Properties and Applications of Metal Phosphates and Pyrophosphates as Proton Conductors.

We review the progress in metal phosphate structural chemistry focused on proton conductivity properties and applications. Attention is paid to structure-property relationships, which ultimately determine the potential use of metal phosphates and derivatives in devices relying on proton conduction. The origin of their conducting properties, including both intrinsic and extrinsic conductivity, is rationalized in terms of distinctive structural features and the presence of specific proton carriers or the factors involved in the formation of extended hydrogen-bond networks. To make the exposition of this large class of proton conductor materials more comprehensive, we group/combine metal phosphates by their metal oxidation state, starting with metal (IV) phosphates and pyrophosphates, considering historical rationales and taking into account the accumulated body of knowledge of these compounds. We highlight the main characteristics of super protonic CsH2PO4, its applicability, as well as the affordance of its composite derivatives. We finish by discussing relevant structure-conducting property correlations for divalent and trivalent metal phosphates. Overall, emphasis is placed on materials exhibiting outstanding properties for applications as electrolyte components or single electrolytes in Polymer Electrolyte Membrane Fuel Cells and Intermediate Temperature Fuel Cells.

Exploiting the Multifunctionality of M2+/Imidazole-Etidronates for Proton Conductivity (Zn2+) and Electrocatalysis (Co2+, Ni2+) toward the HER, OER, and ORR.

This work deals with the synthesis and characterization of one-dimensional (1D) imidazole-containing etidronates, [M2(ETID)(Im)3]·nH2O (M = Co2+ and Ni2+; n = 0, 1, 3) and [Zn2(ETID)2(H2O)2](Im)2, as well as the corresponding Co2+/Ni2+ solid solutions, to evaluate their properties as multipurpose materials for energy conversion processes. Depending on the water content, metal ions in the isostructural Co2+ and Ni2+ derivatives are octahedrally coordinated (n = 3) or consist of octahedral together with dimeric trigonal bipyramidal (n = 1) or square pyramidal (n = 0) environments. The imidazole molecule acts as a ligand (Co2+, Ni2+ derivatives) or charge-compensating protonated species (Zn2+ derivative). For the latter, the proton conductivity is determined to be ∼6 × 10-4 S·cm-1 at 80 °C and 95% relative humidity (RH). By pyrolyzing in 5%H2-Ar at 700-850 °C, core-shell electrocatalysts consisting of Co2+-, Ni2+-phosphides or Co2+/Ni2+-phosphide solid solution particles embedded in a N-doped carbon graphitic matrix are obtained, which exhibit improved catalytic performances compared to the non-N-doped carbon materials. Co2+ phosphides consist of CoP and Co2P in variable proportions according to the used precursor and pyrolytic conditions. However, the Ni2+ phosphide is composed of Ni2P exclusively at high temperatures. Exploration of the electrochemical activity of these metal phosphides toward the oxygen evolution reaction (OER), oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), and hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) reveals that the anhydrous Co2(ETID)(Im)3 pyrolyzed at 800 °C (CoP/Co2P = 80/20 wt %) is the most active trifunctional electrocatalyst, with good integrated capabilities as an anode for overall water splitting (cell voltage of 1.61 V) and potential application in Zn-air batteries. This solid also displays a moderate activity for the HER with an overpotential of 156 mV and a Tafel slope of 79.7 mV·dec-1 in 0.5 M H2SO4. Ni2+- and Co2+/Ni2+-phosphide solid solutions show lower electrochemical performances, which are correlated with the formation of less active crystalline phases.

Structural and proton conductivity studies of fibrous π-Ti2O(PO4)2·2H2O: application in chitosan-based composite membranes.

Although the fibrous polymorphic modification of titanium phosphate, π-Ti2O(PO4)2·2H2O (π-TiP) has been known for decades, its crystal structure has remained unsolved. Herewith, we report the crystal structure of π-TiP at room temperature, as determined from synchrotron radiation powder X-ray diffraction, and corroborated by 31P solid state NMR and accurate density functional theory calculations. In contrast to the previously reported ρ-TiP polymorph, the as-synthesized hydrated phase crystallizes in the monoclinic system (P21/c, a = 5.1121(2) Å, b = 14.4921(9) Å, c = 12.0450(11), ß = 115.31(1)°, Z = 4), and is composed of corner-sharing titanium octahedra and phosphate units arranged in a pattern that is unique to the ρ-TiP polymorph. The unit cell was confirmed by electron diffraction, while the formation of planar packing imperfections and stacking faults along the [101] plane was revealed by HRTEM analysis. An in situ dehydration study of π-TiP, monitored by high-temperature powder X-ray diffraction, led to a new anhydrous monoclinic (P21/c, a = 5.1187(13) Å, b = 11.0600(21) Å, c = 14.4556(26), ß = 107.65(2)°, Z = 4) phase that crystallizes at 500 °C. The latter resembles the packing fashion of the parental π-TiP, albeit titanium atoms are present in both distorted tetrahedral and octahedral coordination environments. Anhydrous π-TiP was found to partially rehydrate at room temperature, reversibly adopting the structure of the initial phase. The studies carried out under different conditions of leaching and impregnation with H3PO4 showed that π-TiP exhibits an extrinsic proton conductivity (1.3 × 10-3 S cm-1 at 90 °C and 95% RH) due to the presence of the protonated phosphate species bound on the particles surface, as revealed by 31P MAS-NMR spectroscopy data. The composite membranes of Chitosan (CS) matrices filled with H3PO4-impregnated π-TiP solid show an increment of proton conductivity up to 4.5 × 10-3 S cm-1, at 80 °C and 95% RH, which is 1.8-fold higher than those of the bare CS membranes.

Synthesis and electrochemical properties of metal(ii)-carboxyethylphenylphosphinates.

We report herein the synthesis, structural characterization and electrocatalytic properties of three new coordination polymers, resulting from the combination of divalent metal (Ca2+, Cd2+ or Co2+) salts with (2-carboxyethyl)(phenyl)phosphinic acid. In addition to the usual hydrothermal procedure, the Co2+ derivative could also be prepared by microwave-assisted synthesis, in much shorter times. The crystal structures were solved by ab initio calculations, from powder diffraction data. Compounds MII[O2P(CH2CH2COOH)(C6H5)]2 {M = Cd (1) or Ca (2)} crystallize in the monoclinic system and display a layered topology, with the phenyl groups pointing toward the interlayer space in a interdigitated fashion. Compound Co2[(O2P(CH2CH2COO)(C6H5)(H2O)]2·2H2O (3) presents a 1D structure composed of zig-zag chains, formed by edge-sharing cobalt octahedra, with the phenyl groups pointing outside. Packing of these chains is favored by hydrogen bond interactions via lattice water molecules. In addition, H-bonds along the chains are established with the participation of the water molecules and the hydrophilic groups from the ligand. However, the solid exhibits a low proton conductivity, attributed to the isolation of the hydrophilic regions caused by the arrangement of hydrophobic phenyl groups. Preliminary studies on the electrocatalytic performance for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) have been conducted for compound 3 and its pyrolytic derivatives, which were previously thoroughly characterized. By comparison, another Co2+ phosphinate, 4, obtained by microwave-assisted synthesis, but with distinct stoichiometry and a known structure was also tested. For the OER, the best performance was achieved with a derivative of 3, prepared by heating this compound in N2 at 200 °C. This derivative showed overpotential (339 mV, at a current density of 10 mA cm-2) and Tafel slope (51.7 mV dec-1) values comparable to those of other Co2+ related materials.

Phase Transformation Dynamics in Sulfate-Loaded Lanthanide Triphosphonates. Proton Conductivity and Application as Fillers in PEMFCs.

Phase transformation dynamics and proton conduction properties are reported for cationic layer-featured coordination polymers derived from the combination of lanthanide ions (Ln3+) with nitrilo-tris(methylenephosphonic acid) (H6NMP) in the presence of sulfate ions. Two families of materials are isolated and structurally characterized, i.e., [Ln2(H4NMP)2(H2O)4](HSO4)2·nH2O (Ln = Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Er, Yb; n = 4-5, Series I) and [Ln(H5NMP)]SO4·2H2O (Ln = Pr, Nd, Eu, Gd, Tb; Series II). Eu/Tb bimetallic solid solutions are also prepared for photoluminescence studies. Members of families I and II display high proton conductivity (10-3 and 10-2 S·cm-1 at 80 °C and 95% relative humidity) and are studied as fillers for Nafion-based composite membranes in PEMFCs, under operating conditions. Composite membranes exhibit higher power and current densities than the pristine Nafion membrane working in the range of 70-90 °C and 100% relative humidity and with similar proton conductivity.

NH3/H2O-mediated proton conductivity and photocatalytic behaviour of Fe(ii)-hydroxyphosphonoacetate and M(ii)-substituted derivatives.

Synthesis redesign and derivatisation of Fe(ii)-hydroxyphosphonoacetate, incorporating different ammonia loads and M(ii) isomorphic substitutions (M = Mn, Co and Zn), have been implemented. The NH3 adsorption led to materials with enhanced proton conductivity, up to ∼10-3 S cm-1, although it caused a progressive amorphization. The Pair Distribution Function (PDF) analysis for this material confirmed the loss of crystallinity but the local order appeared to be maintained. The parent compound was shown to be an efficient photocatalyst for phenol, 4-chlorophenol and methylene blue even under mild conditions, with TOC removal of 75-90% at 50-150 min of reaction. The M(ii)-substituted derivatives displayed similar behaviour in properties, and therefore their multifunctional character, as the parent compound, although with slightly reduced capabilities.

Phosphonate Decomposition-Induced Polyoxomolybdate Dumbbell-Type Cluster Formation: Structural Analysis, Proton Conduction, and Catalytic Sulfoxide Reduction.

The reaction of MoO42- with a number of phosphonic acids [bis(phosphonomethyl)glycine, R,S-hydroxyphosphonoacetic acid, 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic acid, phenylphosphonic acid, aminotris(methylene phosphonic acid), and 1,2-ethylenediphosphonic acid] under oxidizing (H2O2) hydrothermal conditions at low pH leads to rupture of the P-C bond, release of orthophosphate ions, and generation of the octanuclear, phosphate-bridged, polyoxometalate molybdenum cluster (NH4)5[Mo8(OH)2O24(µ8-PO4)](H2O)2 (POMPhos). This cluster has been fully characterized and its structure determined. It was studied as a proton conductor, giving moderate values of σ = 2.13 × 10-5 S·cm-1 (25 °C) and 1.17 × 10-4 S·cm-1 (80 °C) at 95% relative humidity, with Ea = 0.27 eV. The POMPhos cluster was then thermally treated at 310 °C, yielding (NH4)2.6(H3O)0.4(PO4Mo12O36) together with an amorphous impurity containing phosphate and molybdenum oxide. This product was also studied for its proton conductivity properties, giving rise to an impressively high value of σ = 2.43 × 10-3 S·cm-1 (25 °C) and 6.67 × 10-3 S·cm-1 (80 °C) at 95% relative humidity, 2 orders of magnitude higher than those corresponding to the "as-synthesized" solid. The utilization of POMPhos in catalytic reduction of different sulfoxides was also evaluated. POMPhos acts as an efficient homogeneous catalyst for the reduction of diphenyl sulfoxide to diphenyl sulfide, as a model reaction. Pinacol was used as a low-cost, environmentally friendly, and highly efficient reducing agent. The effects of different reaction parameters were investigated, namely the type of solvent and reducing agent, presence of acid promoter, reaction time and temperature, loading of catalyst and pinacol, allowing to achieve up to 84-99% yields of sulfide products under optimized conditions. Substrate scope was tested on the examples of diaryl, alkylaryl, dibenzyl, and dialkyl sulfoxides and excellent product yields were obtained.

Three-Component Copper-Phosphonate-Auxiliary Ligand Systems: Proton Conductors and Efficient Catalysts in Mild Oxidative Functionalization of Cycloalkanes.

The synthesis, structural characterization, topological analysis, proton conductivity, and catalytic properties are reported of two Cu(II)-based compounds, namely a dinuclear Cu(II) complex [Cu2(µ-VPA)2(phen)2(H2O)2]·8H2O (1) (H2VPA = vinylphosphonic acid, phen = 1,10-phenanthroline) and a 1D coordination polymer [Cu(µ-SO4)(phen)(H2O)2]∞ (2). Their structural features and H-bonding interactions were investigated in detail, showing that the metal-organic structures of 1 and 2 are extended by multiple hydrogen bonds to more complex 2D or 1D H-bonded architectures with the kgd [Shubnikov plane net (3.6.3.6)/dual] and SP 1-periodic net (4,4)(0,2) topology, respectively. These nets are primarily driven by the H-bonding interactions involving water ligands and H2O molecules of crystallization; besides, the (H2O)4/(H2O)5 clusters were identified in 1. Both 1 and 2 are moderate proton conductors, with proton conductivity values, σ = 3.65 × 10-6 and 3.94 × 10-6 S·cm-1, respectively (measured at 80 °C and 95% relative humidity). Compounds 1 and 2 are also efficient homogeneous catalysts for the mild oxidative functionalization of C5-C8 cycloalkanes (cyclopentane, cyclohexane, cycloheptane, and cyclooctane), namely for the oxidation by H2O2 to give cyclic alcohols and ketones and the hydrocarboxylation by CO/H2O and S2O82- to the corresponding cycloalkanecarboxylic acids as major products. The catalytic reactions proceed under mild conditions (50-60 °C) in aqueous acetonitrile medium, resulting in up to 34% product yields based on cycloalkane substrate.

Influence of Proton Conducting Cations on the Structure and Properties of 2D Anilate-Based Magnets.

The syntheses, structures, magnetic, and proton conductivity properties of a family of bimetallic anilate-based compounds with inserted alkylammonium cations are presented. The structures of (Me2NH2)[MnIICrIII(Br2An)3]·2H2O (1), (Et2NH2)[MnIICrIII(Br2An)3] (2), (Et3NH)[MnIICrIII(Cl2An)3] (3), and [(Et)(i-Pr)2NH][MnIICrIII(Br2An)3]·(CHCl3)0.5·(H2O) (4) contain a 2D anionic network formed by Mn(II) and Cr(III) ions linked through anilate ligands. In 1, 2, and 3, the hexagonal holes of this network are occupied by Me2NH2+, Et2NH2+, or Et3NH+ cations. Interestingly, the small increase of size of the templating cation in 4 ([(Et)(i-Pr)2NH]+ in the place of Me2NH2+, Et2NH2+ or Et3NH+), gives rise to a different structure with half of the cations placed within the layers and the other one in the space between the layers. This leads to bilayers with an interlayer separation similar to those of 1, 2, and 3 separated by larger interbilayer distances. Compounds 1, 2, and 3 show a ferrimagnetic ordering with a Tc of 8.0 K (1), 8.9 K (2), and 8.0 K (3). In 4, the presence of different interlayer distances leads to a metamagnetic behavior when the sample is measured in contact with the mother liquor. The behavior changes in the dry sample, which shows a ferrimagnetic ordering as that of 1, 2, and 3 due to collapse of the structure as confirmed by powder X-ray diffraction. Interestingly, the metamagnetic behavior is recovered after reimmersing the crystals in the mother liquor proving the reversibility of the process. All solids are Grotthuss-type proton conductors with conductivity values ranging between 2.3 × 10-6 S·cm-1 for 3 and 2.4 × 10-5 S·cm-1 for 1 measured at 70 °C and 95% relative humidity and activation energies of ∼0.2 eV.

Luminescent and Proton Conducting Lanthanide Coordination Networks Based On a Zwitterionic Tripodal Triphosphonate.

The synthesis, structural characterization, luminescence properties, and proton conduction performance of a new family of isostructural cationic 2D layered compounds are reported. These have the general formula [Ln(H4NMP)(H2O)2]Cl·2H2O [Ln = La(3+), Pr(3+), Sm(3+), Eu(3+), Gd(3+), Tb(3+), Dy(3+), Ho(3+), H6NMP = nitrilotris(methylphosphonic acid)], and contain Cl(-) as the counterion. In the case of Ce(3+), a 1D derivative, [Ce2(H3NMP)2(H2O)4]·4.5H2O, isostructural with the known lanthanum compound has been isolated by simply crystallization at room temperature. The octa-coordinated environment of Ln(3+) in 2D compounds is composed by six oxygen atoms from three different ligands and two oxygens from each bound water. Two of the three phosphonate groups act as both chelating and bridging linkers, while the third phosphonate group acts solely as a bridging moiety. The materials are stable at low relative humidity at less at 170 °C. However, at high relative humidity transform to other chloride-free phases, including the 1D structure. The proton conductivity of the 1D materials varies in a wide range, the highest values corresponding to the La derivative (σ ≈ 2 × 10(-3) S·cm(-1) at RH 95% and 80 °C). A lower proton conductivity, 3 × 10(-4) S·cm(-1), was measured for [Gd(H4NMP)(H2O)2]Cl·2H2O at 80 °C, which remains stable under the work conditions used. Absorption and luminescence spectra were recorded for selected [Ln(H4NMP)(H2O)2]Cl·2H2O compounds. In all of them, the observed transitions are attributed solely to f-f transitions of the lanthanide ions present, as the H4NMP(2-) organic group has no measurable absorption or luminescence properties.

Guest molecule-responsive functional calcium phosphonate frameworks for tuned proton conductivity.

We report the synthesis, structural characterization, and functionality (framework interconversions together with proton conductivity) of an open-framework hybrid that combines Ca(2+) ions and the rigid polyfunctional ligand 5-(dihydroxyphosphoryl)isophthalic acid (PiPhtA). Ca2[(HO3PC6H3COOH)2]2[(HO3PC6H3(COO)2H)(H2O)2]·5H2O (Ca-PiPhtA-I) is obtained by slow crystallization at ambient conditions from acidic (pH ≈ 3) aqueous solutions. It possesses a high water content (both Ca coordinated and in the lattice), and importantly, it exhibits water-filled 1D channels. At 75 °C, Ca-PiPhtA-I is partially dehydrated and exhibits a crystalline diffraction pattern that can be indexed in a monoclinic cell with parameters close to the pristine phase. Rietveld refinement was carried out for the sample heated at 75 °C, Ca-PiPhtA-II, using synchrotron powder X-ray diffraction data, which revealed the molecular formula Ca2[(HO3PC6H3COOH)2]2[(HO3PC6H3(COO)2H)(H2O)2]. All connectivity modes of the "parent" Ca-PiPhtA-I framework are retained in Ca-PiPhtA-II. Upon Ca-PiPhtA-I exposure to ammonia vapors (28% aqueous NH3) a new derivative is obtained (Ca-PiPhtA-NH3) containing 7 NH3 and 16 H2O molecules according to elemental and thermal analyses. Ca-PiPhtA-NH3 exhibits a complex X-ray diffraction pattern with peaks at 15.3 and 13.0 Å that suggest partial breaking and transformation of the parent pillared structure. Although detailed structural identification of Ca-PiPhtA-NH3 was not possible, due in part to nonequilibrium adsorption conditions and the lack of crystallinity, FT-IR spectra and DTA-TG analysis indicate profound structural changes compared to the pristine Ca-PiPhtA-I. At 98% RH and T = 24 °C, proton conductivity, σ, for Ca-PiPhtA-I is 5.7 × 10(-4) S·cm(-1). It increases to 1.3 × 10(-3) S·cm(-1) upon activation by preheating the sample at 40 °C for 2 h followed by water equilibration at room temperature under controlled conditions. Ca-PiPhtA-NH3 exhibits the highest proton conductivity, 6.6 × 10(-3) S·cm(-1), measured at 98% RH and T = 24 °C. Activation energies (Ea) for proton transfer in the above-mentioned frameworks range between 0.23 and 0.4 eV, typical of a Grothuss mechanism of proton conduction. These results underline the importance of internal H-bonding networks that, in turn, determine conductivity properties of hybrid materials. It is highlighted that new proton transfer pathways may be created by means of cavity "derivatization" with selected guest molecules resulting in improved proton conductivity.

Structural variability in multifunctional metal xylenediaminetetraphosphonate hybrids.

Two new families of divalent metal hybrid derivatives from the aromatic tetraphosphonic acids 1,4- and 1,3-bis(aminomethyl)benzene-N,N'-bis(methylenephosphonic acid), (H2O3PCH2)2-N-CH2C6H4CH2-N(CH2PO3H2)2 (designated herein as p-H8L and m-H8L) have been synthesized by crystallization at room temperature and hydrothermal conditions. The crystal structures of M[(HO3PCH2)2N(H)CH2C6H4CH2N(H)(CH2PO3H)2(H2O)2]·2H2O (M = Mg, Co, and Zn), M-(p-H6L), and M[(HO3PCH2)2N(H)CH2C6H4CH2N(H)(CH2PO3H)2]·nH2O (M = Ca, Mg, Co, and Zn and n = 1-1.5), M-(m-H6L), were solved ab initio by synchrotron powder diffraction data using the direct methods and subsequently refined using the Rietveld method. The crystal structure of the isostructural M-(p-H6L) is constituted by organic-inorganic monodimensional chains where the phosphonate moiety acts as a bidentate chelating ligand bridging two metal octahedra. M-(m-H6L) compounds exhibit a 3D pillared open-framework with small 1D channels filled with water molecules. These channels are formed by the pillaring action of the organic ligand connecting adjacent layers through the phosphonate oxygens. Thermogravimetric and X-ray thermodiffraction analyses of M-(p-H6L) showed that the integrity of their crystalline structures is maintained up to 470 K, without significant reduction of water content, while thermal decomposition takes place above 580 K. The utility of M-(p-H6L) (M = Mg and Zn) hybrid materials in corrosion protection was investigated in acidic aqueous solutions. In addition, the impedance data indicate both families of compounds display similar proton conductivities (σ ∼ 9.4 × 10(-5) S·cm(-1), at 98% RH and 297 K), although different proton transfer mechanisms are involved.