In vitro embryotoxicity of a series of para-substituted phenols: structure, activity, and correlation with in vivo data.

The embryotoxicity of phenol and twelve para-substituted congeners on mid-gestation rat embryos was evaluated in vitro. Through application of correlative procedures and stepwise regression, equations describing the relationship between physical-chemical properties and various measures of activity were developed. Embryotoxicity was quantified by the log of the reciprocal of the potency estimates for reduction in selected growth parameters and induction of four morphological defects. In general, co-cultured hepatocytes ameliorated embryotoxicity; only phenol-induced embryotoxicity was enhanced by the presence of hepatocytes. In the absence of hepatocytes, measures of growth retardation were positively correlated with molar refractivity of the phenols. With hepatocytes, lipophilicity became important for describing the potential to induce growth deficits. The structural defects had varying correlation patterns in both culture systems. Potencies of these congeners in vitro were also compared to maternal and developmental potencies observed in vivo (Kavlock, Teratology, 41:43-59, '90). Two of the congeners were very toxic in both systems. For the remaining congeners, one maternal toxicity measure was found to be positively correlated with embryotoxicity for growth and development in vitro without hepatocytes. With hepatocytes, a broad spectrum of correlations, both positive and negative, were observed between in vivo developmental toxicity endpoints and in vitro embryotoxicity. Data from preliminary dosimetry studies suggest that phenol congeners may accumulate in embryos exposed in vitro more readily than with in vivo exposure. Potency calculations based on dosimetry information may demonstrate better correlations between data and allow additional relationships between chemical structure and activity to be developed.

In vitro culture of postimplantation hamster embryos.

In vitro culture of intact rat and mouse embryos has been described extensively, but information on the culture of other species is sparse. The present study examined some culture requirements of early somite stage hamster embryos and assessed the embryotoxic effects of sodium salicylate (SS), a direct acting chemical and cyclophosphamide (CP), a proteratogen, on these embryos. Hamster embryos explanted on gestation days (GD) 8 and 9 were cultured in Waymouth's embryo-hepatocyte co-cultivation medium (WEHC), 70% McCoy's 5A medium-30% male rat serum (MMRS) or 100% male rat serum (MRS) for 24 hours under various oxygen concentrations. Embryos cultured GD 8 to 9 in the various media grew and differentiated much as they did in vivo, while embryos cultured GD 9 to 10 grew best in MMRS as compared to embryos at the same stage in vivo. Embryos exposed to SS in MMRS at concentrations of 250, 300, or 400 micrograms/ml showed dose related embryotoxicity which included CNS defects, absence of hind limb bud formation, and lack of axial rotation. Hamster embryos co-cultivated with pregnant hamster hepatocytes and treated with 2.5, 6.25 and 12.5 micrograms/ml of CP, showed dose-dependent toxicity when compared to co-cultivated controls. Hamster embryos develop extensively in culture over a 24 hour period. This system may therefore provide a valuable tool for evaluating the species differences of a variety of potential teratogens and embryotoxins and allow the comparison of these embryotoxic effects between rat, mouse and hamster during similar stages of organogenesis.

The potential relationship of maternal toxicity, general stress, and fetal outcome.

Standard teratology bioassays generally call for a top dose level which is sufficient to induce some form of overt maternal toxicity such as death or weight loss. The presence of such maternal toxicity is often a confound in the interpretation of experimental results, especially at those dose levels producing the toxicity. While the physiological bases for the toxicity vary widely in a compound-related fashion, one underlying factor that remains constant for most induced toxicity is the presence of generalized stress in the affected animals. Previous studies have indicated that pregnant animals treated acutely with toxic levels of a variety of pharmacologically unrelated chemicals produced litters without a recognizable syndrome of defects, except for an increased incidence of supernumerary ribs (SNR). The present study reports on the effects of immobilization stress on the production of SNR in the Sprague-Dawley rat and the CD-1 mouse. Pregnant animals were immobilized in the supine position for 12-hour periods during the day of greatest sensitivity to SNR production (days 9 and 10 in the mouse and rat, respectively). Animals were killed immediately before term and the fetuses were examined. An increase in SNR was noted in immobilized mice but not rats. These results suggest that such fetal effects may be the result of general agent-induced maternal stress.

The induction of supernumerary ribs in rodents: role of the maternal stress.

Increased incidences of supernumerary ribs (SNR) are a relatively common finding in standard teratology bioassays, and previous studies have indicated a possible correlation between their occurrence and general maternal stress. The present study describes the effects of immobilization stress on the induction of supernumerary ribs. To isolate the sensitive period of SNR induction, Sprague-Dawley rats and CD-1 mice were treated with 300 and 1,500 mg/kg, respectively, of sodium salicylate on single days 7-11 of gestation. In the rat, day 10 was found to be the sensitive period of lumbar rib induction (32% SNR vs 10% on other days) while day 9 was critical in the mouse (71% SNR vs less than 29% on other days). In a second set of experiments, maternal stress was accomplished by restraining two groups of gravid females in the supine position for 12 hours on the predetermined sensitive day. One group was immobilized from 9 am to 9 pm, while the second group was restrained from 9 pm to 9 am. Concurrent controls were food and water deprived for similar periods. Additional untreated controls were also included. An increase in supernumerary ribs was noted in stressed mice but not in rats. The 9 am to 9 pm mouse group exhibited the highest increase in supernumerary ribs (41%) as well as significant incidences of fused ribs and exencephaly. A significant linear relationship between maternal weight loss during treatment and increases in supernumerary ribs was also noted. Results suggest that for some compounds, supernumerary ribs may be the indirect result of agent-induced, generalized maternal stress in the CD-1 mouse.

Co-culture of rat embryos and hepatocytes: in vitro detection of a proteratogen.

The technique of whole embryo culture developed by New [Environ Health Perspect 18:105-110, 1976] provides a sensitive assay to evaluate the effects of a test chemical on embryo development independent of maternal influences. To detect proteratogens, this assay must be coupled with an exogenous metabolic activation system. We have developed methods for the co-cultivation of rat embryos with primary hepatocytes, which offers several advantages over subcellular fractions when providing metabolic activation for in vitro assays. In the present study, rat embryos removed from the dam on day 10 of pregnancy were co-cultivated in vitro with primary cultures of rat, rabbit, or hamster hepatocytes. Embryos co-cultivated with hepatocytes developed normally, as did embryos exposed to a test chemical, cyclophosphamide (CP) in the absence of hepatocytes. When embryos were co-cultivated with hepatocytes and exposed to CP, a dose-related embryotoxicity was observed, indicating metabolic activation of the proteratogen. Using hepatocytes isolated from rats pretreated in vivo with phenobarbital, we observed an increase in CP-induced malformations and embryotoxicity compared to those of embryos exposed to CP in the presence of uninduced hepatocytes. The teratogenic bioactivation of CP was inhibited in vitro by the addition of metyrapone. When similar numbers of hepatocytes were used for metabolic activation of CP the induced embryotoxicity was greater in the presence of rabbit and hamster hepatocytes than with rat hepatocytes. Development of procedures for the culture of rat embryos with hepatocytes from other species suggests the utility of this in vitro system for the investigation of species differences in sensitivity to chemical teratogens.