Quantification of surface functional groups on silica nanoparticles: comparison of thermogravimetric analysis and quantitative NMR.

Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) coupled with evolved gas analysis-FT-IR has been examined as a potential method to study the functional group content for surface modified silica nanoparticles. A comparison with a quantitative solution NMR method based on analysis of groups released after dissolution of the silica matrix is used to provide benchmark data for comparison and to assess the utility and limitations of TGA. This study focused primarily on commercially available silicas and tested whether it was possible to use a correction based on bare silica to account for the significant mass loss that occurs due to condensation of surface hydroxyl groups and loss of matrix-entrapped components at temperatures above ∼200 °C. Although this approach has been used successfully in the literature for in-house prepared samples, it was problematic for commercial silicas prepared by the Stöber method. For these materials the agreement between estimates from qNMR and TGA mass loss was poor in many cases. However much better agreement was observed for samples for which the mass loss above 200 °C is relatively low, such as non-porous silica, or samples for which the mass fraction of functional group is large (e.g., high molecule weight groups or multilayers). FT-IR was useful in identifying the likely structure of the components lost from the surface at various temperatures and in some cases provided evidence of contaminants in the sample. Nevertheless, in other cases correlation of thermograms and FT-IR with NMR data was necessary, particularly for samples where multi-step modification of the silica surface results in incomplete functionalization that gives a mixture of products. Overall the results indicate that TGA provides reliable results for silicas of low porosity or those for which the functional group accounts for a significant fraction of the total sample mass. It is also suitable as a supplementary or screening technique to indicate the presence of coatings or covalent surface modification, prior to applying other techniques or for routine analyses where sensitivity is not critical.

Quantification of amine functional groups on silica nanoparticles: a multi-method approach.

Surface chemistry is an important factor for quality control during production of nanomaterials and for controlling their behavior in applications and when released into the environment. Here we report a comparison of four methods for quantifying amine functional groups on silica nanoparticles (NPs). Two colorimetric assays are examined, ninhydrin and 4-nitrobenzaldehyde, which are convenient for routine analysis and report on reagent accessible amines. Results from the study of a range of commercial NPs with different sizes and surface loadings show that the assays account for 50-100% of the total amine content, as determined by dissolution of NPs under basic conditions and quantification by solution-state 1H NMR. To validate the surface quantification by the colorimetric assays, the NPs are modified with a trifluoromethylated benzaldehyde probe to enhance sensitivity for quantitative 19F solid state NMR and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). Good agreement between the assays and the determination from solid-state NMR is reinforced by elemental ratios from XPS, which indicate that in most cases the difference between total and accessible amine content reflects amines that are outside the depth probed by XPS. Overall the combined results serve to validate the relatively simple colorimetric assays and indicate that the reactions are efficient at quantifying surface amines, by contrast to some other covalent modifications that have been employed for functional group quantification.

Quantification and Stability Determination of Surface Amine Groups on Silica Nanoparticles Using Solution NMR.

Surface chemistry is a critical factor for determining the behavior of a nanomaterial after incorporation in composites, devices, and biomedical products, and is also important for nanotoxicology studies. We have developed an optimized protocol for dissolution of aminated silicas and determination of functional-group contents by quantitative 1H NMR (qNMR) analysis of the released amines. A number of variables were optimized for the dissolution protocol, including the base concentration, mass of silica, time, temperature, and method of sample agitation, in order to achieve adequate NMR signals for quantification. The protocol was tested using nanoparticles from a single commercial supplier with sizes ranging from 20 to 120 nm that were functionalized with 3-aminopropyl groups. Interestingly the batch-to-batch variability for some sizes of these aminated silicas was as high as 50%. Amine contents measured by a ninhydrin colorimetric assay were typically ∼20% lower than those measured by qNMR, consistent with measurement of only ninhydrin-reagent accessible amines. The dissolution-qNMR protocol was compatible with aminated silicas from other commercial suppliers, and in these cases, an even larger variability in surface coverage was observed. Silica nanoparticles with longer-chain amines and variable amine loadings were synthesized to demonstrate the ability to quantify amines with more complex structures and to assess the limit of quantification for the dissolution-qNMR method. Finally, the stability of the aminated nanoparticles was examined. Loss of 3-aminopropyl groups occurred in water at room temperature and was significantly more rapid at higher temperatures. Amine loss increased with increasing surface coverage and was slower for long-chain amines, consistent with studies of amine stability on planar silica. Overall, this work highlights the importance of developing methods for quantifying surface functionalization, particularly given the variability in surface coverage for commercial samples, and for ensuring that the amine group is stable under its usage conditions.

Interaction of saponin 1688 with phase separated lipid bilayers.

Saponins are a diverse family of naturally occurring plant triterpene or steroid glycosides that have a wide range of biological activities. They have been shown to permeabilize membranes and in some cases membrane disruption has been hypothesized to involve saponin/cholesterol complexes. We have examined the interaction of steroidal saponin 1688-1 with lipid membranes that contain cholesterol and have a mixture of liquid-ordered (Lo) and liquid-disordered (Ld) phases as a model for lipid rafts in cellular membranes. A combination of atomic force microscopy (AFM) and fluorescence was used to probe the effect of saponin on the bilayer. The results demonstrate that saponin forms defects in the membrane and also leads to formation of small aggregates on the membrane surface. Although most of the membrane damage occurs in the liquid-disordered phase, fluorescence results demonstrate that saponin localizes in both ordered and disordered membrane phases, with a modest preference for the disordered regions. Similar effects are observed for both direct incorporation of saponin in the lipid mixture used to make vesicles/bilayers and for incubation of saponin with preformed bilayers. The results suggest that the initial sites of interaction are at the interface between the domains and surrounding disordered phase. The preference for saponin localization in the disordered phase may reflect the ease of penetration of saponin into a less ordered membrane, rather than the actual cholesterol concentration in the membrane. Dye leakage assays indicate that a high concentration of saponin is required for membrane permeabilization consistent with the supported lipid bilayer experiments.

The interaction of streptococcal enolase with canine plasminogen: the role of surfaces in complex formation.

The enolase from Streptococcus pyogenes (Str enolase F137L/E363G) is a homo-octamer shaped like a donut. Plasminogen (Pgn) is a monomeric protein composed of seven discrete separated domains organized into a lock washer. The enolase is known to bind Pgn. In past work we searched for conditions in which the two proteins would bind to one another. The two native proteins in solution would not bind under any of the tried conditions. We found that if the structures were perturbed binding would occur. We stated that only the non-native Str enolase or Pgn would interact such that we could detect binding. We report here the results of a series of dual polarization interferometry (DPI) experiments coupled with atomic force microscopy (AFM), isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), dynamic light scattering (DLS), and fluorescence. We show that the critical condition for forming stable complexes of the two native proteins involves Str enolase binding to a surface. Surfaces that attract Str enolase are a sufficient condition for binding Pgn. Under certain conditions, Pgn adsorbed to a surface will bind Str enolase.

Membrane selectivity and biophysical studies of the antimicrobial peptide GL13K.

GL13K is a short (13 amino acid) antimicrobial peptide derived from the parotid secretory protein. GL13K has been found to exhibit anti-inflammatory and antibacterial activities in physiological salt conditions. We investigated the mechanism of interaction of GL13K, with model membranes comprising 1, 2-dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC) and 1, 2-dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol (DOPG) using various biophysical and imaging techniques. Circular dichroism studies showed that GL13K adopts a ß-sheet structure in the presence of negatively charged DOPG liposomes while it retains its random coil structure with zwitterionic DOPC liposomes. GL13K did not cause any fusion of these liposomes but was able to selectively disrupt the negatively charged membranes of DOPG leading to vesicular leakage. There was no or minimal evidence of GL13K interaction with DOPC liposomes, however an analysis of supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) using atomic force microscopic (AFM) imaging and dual polarization interferometry (DPI) suggested that GL13K can interact with the surface of a DOPC planar bilayer. In the case of DOPG bilayers, AFM and DPI clearly showed membrane thinned regions where a portion of lipid molecules has been removed. These results suggest that the mechanism of GL13K action on bacterial membranes involves localized removal of lipid from the membrane via peptide-induced micellization.