Insights into the Role of Innate Immunity in Cervicovaginal Papillomavirus Infection from Studies Using Gene-Deficient Mice.

We demonstrate that female C57BL/6J mice are susceptible to a transient lower genital tract infection with MmuPV1 mouse papillomavirus and display focal histopathological abnormalities resembling those of human papillomavirus (HPV) infection. We took advantage of strains of genetically deficient mice to study in vivo the role of innate immune signaling in the control of papillomavirus. At 4 months, we sacrificed MmuPV1-infected mice and measured viral 757/3139 spliced transcripts by TaqMan reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR), localization of infection by RNAscope in situ hybridization, and histopathological abnormities by hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining. Among mice deficient in receptors for pathogen-associated molecular patterns, MyD88-/- and STING-/- mice had 1,350 and 80 copies of spliced transcripts/µg RNA, respectively, while no viral expression was detected in MAVS-/- and Ripk2-/- mice. Mice deficient in an adaptor molecule, STAT1-/-, for interferon signaling had 46,000 copies/µg RNA. Among mice with targeted deficiencies in the inflammatory response, interleukin-1 receptor knockout (IL-1R-/-) and caspase-1-/- mice had 350 and 30 copies/µg RNA, respectively. Among mice deficient in chemokine receptors, CCR6-/- mice had 120 copies/µg RNA, while CXCR2-/- and CXCR3-/- mice were negative. RNAscope confirmed focal infection in MyD88-/-, STAT1-/-, and CCR6-/- mice but was negative for other gene-deficient mice. Histological abnormalities were seen only in the latter mice. Our findings and the literature support a working model of innate immunity to papillomaviruses involving the activation of a MyD88-dependent pathway and IL-1 receptor signaling, control of viral replication by interferon-stimulated genes, and clearance of virus-transformed dysplastic cells by the action of the CCR6/CCL20 axis.IMPORTANCE Papillomaviruses infect stratified squamous epithelia, and the viral life cycle is linked to epithelial differentiation. Additionally, changes occur in viral and host gene expression, and immune cells are activated to modulate the infectious process. In vitro studies with keratinocytes cannot fully model the complex viral and host responses and do not reflect the contribution of local and migrating immune cells. We show that female C57BL/6J mice are susceptible to a transient papillomavirus cervicovaginal infection, and mice deficient in select genes involved in innate immune responses are susceptible to persistent infection with variable manifestations of histopathological abnormalities. The results of our studies support a working model of innate immunity to papillomaviruses, and the model provides a framework for more in-depth studies. A better understanding of mechanisms of early viral clearance and the development of approaches to induce clearance will be important for cancer prevention and the treatment of HPV-related diseases.

Bovine papillomavirus prostate cancer antigen virus-like particle vaccines are efficacious in advanced cancers in the TRAMP mouse spontaneous prostate cancer model.

Prostate cancer is a candidate for immunotherapy because cancer cells express tissue-specific proteins that can be therapeutic targets. However, immune checkpoint inhibitors and active immunization have performed poorly in clinical trials. We developed a novel virus-like particle (VLP) vaccine composed of bovine papillomavirus L1 protein engineered to display surface docking sites. We decorated VLPs with peptides encoding T cell epitopes from two prostate cancer-associated tumor antigens, prostate stem cell antigen (PSCA), and prostatic acid phosphatase (PAP-1 and PAP-2), and a neo-antigen, stimulator of prostatic adenocarcinoma-specific T cells (SPAS-1). The VLP vaccines induced a mean frequency of antigen-specific IFN-γ secreting CD8 + T cells of 2.9% to PSCA, 9.5% to SPAS-1, 0.03% to PAP-1, and 0.03% to PAP-2 in tumor-bearing TRAMP mice. We treated TRAMP mice at 19-20 weeks of age, when mice have advanced stages of carcinogenesis, with either VLP vaccine, anti-PD1 antibody, or combination immunotherapy. The VLP vaccine alone or in combination with anti-PD1 antibody significantly reduced tumor burden, while anti-PD1 antibody had a modest non-significant therapeutic effect. All treatments significantly increased CD3 + and CD8 + T cell infiltration into tumor tissue compared to control mice, and combination therapy resulted in significantly greater CD3 + and CD8 + T cell infiltration than monotherapy. Reduction in tumor burden in vaccine-treated mice was inversely correlated with CD8 + T cell numbers in tumor tissue. No other immunotherapy has shown efficacy in this animal model of advanced prostate cancer, making bovine papillomavirus VLPs an attractive vaccine technology to test in patients with metastatic prostate cancer.

Interferon lambda4 polymorphism is not associated with human papillomavirus infection outcome.

Interferon (IFN) lambdas are important specific components of the mucosal innate immune response. The IFN lambda 4 (IFNL4) dinucleotide polymorphism (ΔG/TT) determines the IFN lambdas and related Interferon-stimulated genes activation, in HCV and other chronic infections. Our group first reported that IFN Lambda response was impaired in high-risk Human Papillomavirus (HPV) cervical infections and in precancerous lesions. Accordingly, we sought to evaluate the possible role of the IFNL4 polymorphism in determining HPV infection outcome. The ΔG/TT alleles were not differently distributed in 221 women with high- or low-risk HPV infection, with HPV infection clearance or persistence, and with abnormal cytology.

Spontaneous and Vaccine-Induced Clearance of Mus Musculus Papillomavirus 1 Infection.

Mus musculus papillomavirus 1 (MmuPV1/MusPV1) induces persistent papillomas in immunodeficient mice but not in common laboratory strains. To facilitate the study of immune control, we sought an outbred and immunocompetent laboratory mouse strain in which persistent papillomas could be established. We found that challenge of SKH1 mice (Crl:SKH1-Hrhr) with MmuPV1 by scarification on their tail resulted in three clinical outcomes: (i) persistent (>2-month) papillomas (∼20%); (ii) transient papillomas that spontaneously regress, typically within 2 months (∼15%); and (iii) no visible papillomas and viral clearance (∼65%). SKH1 mice with persistent papillomas were treated by using a candidate preventive/therapeutic naked-DNA vaccine that expresses human calreticulin (hCRT) fused in frame to MmuPV1 E6 (mE6) and mE7 early proteins and residues 11 to 200 of the late protein L2 (hCRTmE6/mE7/mL2). Three intramuscular DNA vaccinations were delivered biweekly via in vivo electroporation, and both humoral and CD8 T cell responses were mapped and measured. Previously persistent papillomas disappeared within 2 months after the final vaccination. Coincident virologic clearance was confirmed by in situ hybridization and a failure of disease to recur after CD3 T cell depletion. Vaccination induced strong mE6 and mE7 CD8+ T cell responses in all mice, although they were significantly weaker in mice that initially presented with persistent warts than in those that spontaneously cleared their infection. A human papillomavirus 16 (HPV16)-targeted version of the DNA vaccine also induced L2 antibodies and protected mice from vaginal challenge with an HPV16 pseudovirus. Thus, MmuPV1 challenge of SKH1 mice is a promising model of spontaneous and immunotherapy-directed clearances of HPV-related disease.IMPORTANCE High-risk-type human papillomaviruses (hrHPVs) cause 5% of all cancer cases worldwide, notably cervical, anogenital, and oropharyngeal cancers. Since preventative HPV vaccines have not been widely used in many countries and do not impact existing infections, there is considerable interest in the development of therapeutic vaccines to address existing disease and infections. The strict tropism of HPV requires the use of animal papillomavirus models for therapeutic vaccine development. However, MmuPV1 failed to grow in common laboratory strains of mice with an intact immune system. We show that MmuPV1 challenge of the outbred immunocompetent SKH1 strain produces both transient and persistent papillomas and that vaccination of the mice with a DNA expressing an MmuPV1 E6E7L2 fusion with calreticulin can rapidly clear persistent papillomas. Furthermore, an HPV16-targeted version of the DNA can protect against vaginal challenge with HPV16, suggesting the promise of this approach to both prevent and treat papillomavirus-related disease.

TLR9 is expressed in human papillomavirus-positive cervical cells and is overexpressed in persistent infections.

Control of human papillomavirus (HPV) infection involves the activation of Toll-like receptors (TLRs), key components of the mucosal antiviral response. Available studies on TLR expression in HPV-positive cervical cells are limited and reported conflicting results. This study quantified TLR 2, 3, 4, 7 and 9 transcripts in low-risk (LR) and high-risk (HR) HPV-positive and HPV-negative cervical samples from 154 women attending a gynaecological clinic. Expression levels of TLR 2, 3, 4 and 7 did not differ among samples, whereas TLR9 levels were quite significantly higher in LR and marginally significant in HR HPV-positive samples, with respect to the HPV-negative samples. Interestingly, in a subgroup of women with documented previous HPV-infection, TLR9 levels were extremely higher in patients persistently positive to the same HPV genotype for more than 1 year, with respect to women who cleared HPV infection and to those re-infected with a different genotype. These findings implicate TLR9 in the response to LR and HR HPVs, including HPV 16 known to interfere with TLR9 transcription in cell lines. Elevated TLR9 levels without HPV clearance in persistently infected women could drive inflammation thereby contributing to cervical cancer risk.

Interferon lambda 1 expression in cervical cells differs between low-risk and high-risk human papillomavirus-positive women.

Persistent infection by high-risk (HR) human papillomavirus (HPV) types is a prerequisite for progression to cancer. HR-HPVs may lead to a deregulation of innate immunity by interfering with the epithelial type I interferon (IFN) response, whereas very little is known about type III IFNs, a key component of the mucosal antiviral response. This study reports a first attempt to evaluate the activation of type III IFN genes (IFN lambda 1-3), IFN lambda receptor genes (IFN-lambdaR1 and IL10R2), and IFN-induced genes (MxA, ISG15, ISG56) in HPV-positive and HPV-negative cervical cells from 154 women attending the gynecological unit of a university hospital in Rome. Despite an increased individual variability, a coordinated expression of several IFN lambda-related genes was observed. Furthermore, IFN lambda 1 and IFN-lambdaR1 genes were expressed at higher levels in cervical cells positive to low-risk (LR) HPV compared to HR-HPV and HPV-negative cells. Consistently, ISG15 expression was significantly higher in LR-HPV-infected women than in the other groups. Moreover, IFN lambda 1 expression decreased significantly with abnormal cytological results. This study is the first to show the activation of a type III IFN response in LR-HPV-positive cervical cells and suggests that the lack of this response in HR-HPV infection may be related to lesion progression.

High detection rate of human papillomavirus in anal brushings from women attending a proctology clinic.

OBJECTIVES: To study human papillomavirus (HPV) anal infection in anal brushings from women attending a proctology clinic, and compare results with those obtained from paired cervical brushings. METHODS: Women attending a university hospital proctology clinic for anal conditions or as part of a screening campaign, were enrolled consecutively, excluding those reporting previous HPV-related pathologies. HPV genotypes in anal and cervical brushings were determined by sequencing and, in most cases, type-specific viral loads were measured. RESULTS: HPV DNA was detected in 28.3% of anal brushings, with 47.4% of HPV genotypes being high risk. Cervical HPV detection was at almost the same rate but HPV status was discordant in about half those women with at least one positive specimen. Abnormal cytological findings were more common in anal than in cervical samples, in particular in the proctology outpatients. Viral load measurements excluded the existence of a multiple infection with genotypes detected in discordant anal- and cervical-paired samples and showed a significant correlation between anal and cervical paired concordant samples. CONCLUSIONS: The high rate of HPV detection in anal brushings that is not usually related to HPV positivity in cervical brushings could provide support for offering HPV DNA tests to women attending proctology clinics.