Establishment of transplantation tolerance via minimal conditioning in aged recipients.

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism is a powerful means of generating donor-specific tolerance, allowing long-term graft acceptance without lifelong dependence on immunosuppressive drugs. To avoid the need for whole body irradiation and associated side effects, we utilized a radiation-free minimal conditioning regime to induce long-term tolerance across major histocompatibility barriers. We found that low-dose busulfan, in combination with host T cell depletion and short-term sirolimus-based immunosuppression, facilitated efficient donor engraftment. Tolerance was achieved when mice were transplanted with whole or T cell-depleted bone marrow, or purified progenitor cells. Tolerance induction was associated with an expansion in regulatory T cells and was not abrogated in the absence of a thymus, suggesting a dominant or compensatory peripheral mode of tolerance. Importantly, we were able to generate durable chimerism and tolerance to donor skin grafts in both young and aged mice, despite age-related thymic atrophy and immune senescence. Clinically, this is especially relevant as the majority of transplant recipients are older patients whose immune recovery might be dangerously slow and would benefit from radiation-free minimal conditioning regimes that allow efficient donor engraftment without fully ablating the recipient immune system.

Analysis of thymic stromal cell populations using flow cytometry.

The complexity of the lymphostromal interplay that is essential to alphabetaT-cell development is reflected by the heterogeneity of both lymphocytes and thymic stromal cells. While panels of monoclonal antibodies have described many of the cellular components of these microenvironments, the means to quantify stromal cell subsets using flow cytometry remains poorly defined. This study refines and compares various stromal cell isolation procedures and determines the effects of various digestion enzymes on important surface molecules. Three- and four-color flow cytometry is used to correlate established and novel stromal cell markers to define thymic fibroblasts, epithelium and a unique subset of thymic endothelium that express MHC class II. This work provides a basis for the purification of thymic stromal cells for further phenotypic, functional and genetic analysis.

Thymic stromal cells and positive selection.

The intrathymic differentiation events leading to the development and export of mature T cells tolerant to self yet capable of responding to foreign peptide antigen in the context of self-MHC are clearly both dynamic and complex. The changing phenotype of the developing thymocyte as it migrates through and interacts with the heterogeneous thymic microenvironment and the intracellular signalling events associated with such interactions are being extensively studied, yet many aspects remain poorly defined, such as the precise relationship between stromal cells and thymic selection. Positive and negative selection are crucial events in the development of T cells, leading to a diverse yet non-autoreactive immune system. A breakdown in either of these processes could lead to either a reduced T cell repertoire or the escape into the periphery of autoreactive T cells - both clearly having deleterious consequences for the health of the individual. This review aims to summarise the current status of research in thymic positive selection with emphasis on the role of different cell types and peptides.

ChT1, an Ig superfamily molecule required for T cell differentiation.

The thymus is colonized by circulating progenitor cells that differentiate into mature T cells under the influence of the thymic microenvironment. We report here the cloning and function of the avian thymocyte Ag ChT1, a member of the Ig superfamily with one V-like and one C2-like domain. ChT1-positive embryonic bone marrow cells coexpressing c-kit give rise to mature T cells upon intrathymic cell transfer. ChT1-specific Ab inhibits T cell differentiation in embryonic thymic organ cultures and in thymocyte precursor cocultures on stromal cells. Thus, we provide clear evidence that ChT1 is a novel Ag on early T cell progenitors that plays an important role in the early stages of T cell development.

An adult thymic stromal-cell suspension model for in vitro positive selection.

Presented here is a cell-suspension model for positive selection using thymocytes from alphabeta-TCR (H-2Db-restricted) transgenic mice specific to the lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) on a nonselecting MHC background (H-2d or TAP-1 -/-), cocultured with freshly isolated adult thymus stromal cells of the selecting MHC type. The thymic stromal cells alone induced positive selection of functional CD4- CD8+ cells whose kinetics and efficiency were enhanced by nominal peptide. Fibroblasts expressing the selecting MHC alone did not induce positive selection; however, together with nonselecting stroma and nominal peptide, there was inefficient positive. These results suggest multiple signaling in positive selection with selection events able to occur on multiple-cell types. The ease with which this model can be manipulated should greatly facilitate the resolution of the mechanisms of positive selection in normal and pathological states.

Positive selection of low responsive, potentially autoreactive T cells induced by high avidity, non-deleting interactions.

Using a novel cell suspension model we investigated the relative abilities of nominal peptide and variants thereof to modulate de novo positive selection of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)-specific TCR transgenic T cells. Confirming our earlier findings intermediate concentrations (10(-7) to 10(-5) M) of the nominal agonist peptide, p33, induced CD8 co-receptor down-modulation at the level of the entire receptor and the CD8beta chain as a consequence of high but non-deleting signal interactions. Agonist peptide variants caused down-modulation of the CD8beta chain but to a lesser degree. An antagonist peptide capable of inducing positive selection did not cause such modifications of the co-receptor. The positively selected TCRhiCD8alpha alpha and TCRhiCD8- cells were functional but not as efficient as TCRhiCD8alphabeta cells, presumably due to lower avidity interactions in the absence of the CD8beta chain or entire co-receptor. CD8beta mRNA was absent in these cells and was not up-regulated when further stimulated with fresh antigen-presenting cells pulsed with 10(-5) M p33. Effectively our data suggest that it is not the agonist or antagonist nature of a peptide per se but the overall strength of signalling that determines whether a cell will be positively or negatively selected, or die by neglect. Furthermore the agonist/antagonist properties of peptides defined at the level of mature T cell function do not unequivocally predict their effect on positive/negative selection. The ability of the T cell to down-modulate its CD8 co-receptor in response to high but non-deleting peptide interactions during positive selection allows the survival of T cells with a broader range of affinities and represents a possible mechanism by which low responsive but potentially autoreactive cells may escape into the periphery.

Receptor-specific allelic exclusion of TCRV alpha-chains during development.

Expression of a single Ag receptor on lymphocytes is maintained via allelic exclusion that generates cells with a clonal receptor repertoire. We show in normal mice and mice expressing functionally rearranged TCR alphabeta transgenes that allelic exclusion at the TCR alpha locus is not operational in immature thymocytes, whereas most mature T cells express a single TCRV alpha-chain. TCRV alpha allelic exclusion in mature thymocytes is regulated through a CD45 tyrosine phosphatase-mediated signal during positive selection. Using functional and genetic systems for selection of immature double TCRV alpha+ thymocytes, we show that peptide-specific ligand recognition provides the signal for allelic exclusion, i.e., mature T cells maintain expression of the ligand-specific TCRV alpha-chain, but lose the nonfunctional receptor. Whereas activation of TCRV beta-chains or CD3epsilon leads to receptor internalization, TCRV alpha ligation promotes retention of the TCR on the cell surface. Although both TCRV alpha- and TCRV beta-chains trigger phosphotyrosine signaling, only the TCRV beta-chain mediates membrane recruitment of the GTPase dynamin. These data indicate that TCRV alpha-directed signals for positive selection control allelic exclusion in T cells, and that developmental signals can select for single receptor usage.

Agonist peptide modulates T cell selection thresholds through qualitative and quantitative shifts in CD8 co-receptor expression.

Engagement of the TCR is a pivotal step in thymocyte development, ultimately resulting in the survival (positive selection) or loss (negative selection) of developing T cells. The roles of peptides and stromal cell interactions necessary for these selection events, however, are still poorly understood. To investigate the effects of agonist peptide in positive selection, we used a novel cell suspension model for in vitro thymic positive selection in adults. Target thymocytes from H-2Db-restricted TCR transgenic mice, specific to the lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) peptide bred on a non-selecting MHC background (H-2d or TAP-1-/-), were co-cultured with freshly isolated H-2b thymic stromal cells. In the presence of selecting stroma the nominal agonist LCMV peptide induced apoptosis at high concentrations and at low concentrations enhanced the efficiency of positive selection both in numbers of cells 'rescued' and kinetics of appearance of selected single-positive cells. We further illustrate down-modulation of CD8 alpha beta or CD8 beta at high but non-deleting concentrations of agonist peptide. This highlights the ability of the T cell, within the window of positive selection, to modify surface co-receptors both qualitatively and quantitatively in response to increasing avidity TCR-peptide-MHC interactions. The direct consequence of this would be to lower the total signaling events below the threshold for apoptosis induction. Hence if self peptide were not presented in sufficient quantities in the thymus, autoreactive cells may escape deletion and may actually be positively selected.

The interferon regulatory transcription factor IRF-1 controls positive and negative selection of CD8+ thymocytes.

Little is known about the molecular mechanisms and transcriptional regulation that govern T cell selection processes and the differentiation of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. Mice lacking the interferon regulatory transcription factor-1 (IRF-1) have reduced numbers of mature CD8+ cells within the thymus and peripheral lymphatic organs. Here we show that positive and negative T cell selection of two MHC class I-restricted TCR alphabeta transgenes, H-Y and P14, are impaired in IRF-1-/- mice. The absence of IRF-1 resulted in decreased expression of LMP2, TAP1, and MHC class I on thymic stromal cells. Despite decreased MHC class I expression on IRF-1-/- thymic stromal cells, the defect in CD8+ T cells development did not reside in the thymic environment, and IRF-1-/- stromal cells can fully support development of CD8+ thymocytes in in vivo bone marrow chimeras and in vitro reaggregation cultures. Moreover, IRF-1-/- thymocytes displayed impaired TCR-mediated signal transduction, and the induction of negative selection in TCR Tg thymocytes from IRF-1-/- mice required a 1000-fold increase in selecting peptide. We also provide evidence that IRF-1 is mainly expressed in mature, but not immature, thymocytes and that expression of IRF-1 in immature thymocytes is induced after peptide-specific TCR activation. These results indicate that IRF-1 regulates gene expression in developing thymocytes required for lineage commitment and selection of CD8+ thymocytes.