Direct visualization of serine hydrolase activities in complex proteomes using fluorescent active site-directed probes.

The field of biochemistry is currently faced with the enormous challenge of assigning functional significance to more than thirty thousand predicted protein products encoded by the human genome. In order to accomplish this daunting task, methods will be required that facilitate the global analysis of proteins in complex biological systems. Recently, methods have been described for simultaneously monitoring the activity of multiple enzymes in crude proteomes based on their reactivity with tagged chemical probes. These activity based probes (ABPs) have used either radiochemical or biotin/avidin-based detection methods to allow consolidated visualization of numerous enzyme activities. Here we report the synthesis and evaluation of fluorescent activity based probes for the serine hydrolase super-family of enzymes. The fluorescent methods detailed herein provide superior throughput, sensitivity, and quantitative accuracy when compared to previously described ABPs, and provide a straight-forward platform for high-throughput proteome analysis.

Ultra-high throughput screen of two-million-member combinatorial compound collection in a miniaturized, 1536-well assay format.

Results of a complete survey of the more than 2-million-member Pharmacopeia compound collection in a 1536-well microvolume screening assay format are reported. A complete technology platform, enabling the performance of ultra-high throughput screening in a miniaturized 1536-well assay format, has been assembled and utilized. The platform consists of tools for performing microvolume assays, including assay plates, liquid handlers, optical imagers, and data management software. A fluorogenic screening assay for inhibition of a protease enzyme target was designed and developed using this platform. The assay was used to perform a survey screen of the Pharmacopeia compound collection for active inhibitors of the target enzyme. The results from the survey demonstrate the successful implementation of the ultra-high throughout platform for routine screening purposes. Performance of the assay in the miniaturized format is equivalent to that of a standard 96-well assay, showing the same dependence on kinetic parameters and ability to measure enzyme inhibition. The survey screen identified an active class of compounds within the Pharmacopeia compound collection. These results were confirmed using a standard 96-well assay.

Ligand discovery using encoded combinatorial libraries.

Solid-phase combinatorial synthesis using split-pool or direct divide methods allows large libraries of complex molecules to be generated. Encoding techniques used during synthesis allow the identities of the products to be determined readily. An overview of this process and its application to ligand discovery are presented, along with comparisons to alternative approaches. Libraries are classified depending upon their intended use as discovery libraries (for broad screening), targeted libraries (for structure-based screening) and optimization libraries (for activity improvement). Biological assays can be performed on the solid support that is used in synthesis, or in solution under in vitro or in vivo conditions, with readouts indicative of either receptor binding or biological activity. This approach has led to numerous examples of successful ligand discovery.

Ligand-receptor binding measured by laser-scanning imaging.

This report describes the integration of laser-scanning fluorometric cytometry and nonseparation ligand-binding techniques to provide new assay methods adaptable to miniaturization and high-throughput screening. Receptor-bound, cyanine dye-labeled ligands, [Cy]ligands, were discriminated from those free in solution by measuring the accumulated fluorescence associated with a receptor-containing particle. To illustrate the various binding formats accommodated by this technique, saturation- and competition-binding analyses were performed with [Cy]ligands and their cognate receptors expressed in CHO cells or as fusion proteins coated on polystyrene microspheres. We have successfully applied this technique to the analysis of G protein-coupled receptors, cytokine receptors, and SH2 domains. Multiparameter readouts from ligands labeled separately with Cy5 and Cy5.5 demonstrate the simultaneous analysis of two target receptors in a single well. In addition, laser-scanning cytometry has been used to assay enzymes such as phosphatases and in the development of single-step fluorescent immunoassays.

Chemokine receptor-ligand interactions measured using time-resolved fluorescence.

Two G protein-coupled receptor subtypes (CXCR1 and CXCR2) mediate Interleukin-8 (IL8) action in cells. A nonradioactive lanthanide-chelate derivatized IL8 ligand was developed to measure the binding activity of the chemokine receptors, CXCR1 and CXCR2. Site-specific mutagenesis of the carboxyl-terminal serine of IL8 to cysteine resulted in a mutant IL8 (IL8-S72C) having a single free sulfhydryl. Using an iodoacetamide derivative of the Eu3+-chelate of N-(p-benzoic acid)diethylenetriamine-N,N',N"-tetraacetic acid (DTTA), incorporation of one Eu3+ per IL8 molecule ([Eu3+]IL8-S72C) was achieved. The dissociation constant for this conjugate was similar to that measured for [125I]IL8 ( approximately 2 nM) when measured by time-resolved fluorometry using CHO cell lines stably expressing CXCR1 or CXCR2 receptors. The sensitivity, stability, and high specific activity of europium-labeled IL8 demonstrate the usefulness of lanthanide-labeled proteins in the measurement of receptor-ligand interactions and may be extended to other peptide ligands.

New technologies for high-throughput screening.

To screen efficiently the millions of compounds that are synthesized using combinatorial and automated methods, dramatically improved assay technologies are currently needed. In 96-well microtiter plates, nonradioactive techniques (primarily fluorimetric) and cell-based functional methods have moved to the cutting edge, while clever assays that extract information from large bead-based combinatorial libraries have begun to show considerable promise. In the future, miniaturized assays that break out of the 96-well format will be enabled by innovative technologies for high-throughput screening.

Reconstitution of active human calcineurin from recombinant subunits expressed in bacteria.

Calcineurin, a protein phosphatase found in eukaryotic cells, presents a challenging problem in heterologous protein expression because it is both heterodimeric and posttranslationally modified. In this paper, we describe the cloning of both subunits (catalytic A and regulatory B) of calcineurin from a human cDNA library and their expression at high levels in Escherichia coli. The calcineurin A subunit is expressed as an insoluble glutathione S-transferase fusion protein, while the calcineurin B subunit is soluble upon direct expression. Catalytically active holoenzyme is derived from the separately expressed subunits using a three-step refolding protocol. First, the fusion protein is solubilized, then it is cleaved at the fusion junction with thrombin, and, finally, a catalytically competent calcineurin A:calcineurin B:calmodulin complex is reconstituted by cofolding the separately purified components. In addition, we show that a similar refolding protocol can be applied to a C-terminally truncated form of calcineurin A, which lacks an autoinhibitory and calmodulin-binding domain.

Stromelysin-1: three-dimensional structure of the inhibited catalytic domain and of the C-truncated proenzyme.

The proteolytic enzyme stromelysin-1 is a member of the family of matrix metalloproteinases and is believed to play a role in pathological conditions such as arthritis and tumor invasion. Stromelysin-1 is synthesized as a pro-enzyme that is activated by removal of an N-terminal prodomain. The active enzyme contains a catalytic domain and a C-terminal hemopexin domain believed to participate in macromolecular substrate recognition. We have determined the three-dimensional structures of both a C-truncated form of the proenzyme and an inhibited complex of the catalytic domain by X-ray diffraction analysis. The catalytic core is very similar in the two forms and is similar to the homologous domain in fibroblast and neutrophil collagenases, as well as to the stromelysin structure determined by NMR. The prodomain is a separate folding unit containing three alpha-helices and an extended peptide that lies in the active site of the enzyme. Surprisingly, the amino-to-carboxyl direction of this peptide chain is opposite to that adopted by the inhibitor and by previously reported inhibitors of collagenase. Comparison of the active site of stromelysin with that of thermolysin reveals that most of the residues proposed to play significant roles in the enzymatic mechanism of thermolysin have equivalents in stromelysin, but that three residues implicated in the catalytic mechanism of thermolysin are not represented in stromelysin.

A paradigm for drug discovery employing encoded combinatorial libraries.

Very large combinatorial libraries of small molecules on solid supports can now be synthesized and each library element can be identified after synthesis by using chemical tags. These tag-encoded libraries are potentially useful in drug discovery, and, to test this utility directly, we have targeted carbonic anhydrase (carbonate dehydratase; carbonate hydro-lyase, EC 4.2.1.1) as a model. Two libraries consisting of a total of 7870 members were synthesized, and structure-activity relationships based on the structures predicted by the tags were derived. Subsequently, an active representative of each library was resynthesized (2-[N-(4-sulfamoylbenzoyl)-4'-aminocyclohexanespiro]-4-oxo-7 -hydroxy- 2,3-dihydrobenzopyran and [N-(4-sulfamoylbenzoyl)-L-leucyl]piperidine-3-carboxylic acid) and these compounds were shown to have nanomolar dissociation constants (15 and 4 nM, respectively). In addition, a focused sublibrary of 217 sulfamoylbenzamides was synthesized and revealed a clear, testable structure-activity relationship describing isozyme-selective carbonic anhydrase inhibitors.

Regulation of calcineurin phosphatase activity and interaction with the FK-506.FK-506 binding protein complex.

The immunosuppressant FK-506 (tacrolimus) forms a complex with a ubiquitous intracellular receptor, FK-506 binding protein (FKBP12), and this complex inhibits the heterodimeric Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent phosphatase, calcineurin, an essential component of the T-cell receptor signal transduction pathway. Using a series of truncated calcineurin catalytic subunits, we show here that a region within the catalytic subunit that regulates phosphatase activity, the autoinhibitory domain, also regulates the Ca(2+)-dependent interaction of calcineurin with the FK-506.FKBP12 complex. Deletion of this domain produces constitutive activation of the phosphatase as demonstrated by transient transfection experiments in which expression of the truncated protein permitted Ca(2+)-independent induction of interleukin-2 transcription. Thus, deletion of the autoinhibitory domain is necessary and sufficient to constitutively activate calcineurin (CaN). Furthermore, CaN A467-492, an inhibitory peptide based on the autoinhibitory domain from calcineurin (ITSFEEAKGLDRINERMPPRRDAMP), inhibited dephosphorylation of the RII peptide substrate competitively with a Ki = 4 microM, consistent with binding of the autoinhibitory domain at the active site of the enzyme. To assess the role of the autoinhibitory domain in regulating the interaction of CaN with the FK-506.FKBP12 complex, we reconstituted wild type and mutant phosphatase heterodimers using in vitro transcribed and translated subunits. Association of the reconstituted calcineurin heterodimers with FKBP12 was dependent on FK-506. In the case of the wild type heterodimer, association with the FK-506.FKBP12 complex was also dependent upon Ca2+; however, mutant catalytic subunits, in which the autoinhibitory domains were deleted, associated with the drug-binding protein complex in the presence of 10 mM EGTA. These results indicate that the conserved autoinhibitory domain regulates both Ca(2+)-dependent phosphatase activity and association with the FK-506.FKBP12 complex.

Improved calcineurin inhibition by yeast FKBP12-drug complexes. Crystallographic and functional analysis.

The protein phosphatase calcineurin is the putative target for the immunosuppressive drug FK-506. The enzyme is inhibited by the complex of the drug with its intracellular receptor, the 12-kDa FK-506-binding protein (FKBP12), and the strength of inhibition usually correlates strongly with immunosuppressive potency. We find, however, that the complex of yeast FKBP12 with L-685,818, a well characterized antagonist of FK-506 immunosuppression, is a potent inhibitor of calcineurin. The corresponding human complex does not inhibit the enzyme, and both human and yeast complexes with FK-506 do inhibit. To understand the structural basis of these findings, we have determined the three-dimensional structure of the complex of yeast FKBP12 with FK-506 by x-ray crystallography, and have found that the structure of the yeast complex is strikingly similar to its human homolog. These observations indicate that specific sequence elements in the yeast protein provide stronger binding interactions with a heterologous calcineurin than do the corresponding elements in the human protein, and suggest structural modifications that may improve the potency of this class of immunosuppressants.

Amino acid binding by the class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases: role for a conserved proline in the signature sequence.

Although partial or complete three-dimensional structures are known for three Class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, the amino acid-binding sites in these proteins remain poorly characterized. To explore the methionine binding site of Escherichia coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase, we chose to study a specific, randomly generated methionine auxotroph that contains a mutant methionyl-tRNA synthetase whose defect is manifested in an elevated Km for methionine (Barker, D.G., Ebel, J.-P., Jakes, R.C., & Bruton, C.J., 1982, Eur. J. Biochem. 127, 449-457), and employed the polymerase chain reaction to sequence this mutant synthetase directly. We identified a Pro 14 to Ser replacement (P14S), which accounts for a greater than 300-fold elevation in Km for methionine and has little effect on either the Km for ATP or the kcat of the amino acid activation reaction. This mutation destabilizes the protein in vivo, which may partly account for the observed auxotrophy. The altered proline is found in the "signature sequence" of the Class I synthetases and is conserved. This sequence motif is 1 of 2 found in the 10 Class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and, in the known structures, it is in the nucleotide-binding fold as part of a loop between the end of a beta-strand and the start of an alpha-helix. The phenotype of the mutant and the stability and affinity for methionine of the wild-type and mutant enzymes are influenced by the amino acid that is 25 residues beyond the C-terminus of the signature sequence.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Assembly of a class I tRNA synthetase from products of an artificially split gene.

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases arose early in evolution and established the rules of the genetic code through their specific interactions with amino acids and RNA molecules. About half of these tRNA charging enzymes are class I synthetases, which contain similar N-terminal nucleotide-fold-like structures that are joined to variable domains implicated in specific protein-tRNA contacts. Here, we show that a bacterial synthetase gene can be split into two nonoverlapping segments. We split the gene for Escherichia coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase (a class I synthetase) at several sites near the interdomain junction, such that one segment codes for the nucleotide-fold-containing domain and the other provides determinants for tRNA recognition. When the segments are folded together, they can recognize and charge tRNA, both in vivo and in vitro. We postulate that an early step in the assembly of systems to attach amino acids to specific RNA molecules may have involved specific interactions between discrete proteins that is reflected in the interdomain contacts of modern synthetases.

Understanding structural relationships in proteins of unsolved three-dimensional structure.

The locations of functionally important sequences and general structural motifs have been assigned to Ile-tRNA synthetase. However, a function has not been established for some segments of the protein (e.g., CP1). The method of structural modeling described here cannot establish the details of a 3 A crystal structure, and, in contrast to a crystal structure, the precision of the model varies according to the extent of a sequence similarity or the functional importance of a region. In Ile-tRNA synthetase, the signature sequence and the flanking regions are likely to be similar in structure to the proteins on which the model is based. For other regions, it may be possible to build a three-dimensional model by connecting well defined regions and refining the positions of the connecting elements by energy minimization. Structural modelling of this kind must be done cautiously, because the order and orientation of the elements of a structural motif can change in subtle ways. In the case of Tyr-tRNA synthetase, the beta-strand nearest the N-terminus is the outermost strand of the nucleotide binding fold; in Met-tRNA synthetase, the same strand is innermost. Furthermore, the orientation of this strand may be antiparallel (Tyr-tRNA synthetase) or parallel (Met-tRNA synthetase). Because multiple structures that differ in their orientations of structural elements are possible, the structural analogies between proteins should not be naively extrapolated without independent experimental support. As described above, some regions of proteins tolerate internal deletions and insertions. This provides further experimental support for the practice of allowing for gaps in computer-generated sequence alignments. Nevertheless, because some regions are more tolerant of insertions and deletions than others, the structural and functional significance of a region of broken alignment must be assessed carefully. All gaps in sequence alignments cannot be treated equally, and each must be evaluated within its own context. In the synthetases of known structure, structural analogy can be used to identify important functional elements. For example, the amino acid binding site of Met-tRNA synthetase might be formed, at least in part, by a peptide that encompasses Ala50; this amino acid aligns with Gly94 of the Ile-tRNA synthetase. This is an example in which results on a protein of unknown structure (Ile-tRNA synthetases) can lead to identification of a potential substrate binding site in a protein of known structure (Met-tRNA synthetase).

Evolutionary optimization of the catalytic effectiveness of an enzyme.

The kinetic and thermodynamic features of reactions catalyzed by present-day enzymes appear to be the consequence of the evolution of these proteins toward maximal catalytic effectiveness. These features are identified and analyzed (in detail for one substrate-one product enzymes) by using ideas that link the energetics of the reaction catalyzed by an enzyme to the maximization of its catalytic efficiency. A catalytically optimized enzyme will have a value for the "internal" equilibrium constant (Kint, the equilibrium constant between the substrates and the products of the enzyme when all are bound productively) that depends on how close to equilibrium the enzyme maintains its reaction in vivo. Two classes are apparent. For an enzyme that operates near equilibrium, the catalytic efficiency is sensitive to the value of Kint, and the optimum value of Kint is near unity. For an enzyme that operates far from equilibrium, the catalytic efficiency is less sensitive to the value of Kint, and Kint assumes a value that ensures that the rate of the chemical transformation is equal to the rate of product release. In each of these cases, the internal thermodynamics is "dynamically matched", where the concentrations of substrate- and product-containing complexes are equal at the steady state in vivo.

Internal thermodynamics of enzymes determined by equilibrium quench: values of Kint for enolase and creatine kinase.

The equilibrium constant (Kint) for the enzyme-bound substrate and product of a one substrate/one product enzyme (enolase) and for those of a two substrate/two product enzyme (creatine kinase) have been determined. The values of Kint were determined by the rapid quenching of equilibrium mixtures of enzyme and radiolabeled substrate and product, under conditions where all of the marker substrate and product are bound. The scope and limitations of this method are discussed. Values of Kint have been collected from the literature, and it is shown that these data are consistent with the theory for kinetically optimized enzymes that is developed in the preceding paper.