New 2,4-bis[(substituted-aminomethyl)phenyl]phenylquinazoline and 2,4-bis[(substituted-aminomethyl)phenyl]phenylquinoline Derivatives: Synthesis and Biological Evaluation as Novel Anticancer Agents by Targeting G-Quadruplex.

The syntheses of novel 2,4-bis[(substituted-aminomethyl)phenyl]phenylquinazolines 12 and 2,4-bis[(substituted-aminomethyl)phenyl]phenylquinolines 13 are reported here in six steps starting from various halogeno-quinazoline-2,4-(1H,3H)-diones or substituted anilines. The antiproliferative activities of the products were determined in vitro against a panel of breast (MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231), human adherent cervical (HeLa and SiHa), and ovarian (A2780) cell lines. Disubstituted 6- and 7-phenyl-bis(3-dimethylaminopropyl)aminomethylphenyl-quinazolines 12b, 12f, and 12i displayed the most interesting antiproliferative activities against six human cancer cell lines. In the series of quinoline derivatives, 6-phenyl-bis(3-dimethylaminopropyl)aminomethylphenylquinoline 13a proved to be the most active. G-quadruplexes (G4) stacked non-canonical nucleic acid structures found in specific G-rich DNA, or RNA sequences in the human genome are considered as potential targets for the development of anticancer agents. Then, as small aza-organic heterocyclic derivatives are well known to target and stabilize G4 structures, their ability to bind G4 structures have been determined through FRET melting, circular dichroism, and native mass spectrometry assays. Finally, telomerase inhibition ability has been also assessed using the MCF-7 cell line.

Neuronal morphology and synaptic plasticity in the hippocampus of vitamin A deficient rats.

Vitamin A (retinol) and related retinoids are micronutrients provided by food. Retinol derivatives are growth factors important for development, cell differentiation and tissue homeostasis, especially in the brain.Objective: The hippocampus is a pivotal brain structure for learning and memory and hippocampal-dependent memory is highly sensitive to retinoids action. However, the underlying mechanisms are still unclear. In this study, we characterized the impact of vitamin A deficiency on memory and neuronal plasticity, focusing on the CA1 region of the hippocampus in rats.Methods: Weaned male Wistar rats were fed a control (5 UI/g) or deficient vitamin A diet (0 UI/g) for 10 weeks. The effect of vitamin A supplementation (20 UI/g) for 3 weeks was also tested. Memory performances were assessed in the Y-maze (n = 24-30/group), retinoic acid levels were measured (LC-MS/MS) in the serum and in the hippocampus (n = 5/group), CA1 neuronal architecture was analyzed with Golgi staining (n = 17-20 neurons/group) and electrophysiological patch-clamp recordings were performed on hippocampal brain slices (n = 6-11/group).Results: Vitamin A deficiency from weaning significantly lowered hippocampal levels of retinoic acid, reduced dendritic length and branching of CA1 pyramidal neurons and decreased spontaneous glutamatergic synaptic events and synaptic plasticity. When replenishment with moderate dose of dietary vitamin A for 3 weeks was done, most of the synaptic and morphological alterations were absent.Conclusion: This study provides new mechanistic insight to understand the critical role of retinoic acid in hippocampal function.

Analysis of the Phospholipid Profile of the Collection Strain PAO1 and Clinical Isolates of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in Relation to Their Attachment Capacity.

Bacteria form multicellular and resistant structures named biofilms. Biofilm formation starts with the attachment phase, and the molecular actors involved in this phase, except adhesins, are poorly characterized. There is growing evidence that phospholipids are more than simple structural bricks. They are involved in bacterial adaptive physiology, but little is known about their role in biofilm formation. Here, we report a mass spectrometry analysis of the phospholipid (PL) profile of several strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolated from cystic fibrosis patients. The aim of our study was to evaluate a possible link between the PL profile of a strain and its attachment phenotype. Our results showed that PL profile is strongly strain-dependent. The PL profile of P. aeruginosa PAO1, a collection strain, was different from those of 10 clinical isolates characterized either by a very low or a very high attachment capacity. We observed also that the clinical strain's PL profiles varied even more importantly between isolates. By comparing groups of strains having similar attachment capacities, we identified one PL, PE 18:1-18:1, as a potential molecular actor involved in attachment, the first step in biofilm formation. This PL represents a possible target in the fight against biofilms.

Characterization of Isomers of Lipid A from Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 by Liquid Chromatography with Tandem Mass Spectrometry with Higher-Energy Collisional Dissociation and Ultraviolet Photodissociation.

Lipopolysaccharides (LPS) constitute the outermost layer of Gram-negative bacteria and consequently play an important role in bacterial infections. In order to address public health issues posed by Gram-negative bacteria, it is necessary to elucidate the structure of the molecular actors at the forefront of infections. LPS virulence and toxicity are partially modulated by lipid A, a hydrophobic saccharolipid that anchors LPS to the bacterial outer membrane. Understanding the lipid A structure is inherently intertwined with understanding its role as an endotoxin. Accordingly, several successful strategies incorporating tandem mass spectrometry have been applied toward the structural analysis of lipid A. Herein, a shotgun HCD strategy was applied toward the characterization of the lipid A profile of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1. This analysis was enhanced by the development of an LC-MS/MS approach to eliminate isomeric signals in the MS/MS spectra that confounded characterization. Importantly, combining reverse phase chromatography with HCD and ultraviolet photodissociation analyses of the lipid A profile revealed the presence of previously unreported lipid A acyl chain positional isomers. Altogether, these strategies provide the most in-depth structural and molecular characterization of PAO1 lipid A to date.

Lipid selectivity in detergent extraction from bilayers.

Despite numerous studies on detergent-induced solubilization of membranes and on the underlying mechanisms associated with this process, very little is known regarding the selectivity of detergents for lipids during their extraction from membranes. To get insights about this phenomenon, solubilization of model bilayers prepared from binary lipid mixtures by different detergents was examined. Three commonly used detergents were used: the non-ionic Triton X-100 (TX), the negatively-charged sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS), and the positively-charged n-dodecyltrimethylammonium chloride (DTAC). Two model membranes were used in order to identify if specific intermolecular interactions can lead to lipid selectivity: bilayers made of a binary mixture of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) and 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (POPE), and of a binary mixture of POPC and 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoglycerol (POPG). Therefore, it was possible to describe systems presenting a combination of detergents bearing different charges with bilayers with different polymorphic propensities and charge. In conditions for which partial solubilization was observed, the composition of the extracted lipid phase was quantified with Liquid Chromatography coupled to Mass Spectrometry to elucidate whether a lipid selectivity occurred in the solubilization process. On one hand, it is found that repulsive or attractive electrostatic interactions did not lead to any lipid selectivity. On the other hand, POPE was systematically less extracted than POPC, regardless of the detergent nature. We propose that this lipid selectivity is inherent to the molecular shape of POPE unsuited for micelles curvature properties.

Effect of matrices and additives on phosphorylated and ketodeoxyoctonic acid lipids A analysis by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-mass spectrometry.

Lipid A is a major compound of the outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria and is a key factor of bacterial virulence. As lipid A's structure differs among bacterial species and varies between strains of the same species, knowing its modifications is essential to understand its implications in the infectious process. To analyze these lipids, matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) is a well-suited method that is fast and efficient. However, there are limitations with the matrix and additives used, such as the suppression of signal or prompt fragmentations that could give a false overview of lipid A composition in biological samples. For a comprehensive analysis of the entire lipid A species present in a sample, we tested 16 matrices and 11 additives on two commercial lipids A. The first commercial one contains single phosphorylation group, and the second contains two phosphorylation and two ketodeoxyoctonic acid (KDO) groups. The lipid A containing KDO groups was essentially detected by the 3-hydroxypicolinic acid (3-HPA) matrix, whereas the monophosphorylated lipid A could be detected by 13 matrices out of the 16. We also demonstrated that the signal of diphosphorylated lipid A can be enhanced with the use of additives in the matrix. Our study indicated that the best conditions to obtain a clear signal of both lipids A without prompt fragmentation was the use of 3-HPA with 10mM trifluoroacetic acid (TFA).

Tandem NMR and Mass Spectrometry Analysis of Human Nuclear Membrane Lipids.

The human nuclear membrane is composed of a double bilayer, the inner membrane being linked to the protein lamina network and the outer nuclear membrane continuous with the endoplasmic reticulum. Nuclear membranes can form large invaginations inside the nucleus; their specific roles still remain unknown. Although much of the protein identification has been determined, their lipid composition remains largely undetermined. In order to understand the mechanical and dynamic properties of nuclear membranes we investigated their lipid composition by two quantitative methods, namely, 31P and 1H multidimensional NMR and mass spectrometry, using internal standards. We also developed a nondetergent nuclei extraction protocol allowing to produce milligram quantities of nuclear membrane lipids. We found that the nuclear membrane lipid extract is composed of a complex mixture of phospholipids with different phosphatidylcholine species present in large amounts. Negatively charged lipids, with elevated amounts of phosphatidylinositol (PI), were also present. Mass spectrometry confirmed the phospholipid composition and provided further information on acyl-chain length and unsaturation. Lipid chain lengths ranged between 30 and 38 carbon atoms (two chains summed up) with a high proportion of 34 carbon atom length for most species. PI lipids have high amounts of chain lengths with 36-38 carbons. Independent of the chain length unsaturations were highly elevated with one to two double bonds per lipid species.

Normalization of hippocampal retinoic acid level corrects age-related memory deficits in rats.

Dietary micronutrients constitute a major environmental factor influencing aging processes. Vitamin A (vit. A) is the precursor of retinoic acid, a bioactive molecule that controls the expression of several genes involved in brain function. Evidence suggests a reduction of vit. A bioavailability with aging, but its impact on neuronal network is poorly understood. We investigated the mechanisms linking memory impairments with specific alterations of retinoic acid metabolism in the hippocampus. We compared young (10 weeks) and aged (16 months) rats, supplemented or not with dietary vit. A (20 IU retinol/g) for 4 weeks. Our study reveals that aging induced dysregulation of gene expression involved in vit. A and retinoic acid metabolism in the liver. Furthermore, vit. A supplementation restored the integrity of the hippocampal neuronal morphology altered by aging. Importantly, we found a high correlation between hippocampal levels of retinoic acid and memory performance. The present work establishes the link between collapse of retinoid metabolism and age-related cognitive decline, highlighting the role of vit. A in maintaining memory through aging.

Phospholipid Content of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 Is Modulated by the Growth Phase Rather Than the Immobilization State.

Biofilms have significance in medical, industrial, and environmental settings, and can cause important damage. As biofilms are tolerant to various stresses, including antibiotics, it is necessary to better understand their formation. For this reason, we characterized the phospholipidome of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, an opportunistic pathogen involved in numerous infections, during the first steps of the biofilm development. By a liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry time-course analysis over a 24-h period, we compared the phospholipid (PL) composition of immobilized (attached) and planktonic (unattached) P. aeruginosa PAO1 cells. Our results showed that the PL content of P. aeruginosa PAO1 was mainly modulated by the incubation time, thus related to bacterial growth but also, more modestly, by the immobilization state. We observed that relative amounts of PL varied over time with two main profiles and that these profiles are correlated to its fatty acid composition, including the degree of unsaturation. A statistical analysis revealed that the PL contents of both attached and unattached PAO1 cells were significantly different mainly after 3 and 6 h of incubation and that the amounts of two PL presented a statistical difference between attached and unattached cells all along the 24-h period: PtdEtn 16:0_18:1 and PtdEtn 18:1_18:1.

Caveolae-mediated effects of TNF-α on human skeletal muscle cells.

Chronic diseases are characterized by the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines such than TNF-α and are frequently correlated with muscle wasting conditions. Among the pleiotropic effects of TNF-α within the cell, its binding to TNFR1 receptor has been shown to activate sphingomyelinases leading to the production of ceramides. Sphingomyelinases and TNF receptor have been localized within caveolae which are specialized RAFT enriched in cholesterol and sphingolipids. Because of their inverted omega shape, maintained by the oligomerization of specialized proteins, caveolins and cavins, caveolae serve as membrane reservoir therefore providing mechanical protection to plasma membranes. Although sphingolipids metabolites, caveolins and TNF-α/TNFR1 have been shown to independently interfere with muscle physiology, no data have clearly demonstrated their concerted action on muscle cell regeneration. In this context, our study aimed at studying the molecular mechanisms induced by TNF-α at the level of caveolae in LHCN-M2 human muscle satellite cells. Here we showed that TNF-α-induced production of ROS and nSMase activation requires caveolin. More strikingly, we have demonstrated that TNF-α induces the formation of additional caveolae at the plasma membrane of myoblasts. Furthermore, TNF-α prevents myoblast fusion suggesting that inflammation could modulate caveolae organization/function and satellite cell function.

Contribution of the precursors and interplay of the pathways in the phospholipid metabolism of the malaria parasite.

The malaria parasite, Plasmodium falciparum, develops and multiplies in the human erythrocyte. It needs to synthesize considerable amounts of phospholipids (PLs), principally phosphatidylcholine (PC), phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), and phosphatidylserine (PS). Several metabolic pathways coexist for their de novo biosynthesis, involving a dozen enzymes. Given the importance of these PLs for the survival of the parasite, we sought to determine their sources and to understand the connections and dependencies between the multiple pathways. We used three deuterated precursors (choline-d9, ethanolamine-d4, and serine-d3) to follow and quantify simultaneously their incorporations in the intermediate metabolites and the final PLs by LC/MS/MS. We show that PC is mainly derived from choline, itself provided by lysophosphatidylcholine contained in the serum. In the absence of choline, the parasite is able to use both other precursors, ethanolamine and serine. PE is almost equally synthesized from ethanolamine and serine, with both precursors being able to compensate for each other. Serine incorporated in PS is mainly derived from the degradation of host cell hemoglobin by the parasite. P. falciparum thus shows an unexpected adaptability of its PL synthesis pathways in response to different disturbances. These data provide new information by mapping the importance of the PL metabolic pathways of the malaria parasite and could be used to design future therapeutic approaches.

Liver Reptin/RUVBL2 controls glucose and lipid metabolism with opposite actions on mTORC1 and mTORC2 signalling.

OBJECTIVE: The AAA+ ATPase Reptin is overexpressed in hepatocellular carcinoma and preclinical studies indicate that it could be a relevant therapeutic target. However, its physiological and pathophysiological roles in vivo remain unknown. This study aimed to determine the role of Reptin in mammalian adult liver. DESIGN AND RESULTS: We generated an inducible liver-specific Reptin knockout (RepinLKO ) mouse model. Following Reptin invalidation, mice displayed decreased body and fat mass, hypoglycaemia and hypolipidaemia. This was associated with decreased hepatic mTOR protein abundance. Further experiments in primary hepatocytes demonstrated that Reptin maintains mTOR protein level through its ATPase activity. Unexpectedly, loss or inhibition of Reptin induced an opposite effect on mTORC1 and mTORC2 signalling, with: (1) strong inhibition of hepatic mTORC1 activity, likely responsible for the reduction of hepatocytes cell size, for decreased de novo lipogenesis and cholesterol transcriptional programmes and (2) enhancement of mTORC2 activity associated with inhibition of the gluconeogenesis transcriptional programme and hepatic glucose production. Consequently, the role of hepatic Reptin in the pathogenesis of insulin resistance (IR) and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease consecutive to a high-fat diet was investigated. We found that Reptin deletion completely rescued pathological phenotypes associated with IR, including glucose intolerance, hyperglycaemia, hyperlipidaemia and hepatic steatosis. CONCLUSION: We show here that the AAA +ATPase Reptin is a regulator of mTOR signalling in the liver and global glucido-lipidic homeostasis. Inhibition of hepatic Reptin expression or activity represents a new therapeutic perspective for metabolic syndrome.

Derivatization-free LC-MS/MS method for estrogen quantification in mouse brain highlights a local metabolic regulation after oral versus subcutaneous administration.

17ß-Estradiol (17ß-E2) is a steroid with pleiotropic actions. In addition to being a sexual hormone, it is also produced in the brain where it modulates the reproductive axis. It has been shown that 17ß-E2 also acts on synaptic plasticity and plays a role in neurological pathways and in neurodegenerative diseases. Assaying this steroid in the brain is thus interesting to improve our knowledge of 17ß-E2 effects in the brain. However, 17ß-E2 concentration in the central nervous system has been reported to be of a few nanograms per gram wet weight (nanomolar range concentration); therefore, its quantification requires both an efficient extraction process and a sensitive detection method. Herein is presented a derivatization-free procedure based on solid-phase extraction followed by LC-MS/MS analysis, targeted on 17ß-E2, its isomer17α-E2, and its metabolites estrone (E1) and estriol (E3). This extraction process allowed reaching 96% 17ß-E2 recovery from the mouse brain. Limit of detection (LOD) and limit of quantification (LOQ) values of 0.5 and 2.5 pmol mL-1, respectively, were reached for both 17α-E2 and 17ß-E2. LOD values for E1 and E3 were 0.01 and 0.025 pmol mL-1, respectively. The variation coefficients for intra- and inter-assays were 6 and 14%, respectively, for both estradiol forms. The method was applied to assess estrogen levels in the mouse brain and hippocampus after 17ß-E2 acute (subcutaneous injection) and chronic (drinking water) physiological administration. Total estrogen levels were determined after enzymatic deconjugation and compared to free estrogen levels. While 17α-E2 was not detected in biological samples, 17ß-E2 and metabolite measurements highlight a local biotransformation of estrogens after physiological administration via drinking water. Graphical abstract Method workflow: After oral or subcutaneous Estradiol administration, mouse brain or hippocampus was removed. Samples were homogenized and prepared according to a liquid-liquid extraction, followed by a solid-phase extraction. Then, LC-MS/MS was optimized to quantify 17ß-E2, its isomer17α-E2, its metabolites estrone (E1) and estriol (E3) and their conjugates.

Revisiting Plant Plasma Membrane Lipids in Tobacco: A Focus on Sphingolipids.

The lipid composition of plasma membrane (PM) and the corresponding detergent-insoluble membrane (DIM) fraction were analyzed with a specific focus on highly polar sphingolipids, so-called glycosyl inositol phosphorylceramides (GIPCs). Using tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) 'Bright Yellow 2' cell suspension and leaves, evidence is provided that GIPCs represent up to 40 mol % of the PM lipids. Comparative analysis of DIMs with the PM showed an enrichment of 2-hydroxylated very-long-chain fatty acid-containing GIPCs and polyglycosylated GIPCs in the DIMs. Purified antibodies raised against these GIPCs were further used for immunogold-electron microscopy strategy, revealing the distribution of polyglycosylated GIPCs in domains of 35 ± 7 nm in the plane of the PM. Biophysical studies also showed strong interactions between GIPCs and sterols and suggested a role for very-long-chain fatty acids in the interdigitation between the two PM-composing monolayers. The ins and outs of lipid asymmetry, raft formation, and interdigitation in plant membrane biology are finally discussed.

Characterization of glycosyl inositol phosphoryl ceramides from plants and fungi by mass spectrometry.

Although glycosyl inositol phosphoryl ceramides (GIPCs) represent the most abundant class of sphingolipids in plants, they still remain poorly characterized in terms of structure and biodiversity. More than 50 years after their discovery, little is known about their subcellular distribution and their exact roles in membrane structure and biological functions. This review is focused on extraction and characterization methods of GIPCs occurring in plants and fungi. Global methods for characterizing ceramide moieties of GIPCs revealed the structures of long-chain bases (LCBs) and fatty acids (FAs): LCBs are dominated by tri-hydroxylated molecules such as monounsaturated and saturated phytosphingosine (t18:1 and t18:0, respectively) in plants and mainly phytosphingosine (t18:0 and t20:0) in fungi; FA are generally 14-26 carbon atoms long in plants and 16-26 carbon atoms long in fungi, these chains being often hydroxylated in position 2. Mass spectrometry plays a pivotal role in the assessment of GIPC diversity and the characterization of their structures. Indeed, it allowed to determine that the core structure of GIPC polar heads in plants is Hex(R1)-HexA-IPC, with R1 being a hydroxyl, an amine, or a N-acetylamine group, whereas the core structure in fungi is Man-IPC. Notably, information gained from tandem mass spectrometry spectra was most useful to describe the huge variety of structures encountered in plants and fungi and reveal GIPCs with yet uncharacterized polar head structures, such as hexose-inositol phosphoceramide in Chondracanthus acicularis and (hexuronic acid)4-inositol phosphoceramide and hexose-(hexuronic acid)3-inositol phosphoceramide in Ulva lactuca.

Biochemical survey of the polar head of plant glycosylinositolphosphoceramides unravels broad diversity.

Although Glycosyl-Inositol-Phospho-Ceramides (GIPCs) are the main sphingolipids of plant tissues, they remain poorly characterized in term of structures. This lack of information, notably with regard to polar heads, currently hampers the understanding of GIPC functions in biological systems. This situation prompted us to undertake a large scale-analysis of plant GIPCs: 23 plant species chosen in various phylogenetic groups were surveyed for their total GIPC content. GIPCs were extracted and their polar heads were characterized by negative ion MALDI and ESI mass spectrometry. Our data shed light on an unexpected broad diversity of GIPC distributions within Plantae, and the occurrence of yet-unreported GIPC structures in green and red algae. In monocots, GIPCs with three saccharides were apparently found to be major, whereas a series with two saccharides was dominant in Eudicots within a few notable exceptions. In plant cell cultures, GIPC polar heads appeared to bear a higher number of glycan units than in the tissue from which they originate. Perspectives are discussed in term of GIPC metabolism diversity and function of these lipids.

Enzymatic synthesis of phosphatidylserine using bile salt mixed micelles.

Phosphatidylserine (PS) rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids of the n-3 series was obtained by enzymatic synthesis with phospholipase D (PLD) and a marine lipid extract as substrate. Synthesis was performed using mixed micelles composed of either sodium deoxycholate (SDC) or sodium cholate (SC). To limit the use of surfactant and to monitor the performance of PLD, the mixed micelles were characterized both in terms of bile salt/lipid molar ratio in the aggregates and of mean diameter. A fractional factorial experiment was selected to study the effect of pH, temperature, enzyme, L-serine concentrations, bile salt/lipid molar ratio and Ca(2+) content (in the case of SC only) on PS synthesis. The amount of L-serine was the main factor governing the equilibrium between transphosphatidylation and hydrolysis reaction. Increasing the bile salt/lipid molar ratio decreased PS synthesis yield. In contrast, pH (6.5-8) and temperature (35-45°C) did not affect PLD activity in the tested conditions. This statistical approach allowed determining a combination of parameters (pH, temperature, bile salt/lipid molar ratio, enzyme and alcohol acceptor concentrations) for PS synthesis. After 24 h, the transphosphatidylation reaction led to 57±2% and 56±3% of PS in the phospholipid mixtures with SDC and SC, respectively. In both cases, about 10% of phosphatidic acid was present as a side-product. On the whole, this work provided fundamental basis for a possible development of enzymatic PLD technology using food-grade emulsifiers to produce PS complying with industrial constraints for nutritional applications.

A single run LC-MS/MS method for phospholipidomics.

Liquid chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry has been compared to shotgun analysis with the objective of finding the best compromise for a single run analysis of whole cell phospholipids. Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC), normal phase (NP), and reversed phase (RP) liquid chromatography were evaluated with reference phospholipids belonging to phosphatidic acid (PA), phosphatidylcholine (PC), phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), phosphatidylglycerol (PG), phosphatidylinositol (PI), and phosphatidylserine (PS) classes. NP-HPLC- and RP-HPLC-ESI-MS/MS were applied to yeast phospholipidome analysis, using a wild-type strain and two strains defective for acyltransferases that are known to be involved in de novo phospholipid synthesis or phospholipid remodeling. The MRM mode was used for relative quantitation of individual compounds based on reference phospholipids bearing fatty acid chains with an odd number of carbon atoms. Combined LC-MS/MS was found superior to shotgun analysis, leading to a larger number of quantified species than shotgun analysis. Finally, RP-HPLC-MS/MS was the preferred method for its higher selectivity, robustness, and better repeatability.