The role of monoclonal antibody affinity in tumor immunotherapy evaluated in in vivo models for minimal residual disease.

To evaluate the role of affinity in monoclonal antibody (mAb)-mediated treatment of carcinomas, we compared the antibodies 17-1A and 323/A3 that bind with different affinities overlapping epitopes on the epithelial adhesion molecule Ep-CAM. This comparison was performed in several models for minimal residual disease in mice grafted with Ep-CAM transfected B16 melanoma cells originating from C57BL/6 mice. These cells were either grafted subcutaneously or injected intravenously into nude BALB/c mice, or grafted subcutaneously in immunocompetent C57BL/6 mice. In the BALB/c subcutaneous model, significant therapeutic results (p < 0.05) compared with the control mAb were obtained with both mAbs 17-1A and 323/A3. However, when treating lung metastases in nude BALB/c mice that had developed after intravenous injection of the B16/Ep-CAM tumor cells, only the high-affinity 323/A3 mAb could significantly (p < 0.05) reduce the number of metastases that appeared. In syngeneic C57BL/6 mice grafted subcutaneously with B16/ Ep-CAM cells, a single 323/A3 or 17-1A mAb injection had no effect, in contrast to that observed for the nude BALB/c mouse model. However, multiple injections of the 323/A3 mAb significantly (p < 0.005) reduced the mean tumor volume, although they did not prevent tumor development. The results show that in vivo antibody-mediated effector cell activation and subsequent tumor cell elimination is determined by mAb affinity and target antigen density. Therefore, treatment of minimal residual disease with high-affinity mAb 323/ A3 is expected to improve the clinical results obtained with mAb 17-1A.

Immunotherapy with low and high affinity monoclonal antibodies 17-1A and 323/A3 in a nude mouse xenograft carcinoma model.

The therapeutic effects of the low and high affinity mAbs 17-1A and 323/A3 were investigated in nude mice xenografted with LS 180 human colorectal carcinoma cells. Treatment of mice grafted with dispersed tumor cells, before formation of a tumor nodule, was started 1 day after s.c. injection of tumor cells and consisted of a single i.p. injection of murine 17-1A or 323/A3 mAb. Tumor appearance after a single injection of either 17-1A or 323/A3 was delayed as compared to injection of an irrelevant mAb. Both 17-1A and 323/A3 reduced the tumor growth rate, and both mAbs decreased the total number of mice that eventually developed a tumor. In all experiments, 323/A3 showed consistently better treatment effects on xenografted mice than mAb 17-1A. For treatment of established tumors with mAb 17-1A or 323/A3 therapy was delayed until a tumor nodule was macroscopically detectable. One single i.p. injection of mAb 17-1A had no effect on further tumor growth and mean tumor size as compared to the control group injected with irrelevant mAb. One single i.p. injection with mAb 323/A3 reduced the tumor growth rate in some mice with established tumors and resulted in a significant difference of mean tumor size of this group as compared to the 17-1A treated mice and the control groups. Multiple injections with mAb 17-1A also had no effects on established tumors, in contrast to mAb 323/A3, where serial injections resulted in tumor growth reduction and, eventually, in some mice reduction in tumor size. In summary, we showed that in nude mice mAb 323/A3 (Ka = 2 x 10(9) M-1) is much more potent than mAb 17-1A (Ka = 5 x 10(7) M-1) in eradication of nonestablished tumor cells and treatment of small established tumors. These results suggest that high affinity mAbs like 323/A3 might dramatically improve the clinical results obtained thus far with the low affinity mAb 17-1A in the adjuvant treatment of surgically resected Dukes C colorectal cancer patients with minimal residual disease.