In-vitro comparison of mechanical resistance between two straight plates and a Y-plate for fixation of mandibular condyle fractures.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the mechanical resistance of conventional plates with a modified Y-plate in mandibular condyle fracture. MATERIALS AND METHODS: 40 synthetic hemi-mandibular polyurethane replicates were used. Two groups of fixing materials were included: 20 mandibles fixed with 40 straight plates with four roles each (2.0 mm system) and 20 mandibles fixed with 20 Y-shaped plates (2.0 mm system and 1.5 mm thickness). The samples were submitted to linear loading in the following directions: 10 mandibles from each group from lateral to medial and 10 mandibles from each group from anterior to posterior. A universal loading machine, Instron Universal 4411, was used to performed the tests, and the resistance of each fixed mandible was assessed at displacements of 1 mm, 3 mm, and 5 mm. The t-test for independent samples was performed. The p value was set at <0.05. RESULTS: The worst mechanical resistance was found in the Y-plates loaded from anterior to posterior. The best mechanical resistance was in two straight hole plates loaded from lateral to medial. The Y-plates and two straight hole plates showed similar resistance when a lateral to medial load was applied. CONCLUSION: There was no difference between the plates when lateral to medial loading was tested.

Development plates for stable internal fixation: Study of mechanical resistance in simulated fractures of the mandibular condyle.

OBJECTIVE: To develop Y-shaped plates with different thicknesses to be used in simulated fractures of the mandibular condyle. Ten plates were developed in Y shape, containing eight holes, and 30 synthetic polyurethane mandible replicas were developed for the study. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The load test was performed on an Instron Model 4411 universal testing machine, applying load in the mediolateral and anterior-posterior positions on the head of the condyle. Two-way ANOVA with Tukey testing with a 5% significance level was used. RESULTS: It was observed that when the load was applied in the medial-lateral plate of greater thickness (1.5 mm), it gave the highest strength, while in the anteroposterior direction, the plate with the highest resistance was of the lesser thickness (0.6 mm). A plate with a thickness of 1.5 mm was the one with the highest average value for all displacements. In the anteroposterior direction, the highest values of resistance were seen in the displacement of 15 mm. CONCLUSION: After comparing the values of the biomechanical testing found in the scientific literature, it is suggested that the use of Y plates are suitable for use in subcondylar fractures within the limitations of the study.