[Shared decision-making using outcome information: qualitative research among patients]. / Samen beslissen met ROM als informatiebron: kwalitatief onderzoek onder cliënten.

BACKGROUND: In the period 2019-2022, eight mental health care organizations have been working on the development and implementation of shared decision-making (SDM) using routine outcome monitoring (ROM) as a source of information. AIM: To obtain insight in needs and experiences of patients among SDM using ROM, and to investigate which implementation approach this requires. METHOD: Explorative, qualitative research consisting of semi-structured interviews and focusgroups with patients (n = 101) treated by mental health care organizations across the Netherlands. RESULTS: Patients reported SDM as important. Generic aspects (listening, trust, complete information and equal input) and customization (connecting to the need for help, and for every decision meta-communication about the roles of patients, relatives and clinicians and the way of giving information) were equally important. Patients valued ROM as source of information during SDM, providing that questionnaires are not too long, are related to the problems and results are discussed. CONCLUSION: SDM using ROM is as yet not widely implemented in mental health care. This requires continuous stimulation and evaluation. Implementation requires (re)training clinicians and supporting patients by relatives, peer experts and psycho-education. Patients appreciate ROM as an aid in SDM; access to their own ROM is helpful here.

Factors influencing the admission decision for Medical Psychiatry Units: A concept mapping approach.

OBJECTIVE: Medical Psychiatry Units (MPUs), also known as Complexity Intervention Units (CIUs), provide care for complex patients suffering from both psychiatric and physical disorders. Because there is no consensus on the indications for admission to an MPU, daily practice and effectiveness research are hampered. This study therefore used a concept mapping approach to investigate which organizational and medical factors determine the decision to admit a patient to an MPU. METHODS: The first step of the concept mapping approach was to create a list of factors determining MPU admission from literature. Secondly, clinical experts sorted and ranked these factors. The sorted and ranked data were then analyzed, and a draft conceptual framework was created. A final conceptual MPU admission framework was then drawn during an expert consensus meeting and recommendations for implementation were suggested. RESULTS: Thirteen clinical experts defined 90 factors from literature, which were sorted and ranked by 40 experts from 21 Dutch hospitals. This concept mapping approach resulted in a five-cluster solution for an MPU admission framework based on: 1. Staff competencies and organizational pre-requisites; 2. Patient context; 3. Patient characteristics; 4. Medical needs and capabilities; and 5. Psychiatric symptoms and behavioral problems. Furthermore, three inclusion and two exclusion criteria were formulated to help the clinicians decide whether or not to admit patients to an MPU. These criteria can be implemented in daily practice. CONCLUSION: Implementing the five criteria derived from this conceptual framework will help make the admission decision for complex patients with psychiatric and physical disorders to an MPU more correct, consistent, and transparent.

Attitudes of general hospital consultants towards psychosocial and psychiatric problems in Netherlands.

Psychosocial and psychiatric problems are common in patients admitted to general hospitals, and can negatively influence course of somatic diseases. Hence, early identification and adequate management is important. The aim of this study is to investigate attitudes towards psychosocial and psychiatric problems by non-psychiatrist consultants in an academic hospital. Data were collected by anonymous, self- administered questionnaires which were provided to all consultants during morning reports and by email. Of 431 eligible participants, 187(43%) completed the questionnaire: 64% during morning reports, and 36% by email. Almost all consultants report generally positive attitudes towards mental health problems. However, we identified several obstacles towards management. First, there was a discrepancy between positive attitude and the willingness to take on management responsibility. Reported reasons for this discrepancy were time constraints and lack of skills. We also found that consultants feel little responsibility for the management of depression and chronic drinking. Physicians have generally more positive attitudes than surgeons. Finally, all consultants are less likely to refer patients with dementia and treatment non-compliance to psychiatry, for reasons of perceived ineffectiveness and fear of stigmatizing patients. We conclude targeted education on the management of these problems for hospital consultants is still warranted.

A randomized clinical trial on the effectiveness of an intervention to treat psychological distress and improve quality of life after autologous stem cell transplantation.

Psychological distress contributes to impaired quality of life in hematological cancer patients. Stepped care treatment, in which patients start with the least intensive treatment most likely to work and only receive more intensive interventions if needed, could improve distress. We aimed to evaluate the outcome of stepped care treatment on psychological distress and physical functioning in patients treated with autologous stem cell transplantation for hematological malignancies. In the present study, we performed a randomized clinical trial with two treatment arms: stepped care and care as usual. Baseline assessment and randomization occurred during pre-transplant hospitalization. Stepped care was initiated after 6 weeks, consisting of (1) watchful waiting, (2) Internet-based self-help intervention, and (3) face-to-face counseling/ psychopharmacological treatment/ referral. Follow-up measurements were conducted at 13, 30, and 42 weeks after transplantation. Stepped care (n = 47) and care as usual (n = 48) were comparable on baseline characteristics. The uptake of the intervention was low: 24 patients started with step 1, 23 with step 2, and none with step 3. Percentages of distressed patients ranged from 4.1 to 9.7 %. Ten percent of patients received external psychological or psychiatric care. No statistically significant differences were found between stepped care and care as usual on psychological distress or physical functioning in intention to treat analyses, nor in per protocol analyses. The stepped care program was not effective in decreasing psychological distress. The low intervention uptake, probably related to the low levels of psychological distress, offers an explanation for this outcome. Future research should take into account patients' specific care needs. Netherlands Trial Registry identifier: NTR1770.

Predictors of health-related quality of life in patients treated with auto- and allo-SCT for hematological malignancies.

Identifying factors that predict health-related quality of life (QOL) following hematopoietic SCT, is important in estimating patients' abilities to adjust to the consequences of their disease and treatment. As the studies that have been published on this subject are scattered, the present study aimed to systematically review prognostic factors for health-related QOL after auto- and allo-SCT in hematological malignancies. A systematic, computerized search in Medline, EMBASE, PsycINFO and the Cochrane Library was conducted from 2002 to June 2010. The methodological quality of the studies was assessed using an adaptation of Hayden's criteria list. Qualitative data synthesis was performed to determine the strength of the scientific evidence. In all, 35 studies fulfilled the selection criteria. Strong-moderate evidence was found for GVHD, conditioning regimen, being female, younger age, receiving less social support and pre-transplant psychological distress as predictors of various aspects of health-related QOL following hematopoietic SCT. The results of this review may help transplant teams in selecting patients at risk for experiencing a diminished health-related QOL following hematopoietic SCT. Follow-up treatment can be provided in order to promote QOL.

[The practice guideline 'Consultation psychiatry' of the Dutch Psychiatric Association for psychiatric consultations in primary care and the hospital]. / Richtlijn 'consultatieve psychiatrie' van de nederlandse vereniging voor psychiatrie voor consulten in de eerste lijn en in de ziekenhuissetting.

Psychiatric consultation in primary care as well as in the hospital is both effective and cost-effective if certain procedures are followed. With the professional guideline 'Consultation psychiatry', the Dutch Psychiatric Association aims at setting a standard for psychiatric consultations in non-psychiatric settings. In general practice, the psychiatric consultation is preferably embedded in 'collaborative care', an integrated care model including the general practitioner and a case manager (usually a nurse), with the consultant psychiatrist being regularly available for clearly defined indications. The psychiatrist should see the patient himself or herself, establish a diagnosis and treatment plan, and provide the general practitioner and the patient with a so-called 'consultation letter', which is then discussed with both. In a general hospital, systematic screening of patients at risk of psychiatric comorbidity can be organised. Early detection of complex patients can further improve the effectiveness of psychiatric consultation. Follow-up contacts and investing in liaison contacts improve adherence to the advice provided.

Psychosis in epilepsy patients and other chronic medically ill patients and the role of cerebral pathology in the onset of psychosis: a clinical epidemiological study.

BACKGROUND: In a 3-year epidemiological survey (N=2623) prevalence of psychosis in epilepsy patients as compared with other chronic medically ill patients is assessed. AIM: To explore the role of cerebral pathology as compared to the role of chronic burden of disease in the onset of psychosis. METHOD: One thousand seven hundred fifty two patients with chronic medical disorders admitted to an Academic Hospital and 901 patients with epilepsy admitted to a tertiary care epilepsy clinic were assessed by CIDI, MINI and clinical psychiatric interview in a two stage screening survey. Medical files were searched for MRI scans about cerebral pathology. Poisson regression analysis was performed to estimate the relative risk for psychosis in both groups. RESULTS: In total, 52 patients with prevalent psychosis were found: 49 (5.4%) in the epilepsy clinic and 3 (0.17%) in the Academic Hospital. Age range (18-88), mean age (42) and gender distribution (equal) were similar in both samples. RR is 8.37 (2.74, 25.52). In 16 of the 49 epilepsy patients, cerebral pathology existed with mainly temporal and frontal localisation and of childhood-onset vascular or infectious origin. CONCLUSIONS: This finding suggests that in the onset of psychosis in epilepsy patients, the role of cerebral pathology, especially localized left temporal and frontal, is of strong etiological importance. The following epilepsy endophenotypes should be explored as factors in vulnerability for psychosis as well: frequent and severe epileptic activity; and psychotic reactions to certain AEDs, such as Topiramate and Lamotrigine. Burden of disease does not seem to play an important role.

[Concerns relating to care for transsexuals]. / Zorgen rond de zorg aan transseksuelen.

In the last decade, transsexual patients have increasingly sought sex reassignment (cross-sex hormones and sex reassignment surgery), whilst avoiding adequate diagnostic procedures. They ask non-specialized physicians to prescribe hormones or to perform sex reassignment surgery. Sometimes hormones are ordered through the Internet or obtained from other illegitimate sources. If these patients later turn to a specialized team (for instance for sex reassignment surgery), the obligatory standard diagnostic procedure is problematic: the patient does not accept having to go through a long period of assessment and objective decisionmaking, while the attending health professional feels pressured by the patient's impatience. Non-expert health professionals should draw patients' attention to the necessity of a thorough diagnostic procedure, thus avoiding wrong decisions and future regrets.

Assessing student reflection in medical practice. The development of an observer-rated instrument: reliability, validity and initial experiences.

INTRODUCTION: This study describes the development of an instrument to measure the ability of medical students to reflect on their performance in medical practice. METHODS: A total of 195 Year 4 medical students attending a 9-hour clinical ethics course filled in a semi-structured questionnaire consisting of reflection-evoking case vignettes. Two independent raters scored their answers. Respondents were scored on a 10-point scale for overall reflection score and on a scale of 0-2 for the extent to which they mentioned a series of perspectives in their reflections. We analysed the distribution of scores, the internal validity and the effect of being pre-tested with an alternate form of the test on the scores. The relationships between overall reflection score and perspective score, and between overall reflection score and gender, career preference and work experience were also calculated. RESULTS: The interrater reliability was sufficient. The range of scores on overall reflection was large (1-10), with a mean reflection score of 4.5-4.7 for each case vignette. This means that only 1 or 2 perspectives were mentioned, and hardly any weighing of perspectives took place. The values over the 2 measurements were comparable and were strongly related. Women had slightly higher scores than men, as had students with work experience in health care, and students considering general practice as a career. CONCLUSIONS: Reflection in medical practice can be measured using this semistructured questionnaire built on case vignettes. The mean score allows for the measurement of improvement by future educational efforts. The wide range of individual differences allows for comparisons between groups. The differences found between groups of students were as expected and support the validity of the instrument.

Medical students' cases as an empirical basis for teaching clinical ethics.

PURPOSE: To identify ethical issues that interns encounter in their clinical education and thus build a more empirical basis for the required contents of the clinical ethics curriculum. METHOD: The authors analyzed a total of 522 required case reports on ethical dilemmas experienced by interns from September 1995 to May 1999 at the medical school of Vrije Universiteit in Amsterdam. They identified four regularly described and numerous less frequently described topics. RESULTS: The interns addressed a wide range of ethical themes. In 45% of the cases, they mentioned disclosure or non-disclosure of information and informed consent; in 37%, medical decisions at the end of life; in 16%, medical failures; and in 9%, problems transferring patients from one caregiver to another. The interns also identified 27 themes linked to their unique position as interns and 19 themes related to specific types of patients. CONCLUSION: Based on self-reported experiences, the authors conclude that clinical ethics teachers should reflect on a multitude of dilemmas. Special expertise is required with respect to end-of-life decisions, truth telling, medical failures, and transferring patients from one caregiver to another. The clinical ethics curriculum should encourage students to voice their opinions and deal with values, responsibilities, and the uncertainty and failings of medical interventions.

[Integrated (biopsychosocial) treatment in the family practice: a pregnant patient with a sacral tumor and severe posttraumatic stress disorder]. / Integrale (biopsychosociale) behandeling in de praktijk: een zwangere patiënte met een sacrumtumor en een ernstige posttraumatische stressstoornis.

In a 25-year-old woman pregnant for the second time after a successful first pregnancy, a locally aggressive, invasive sacrum tumour was diagnosed. The execution of the necessary but potentially mutilating surgical procedures was seriously hampered even during the preparative phase, in spite of the conscious wish of the patient to comply, by her severe psychiatric problems (posttraumatic stress disorder with dissociative symptoms). The Psychiatric Consultation Service took over the case management and an integrated (biopsychosocial) diagnostic investigation was carried out, involving analysis of the problems on four system levels: the biological, the psychological, the social and the health care level. An integrated treatment plan was drafted. By collaboration of the entire multidisciplinary treatment team conditions were secured under which patient would let herself be treated. In this way she was enabled to undergo the necessary procedures, with good results.

Prediction of acute and late responses to light therapy from vocal (pitch) and self-rated activation in seasonal affective disorder.

It was hypothesized that pre-treatment activation plays a role in the response to light therapy in Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD). In 55 SAD patients (DSMIII-R) energetic and tense activation was assessed before light therapy via self-rating (AD-ACL) and voice sound characteristics (mean pitch and variation in pitch). These variables were studied in relation to the "acute" response to 4 days of light therapy (30 min, 10000 lux) and to a "late" response (11 (10) days after light therapy had stopped). Acute response was defined as the percent change in 3 times daily self-rated depressed mood (AMS) with respect to the average of 4 baseline days. "Late" response was defined as the percent change in HRSD or AMS scores between baseline and 11 (10) days after light therapy. It was found that patients having high pitched voices with small variation in this pitch benefitted more from light therapy than the patients with low pitch and large variation in pitch levels. This effect was only significant after the first day of light exposure. No other significant relations were found between baseline activation and acute or late responses to light therapy. Hence, light therapy seems to give extra comfort in "tense" patients, who become rapid responders to light therapy.