Determining transition states from kinetic isotope effects.

BEBOVA-based TS determination has been very successful in elucidating enzyme mechanisms at a level of detail that would be otherwise inaccessible. The resulting TS structures have been used successfully as the basis for designing TS mimics as enzyme inhibitors with dissociation constants to 10(-11) M. The structure interpolation approach has systematized the process of finding a TS, increasing both the speed and the accuracy of TS determination. The combination of information from several TSs into a unified model increases the accuracy of the process significantly and results in an extremely sensitive probe of changes in TS with varying reaction conditions (i.e., enzymatic vs nonenzymatic reactions, different enzymes, or different nucleophiles). The TS determination process is summarized in Fig. 15.

Transition-state structure for the ADP-ribosylation of recombinant Gialpha1 subunits by pertussis toxin.

Pertussis toxin ADP-ribosylates a specific Cys side chain in the alpha-subunit of several G-proteins. Recombinant Gialpha1-subunits were rapidly ADP-ribosylated in the absence of betagamma-subunits, with a Km of 800 microM and a kcat of 40 min-1. Addition of betagamma-subunits decreases Km to 0.3 microM with little change of kcat. Kinetic isotope effects established the transition-state structure for ADP-ribosylation of Gialpha1 subunits. The transition state is dissociative, with a 2.1 A bond to the nicotinamide leaving group and a bond of 2.5 A to the sulfur nucleophile. The nucleophilic participation of Gialpha1 at the transition state is greater than that for water in the hydrolysis of NAD+by pertussis toxin. Crystal structures for Gialpha1 show the Cys nucleophile in a disordered segment or inaccessible for attack on NAD+. Therefore, transition-state formation requires an altered Gialpha1 conformation to expose and ionize Cys. The transition state has been docked into the crystal structure of pertussis toxin in a geometry required for transition state formation.

Affinity purification and elimination of methionine oxidation in recombinant human cystatin C.

Recombinant human cystatin C (cC), a cysteine protease inhibitor, contained methionine sulfoxide [Met(O)] residues when expressed in Escherichia coli under aerobic conditions or upon allowing osmotic shock solutions from anaerobically grown cultures to warm to room temperature. Oxidation occurred in the periplasmic space or intracellularly during aerobic expression. Both Met14 and Met41 were subject to oxidation, as determined by NMR spectroscopy and mass spectrometry. Oxidation of Met110 was not observed. Growth under anaerobic conditions and modified purification procedures prevented oxidation. Through the use of a new form of affinity purification, cC was purified to > 99% in one step on E-64-papain-Sepharose (E-64 is 1-[N-[(L-3-trans-carboxyoxirane-2-carbonyl)-L-leucyl]amino]-4-g uanidinobutane), with elution with sodium trichloroacetate. The dissociation equilibrium constants (Kd) for the interaction of unoxidized cC, (Met(O)14)cC, and (Met(O)41)cC with S-(N-ethylsuccinimidyl)papain were experimentally identical: 1.8 (+/-0.2) x 10(-7), 1.6 (+/-0.2) x 10(-7), and 1.4 (+/-0.5) x 10(-7) M, respectively. This implies that the structure of the protease-binding region of mono-oxidized cC's was unchanged. The NMR observation of small, localized conformational changes was consistent with this. (Met(O)14)cC and (Met(O)14,Met(O)41)cC eluted earlier upon analytical affinity chromatography.

Processing of the papain precursor. The ionization state of a conserved amino acid motif within the Pro region participates in the regulation of intramolecular processing.

The cysteine protease papain is synthesized as a 40-kDa inactive precursor with a 107-amino-acid N-terminal pro region. Although sequence conservation in the pro region is lower than in the mature proteases, a conserved motif (Gly-Xaa-Asn-Xaa-Phe-Xaa-Asp-36, papain precursor numbering) was found within the pro region of cysteine proteases of the papain superfamily. To determinate the function to this conserved motif, we have mutagenized at random each of the 4 residues individually within the pro region of the papain precursor. Precursor mutants were expressed in yeast, screened according to their ability to be processed through either a cis or trans reaction, into mature active papain. Three classes of mutants were found. Non-functional propapain mutants of the first class are completely degraded by subtilisin indicating that they are not folded into a native state. Mutants of the second class were neutral with respect to cis and trans processing. The third class included mutants that mostly accumulated as mature papain in the yeast vacuole. They had mutations that had lost the negatively charged Asp-36 residues and a mutation that probably introduces a positive charge, Phe-38His. The precursor of the Phe-38His mutant could be recovered by expression in a vph1 mutant yeast strain which has a vacuolar pH of about 7. The Phe-38His propapain mutant has an optimum pH of autoactivation about one pH unit higher than the wild type molecule. These results indicate that the electrostatic status of the conserved motif participates in the control of intramolecular processing of the papain precursor.

Alignment/phylogeny of the papain superfamily of cysteine proteases.

An alignment/phylogeny of the papain superfamily of cysteine proteases was created using an initial structure-based alignment followed by successive iterations of sequence alignment and phylogenetic inference. The iterative approach resulted in significant improvements in the alignment/phylogeny. There were three groups of cysteine proteases that were distantly related and which could be aligned against each other only in the active site regions: the papain group, which included such stereotypical cysteine proteases as cathepsins B, C, H, L and S; and the bleomycin hydrolase and calpain groups. There was one bacterial sequence in each of the bleomycin hydrolase and calpain groups. The former probably arose by lateral gene transfer, the latter possibly by direct evolution from an ancestral protease predating the eukaryote/prokaryote divergence. The phylogeny of the papain group indicated that many families diverged almost simultaneously early during eukaryotic evolution. In mammals there are at least 12 distinct families of cysteine proteases, possibly many more, including at least two as yet uncharacterized enzymes.

Local pH-dependent conformational changes leading to proteolytic susceptibility of cystatin C.

Cystatin C, a cysteine protease inhibitor, was subject to hydrolysis at two sites when complexed with papain and in the presence of excess papain. A pH-dependent cleavage at His-86 increases Asp-87 was observed, as well as a pH-independent one at Gly-4 increases Lys-5. His-86 increases Asp-87 hydrolysis increased with decreasing pH and was characterized kinetically. It could be described by a single ionization with pKa = 3.4 +/- 0.2 and (kcat./Km)max. = 1.4 (+/- 0.4) x 10(4) M-1.s-1 at I = 0.3 M. C.d. spectroscopy, also at I = 0.3 M, demonstrated a conformational change with pKa = 3.2 +/- 0.2, indicating that the pH-dependence of hydrolysis was due to a conformational change in cystatin C. At I = 0.15 M, the pKa of the conformational change observed by c.d. shifted to 4.1 +/- 0.1. This indicates that at physiological ionic strength of 0.15 M, a significant proportion of cystatin C complexed with protease would be in a proteolytically labile conformation over the pH range 4.5 to 5, which is encountered in lysosomes. This may constitute a mechanism for clearing inappropriately localized cystatins. A pH-dependent conformational variability in this region of the inhibitor could explain the differences in the X-ray crystallographic and n.m.r. structures of the homologous chicken cystatin. The ionic-strength dependence of ionization indicates a hydrophobic stabilization of the ionizable group. The lack of pH-dependence of hydrolysis at Gly-4 increases Lys-5, with kcat./Km = 220 +/- 41 M-1.s-1 in the pH range 3.89 to 7.96 was unexpected in light of the normal, bell-shaped pH-dependence of papain-catalysed hydrolyses. This may reflect a different rate-limiting step of cystatin C hydrolysis.

Cooperativity of papain-substrate interaction energies in the S2 to S2' subsites.

Enzyme-substrate contacts in the hydrolysis of ester substrates by the cysteine protease papain were investigated by systematically altering backbone hydrogen-bonding and side-chain hydrophobic contacts in the substrate and determining each substrate's kinetic constants. The observed specificity energies [defined as delta delta G obs = -RT ln [(kcat/KM)first/(kcat/KM)second)]] of the substrate backbone hydrogen bonds were -2.7 kcal/mol for the P2 NH and -2.6 kcal/mol for the P1 NH when compared against substrates containing esters at those sites. The observed binding energies were -4.0 kcal/mol for the P2 Phe side chain, -1.0 kcal/mol for the P1' C=O, and -2.3 kcal/mol for the P2' NH. The latter three values probably all significantly underestimate the incremental binding energies. The P2 NH, P2 Phe side-chain, and P1 NH contacts display a strong interdependence, or cooperativity, of interaction energies that is characteristic of enzyme-substrate interactions. This interdependence arises largely from the entropic cost of forming the enzyme-substrate transition state. As favorable contacts are added successively to a substrate, the entropic penalty associated with each decreases and the free energy expressed approaches the incremental interaction energy. This is the first report of a graded cooperative effect. Elucidation of favorable enzyme-substrate contacts remote from the catalytic site will assist in the design of highly specific cysteine protease inhibitors.