An examination of the comparative reliability, validity, and accuracy of performance ratings made using computerized adaptive rating scales.

This laboratory research compared the reliability, validity, and accuracy of a computerized adaptive rating scale (CARS) format and 2 relatively common and representative rating formats. The CARS is a paired-comparison rating task that uses adaptive testing principles to present pairs of scaled behavioral statements to the rater to iteratively estimate a ratee's effectiveness on 3 dimensions of contextual performance. Videotaped vignettes of 6 office workers were prepared, depicting prescripted levels of contextual performance, and 112 subjects rated these vignettes using the CARS format and one or the other competing format. Results showed 23%-37% lower standard errors of measurement for the CARS format. In addition, validity was significantly higher for the CARS format (d = .18), and Cronbach's accuracy coefficients showed significantly higher accuracy, with a median effect size of .08. The discussion focuses on possible reasons for the results.

Selecting pilots with crew resource management skills.

For years, pilot selection has focused primarily on the identification of individuals with superior flying skills and abilities. More recently, the aviation community has become increasingly aware that successful completion of a flight or mission requires not only flying skills but the ability to work well in a crew situation. This project involved development and validation of a crew resource management (CRM) skills test for Air Force transport pilots. A significant relation was found between the CRM skills test and behavior-based ratings of aircraft commander CRM performance, and the implications of these findings for CRM-based selection and training are discussed.

Personnel selection.

This chapter reviews literature from approximately mid-1993 through early 1996 in the areas of performance and criteria, validity, statistical and equal opportunity issues, selection for work groups, person-organization fit, applicant reactions to selection procedures, and research on predictors, including ability, personality, assessment centers, interviews, and biodata. The review revolves around three themes: (a) attention toward criteria and models of performance, (b) interest in personality measures as predictors of job performance, and (c) work on the person-organization fit selection model. In our judgment, these themes merge when it is recognized that development of performance models that differentiate criterion constructs reveal highly interpretable relationships between the predictor domain (i.e. ability, personality, and job knowledge) and the criterion domain (i.e. technical proficiency, extra-technical proficiency constructs such as prosocial organizational behavior, and overall job performance). These and related developments are advancing the science of personnel selection and should enhance selection practices in the future.

Barrier inhibition of a temporal neuraxial influence on early chick somitic myogenesis.

Skeletal myogenesis in the chick embryo first occurs in the somite. Somites are transient, paired mesodermal structures adjacent to the neural tube. Somites form from the segmental plate mesenchyme at approximately 90-min intervals. We identify somitic myogenic cells by using confocal microscopy to detect the muscle specific intermediate filament protein, desmin, in whole mount chick embryo preparations. The appearance of desmin in somitic cells does not occur at a constant interval after the somite has formed. The rate of chick somitic myogenic onset, as evidenced by detection of desmin, is approximately 1.5 times faster than the rate of somitogenesis (Borman and Yorde [1994] J. Histochem. Cytochem. 42:265-272). Somitic myogenesis does not appear to be directly linked to somitogenesis but instead may be regulated by some influence external to the somite. Here we have specifically addressed the issue of whether an impermeable barrier placed between the neuraxis and the somites can prevent the onset of somitic myogenesis. When tantalum foil barriers are placed medial to the caudalmost 3-5 somites of embryos having up to 20 somites total (stage 13), the predominant result is an inhibition of myogenic cells lateral to the barrier. Conversely, when the tantalum foil is placed medial to the caudal somites of an embryo having 21 somites (stage 14) or more, desmin is detected lateral to the barrier in most cases. There is a temporal influence originating in the neuraxis which plays a role in the onset of somitic myogenesis. Although the nature of this interaction between the neuraxis and the somites is not yet clear, we have defined a precise temporal location within the developing embryo at which this tissue interaction is taking place.

Analysis of the in vivo myogenic status of chick somites by desmin expression in vitro.

Expression of the muscle specific intermediate filament protein, desmin, is an early marker for chick somitic myogenesis. Somites are transient, paired, mesodermal structures adjacent to the neural tube which are formed very uniformly in a cranial to caudal fashion. The developmental somitic expression of desmin in vivo has been reported previously (Holtzer et al. [1991] "Frontiers in Muscle Research." New York: Elsevier Science, pp 187-207; Borman and Yorde [1994] J. Histochem. Cytochem. 42:265-272). Here we explore the ability of those somitic cells which are desmin negative in vivo to successfully carry out a myogenic program of development in the absence of the surrounding embryonic microenvironment. Somites which are known to be overtly desmin negative in the embryo were explanted and cultured on collagen gels for 4 days. Immuno-detection of desmin identified a population of somites that could support desmin positive cells in vitro as well as a population of somites that could not. The cranially located somites must remain in the embryo for a greater length of time than the caudally positioned somites prior to each being able to express desmin in vitro. In embryos of many ages there is also a population of somites unable to support desmin expression in vitro. The rate at which this ability to support somitic desmin expression in vitro progresses caudally in the embryo is significantly greater than the rate at which somites form. Notably, the detected expression of desmin in somites in vitro is parallel to the rate at which overt expression of desmin in vivo is detected. The implication for these observations with regard to the regulation of somitic myogenesis is discussed.

Analysis of chick somite myogenesis by in situ confocal microscopy of desmin expression.

We explored the relationship in chick embryos between somitogenesis and the onset of somite myogenesis by immunodetection of the muscle-specific intermediate filament protein desmin. Early somite desmin expression was detected by whole-mount in situ confocal microscopy. No detectable somite desmin was observed in embryos of 15 somites (Stage 12) or younger. In embryos having between 16 and 26 somites (Stages 12-15), desmin could be detected in somites positioned increasingly more caudal in the embryo. Finally, in embryos of 27 somites (Stage 16) and older, somite desmin expression was consistently present in all but the caudal-most six somites. Although the rate of somite formation is fairly constant, the rate of observed somite desmin expression progressing caudally in the embryo is greater initially than the rate of segmentation. After an embryo has formed about 27 somites, the rate of desmin appearance parallels the rate of segmentation at a distance of about six somites. This result suggests that very early somite myogenesis is not linked to somitogenesis.