Why do some females reject males? The molecular basis for male-specific graft rejection.

The male-specific minor histocompatibility antigen H-Y plays an important role in both graft rejection and graft-versus-host disease following transplantation of male tissue into females that are completely matched at the major histocompatibility loci. The recent identification of two peptides that, in association with the mouse H-2Kk or human HLA B7 major histocompatibility class I molecules, are recognised by H-Y-specific T cells, has provided evidence for the molecular basis for such anti-H-Y responses. These peptides are encoded by the mouse and human homologues of a ubiquitously expressed Y chromosome gene, Smcy, whilst the equivalent peptides encoded by the X chromosome homologues of this gene fail to be recognised. Genetic studies have demonstrated that, as is the case for other minor histocompatibility antigens, peptide epitopes from several closely linked genes may be required to interact in order to elicit a response against H-Y. Definition of the peptides and the genes that encode these epitopes will allow the development of tolerogenic protocols that could specifically down-modulate the response to H-Y and perhaps even other minor histocompatibility antigens.

Acceptance of skin grafts between mice bearing different allelic forms of beta 2-microglobulin.

Single amino acid disparities in MHC class I molecules can elicit transplantation responses. Since beta 2 microglobulin (beta 2m) is noncovalently associated with class I antigens on the cell membrane we investigated whether the single amino acid polymorphism at position 85 (Asp-->Ala) in the mouse beta 2m molecule can cause skin graft rejection. A B2mb transgene was introduced into CBA(B2ma) mice which subsequently expressed both forms of beta 2m. Skin from these CBA beta 2mb transgenic mice was not rejected by the parental CBA strain. Previous studies showed that cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses directed against beta 2mb use H2Kb as a restriction element. We therefore produced mice expressing H2Kb and H2Ab as well as beta 2mb by crossing CBA.beta 2mb mice with either CBA.Kb (CBK) transgenic mice or C3H.SW mice and used these as skin graft donors for beta 2mb negative littermates. In both cases rejection of transgenic skin only occurred when mice had received both a beta 2mb graft and an H2-disparate allograft lying adjacent in the same site. Introduction of the male specific antigen, H-Y, as a helper determinant did not result in rejection of beta 2mb skin. Neither did two CTL determinants (P91A and beta 2mb) on the same graft complement one another to elicit a transplantation response. Prior immunisation with tissues expressing the beta 2m disparity alone did not generate in vivo or in vitro beta 2mb-specific CTL responses, suggesting that this single amino acid difference is not sufficient to elicit a CTL or helper T cell response.

Expression of major histocompatibility complex class I antigens at low levels in the thymus induces T cell tolerance via a non-deletional mechanism.

Transgenic CBA (H-2k haplotype) mice expressing the H-2 Kb major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I gene under control of transcriptional promoter elements from a milk protein gene display high-level H-2 Kb transcription in lactating mammary glands and low-level transcription in skin and thymus of male and virgin female transgenic mice. However, H-2 Kb antigen could be detected only in lactating mammary gland epithelial cells by immunohistological methods. All transgenic mice are tolerant of H-2 Kb since they fail to reject skin grafts from mice expressing H-2 Kb molecules. Furthermore, anti-H-2 Kb cytotoxic responses could not be generated using responder T cells from transgenic mice but T cells from the same mice proliferated, in the presence of interleukin-2, in response to stimulator cells expressing H-2 Kb. Tolerance to H-2 Kb is induced in the thymus since CBA mice grafted with thymus tissue from transgenic mice fail to reject H-2 Kb disparate skin grafts. However, experiments with double-transgenic mice also expressing a T cell receptor with anti-H-2 Kb specificity reveal that tolerance induction is not brought about by elimination of thymocytes bearing H-2 Kb-reactive receptors. Instead, a non-deletional mechanism which results in down-modulation of both CD8 and T cell receptor expression in peripheral T cells correlates with the induction of tolerance in these mice. These data reveal that extremely low levels of self-antigen expression in the thymus are sufficient to induce tolerance via non-deletional mechanisms.

Anti-H-Y responses of H-2b mutant mice.

Two strains of H-2b mutant mice, H-2ba and H-2bf, in which the mutational event took place at H-2K, make anti-H-Y cytotoxic T cell responses which are H-2-restricted, Db-associated and indistinguishable in target cell specificity from those of H-2b mice. Thus, alteration of the H-2K molecule affects neither the Ir gene controlling the response, nor the associative antigen. On the other hand, one H-2Db mutant strain, H-2bo, although it makes a good anti-H-Y cytotoxic response, shows target cell specificity restricted to its own Dbo antigen(s), and neither H-2b, H-2ba or H-2bf anti-H-Y cytotoxic cells kill H-2bo male target cells. Thus, the alteration of the H-2Db molecule does not affect the Ir gene of H-2b mice, but it does alter the H-2Db-associative antigen.

Cytotoxic T-cell responses to H-Y: mapping of the Ir genes.

The secondary cytotoxic responses to the male specific antigen (H-Y) in in mice show H-2 restrictions so that cytotoxic female cells must share K and/or D end antigen with the male target cells. The production of cytotoxic cells is under the control of Ir genes, thus offering the possibility of studying the function of Ir genes in H-2-restricted cytotoxic responses. There are two kinds of Ir genes regulating this response; the dominant gene in the H-2b haplotype and complementary genes in other haplotypes. Now we have been able to map the dominant gene and some of the complementary genes: the dominant genes is in IAb, and in H-2k/H-2d complementation, the Ir genes are in ICk and ICd, and in H-2k/H2s and H-2k/H-2q complementations, at least the H-2k gene is in IC.

Cytotoxic T-cell responses to H-Y: correlation with the rejection of syngeneic male skin grafts.

The ability of female mice to rapidly reject syngenic male skin grafts is largely determined by dominant genes in the IB region of the H-2b halotype, whereas the ability to produce anti-H-Y cytotoxic cells is determined by a dominant gene in the IA region the H-2b halotype, or by complementary genes in the IC region of some other haplotypes. Thus, it seems that H-2-retricted anti-H-Y cytotoxic T cells are not responsible for the rejection of syngeneic male skin grafts.