Evaluating the effects of comprehensive simulation on central venous catheterization training: a comparative observational study.

BACKGROUND: Simulation-based training (SBT) is vital to complex medical procedures such as ultrasound guided central venous catheterization (US-IJCVC), where the experience level of the physician impacts the likelihood of incurring complications. The Dynamic Haptic Robotic Trainer (DHRT) was developed to train residents in CVC as an improvement over manikin trainers, however, the DHRT and manikin trainer both only provide training on one specific portion of CVC, needle insertion. As such, CVC SBT would benefit from more comprehensive training. An extended version of the DHRT was created, the DHRT + , to provide hands-on training and automated feedback on additional steps of CVC. The DHRT + includes a full CVC medical kit, a false vein channel, and a personalized, reactive interface. When used together, the DHRT and DHRT + systems provide comprehensive training on needle insertion and catheter placement for CVC. This study evaluates the impact of the DHRT + on resident self-efficacy and CVC skill gains as compared to training on the DHRT alone. METHODS: Forty-seven medical residents completed training on the DHRT and 59 residents received comprehensive training on the DHRT and the DHRT + . Each resident filled out a central line self-efficacy (CLSE) survey before and after undergoing training on the simulators. After simulation training, each resident did one full CVC on a manikin while being observed by an expert rater and graded on a US-IJCVC checklist. RESULTS: For two items on the US-IJCVC checklist, "verbalizing consent" and "aspirating blood through the catheter", the DHRT + group performed significantly better than the DHRT only group. Both training groups showed significant improvements in self-efficacy from before to after training. However, type of training received was a significant predictor for CLSE items "using the proper equipment in the proper order", and "securing the catheter with suture and applying dressing" with the comprehensive training group that received additional training on the DHRT + showing higher post training self-efficacy. CONCLUSIONS: The integration of comprehensive training into SBT has the potential to improve US-IJCVC education for both learning gains and self-efficacy.

Identifying diversity of patient anatomy through automated image analysis of clinical ultrasounds.

PURPOSE: Central venous catheterization (CVC) carries inherent risks which can be mitigated through the use of appropriate ultrasound-guidance during needle insertion. This study aims to comprehensively understand patient anatomy as it is visualized during CVC by employing a semi-automated image analysis method to track the internal jugular vein and carotid artery throughout recorded ultrasound videos. METHODS: The ultrasound visualization of 50 CVC procedures were recorded at Penn State Health Milton S. Hershey Medical Center. The developed algorithm was used to detect the vessel edges, calculating metrics such as area, position, and eccentricity. RESULTS: Results show typical anatomical variations of the vein and artery, with the artery being more circular and posterior to the vein in most cases. Notably, two cases revealed atypical artery positions, emphasizing the algorithm's precision in detecting anomalies. Additionally, dynamic vessel properties were analyzed, with the vein compressing on average to 13.4% of its original size and the artery expanding by 13.2%. CONCLUSION: This study provides valuable insights which can be used to increase the accuracy of training simulations, thus enhancing medical education and procedural expertise. Furthermore, the novel approach of employing automated data analysis techniques to clinical recordings showcases the potential for continual assessment of patient anatomy, which could be useful in future advancements.

Evaluating the Impact of Assessment Metrics for Simulated Central Venous Catheterization Training.

INTRODUCTION: Performance assessment and feedback are critical factors in successful medical simulation-based training. The Dynamic Haptic Robotic Trainer (DHRT) allows residents to practice ultrasound-guided needle insertions during simulated central venous catheterization (CVC) procedures while providing detailed feedback and assessment. A study was performed to examine the effectiveness of the DHRT in training the important skills of needle tip tracking and aspiration and how these skills impact procedural complications in simulated CVC. METHODS: The DHRT data were collected for 163 residents at 2 hospitals for 6 simulated needle insertions. Users were given automated feedback on 5 performance metrics, which measure aspiration rate, arterial punctures, punctures through and through the vein, loss of access to the vein, and successful access to the vein. Aspiration rates and tip tracking rates were analyzed to determine their significance in preventing CVC complications and improving performance. RESULTS: Tip tracking rates higher than 40% were 2.3 times more likely to result in successful venous access than rates less than 10%. Similarly, aspiration rates higher than 80% were 2.6 times more likely to result in successful venous access than rates less than 10%. Proper tip tracking and aspiration both reduced mechanical complications. Resident performance improved for all metrics except tip tracking. CONCLUSIONS: Proper tip tracking and aspiration both reduced complications and increased the likelihood of success. However, the skill of tip tracking was not effectively learned through practice without feedback. Therefore, ultrasound-guided needle-based procedures, including CVC, can be improved by providing specific feedback to users on their ultrasound usage to track needle insertions.

Slow and Steady: Examining the impact of hands-on instructions on learnability of a training simulator to enhance development of core skills in Central Venous Catheterization.

Instructional design is the theory surrounding how learners perceive information and is prevalent in simulation-based medical education. Simulation is used for a variety of medical procedures including central venous catheterization (CVC). The dynamic haptic robotic trainer (DHRT) is a CVC teaching simulator developed to specifically focus on training the needle insertion portion of CVC. While the DHRT has been validated to teach CVC as well as other training methods, an opportunity was seen to redesign the instructions of the DHRT to increase the learnability of the system. A hands-on instructional walkthrough was designed. A group trained with the hands-on instructions was compared to a previous group to assess initial insertion performance. Results indicate that changing the instructional method to be hands-on may have an impact on system learnability and help reinforce development of core components of CVC.

Preparing for the lasting effects of COVID-19 on medical training: The design and pilot study of a low-fidelity virtual reality prototype for Central Venous Catheterization training.

Over the last several decades we have seen a shift from in-person to online training that has been exasperated by the COVID-19 pandemic. Researchers believe that many of these effects will be lasting which makes it even more important that the Human Factors community seek to step back and understand how to best train complex skills in a virtual world. The current paper is focused on understanding the utility of Virtual Reality (VR) in medical education for a hands-on procedural heavy procedure - ultrasound-guided Internal Jugular Central Venous Catheterization. Specifically, the objective of this study is to identify the potential utility of VR in US-IJCVC training through the design of a low-fidelity prototype and user interviews with three subject-matter experts. Results showed that the VR prototype designed is useful and provides a depth of knowledge and educational value which can be used to design innovative VR training approaches.

Going the (social) distance: Comparing the effectiveness of online versus in-person Internal Jugular Central Venous Catheterization procedural training.

BACKGROUND: This study compares surgical residents' knowledge acquisition of ultrasound-guided Internal Jugular Central Venous Catheterization (US-IJCVC) between in-person and online procedural training cohorts before receiving independent in-person Dynamic Haptic Robotic Simulation training. METHODS: Three surgical residency procedural training cohorts, two in-person (N = 26) and one online (N = 14), were compared based on their performance on a 24-item US-IJCVC evaluation checklist completed by an expert physician completed after training. Pre- and post-training US-IJCVC knowledge was also compared for the online cohort. RESULTS: No significant change in the pass rates on the US-IJCVC checklist was found between in-person and online cohorts (p = 0.208). There were differences in the Economy of Time and Motion between in-person and online cohorts (p < 0.005). The online cohort had significant increases in US-IJCVC knowledge pre-to post-training (p < 0.008). CONCLUSION: Online training with independent simulation practice was as effective as in-person training for US-IJCVC.

FUN AND GAMES: DESIGNING A GAMIFIED CENTRAL VENOUS CATHETERIZATION TRAINING SIMULATOR.

Gamification, or adding elements of games to training systems, has the potential to increase learner engagement and information retention. However, the use of gamification has yet to be explored in Central Venous Catheterization (CVC) trainers which teach a commonly performed medical procedure with high incidence rates. In order to combat these errors, a Dynamic Haptic Robotic Trainer (DHRT) was developed, which focuses on vessel identification and access. A DHRT+ system is currently under development that focuses on whole procedure training (e.g. sterilization and catheter insertion), including a gamified Graphical User Interface. The goal of this paper was to (1) develop a game-like, patient-centered interface to foster personalized learning and (2) understand the perceived utility of gamification for CVC skill development with expert doctors. This paper outlines some of the potential benefits and deficits of the use of gamification in medical trainers that can be used to drive simulation design.

OBJECTIVE ASSESSMENT METRICS FOR CENTRAL LINE SIMULATORS: AN EXPLORATION OF CAUSAL FACTORS.

The Dynamic Haptic Robotic Trainer (DHRT) was developed to minimize the up to 39% of adverse effects experienced by patients during Central Venous Catheterization (CVC) by standardizing CVC training, and provide automated assessments of performance. Specifically, this system was developed to replace manikin trainers that only simulate one patient anatomy and require a trained preceptor to evaluate the trainees' performance. While the DHRT system provides automated feedback, the utility of this system with real-world scenarios and expertise has yet to be thoroughly investigated. Thus, the current study was developed to determine the validity of the current objective assessment metrics incorporated in the DHRT system through expert interviews. The main findings from this study are that experts do agree on perceptions of patient case difficulty, and that characterizations of patient case difficulty is based on anatomical characteristics, multiple needle insertions, and prior catheterization.