RESUMO
Objetivo Comparar el efecto preventivo de caries dental de dos frecuencias de aplicación de barniz fluorado (BF) con un grupo que utilizó instrucciones de cepillado con dentífrico fluorado. Materiales y Método Se siguieron durante 22 meses a 203 niños de una escuela primaria en la delegación Tláhuac, Ciudad de México, quienes fueron asignados aleatoriamente a uno de los siguientes grupos: 1) instrucciones de cepillado con dentífrico fluorado 3 veces al año, 2) BF semestral, 3) BF tres aplicaciones semanales al año. El BF contenía fluorosilano (1000 ppm F), el dentífrico NaF (1450 ppm F). Se registró el índice de caries CPOD y la presencia de manchas blancas usando los criterios del ICDAS (International Caries Detection and Assessment System). Resultados Al inicio del estudio, el promedio de edad fue 9,3 (DE 0,76) años, el promedio de lesiones blancas 0,63 (DE 1,48) y del CPOD 0,70 (DE 1,11). CPOD inicial y final en los tres grupos fueron: instrucciones de cepillado usando dentífrico fluorado 0,67 y 1,17, BF semestral 0,77 y 1,46 y grupo BF 3 aplicaciones 0,67 y 1,03, respectivamente.. De acuerdo a los resultados del modelo GEE (Generalized Estimating Equations), no se detectaron diferencias significativas en el incremento de lesiones blancas o en el CPOD para el índice de caries (CPOD) entre los tres grupo; para el CPOD las aplicaciones semestrales mostraron RR=1,24 (p=0,178) y para 3 aplicaciones RR=0,83, (p=0,298), comparando con el grupo de instrucciones de cepillado con dentífrico fluorado, controlando por edad, sexo, cpod inicial y frecuencia de cepillado. Conclusiones Los escolares mostraron una baja incidencia de caries utilizando cualquiera de los tres regímenes preventivos aplicados.(AU)
Objective To compare preventive effect on dental caries of two frequencies of fluoridated varnish (FV) applications and a group given brushing instructions and using fluoridated toothpaste. Materials and Methods Follow-up study of 203 children attending an elementary school in the municipality of Tláhuac, Mexico City. The children were followed for 22 months. The students were randomly assigned to one of the following groups: 1) brushing instructions with fluoridated toothpaste, 2) FV every six months, 3) three FV applications per week per year. The FV contained fluorosilane (1000 ppm F) and NaF dentifrice (1450 ppm F). The DMFT-caries index and the presence of white spots were recorded (ICDAS, International Caries Detection and Assessment System). Results At baseline, the mean age of the children was 9.3 (SD 0.76) years, white lesions 0.63 (SD 1.48) and DMFT =0.70 (SD 1.11). Averages of the initial and final DMFT scores in the three groups were 0.67 and 1.17 for the toothpaste group, 0.77 and 1.46 for FV twice a year group, and 0.67 y 1.03 for the three-applications-FV group. According to the results of the GEE (Generalized-Estimating Equations) model, there were no significant differences in the rate of white lesions or the increase of the DMFT index. The results for the DMFT were: for bi-annual applications of FV, RR=1.24 (p=0.178) and for the three consecutive applications of FV, RR=0.83, (p=0.298) in comparison with the brushing-instructions group using fluoridated toothpaste, among the three treatment groups, controlling for age, sex, and initial-caries index in primary teeth and brushing frequency. Conclusions Schoolchildren showed a low incidence of caries using any of the three preventive regimens applied.(AU)
Assuntos
Humanos , Criança , Higiene Bucal/métodos , Cremes Dentais/administração & dosagem , Cárie Dentária/prevenção & controle , Flúor/administração & dosagem , México/epidemiologiaRESUMO
Objective To compare preventive effect on dental caries of two frequencies of fluoridated varnish (FV) applications and a group given brushing instructions and using fluoridated toothpaste. Materials and Methods Follow-up study of 203 children attending an elementary school in the municipality of Tláhuac, Mexico City. The children were followed for 22 months. The students were randomly assigned to one of the following groups: 1) brushing instructions with fluoridated toothpaste, 2) FV every six months, 3) three FV applications per week per year. The FV contained fluorosilane (1000 ppm F) and NaF dentifrice (1450 ppm F). The DMFT-caries index and the presence of white spots were recorded (ICDAS, International Caries Detection and Assessment System). Results At baseline, the mean age of the children was 9.3 (SD 0.76) years, white lesions 0.63 (SD 1.48) and DMFT =0.70 (SD 1.11). Averages of the initial and final DMFT scores in the three groups were 0.67 and 1.17 for the toothpaste group, 0.77 and 1.46 for FV twice a year group, and 0.67 y 1.03 for the three-applications-FV group. According to the results of the GEE (Generalized-Estimating Equations) model, there were no significant differences in the rate of white lesions or the increase of the DMFT index. The results for the DMFT were: for bi-annual applications of FV, RR=1.24 (p=0.178) and for the three consecutive applications of FV, RR=0.83, (p=0.298) in comparison with the brushing-instructions group using fluoridated toothpaste, among the three treatment groups, controlling for age, sex, and initial-caries index in primary teeth and brushing frequency. Conclusions Schoolchildren showed a low incidence of caries using any of the three preventive regimens applied.