[Antenatal palliative plan following diagnosis of fetal lethal condition: Rennes Teaching Hospital experience]. / Projet palliatif anténatal après diagnostic de malformation fœtale létale : expérience du CHU de Rennes de 2006 à 2012.

OBJECTIVES: To study the pregnancies followed at Rennes University Hospital from 2006 to 2012, after prenatal diagnosis of lethal fetal condition and prenatal project of palliative care at birth consisting of comfort care emphasizing parent-child encounters and bonding. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Retrospective study of 20 pregnancies with diagnosis of lethal fetal condition where parents accepted antenatally the proposal or sought for palliative care at birth. RESULTS: Diagnosis was made at a median age of 20 weeks gestation (12-33). Birth occurred at 37.4 WG, 6 caesarean sections were performed for maternal conditions. Six cases of hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) share common characteristics: good Apgar score, prolonged survival (26hours to 159days) transfer to neonatology ward (6) or later at home (4). In four multiple pregnancies, the choice of SP mainly contributed to protect healthy twins during pregnancy. In birth room, there was no need for invasive procedure or drugs. Death: one occurred during labor, 8 in birth room before H2, others in neonatal ward before d4 (excluding HLHS). CONCLUSION: These data will enable better antenatal preparation of both teams and parents. Lifetime, however short, allowed parents to meet with their child alive this permitting collection of memory traces and bonding.

[Severe hypoplastic left heart syndrome: palliative care after prenatal diagnosis]. / Hypoplasies sévères du ventricule gauche: soins palliatifs après un diagnostic prénatal.

We analyzed 16 cases of hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) submitted to the multidisciplinary center at Rennes Teaching Hospital from 2006 to 2010 for prenatal diagnosis. The information given to parents at the moment of choice is capital for them to make their own decision: in our team the real choice for parents stands between termination of pregnancy (TOP) and palliative care (PC). The Norwood procedure is rarely proposed to parents in France and it is performed in very few centers. Heart transplant is never proposed nor done at this age. The objectives of our study were to understand the reasons for the choice of PC, take stock of our experience of PC, and relate the benefits but also the disadvantages of PC. Over the 16 patients whose fetus had HLHS, 9 requested TOP, while 7 others wanted to live their pregnancy and meet their child at birth, therefore requesting neonatal PC. No family asked for the Norwood procedure. Four children died within the first days (D1, D2, D4, D9), 2 others died at 5 and 7 months, 1 child was operated on for coarctation of the aorta (unknown before birth) and is still alive 1.5 years later. Maternal motivations to continue the pregnancy were clearly described for 2 of the 7 cases: religious prohibition of TOP in 1 case, negative experiences of previous abortions in the second case. In another case, the parents hesitated between PC and Norwood surgery. For the other women, the reasons were less clearly expressed. In our series, HLHS is the first indication for PC from prenatal diagnosis (7/16 cases in the same period) while in the literature, heart diseases are the second cause of TOP after the neurological causes. The overrepresentation of this pathology in the families who opt for PC may be due to the unconscious image that both professionals and families have of HLHS: severity of an inevitably fatal disease, rapid postnatal death, and no suffering. Our study may change this view: a child was in fact carrying a curable defect which was discovered 12 days after birth, 2 children died at 5 and 7 months, and 5 of 6 children had major analgesics at the end of life. Nevertheless, the families were supported and followed by the PC network, except 1 who ruptured all contacts in a context of presumed intense suffering, but the other 6 do not regret their choice despite the difficulties.