Financial impact of tertiary care in an academic medical center.

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the financial impact of three complex vascular surgical procedures to both an academic hospital and a department of surgery and to examine the potential impact of decreased reimbursements. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: The cost of providing tertiary care has been implicated as one potential cause of the financial difficulties affecting academic medical centers. METHODS: Patients undergoing revascularization for chronic mesenteric ischemia, elective thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysm repair, and treatment of infected aortic grafts at the University of Florida were compared with those undergoing elective infrarenal aortic reconstruction and carotid endarterectomy. Hospital costs and profit summaries were obtained from the Clinical Resource Management Office. Departmental costs and profit summary were estimated based on the procedural relative value units (RVUs), the average clinical cost per RVU ($33.12), surgeon charges, and the collection rate for the vascular surgery division (30.2%) obtained from the Faculty Group Practice. Surgeon work effort was analyzed using the procedural work RVUs and the estimated total care time. The analyses were performed for all payors and the subset of Medicare patients, and the potential impact of a 15% reduction in hospital and physician reimbursement was analyzed. RESULTS: Net hospital income was positive for all but one of the tertiary care procedures, but net losses were sustained by the hospital for the mesenteric ischemia and infected aortic graft groups among the Medicare patients. In contrast, the estimated reimbursement to the department of surgery for all payors was insufficient to offset the clinical cost of providing the RVUs for all procedures, and the estimated losses were greater for the Medicare patients alone. The surgeon work effort was dramatically higher for the tertiary care procedures, whereas the reimbursement per work effort was lower. A 15% reduction in reimbursement would result in an estimated net loss to the hospital for each of the tertiary care procedures and would exacerbate the estimated losses to the department. CONCLUSIONS: Caring for complex surgical problems is currently profitable to an academic hospital but is associated with marginal losses for a department of surgery. Economic forces resulting from further decreases in hospital and physician reimbursement may limit access to academic medical centers and surgeons for patients with complex surgical problems and may compromise the overall academic mission.

Influence of patient characteristics and treatment options on outcome of patients with prosthetic aortic graft infection.

This study was undertaken to determine the influence of patient characteristics and treatment options on survival and limb loss after treatment of prosthetic aortic graft infection. Fifty-three patients treated for prosthetic aortic graft infection were reviewed. Twenty-three presented with groin infection, 12 with sepsis, 10 with aortoenteric fistula, 4 with limb ischemia, and 4 with pseudoaneurysm. Treatment included staged extraanatomic bypass (EAB) plus graft excision in 23 patients, simultaneous EAB and graft excision in 18, in situ graft replacement in 5, and local therapy only in 7. Axillofemoral bypass was done for revascularization in 53 limbs and axillopopliteal bypass in 16 limbs. The results of this study showed that morbidity and mortality of prosthetic aortic graft infection is influenced by the presentation and type of treatment of the infected graft. Staged axillofemoral bypass (when possible) plus graft excision appears to be associated with acceptable outcome (survival with limb salvage in 74%).

Warfarin improves the outcome of infrainguinal vein bypass grafting at high risk for failure.

OBJECTIVE: Patients with marginal venous conduit, poor arterial runoff, and prior failed bypass grafts are at high risk for infrainguinal graft occlusion and limb loss. We sought to evaluate the effects of anticoagulation therapy after autogenous vein infrainguinal revascularization on duration of patency, limb salvage rates, and complication rates in this subset of patients. METHODS: This randomized prospective trial was performed in a university tertiary care hospital and in a Veterans Affairs Hospital. Fifty-six patients who were at high risk for graft failure were randomized to receive aspirin (24 patients, 27 bypass grafts) or aspirin and warfarin (WAR; 32 patients, 37 bypass grafts). All patients received 325 mg of aspirin each day, and the patients who were randomized to warfarin underwent anticoagulation therapy with heparin immediately after surgery and then were started on warfarin therapy to maintain an international normalized ratio between 2 and 3. Perioperative blood transfusions and complications were compared with the Student t test or with the chi2 test. Graft patency rates, limb salvage rates, and survival rates were compared with the Kaplan-Meier method and the log-rank test. RESULTS: Sixty-one of the 64 bypass grafts were performed for rest pain or tissue loss, and 3 were performed for short-distance claudication. There were no differences between the groups in ages, indications, bypass graft types, risk classifications (ie, conduit, runoff, or graft failure), or comorbid conditions (except diabetes mellitus). The cumulative 5-year survival rate was similar between the groups. The incidence rate of postoperative hematoma (32% vs 3.7%; P = .004) was greater in the WAR group, but no differences were seen between the WAR group and the aspirin group in the number of packed red blood cells transfused, in the incidence rate of overall nonhemorrhagic wound complications, or in the overall complication rate (62% vs 52%). The immediate postoperative primary graft patency rates (97.3% vs 85.2%) and limb salvage rates (100% vs 88.9%) were higher in the WAR group as compared with the aspirin group. Furthermore, the cumulative 3-year primary, primary assisted, and secondary patency rates were significantly greater in the WAR group versus the aspirin group (74% vs 51%, P = .04; 77% vs 56%, P = .05; 81% vs 56%, P = .02) and cumulative limb salvage rates were higher in the WAR group (81% vs 31%, P = .01). CONCLUSIONS: Perioperative anticoagulation therapy with heparin increases the incidence rate of wound hematomas, but long-term anticoagulation therapy with warfarin improves the patency rate of autogenous vein infrainguinal bypass grafts and the limb salvage rate for patients at high risk for graft failure.

Impact of a clinical pathway for elective infrarenal aortic reconstructions.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the impact of a clinical pathway for elective infrarenal aortic reconstruction on outcome, resource utilization, and cost in a university medical center. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Clinical pathways have been reported to control costs, reduce resource utilization, and maintain or improve the quality of patient care, although their use during elective aortic reconstructions remains unresolved. METHODS: A clinical pathway was developed for elective infrarenal aortic reconstructions by a multidisciplinary group comprised of representatives from each involved service. The prepathway practice and costs were analyzed and an efficient, cost-effective practice with specific outcome measures was defined. The impact of the pathway was determined by retrospective comparison of outcome, resource utilization, and cost (total and direct variable) between the pathway patients (PATH, n = 45) and a prepathway control group (PRE, n = 20). RESULTS: There were no significant differences in the patient demographics, comorbid conditions, operative indications, or type of reconstruction between the groups. There were no operative deaths and the overall complication rate (PRE, 35% vs. PATH, 34%) was similar. The pathway resulted in significant decreases in the total length of stay and preoperative length of stay and a trend toward a significant decrease (p = 0.08) in the intensive care length of stay for the admission during which the operation was performed. The pathway also resulted in significant decreases in both direct variable and total hospital costs for this admission, as well as a significant decrease in the overall direct variable and total hospital costs for the operative admission and the preoperative evaluation (< or =30 days before operative admission). Despite these reductions, the discharge disposition, 30-day readmissions, and number of postoperative clinic visits within 90 days of discharge were not different. CONCLUSIONS: Implementation of a clinical pathway for elective infrarenal aortic reconstructions dramatically decreased resource utilization and hospital costs without affecting the quality of patient care and did not appear to shift the costs to another setting.

Improving the cost-effectiveness of carotid endarterectomy.

PURPOSE: Carotid endarterectomy (CEA) has been shown to significantly reduce the risk of stroke caused by carotid artery stenosis. Limiting the costs of CEA without increasing the risks will improve the cost-effectiveness of this procedure. METHODS: Results were prospectively collected from 63 consecutive CEAs performed in 60 patients who were entered into a clinical pathway for CEA that included avoidance of cerebral arteriography, preferential use of regional anesthesia, selective use of the intensive care unit (ICU), and early hospital discharge. The mortality rate, complications, hospital costs, and net income in these patients were then compared with results from 45 CEAs performed in 42 consecutive patients immediately before beginning the CEA pathway. Age, comorbid risk factors, incidence of symptoms, and degree of carotid artery stenosis were similar in both patient groups. RESULTS: The rates of mortality and complications associated with CEA were low (mortality rate, 0%; stroke, 0.9%; transient ischemic attack, 2.8%) and did not vary between the two groups. Implementation of the CEA pathway resulted in significant (p < 0.001) reductions in the use of arteriography (74% to 13%), general anesthesia (100% to 24%), ICU use (98% to 30%), and mean hospital length of stay (5.8 days to 2.0 days). These changes resulted in a 41% reduction in mean total hospital cost ($9652 to $5699) and a 124% increase in mean net hospital income ($1804 to $4039) per CEA (p < 0.01). For the 39 patients (62%) who achieved all elements of the CEA pathway, the mean hospital length of stay was 1.3 days, the mean hospital cost was $4175, and the mean hospital income was $4327. CONCLUSIONS: Costs associated with CEA can be reduced substantially without increased risk. This makes CEA an extremely cost-effective treatment of carotid disease against which new therapeutic approaches must be measured.

Intraoperative prebypass arteriography for infrageniculate revascularization.

BACKGROUND: Selection of the optimal distal target for infrageniculate arterial revascularization remains difficult in patients with multilevel occlusive disease due to poor visualization of the distal vasculature by preoperative arteriography. Prebypass, intraoperative arteriography (IOA) with direct injection of contrast into the infrageniculate arteries may improve distal arterial visualization and bypass target selection. METHODS: One hundred fourteen extremities in 104 consecutive patients requiring infrageniculate bypass were prospectively studied. All patients underwent preoperative contrast arteriography (CA) of the aortoiliac and lower extremity arteries using iodinated and/or CO2 contrast and digital subtraction techniques. IOAs were obtained at operation to confirm the adequacy of the distal runoff from the predicted bypass target and to identify potentially superior targets. The preoperative plan formulated from the CA was compared to the actual procedure performed based on the IOA. The CA and IOA were also independently reviewed postoperatively by two blinded vascular surgeons to determine the number of patent vessel segments visualized and the number of segments with <50% stenosis. RESULTS: Revascularization was done in 105 of 114 extremities (92%), whereas amputation was required as the initial procedure in 9 patients (8%). The IOA altered the operative plan based on the CA in 27 of 144 patients (24%). Changes in the planned bypass procedures included selection of a more distal anastomotic site in 13 of 102 patients (13%), selection of a more proximal anastomotic site in 4 of 102 (4%), selection of a different artery for the distal anastomosis in 3 of 102 (3%), and amputation rather than bypass in 2 of 102 patients (2%) with no suitable distal bypass target on the IOA. The IOA also resulted in bypass rather than planned amputation in 5 of 12 patients (42%) deemed unreconstructable on the preoperative CA. A mean of 13 minutes was required for IOA and an adequate study was obtained on the first attempt in 98 of 144 patients (86%). On postoperative review, more patent vessel segments but fewer segments with <50% stenosis were identified on the IOA compared to the CA. CONCLUSIONS: Prebypass intraoperative arteriography facilitates selection of the optimal distal bypass target during infrageniculate revascularization and can result in initial limb salvage in select patients deemed unreconstructable by preoperative contrast arteriography.

Selection of patients for renal artery repair using captopril testing.

BACKGROUND: Prediction of improvement following surgical or radiologic intervention in patients thought to have renovascular hypertension (RVH) is often unreliable. Use of the angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor captopril in conjunction with measurement of peripheral renin levels or radioisotope renograms is thought to detect patients with functionally significant renal artery stenosis. However, it is unclear whether these tests can identify patients whose hypertension will significantly improve after renal artery repair. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The records of 52 consecutive hypertensive patients undergoing captopril studies followed by renal artery repair were reviewed. All patients had either renal artery stenosis > 75% or renal artery occlusion. Preprocedure evaluation included a captopril challenge test (measurement of peripheral renin levels after captopril ingestion) (n = 12) or a captopril renogram (determination of renal blood flow and glomerular filtration rate before and after captopril administration) (n = 40). Either renal artery bypass/nephrectomy (n = 41) or balloon angioplasty (n = 11) was done in all patients (18 bilateral/34 unilateral). No periprocedural deaths occurred. All surgically placed bypass grafts were shown to be patent by contrast or carbon dioxide arteriography before hospital discharge. RESULTS: Preprocedure captopril tests were positive (suggestive of RVH) in 39 patients (75%) and negative in 13 (25%). All patients with positive captopril tests had improvement in their RVH after intervention (17 cured, 22 improved) while 8 of 13 patients with negative captopril tests had no improvement in blood pressure control. Four of five false-negative tests were associated with a unilateral total renal artery occlusion, making detection of a postcaptopril effect impossible. If these 4 patients are excluded from analysis, preprocedure captopril testing was 98% accurate in predicting postprocedure outcome. CONCLUSIONS: Preprocedure captopril testing permits extremely accurate selection of patients with renal artery stenosis who will benefit from renal artery repair.

Impact of angioscopy on infrainguinal graft patency.

To investigate the impact of angioscopy on infrainguinal graft patency, 50 consecutive cases with angioscopy as an adjuvant to infrainguinal arterial bypass performed during a 12-month period were reviewed (group I). For comparison, 42 similar cases of infrainguinal arterial reconstruction performed during the 12 months prior to introduction of routine intraoperative angioscopy were also reviewed (group II). Patients were followed up for 12 months and graft patency was determined at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months. An abnormality was identified in 13 (26%) group I patients (10, angioscopy alone; 1, arteriography alone; 2, both). Defects were anastomotic abnormalities (n = 7), vein sclerosis (n = 3), retained valve cusp (n = 2), and proximal artery stenosis (n = 1). A similar percentage, but different types of defects, were seen in group II; 11 patients (26%) had an abnormality (anastomotic abnormality [n = 3], vein sclerosis [n = 4], retained valve cusp [n = 1], and arterial outflow stenoses [n = 3]). All significant defects were surgically explored and corrected. Graft patency rates in group I and II at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months were 100% and 85% (P < 0.005), 94% and 80% (P < 0.05), 87% and 74% (P = non-significant [NS]), and 86.1% and 73.7% (P = NS), respectively. Intraoperative angioscopy detects anastomotic and vein graft defects not always seen on arteriography; the repair of these defects significantly improves early infrainguinal bypass graft patency rates.

Local deep hypothermia for combined valvular and coronary heart disease.

Local deep hypothermia was utilized as the sole method of myocardial protection in 113 consecutive aortic valve replacements. Thirty-six patients had simultaneous revascularization, mitral valve replacement, tricuspid valve replacement, or a combination of these. In follow-up for as long as 36 months there have been 3 hospital deaths (2.6%), all occurring in the group having isolated aortic valve replacement. No hospital deaths occurred among patients undergoing a combined procedure.