Development and validation of a ddPCR assay to detect and quantify tobacco DNA in smoke and smokeless tobacco and tobacco-free products.

The last decade, smoke and smokeless products claiming to be tobacco-free, including herbal cigarettes and herbal shisha, became available on the European market and gained popularity. This study proposes a new digital droplet PCR (ddPCR) method, designed based on a previously developed real-time PCR (qPCR) method being currently used by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to specifically detect the presence of tobacco DNA in targeting a sequence from the Nicotiana tabacum nia-1 gene. To ensure a harmonized and reliable control by enforcement laboratories, both of these qPCR and ddPCR methods were then evaluated and validated for their compliance to an international standard. First, the performance of these PCR-based methods was successfully assessed as specific and sensitive, and in line with minimum performance requirements from international standard. Secondly, the transferability to external laboratory was confirmed for these PCR-based methods. Finally, the applicability of these PCR-based methods was demonstrated using 7 ground tobacco reference materials from the Tobacco Research Center (TRC) Toronto University as well as 6 commercial smokeless and tobacco-free smoke and smokeless products. Based on this study, the previously developed qPCR method was confirmed as complying with international standard, ensuring a efficient and harmonize use by enforcement laboratories for tobacco control on the European market. Moreover, this study proposed to enforcement laboratories the possibility to use a ddPCR method, enabling the simultaneous detection and absolute quantification of tobacco DNA as well as a limited impact of PCR inhibitors.

The analysis of cannabinoids in e-cigarette liquids using LC-HRAM-MS and LC-UV.

The use of cannabidiol or CBD products has skyrocketed in the last five years due to the alleged therapeutic benefits, a low potential for abuse and lack of the typical psychoactive effects associated with the use of cannabis products containing high levels of ∆9-tetrahydrocannabinol (∆9-THC). In Belgium, CBD-containing e-liquids with a total THC content lower than 0.2% (w/w) are currently legal. In order to verify the compliance of the different CBD-containing e-cigarette liquids that are available to the Belgian population, a method was developed for screening of 17 cannabinoids and to quantify the major cannabinoids such as CBD, CBDA, ∆9-THC and ∆9-THCA. The latter was fully validated using the 'total error' approach, applying accuracy profiles and conforming to ISO17025. None of the analysed samples exceeded the legal limit for the total amount of ∆9-THC present. However, of the 20 CBD-liquids investigated in this study, only 30% of the samples contained an amount of CBD that was within 10% deviation of the label claim. Moreover, the CBD e-liquids labelled "full/broad spectrum" consisted of several minor alkaloids in comparison to the "classic" CBD e-liquids where the acidic forms of the cannabinoids were not present. Currently, no legislation is available for the regulation of CBD e-liquids, however these results indicate that quality controls are pertinent especially concerning the discrepancy in CBD label accuracy.

Discrepancies between validated GC-FID and UHPLC-DAD methods for the analysis of Δ-9-THC and CBD in dried hemp flowers.

Herbal products for smoking containing cannabidiol (CBD) are available as "low-tetrahydrocannabinol cannabis products" in most EU countries. In Belgium, Δ9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) content of these products must be less than 0.2% w/w, which is also the limit for agricultural hemp. For agricultural hemp, the official and only valid method for European regulators is gas-chromatography coupled to flame ionization detector (GC-FID). There is no such method, for smoking products. Many of these herbal for smoking products are analyzed as part of their quality control and have certificate of analysis. During surveillance by official labs, discrepancies were seen between the official results and the certificate of analysis. In this study, a GC-FID method based on the European method and an ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography coupled to diode array detection (UHPLC-DAD) method were validated and applied for samples analysis in order to investigate these discrepancies. The GC-FID method shows better results for the validation parameters; notably, it has ß-expectation tolerance limits within 10% with a ß value of 95% while the validated UHPLC-DAD method has ß-expectation tolerance limits within 15% with a ß value of 90%. Furthermore, the other parameters evaluated are generally better with the GC-FID method. The statistic t test shows that the difference between both methods was significantly different for total-THC, but not significantly different for the total-CBD. The authors state that, as for agricultural hemp, the GC-FID method is to be preferred for the analysis of THC and CBD in products for smoking.

Impact of the Revised European Tobacco Product Directive on the Quality of E-cigarette Refill Liquids in Belgium.

INTRODUCTION: Since its introduction, the e-cigarette has become a commonly used consumer product. In this study, we investigate whether regulatory changes had an impact on the quality of refill liquids (e-liquids) available on the Belgian market through analysis of their chemical composition. Hence, the nicotine concentration accuracy was investigated in samples before, during and after the implementation of the revised Tobacco Product Directive (TPD) as an indicator of good manufacturing practices. This is, however, not enough to assure the quality. Therefore, extra criteria were also assessed based on TPD requirements. METHODS: By using in-house validated methods, a total of 246 e-liquids purchased prior (2013-2015), during (2016) and after (2017-2018) the implementation of the TPD revisions, were analyzed for the presence of nicotine, nicotine-related impurities, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), caffeine and taurine, and the flavors diacetyl and acetylpropionyl. RESULTS: Although not all manufacturers managed to produce and label their products accurately, nicotine labeling discrepancies have decreased over time. Moreover, also the number of e-liquids, containing high-risk VOCs (10% in 2016 vs. none of the samples in 2017-2018), caffeine (16% in 2017 vs. 5% in 2018), and diacetyl and acetylpropionyl (50% in 2017 vs. 27% in 2018 of sweet-flavored samples) diminished over time. CONCLUSION: Our results demonstrate that the overall quality of the e-liquids has improved after the implementation of the revised TPD. However, the results also show that periodic quality control might be required to ensure further compliance to the TPD. IMPLICATIONS: This study clearly demonstrates that the implementation of the revised TPD has improved the quality of the e-liquids on the Belgian market. However, there are still e-liquids that are not in agreement with the TPD due to nicotine concentration label discrepancies, presence of e-liquid impurities and controversial flavors diacetyl and acetylpropionyl or the additive caffeine.

Identification of flavouring substances of genotoxic concern present in e-cigarette refills.

E-cigarettes have become very popular, a trend that has been stimulated by the wide variety of available e-liquid flavours. Considering the large number of e-liquid flavours (>7000), there is an urgent need to establish a screening strategy to prioritize the flavouring substances of highest concern for human health. In the present study, a prioritization strategy combining analytical screening, in silico tools and literature data was developed to identify potentially genotoxic e-liquid flavourings. Based on the analysis of 129 e-liquids collected on the Belgian market, 60 flavourings with positive in silico predictions for genotoxicity were identified. By using literature data, genotoxicity was excluded for 33 of them whereas for 5, i.e. estragole, safrole, 2-furylmethylketon, 2,5-dimethyl-4-hydroxyl-3(2H)-furanone and transhexanal, there was a clear concern for in vivo genotoxicity. A selection of 4 out of the remaining 22 flavourings was tested in two in vitro genotoxicity assays. Three out of the four tested flavourings induced gene mutations and chromosome damage in vitro, whereas equivocal results were obtained for the fourth compound. Thus, although there is a legislative framework which excludes the use of CMR compounds in e-liquids, flavourings of genotoxic concern are present and might pose a health risk for e-cigarette users.

A simple dilute-and-shoot method for screening and simultaneous quantification of nicotine and alkaloid impurities in electronic cigarette refills (e-liquids) by UHPLC-DAD.

The electronic cigarette (e-cigarette) has emerged as a popular alternative to the traditional hazardous tobacco cigarette. The substantial increase in e-cigarette use also urgently calls for controlling the quality of e-cigarette refill liquid products (e-liquids). Currently, the most important quality indicator of e-liquid products is the quantification of nicotine and its related impurities. Although different methods have been published to measure nicotine and impurity levels, the majority of them use a targeted LC-MS/MS approach. There is, however, a need for more robust quantification methods that are easy to implement in most control (industrial and governmental) laboratories. Therefore, in this study, a simple dilute-and-shoot UHPLC-DAD method has been developed and validated for the simultaneous quantification of nicotine and its alkaloid impurities in electronic cigarette refills. An optimal separation of the alkaloids was achieved in a runtime of 11 min. The method was successfully validated using the "total error" approach in accordance with the validation requirements of ISO-17025. During this validation, interference between the target components and a number of popular flavouring compounds such as vanillin, maltol, ethylacetate, etc. could be excluded. In addition, small changes to the column temperature, pH and molar concentration of the mobile phase buffer were deliberately introduced in order to assess the robustness of the method. Only a slightly different outcome between the newly developed UV-detection method and the targeted MS approach was found, due to the sensitivity of the different detection techniques. However, in the context of quality control of nicotine related impurities, for which the European Pharmacopoeia limits are currently applied, the sensitivity of the UHPLC-DAD method was found to be within the acceptable range. Despite the somewhat lower selectivity of the newly developed UV-detection technique versus a targeted LC-MS/MS approach, it may be concluded that this method is a suitable alternative for quality control purposes.

Development and validation of a HS/GC-MS method for the simultaneous analysis of diacetyl and acetylpropionyl in electronic cigarette refills.

The use of e-cigarettes as alternative for tobacco cigarettes has become increasingly popular, even though their safety has not yet been scientifically established. One of the frequently raised concerns is the potential toxicity of certain flavours present in the e-liquids, such as diacetyl and acetylpropionyl. It is therefore important to be able to identify and quantify both compounds. Numerous analytical methods have been published for determining e-liquid compositions, but concerns exist with respect to the lack of analytical evaluation. Hence in this study, a new HS/GC-MS-based method was developed for the screening and quantification of diacetyl and acetylpropionyl in e-liquids. This method was fully validated using the 'total error' approach. The LOQ of the analytical method was 5ppm for diacetyl and acetylpropionyl. The obtained accuracy profiles show that the ß-expectation tolerance intervals did not exceed the acceptance limits of±10%, meaning that 95% of future measurements will be included in the [-10%, 10%] bias limits. As proof of applicability, the validated method was successfully applied on a small set of e-liquid samples, indicating that this methodology could be used for routine quality control analyses of e-liquids.