral comorbidities. Clinical pharmacology suggests that dopaminergic signaling abnormalities are part of the pathophysiology of TS. Prior molecular imaging studies of nigrostriatal dopaminergic terminal markers report conflicting results. Our goal was to characterize the distribution of nigrostriatal dopaminergic terminals in subjects with TS. METHODS: Thirty-three adult subjects with TS were studied with PET using [11C]dihydrotetrabenazine (DTBZ), a ligand for the type 2 vesicular monoamine transporter, and with [11C] methylphenidate (MP), a ligand for the plasmalemmal dopamine transporter. Subjects were characterized with standard rating instruments for tic severity, obsessive-compulsive behaviors, and attentional deficits. RESULTS: We found no differences between subjects with TS and control subjects in DTBZ and MP binding in any striatal region. There was no correlation between binding measures and clinical variables. Ventral striatal DTBZ and MP binding distributions in subjects with TS were normal. CONCLUSIONS: We found no evidence of increased striatal dopaminergic innervation in Tourette syndrome (TS). Discrepancy between our present results and those of other studies may be explained by heterogeneity of TS.

Decreased locomotor activity in mice expressing tTA under control of the CaMKII alpha promoter.

Transgenic mice in which the tetracycline transactivator (tTA) is driven by the forebrain-specific calcium-calmodulin-dependent kinase II alpha promoter (CaMKII alpha-tTA mice) are used to study the molecular genetics of many behaviors. These mice can be crossed with other transgenic mice carrying a transgene of interest coupled to the tetracycline-responsive promoter element to produce mice with forebrain-specific expression of the transgene under investigation. The value of using CaMKII alpha-tTA mice to study behavior, however, is dependent on the CaMKII alpha-tTA mice themselves lacking a behavioral phenotype with respect to the behaviors being studied. Here we present data that suggest CaMKII alpha-tTA mice have a behavioral phenotype distinct from that of their wild-type (WT) littermates. Most strikingly, we find that CaMKII alpha-tTA mice, both those with a C57BL/6NTac genetic background (B6-tTA) and those with a 129S6B6F1/Tac hybrid genetic background (F1-tTA), exhibit decreased locomotor activity compared with WT littermates that could be misinterpreted as altered anxiety-like behavior. Despite this impairment, neither B6-tTA nor F1-tTA mice perform differently than their WT littermates in two commonly used learning and memory paradigms - Pavlovian fear conditioning and Morris water maze. Additionally, we find data regarding motor coordination and balance to be mixed: B6-tTA mice, but not F1-tTA mice, exhibit impaired performance on the accelerating rotarod and both perform as well as their WT littermates on the balance beam.

TEACH-M: A pilot study evaluating an instructional sequence for persons with impaired memory and executive functions.

PRIMARY OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this pilot study was to evaluate an instructional package that facilitates learning and retention of multi-step procedures for persons with severe memory and executive function impairments resulting from traumatic brain injury. RESEARCH DESIGN: The study used a multiple baseline across participants design. METHODS AND PROCEDURES: Four participants, two males and two females, ranging in age from 36-58 years, were taught a 7-step e-mail task. The instructional package (TEACH-M) was the experimental intervention and the number of correct e-mail steps learned was the dependent variable. MAIN OUTCOMES AND RESULTS: Treatment effects were replicated across the four participants and maintained at 30 days post-treatment. Generalization and social validity data further supported the treatment programme. CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that individuals with severe cognitive impairments are capable of learning new skills. Directions for future research include application of the instructional package to other multi-step procedures.

Neuronal intranuclear inclusions and neuropil aggregates in HdhCAG(150) knockin mice.

We studied the development of neuronal intranuclear inclusions (NIIs), neuropil aggregates (NAs), and expression of expanded repeat polyglutamine protein in the HdhCAG(150) knockin mouse model of Huntington's disease (HD). Diffuse nuclear localization of huntingtin protein (htt) was noted initially within striatal neurons at approximately 28 weeks, followed by the development of striatal htt immunoreactive NIIs by approximately 40 weeks. Striatal NIIs were observed initially in clusters within the matrix compartment but subsequently became diffusely distributed throughout the striatum. In the oldest animals (107 weeks), NIIs were enlarged and diffuse nuclear htt immunoreactivity reduced. Expression of ubiquitin immunoreactive NIIs paralleled but lagged behind the expression of htt immunoreactive NIIs. Abundant NIIs were found by approximately 75 weeks in layers 3 and 4 of somatosensory cortex and in layer 2 of piriform cortex. In the oldest animals, greater than 100 weeks, some NIIs were found in many brain regions. NAs were found mainly within the globus pallidus and substantia nigra, perhaps reflecting expression in striatal terminals. Cyclic AMP response element binding protein (CBP) was not localized to NIIs, arguing against gross sequestration of this transcriptionally active protein. Comparison of the relative levels of a common polyglutamine epitope in HdhCAG(150) knockin and hprtCAG(146) knockin mice shows greater expression of the polyglutamine epitope in the phenotypically less aggressive HdhCAG(150) knockin line. HdhCAG(150) knockin mice may be a model of early pathologic changes in HD.

Sham surgery controls are mitigated trolleys.

Debate continues about the ethics of sham surgery controls. The most powerful argument for sham surgery controls is that rigorous experiments are needed to demonstrate safety and efficacy of surgical procedures. Without such experiments, there is danger of adopting worthless procedures in clinical practice. Opponents of sham surgery controls argue that sham surgery constitutes unacceptable violation of the rights of research subjects. Recent philosophical discussion has used two thought experiments-the transplant case and the trolley problem-to explore the circumstances under which individuals may be harmed to benefit a larger group. The transplant case is felt to exemplify circumstances that forbid harming some to benefit a larger group while the trolley problem exemplifies circumstances that permit harming some to benefit others. I argue that sham surgery controls satisfy criteria derived from the trolley problem and are morally permissible.

The role of radiotracer imaging in Parkinson disease.

Radiotracer imaging (RTI) of the nigrostriatal dopaminergic system is a widely used but controversial biomarker in Parkinson disease (PD). Here the authors review the concepts of biomarker development and the evidence to support the use of four radiotracers as biomarkers in PD: [18F]fluorodopa PET, (+)-[11C]dihydrotetrabenazine PET, [123I]beta-CIT SPECT, and [18F]fluorodeoxyglucose PET. Biomarkers used to study disease biology and facilitate drug discovery and early human trials rely on evidence that they are measuring relevant biologic processes. The four tracers fulfill this criterion, although they do not measure the number or density of dopaminergic neurons. Biomarkers used as diagnostic tests, prognostic tools, or surrogate endpoints must not only have biologic relevance but also a strong linkage to the clinical outcome of interest. No radiotracers fulfill these criteria, and current evidence does not support the use of imaging as a diagnostic tool in clinical practice or as a surrogate endpoint in clinical trials. Mechanistic information added by RTI to clinical trials may be difficult to interpret because of uncertainty about the interaction between the interventions and the tracer.

Differential loss of striatal projection systems in Huntington's disease: a quantitative immunohistochemical study.

Prior studies suggest differences exist among striatal projection neuron types in their vulnerability to Huntington's disease (HD). In the present study, we immunolabeled the fibers and terminals of the four main types of striatal projection neuron in their target areas for substance P, enkephalin, or glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD), and used computer-assisted image analysis to quantify the abundance of immunolabeled terminals in a large sample of HD cases ranging from grade 0 to grade 4 [J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol. 44 (1985) 559], normalized to labeling in control human brains. Our goal was to characterize the relative rates of loss of the two striatopallidal projection systems (to the internal versus the external pallidal segments) and the two striatonigral projections systems (to pars compacta versus pars reticulata). The findings for GAD and the two neuropeptides were similar--the striatal projection to the external pallidal segment was the most vulnerable, showing substantial loss by grade 1. Loss of fibers in both subdivisions of the substantia nigra was also already great by grade 1. By contrast, the loss in the striatal projection system to the internal segment of globus pallidus proceeded more gradually. By grade 4 of HD, however, profound loss in all projection systems was apparent. These findings support the notion that the striatal neurons preferentially projecting to the internal pallidal segment are, in fact, less vulnerable in HD than are the other striatal projection neuron types.

Increased ventral striatal monoaminergic innervation in Tourette syndrome.

BACKGROUND: Excessive striatal dopaminergic innervation is suggested to underlie Tourette syndrome (TS). Prior imaging and postmortem studies yield conflicting data. METHODS: The authors used PET with the type 2 vesicular monoamine transporter ligand [(11)C]dihydrotetrabenazine (DTBZ) to quantify striatal monoaminergic innervation in patients with TS (n = 19) and control subjects (n = 27). Compartmental modeling was used to determine blood to brain ligand transport (K(1)) and tissue to plasma distribution volume (a measure of ligand binding) during continuous infusion of DTBZ. TS data were compared with control data using predefined regions of interest and on a voxel by voxel basis. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in ligand binding or ligand transport between patients with TS and control subjects in the dorsal striatum. With voxel by voxel analysis, there was increased DTBZ binding in the right ventral striatum. CONCLUSIONS: Previously reported differences between patients with TS and control subjects in dorsal striatal dopamine terminal markers may reflect medication-induced regulation of terminal marker expression or be the result of intrinsic differences in striatal dopaminergic synaptic function. Increased right ventral striatal DTBZ binding suggests that abnormal ventral striatal dopaminergic innervation may underlie tics.

Sham surgery controls: intracerebral grafting of fetal tissue for Parkinson's disease and proposed criteria for use of sham surgery controls.

Sham surgery is a controversial and rarely used component of randomised clinical trials evaluating surgical interventions. The recent use of sham surgery in trials evaluating efficacy of intracerebral fetal tissue grafts in Parkinson's disease has highlighted the ethical concerns associated with sham surgery controls. Macklin, and Dekkers and Boer argue vigorously against use of sham surgery controls. Macklin presents a broad argument against sham surgery controls while Dekkers and Boer present a narrower argument that sham surgery is unnecessary in the specific setting of fetal tissue engraftment for Parkinson's disease. I defend sham surgery controls against both these criticisms. Appropriate clinical trial design, sometimes including sham surgery, is needed to ensure that false positive trial results do not occur and endanger public safety. Results of a completed trial of fetal tissue grafting for Parkinson's disease are used to illustrate the potential benefits of, and problems associated with, sham surgery controls. Sham surgery controls, however, should be employed only when absolutely necessary. I suggest criteria for appropriate use of sham surgery controls.