Fluorine substitutions in an antigenic peptide selectively modulate T-cell receptor binding in a minimally perturbing manner.

TCR (T-cell receptor) recognition of antigenic peptides bound and presented by MHC (major histocompatibility complex) molecules forms the basis of the cellular immune response to pathogens and cancer. TCRs bind peptide-MHC complexes weakly and with fast kinetics, features which have hindered detailed biophysical studies of these interactions. Modified peptides resulting in enhanced TCR binding could help overcome these challenges. Furthermore, there is considerable interest in using modified peptides with enhanced TCR binding as the basis for clinical vaccines. In the present study, we examined how fluorine substitutions in an antigenic peptide can selectively impact TCR recognition. Using a structure-guided design approach, we found that fluorination of the Tax peptide [HTLV (human T-cell lymphotropic virus)-1 Tax(11-19)] enhanced binding by the Tax-specific TCR A6, yet weakened binding by the Tax-specific TCR B7. The changes in affinity were consistent with crystallographic structures and fluorine chemistry, and with the A6 TCR independent of other substitutions in the interface. Peptide fluorination thus provides a means to selectively modulate TCR binding affinity without significantly perturbing peptide composition or structure. Lastly, we probed the mechanism of fluorine's effect on TCR binding and we conclude that our results were most consistent with a 'polar hydrophobicity' mechanism, rather than a purely hydrophobic- or electrostatic-based mechanism. This finding should have an impact on other attempts to alter molecular recognition with fluorine.

Methods for quantifying T cell receptor binding affinities and thermodynamics.

αß T cell receptors (TCRs) recognize peptide antigens bound and presented by class I or class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins. Recognition of a peptide/MHC complex is required for initiation and propagation of a cellular immune response, as well as the development and maintenance of the T cell repertoire. Here, we discuss methods to quantify the affinities and thermodynamics of interactions between soluble ectodomains of TCRs and their peptide/MHC ligands, focusing on titration calorimetry, surface plasmon resonance, and fluorescence anisotropy. As TCRs typically bind ligand with weak-to-moderate affinities, we focus the discussion on means to enhance the accuracy and precision of low-affinity measurements. In addition to further elucidating the biology of the T cell mediated immune response, more reliable low-affinity measurements will aid with more probing studies with mutants or altered peptides that can help illuminate the physical underpinnings of how TCRs achieve their remarkable recognition properties.

Conformational changes and flexibility in T-cell receptor recognition of peptide-MHC complexes.

A necessary feature of the immune system, TCR (T-cell receptor) cross-reactivity has been implicated in numerous autoimmune pathologies and is an underlying cause of transplant rejection. Early studies of the interactions of alphabeta TCRs (T-cell receptors) with their peptide-MHC ligands suggested that conformational plasticity in the TCR CDR (complementarity determining region) loops is a dominant contributor to T-cell cross-reactivity. Since these initial studies, the database of TCRs whose structures have been solved both bound and free is now large enough to permit general conclusions to be drawn about the extent of TCR plasticity and the types and locations of motion that occur. In the present paper, we review the conformational differences between free and bound TCRs, quantifying the structural changes that occur and discussing their possible roles in specificity and cross-reactivity. We show that, rather than undergoing major structural alterations or 'folding' upon binding, the majority of TCR CDR loops shift by relatively small amounts. The structural changes that do occur are dominated by hinge-bending motions, with loop remodelling usually occurring near loop apexes. As predicted from previous studies, the largest changes are in the hypervariable CDR3alpha and CDR3beta loops, although in some cases the germline-encoded CDR1alpha and CDR2alpha loops shift in magnitudes that approximate those of the CDR3 loops. Intriguingly, the smallest shifts are in the germline-encoded loops of the beta-chain, consistent with recent suggestions that the TCR beta domain may drive ligand recognition.

Thermodynamics of T-cell receptor-peptide/MHC interactions: progress and opportunities.

alphabeta T-cell receptors (TCRs) recognize peptide antigens presented by class I or class II major histocompatibility complex molecules (pMHC). Here we review the use of thermodynamic measurements in the study of TCR-pMHC interactions, with attention to the diversity in binding thermodynamics and how this is related to the variation in TCR-pMHC interfaces. We show that there is no enthalpic or entropic signature for TCR binding; rather, enthalpy and entropy changes vary in a compensatory manner that reflects a narrow free energy window for the interactions that have been characterized. Binding enthalpy and entropy changes do not correlate with structural features such as buried surface area or the number of hydrogen bonds within TCR-pMHC interfaces, possibly reflecting the myriad of contributors to binding thermodynamics, but likely also reflecting a reliance on van't Hoff over calorimetric measurements and the unaccounted influence of equilibria linked to binding. TCR-pMHC binding heat capacity changes likewise vary considerably. In some cases, the heat capacity changes are consistent with conformational differences between bound and free receptors, but there is little data indicating these conformational differences represent the need to organize disordered CDR loops. In this regard, we discuss how thermodynamics may provide additional insight into conformational changes occurring upon TCR binding. Finally, we highlight opportunities for the further use of thermodynamic measurements in the study of TCR-pMHC interactions, not only for understanding TCR binding in general, but also for understanding specifics of individual interactions and the engineering of TCRs with desired molecular recognition properties.

Kinetics of thermal unfolding of phenylalanine hydroxylase variants containing different metal cofactors (FeII, CoII, and ZnII) and their isokinetic relationship.

The kinetics of thermal unfolding of apo- and holo-Chromobacterium violaceum phenylalanine hydroxylase (cPAH) was investigated using circular dichroism (CD) over the temperature range 44-76 degrees C. In addition to the native cofactor (FeII), the unfolding kinetics of holo-cPAH was characterized using ZnII and CoII as cofactors. Kinetic profiles for apo- and holo-cPAH showed a single-phase exponential rise in the CD signal at lambda=222 nm and a first-order dependence on protein concentration. The extrapolated unfolding rate constants (ku) at ambient temperature followed the order apo>Fe>Zn>>Co. Transition-state analysis of the activation parameters revealed an isokinetic correlation, which suggests a common mechanism for the enzyme variants. The values of the entropy of activation (DeltaS++) for apo- and Fe-cPAH were negative but small: -34+/-24 and -32+/-18 J mol(-1) K(-1), respectively. On the other hand, DeltaS++ values for Zn- and Co-cPAH were large and positive: 54+/-9 and 175+/-27 J mol(-1) K(-1), respectively. Therefore, at higher temperatures the unfolding rates of Zn- and Co-cPAH are affected significantly by entropy, while the unfolding rates of apo- and Fe-cPAH are dominated by enthalpy even at higher temperatures. The rate of unfolding of holo-cPAH did not depend on excess metal concentrations and maintained single-phase kinetic profiles, refuting the occurrence of adventitious metal binding and the notion that unfolding occurs via apo-cPAH exclusively. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) was employed to measure cPAH binding affinities for Fe, Zn, and Co as well as the enthalpy of metal coordination. Dissociation constants (Kd) decreased in the order Fe>Zn>Co. The non-native metals, Zn and Co, were bound more tightly than Fe. The activation enthalpy for unfolding (DeltaH++) displayed a linear correlation with the enthalpy of metal binding obtained from ITC measurements (DeltaHITC). On this basis, a common mechanism (transition state) is suggested for this family of metal cofactors, and the varying enthalpy of activation arises from the differing stabilities of enzyme variants having different metal cofactors.

A comprehensive calorimetric investigation of an entropically driven T cell receptor-peptide/major histocompatibility complex interaction.

The alphabeta T cell receptor (TCR) is responsible for recognizing peptides bound and "presented" by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. We recently reported that at 25 degrees C the A6 TCR, which recognizes the Tax peptide presented by the class I MHC human leukocyte antigen-A*0201 (HLA-A2), binds with a weak DeltaH degrees , a favorable DeltaS degrees , and a moderately negative DeltaC(p). These observations were of interest given the unfavorable binding entropies and large heat capacity changes measured for many other TCR-ligand interactions, suggested to result from TCR conformational changes occurring upon binding. Here, we further investigated the A6-Tax/HLA-A2 interaction using titration calorimetry. We found that binding results in a pK(a) shift, complicating interpretation of measured binding thermodynamics. To better characterize the interaction, we measured binding as a function of pH, temperature, and buffer ionization enthalpy. A global analysis of the resulting data allowed determination of both the intrinsic binding thermodynamics separated from the influence of protonation as well as the thermodynamics associated with the pK(a) shift. Our results indicate that intrinsically, A6 binds Tax/HLA-A2 with a very weak DeltaH degrees , an even more favorable DeltaS degrees than previously thought, and a relatively large negative DeltaC(p). Comparison of these energetics with the makeup of the protein-protein interface suggests that conformational adjustments are required for binding, but these are more likely to be structural shifts, rather than disorder-to-order transitions. The thermodynamics of the pK(a) shift suggest protonation may be linked to an additional process such as ion binding.

Unraveling a hotspot for TCR recognition on HLA-A2: evidence against the existence of peptide-independent TCR binding determinants.

T cell receptor (TCR) recognition of peptide takes place in the context of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule, which accounts for approximately two-thirds of the peptide/MHC buried surface. Using the class I MHC HLA-A2 and a large panel of mutants, we have previously shown that surface mutations that disrupt TCR recognition vary with the identity of the peptide. The single exception is Lys66 on the HLA-A2 alpha1 helix, which when mutated to alanine disrupts recognition for 93% of over 250 different T cell clones or lines, independent of which peptide is bound. Thus, Lys66 could serve as a peptide-independent TCR binding determinant. Here, we have examined the role of Lys66 in TCR recognition of HLA-A2 in detail. The structure of a peptide/HLA-A2 molecule with the K66A mutation indicates that although the mutation induces no major structural changes, it results in the exposure of a negatively charged glutamate (Glu63) underneath Lys66. Concurrent replacement of Glu63 with glutamine restores TCR binding and function for T cells specific for five different peptides presented by HLA-A2. Thus, the positive charge on Lys66 does not serve to guide all TCRs onto the HLA-A2 molecule in a manner required for productive signaling. Furthermore, electrostatic calculations indicate that Lys66 does not contribute to the stability of two TCR-peptide/HLA-A2 complexes. Our findings are consistent with the notion that each TCR arrives at a unique solution of how to bind a peptide/MHC, most strongly influenced by the chemical and structural features of the bound peptide. This would not rule out an intrinsic affinity of TCRs for MHC molecules achieved through multiple weak interactions, but for HLA-A2 the collective mutational data place limits on the role of any single MHC amino acid side-chain in driving TCR binding in a peptide-independent fashion.

Two different T cell receptors use different thermodynamic strategies to recognize the same peptide/MHC ligand.

A6 and B7 are two alphabeta T cell receptors (TCRs) that recognize the Tax peptide presented by the class I major histocompatibility molecule HLA-A2 (Tax/HLA-A2). Despite the fact that the two TCRs have different CDR loops and use different amino acid residues to contact their ligand, both receptors bind ligand with similar diagonal orientations. Here we show that they also bind with very similar binding affinities and kinetics (the DeltaDeltaG degrees for binding is approximately 0.3kcal/mol at 25 degrees C). The two receptors respond similarly to alterations in the MHC molecule, yet differ dramatically in their responses to ionic strength and temperature. The different responses to temperature indicate markedly different binding thermodynamics, which are not predictable from the surface area buried in the interfaces. A6 and B7 thus represent two TCRs that are both compatible with Tax/HLA-A2, although compatibility has been achieved through the use of different thermodynamic strategies. Finally, neither A6 nor B7 are predicted to undergo large conformational adaptations upon binding, distinguishing them from a number of other TCRs whose structure, thermodynamics, and kinetics have been characterized.

Proton transfer in gramicidin channels is modulated by the thickness of monoglyceride bilayers.

The thickness of monoglyceride planar bilayers has significant effects on the transfer of protons in both native gramicidin A (gA) and in covalently linked SS- and RR-dioxolane-linked gA proteins. Planar bilayers with various thicknesses were formed from an appropriate combination of monoglyceride with various fatty acid lengths and solvent. Bilayer thicknesses ranged from 25 A (monoolein in squalene) to 54 A (monoeicosenoin in decane). Single-channel conductances to protons (g(H)) were measured in the concentration range of 10-5000 mM HCl. In native gA as well as in RR channels, the shape of the log(g(H))-log([H(+)]) relationships was nonlinear and remained basically unaltered in monoglyceride bilayers with various thicknesses. For both native gA and RR channels, g(H) values were systematically and significantly larger in thin than in thick bilayers. By contrast, the shape of the log(g(H))-log([H(+)]) relationships in the SS channel was linear (with a slope considerably smaller than 1) in thick (>37 A) bilayers. However, in thin (<37 A) bilayers these plots became nonlinear and g(H) values approached those obtained in native gA channels. The linearization of the log-log plots in the SS channel in thick bilayers is a consequence of a dramatic increase (instead of a decrease as in native gA and RR channels) of g(H) in these bilayers in [H(+)] <1 M. The gating characteristics of the various gA channels as a function of bilayer thickness followed the same pattern as described previously. It was noticed, however, that in the thickest monoglyceride bilayer used in this study, both the SS- and RR-dioxolane-linked channels opened in a mode of bursting activity instead of remaining in the open state as in thin bilayers. It is proposed that the thickness of monoglyceride bilayers modulates proton transfer in native gA channels by a combination of factors including the access resistances of channels to H(+), and fluctuations in both the structure of the lipid bilayer and in the distance between gA monomers. The differential effects of relatively thick monoglyceride bilayers on proton transfer in both dioxolane-linked gA channels must relate to distinct interactions between the bilayers and the SS and RR dioxolanes.

On the origin of closing flickers in gramicidin channels: a new hypothesis.

The submillisecond closing events (flickers) and the single channel conductances to protons (g(H)) were studied in native gramicidin A (gA) and in the SS and RR diastereoisomers of dioxolane-linked gA channels in planar bilayers. Bilayers were formed from glycerylmonooleate (GMO) in various solvents. In GMO/decane (thick) bilayers, the largest flicker frequency occurred in the SS channel (39 s(-1)), followed by the RR (4 s(-1)) and native gA channels (3 s(-1)). These frequencies were attenuated in GMO/squalene (thin) bilayers by 100-, 30-, and 70-fold in the SS, RR, and native gA channels, respectively. In thin bilayers, the average burst duration of native gA channels was 30-fold longer than in thick bilayers. The RR dioxolane-linked gA dimer "inactivated" in GMO/decane but not in squalene-containing bilayers. The mean closed time of flickers (approximately 0.12 ms) was essentially the same in various gA channels. In thin bilayers, g(H) values were larger by approximately 10% (SS), 30% (RR), and 20% (native gA) in relation to thick bilayers. It is concluded that flickers are not related to pre-dissociation or dissociation states of gA monomers, and do not seem to be caused by intrinsic conformational changes of channel proteins. It is proposed that flickers are caused by undulations of the bilayer that obliterate the openings of gA channels. Differences between flicker frequencies in various gA channels are likely to result from variations in channel geometries at the bilayer/channel interface. The smaller g(H) in thick bilayers suggests that the deformation of these bilayers around the gA channel creates a diffusional pathway next to the mouths of the channel that is longer and more restrictive than in thin GMO bilayers. A possible molecular interpretation for these effects is attempted.