Attribute Analytics Performance Metrics from the MAM Consortium Interlaboratory Study.

The multi-attribute method (MAM) was conceived as a single assay to potentially replace multiple single-attribute assays that have long been used in process development and quality control (QC) for protein therapeutics. MAM is rooted in traditional peptide mapping methods; it leverages mass spectrometry (MS) detection for confident identification and quantitation of many types of protein attributes that may be targeted for monitoring. While MAM has been widely explored across the industry, it has yet to gain a strong foothold within QC laboratories as a replacement method for established orthogonal platforms. Members of the MAM consortium recently undertook an interlaboratory study to evaluate the industry-wide status of MAM. Here we present the results of this study as they pertain to the targeted attribute analytics component of MAM, including investigation into the sources of variability between laboratories and comparison of MAM data to orthogonal methods. These results are made available with an eye toward aiding the community in further optimizing the method to enable its more frequent use in the QC environment.

Global intercompany assessment of ICIEF platform comparability for the characterization of therapeutic proteins.

An international team spanning 19 sites across 18 biopharmaceutical and in vitro diagnostics companies in the United States, Europe, and China, along with one regulatory agency, was formed to compare the precision and robustness of imaged CIEF (ICIEF) for the charge heterogeneity analysis of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) mAb and a rhPD-L1-Fc fusion protein on the iCE3 and the Maurice instruments. This information has been requested to help companies better understand how these instruments compare and how to transition ICIEF methods from iCE3 to the Maurice instrument. The different laboratories performed ICIEF on the NIST mAb and rhPD-L1-Fc with both the iCE3 and Maurice using analytical methods specifically developed for each of the molecules. After processing the electropherograms, statistical evaluation of the data was performed to determine consistencies within and between laboratory and outlying information. The apparent isoelectric point (pI) data generated, based on two-point calibration, for the main isoform of the NIST mAb showed high precision between laboratories, with RSD values of less than 0.3% on both instruments. The SDs for the NIST mAb and the rhPD-L1-Fc charged variants percent peak area values for both instruments are less than 1.02% across different laboratories. These results validate the appropriate use of both the iCE3 and Maurice for ICIEF in the biopharmaceutical industry in support of process development and regulatory submissions of biotherapeutic molecules. Further, the data comparability between the iCE3 and Maurice illustrates that the Maurice platform is a next-generation replacement for the iCE3 that provides comparable data.

New Peak Detection Performance Metrics from the MAM Consortium Interlaboratory Study.

The Multi-Attribute Method (MAM) Consortium was initially formed as a venue to harmonize best practices, share experiences, and generate innovative methodologies to facilitate widespread integration of the MAM platform, which is an emerging ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry application. Successful implementation of MAM as a purity-indicating assay requires new peak detection (NPD) of potential process- and/or product-related impurities. The NPD interlaboratory study described herein was carried out by the MAM Consortium to report on the industry-wide performance of NPD using predigested samples of the NISTmAb Reference Material 8671. Results from 28 participating laboratories show that the NPD parameters being utilized across the industry are representative of high-resolution MS performance capabilities. Certain elements of NPD, including common sources of variability in the number of new peaks detected, that are critical to the performance of the purity function of MAM were identified in this study and are reported here as a means to further refine the methodology and accelerate adoption into manufacturer-specific protein therapeutic product life cycles.

PULSE SPR: A High Throughput Method to Evaluate the Domain Stability of Antibodies.

Downstream purification of therapeutic antibodies requires candidates to be stable under various stress conditions, such as low pH. Current approaches to assess the conformational or colloidal stability of biologics may require significant amounts of material, and the testing may occur over an extended period of time. Furthermore, typical methodologies for early stability testing often do not directly address low pH stability, but focus more on conditions suitable for long-term drug product storage. Here we report a high-throughput method that measures protonation-induced unfolding of ligand binding sites for stability evaluation by surface plasmon resonance or PULSE SPR. This method, which requires only several micrograms of sample, is highly sensitive to the structural integrity of ligand binding sites and correlates well with thermal and chemical conformational stability. Combined with ligands targeting different regions of antibodies, this method allows a comprehensive assessment of antibody domain stability. By applying PULSE SPR, we found that antibodies with different complementarity-determining regions (CDRs), frameworks, formats, and interchain disulfide bonds showed different stabilities under acidic conditions. Additionally, biologics that aggregated in solution also had poor low pH stability. Taken together, PULSE SPR is a high-throughput and low sample consumption method that can be adopted to evaluate antibody domain stability and aggregation at low pH, which are two important aspects of therapeutic biologics.

Detection of Alkynes via Click Chemistry with a Brominated Coumarin Azide by Simultaneous Fluorescence and Isotopic Signatures in Mass Spectrometry.

Alkynes are a key component of click chemistry and used for a wide variety of applications including bioconjugation, selective tagging of protein modifications, and labeling of metabolites and drug targets. However, challenges still exist for detecting alkynes because most 1,2,3-triazole products from alkynes and azides do not possess distinct intrinsic properties that can be used for their facile detection by either fluorescence or mass spectrometry. To address this critical need, a novel brominated coumarin azide was used to tag alkynes and detect alkyne-conjugated biomolecules. This tag has several useful properties: first, it is fluorogenic and the click-chemistry products are highly fluorescent and quantifiable; second, its distinct isotopic pattern facilitates identification by mass spectrometry; and third, its click-chemistry products form a unique pair of reporter ions upon fragmentation that can be used for the quick screening of data. Using a monoclonal antibody conjugated with alkynes, a general workflow has been developed and examined comprehensively.

When Good Intentions Go Awry: Modification of a Recombinant Monoclonal Antibody in Chemically Defined Cell Culture by Xylosone, an Oxidative Product of Ascorbic Acid.

With the advent of new initiatives to develop chemically defined media, cell culture scientists screen many additives to improve cell growth and productivity. However, the introduction or increase of supplements, typically considered beneficial or protective on their own, to the basal media or feed stream may cause unexpected detrimental consequences to product quality. For instance, because cultured cells are constantly under oxidative stress, ascorbic acid (vitamin C, a potent natural reducing agent) is a common additive to cell culture media. However, as reported herein, a recombinant monoclonal antibody (adalimumab) in cell culture was covalently modified by xylosone (molecular weight 148), an oxidative product of ascorbate. Containing reactive carbonyl groups, xylosone modifies various amines (e.g., the N-termini of the heavy and light chains and susceptible lysines), forming either hemiaminal (+148 Da) or Schiff base (imine, +130 Da) products. Our findings show, for the first time, that ascorbate-derived xylosone can contribute to an increase in molecular heterogeneity, such as acidic species. Our work serves as a reminder that additives to cell culture and their metabolites may become reactive and negatively impact the overall product quality and should be carefully monitored with any changes in cell culture conditions.

Discovery of a chemical modification by citric acid in a recombinant monoclonal antibody.

Recombinant therapeutic monoclonal antibodies exhibit a high degree of heterogeneity that can arise from various post-translational modifications. The formulation for a protein product is to maintain a specific pH and to minimize further modifications. Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS), citric acid is commonly used for formulation to maintain a pH at a range between 3 and 6 and is generally considered chemically inert. However, as we reported herein, citric acid covalently modified a recombinant monoclonal antibody (IgG1) in a phosphate/citrate-buffered formulation at pH 5.2 and led to the formation of so-called "acidic species" that showed mass increases of 174 and 156 Da, respectively. Peptide mapping revealed that the modification occurred at the N-terminus of the light chain. Three additional antibodies also showed the same modification but displayed different susceptibilities of the N-termini of the light chain, heavy chain, or both. Thus, ostensibly unreactive excipients under certain conditions may increase heterogeneity and acidic species in formulated recombinant monoclonal antibodies. By analogy, other molecules (e.g., succinic acid) with two or more carboxylic acid groups and capable of forming an anhydride may exhibit similar reactivities. Altogether, our findings again reminded us that it is prudent to consider formulations as a potential source for chemical modifications and product heterogeneity.

Arginine modifications by methylglyoxal: discovery in a recombinant monoclonal antibody and contribution to acidic species.

Heterogeneity is common among protein therapeutics. For example, the so-called acidic species (charge variants) are typically observed when recombinant monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are analyzed by weak-cation exchange chromatography (WCX). Several protein post-translational modifications have been established as contributors but still cannot completely account for all heterogeneity. As reported herein, an unexpected modification by methylglyoxal (MGO) was identified, for the first time, in a recombinant monoclonal antibody expressed in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Modifications of arginine residues by methylglyoxal lead to two adducts (dihydroxyimidazolidine and hydroimidazolone) with increases of molecular weights of 72 and 54 Da, respectively. In addition, the modification by methylglyoxal causes the antibody to elute earlier in the weak cation exchange chromatogram. Consequently, the extent to which an antibody was modified at multiple sites corresponds to the degree of shift in elution time. Furthermore, cell culture parameters also affected the extent of modifications by methylglyoxal, a highly reactive metabolite that can be generated from glucose or lipids or other metabolic pathways. Our findings again highlight the impact that cell culture conditions can have on the product quality of recombinant protein pharmaceuticals.

Expression of antibodies using single open reading frame (sORF) vector design: Demonstration of manufacturing feasibility.

Efficient production of large quantities of therapeutic antibodies is becoming a major goal of the pharmaceutical industry. We developed a proprietary expression system using a polyprotein precursor-based approach to antibody expression in mammalian cells. In this approach, the coding regions for heavy and light chains are included within a single open reading frame (sORF) separated by an in-frame intein gene. A single mRNA and subsequent polypeptide are produced upon transient and stable transfection into HEK293 and CHO cells, respectively. Heavy and light chains are separated by the autocatalytic action of the intein and antibody processing proceeds to produce active, secreted antibody. Here, we report advances in sORF technology toward establishment of a viable manufacturing platform for therapeutic antibodies in CHO cells. Increasing expression levels and improving antibody processing by intein and signal peptide selection are discussed.

Comparison of the in vitro and in vivo stability of a succinimide intermediate observed on a therapeutic IgG1 molecule.

Deamidation of asparagine residues, a post-translational modification observed in proteins, is a common degradation pathway in monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). The kinetics of deamidation is influenced by primary sequence as well as secondary and tertiary folding. Analytical hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) is used to evaluate hydrophobicity of candidate mAbs and uncover post-translational modifications. Using HIC, we discovered atypical heterogeneity in a highly hydrophobic molecule (mAb-1). Characterization of the different HIC fractions using LC/MS/MS revealed a stable succinimide intermediate species localized to an asparagine-glycine motif in the heavy chain binding region. The succinimide intermediate was stable in vitro at pH 7 and below and increased on storage at 25°C and 40°C. Biacore evaluation showed a decrease in binding affinity of the succinimide intermediate compared with the native asparagine molecule. In vivo studies of mAb-1 recovered from a pharmacokinetic study in cynomolgus monkeys revealed an unstable succinimide species and rapid conversion to aspartic/iso-aspartic acid. Mutation from asparagine to aspartic acid led to little loss in affinity. This study illustrates the importance of evaluating modifications of therapeutic mAbs both in vitro and in serum, the intended environment of the molecule. Potential mechanisms that stabilize the succinimide intermediate in vitro are discussed.

Quantitation of a recombinant monoclonal antibody in monkey serum by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry.

A method including protein A purification, limited Lys-C digestion, and mass spectrometry analysis was used in the study to quantify a recombinant monoclonal antibody in cynomolgus monkey serum. The same antibody that was isotopically labeled was used as an internal standard. Interferences from serum proteins were first significantly reduced by protein A purification and then by limited Lys-C digestion of protein A bound IgG, including both monkey and the recombinant IgG. Fab fragment of the recombinant human IgG was analyzed directly by LC-MS, while monkey IgG and the Fc fragment of the recombinant human IgG remained bound to protein A resin. Quantitation was achieved by measuring the peak intensity of the Fab from the recombinant human IgG and comparing it to that of the Fab from the stable isotope-labeled internal standard. The results were in good agreement with the values from ELISA. LC-MS can therefore be used as a complementary approach to ELISA to quantify recombinant monoclonal antibodies in serum for pharmacokinetics studies and it can also be used where specific reagents such as antigens are not readily available for ELISA.

Effect of the light chain C-terminal serine residue on disulfide bond susceptibility of human immunoglobulin G1λ.

The light chain cysteine residue that forms an interchain disulfide bond with the cysteine residue in the heavy chain in IgG1κ is the last amino acid. The cysteine residue is followed by a serine residue in IgG1λ. Effect of the serine residue on the susceptibility of disulfide bonds to reduction was investigated in the current study using a method including reduction, differential alkylation using iodoacetic acid with either natural isotopes or enriched with carbon-13, and mass spectrometry analysis. This newly developed method allowed an accurate determination of the susceptibility of disulfide bonds in IgG antibodies. The effect of the serine residue on disulfide bond susceptibility was compared using three antibodies with differences only in the light chain last amino acid, which was either a serine residue, an alanine residue or deleted. The results demonstrated that the presence of the amino acid (serine or alanine) increased the susceptibility of the inter light and heavy chain disulfide bonds to reduction. On the other hand, susceptibility of the two inter heavy chain disulfide bonds and intrachain disulfide bonds was not changed significantly.

Ranking the susceptibility of disulfide bonds in human IgG1 antibodies by reduction, differential alkylation, and LC-MS analysis.

One of the basic structural features of human IgG1 is the arrangement of the disulfide bond structure, 4 inter chain disulfide bonds in the hinge region and 12 intra chain disulfide bonds associated with twelve individual domains. Disulfide bond structure is critical for the structure, stability, and biological functions of IgG molecules. It has been known that inter chain disulfide bonds are more susceptible to reduction than intra chain disulfide bonds. However, a complete ranking of the susceptibility of disulfide bonds in IgG1 molecules is lacking. A method including reduction, differential alkylation, and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) analysis was developed and employed to investigate the complete ranking order of the susceptibility of disulfide bonds in two recombinant monoclonal antibodies. The results confirmed that inter chain disulfide bonds were more susceptible than intra chain disulfide bonds. In addition, it was observed that the disulfide bonds between the light chain and heavy chain were more susceptible than disulfide bonds between the two heavy chains. The upper disulfide bond of the two inter heavy chain disulfide bonds was more susceptible than the lower one. Furthermore, disulfide bonds in the CH2 domain were the most susceptible to reduction. Disulfide bonds in VL, CL, VH, and CH1 domains had similar and moderate susceptibility, while disulfide bonds in the CH3 domain were the least susceptible to reduction. Interestingly, a difference between IgG1kappa and IgG1lambda was also observed. The difference in the susceptibility of inter light heavy chain disulfide bonds and inter heavy chain disulfide bonds was smaller in IgG1kappa than in IgG1lambda. The intra chain disulfide bonds in the Fab region of IgG1kappa were also less susceptible than disulfide bonds in the Fab region of IgG1lambda.

Domain-level stability of an antibody monitored by reduction, differential alkylation, and mass spectrometry analysis.

Human immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) contains 12 domains, and each has an intrachain disulfide bond that connects the two layers of antiparallel beta-sheets. These intrachain disulfide bonds are shielded from solvents under native conditions. Therefore, accessibility of the disulfide bonds to reduction under conditions that unfold antibody has the potential to be a good indicator of the thermodynamic stability of each domain. The stability of a recombinant monoclonal antibody at the domain level was investigated using a novel method involving reduction of the disulfide bonds in the presence of increasing amounts of guanidine hydrochloride and alkylation with [(12)C]iodoacetic acid, which was followed by reduction of the remaining disulfide bonds and alkylation with [(13)C]iodoacetic acid. The percentage of modification by [(12)C]iodoacetic acid of each cysteine residue was calculated using mass spectra of the cysteine-containing tryptic peptides and used to follow the unfolding of each domain. It demonstrated that the CH2 domain was the least stable domain of the antibody, whereas the CH3 domain was the most stable domain of the antibody. Other domains showed intermediate resistance to the denaturant concentration, similar to the overall unfolding transition monitored by the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence wavelength shift.

Analysis of reduced monoclonal antibodies using size exclusion chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry.

Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) has been widely used to detect antibody aggregates, monomer, and fragments. SEC coupled to mass spectrometry has been reported to measure the molecular weights of antibody; antibody conjugates, and antibody light chain and heavy chain. In this study, separation of antibody light chain and heavy chain by SEC and direct coupling to a mass spectrometer was further studied. It was determined that employing mobile phases containing acetonitrile, trifluoroacetic acid, and formic acid allowed the separation of antibody light chain and heavy chain after reduction by SEC. In addition, this mobile phase allowed the coupling of SEC to a mass spectrometer to obtain a direct molecular weight measurement. The application of the SEC-MS method was demonstrated by the separation of the light chain and the heavy chain of multiple recombinant monoclonal antibodies. In addition, separation of a thioether linked light chain and heavy chain from the free light chain and the free heavy chain of a recombinant monoclonal antibody after reduction was also achieved. This optimized method provided a separation of antibody light chain and heavy chain based on size and allowed a direct measurement of molecular weights by mass spectrometry. In addition, this method may help to identify peaks eluting from SEC column directly.

Localization and quantitation of free sulfhydryl in recombinant monoclonal antibodies by differential labeling with 12C and 13C iodoacetic acid and LC-MS analysis.

A low percentage of free sulfhydryl is a common feature of recombinant monoclonal antibodies although, in theory, all cysteine residues should be involved in disulfide bonds. A differential alkylation method was developed to determine the percentage of free sulfhydryl at each cysteine residue of four recombinant monoclonal antibodies. Free sulfhydryl was first alkylated with 12C iodoacetic acid. Free sulfhydryl, resulting from the reduction of disulfide bonds, was then alkylated with 13C iodoacetic acid. Cysteine containing peptides that were modified by 13C iodoacetic acid showed a molecular weight that was 2 Da higher than the same peptide that was modified by 12C iodoacetic acid. Peptides, containing the same cysteine residues that were modified with both alkylation reagents, coeluted on reversed-phase chromatography. Analysis by mass spectrometry resulted in two partially overlapped m/z series for each cysteine containing peptide, corresponding to modification by iodoacetic acid with 12C or 13C. The percentage of free sulfhydryl was then calculated using the two m/z series at each cysteine site. A low percentage of free sulfhydryl was detected at every cysteine residue in the four antibodies studied. Although different antibodies contained different levels of free sulfhydryl, similar distribution of free sulfhydryl in the domain structures was observed in the four antibodies.

Identification and localization of unpaired cysteine residues in monoclonal antibodies by fluorescence labeling and mass spectrometry.

Each human IgG1 antibody contains a total of thirty-two cysteine residues. In theory, all of them are involved in disulfide bonds, and no free sulfhydryl should be detected. However, literature has suggested that the presence of low levels of free sulfhydryl groups is likely a common feature of recombinant and wild type IgG1 antibodies. Currently, there is little information correlating the presence of free sulfhydryl to specific cysteine residues. The presence of free sulfhydryl groups in five recombinant monoclonal antibodies and their locations were further investigated in the current study. Free sulfhydryl groups were first modified using 5-idoacetamidofluorescein (5-IAF), which was followed by reduction of disulfide bonds and alkylation with iodoacetic acid (IAA). This procedure allowed differentiation of free cysteine residues from cysteine residues that were involved in disulfide bonding. In addition, it allowed a sensitive fluorescence detection of peptides with free sulfhydryl groups. The locations of the free sulfhydryl groups were determined using mass spectrometry after fraction collection. The results indicated that different antibodies had different levels of free sulfhydryl due to multiple unpaired cysteine residues commonly in the constant domains. Furthermore, free sulfhydryl due to unpaired cysteine residues in the variable domains varied for different antibodies. Interestingly, free sulfhydryl was rarely associated with cysteine residues that were involved in interchain disulfide bonds.

Effect of the conserved oligosaccharides of recombinant monoclonal antibodies on the separation by protein A and protein G chromatography.

Glycosylation of the conserved asparagine residue in CH2 domains of IgG molecules is an important post-translational modification. The presence of oligosaccharides is critical for structure, stability and biological function of IgG antibodies. Effect of the glycosylation states of recombinant monoclonal antibodies on protein A and protein G chromatography was evaluated. Antibodies lacking oligosaccharides eluted later from protein A and earlier from protein G columns than antibodies with oligosaccharides using a gradient of decreasing pH. Interestingly, different types of oligosaccharides also affected the elution of the antibodies. Antibodies with high mannose type oligosaccharides were enriched in later eluting fractions from protein A and earlier eluting fractions from protein G. While antibodies with more mature oligosaccharides, such as core fucosylated biantennary complex oligosaccharides with zero (Gal 0), one (Gal 1) or two (Gal 2) terminal galactoses, were enriched in earlier eluting fractions from protein A and in the later eluting fractions from protein G. However, analysis by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) revealed that antibody binding affinity to protein A and protein G was not affected by the absence or presence of oligosaccharides. It was thus concluded that the elution difference of antibodies with or without oligosaccharides and antibodies with different types of oligosaccharides were due to differential structural changes around the CH2-CH3 domain interface under the low pH conditions used for protein A and protein G chromatography.

Glutamine deamidation of a recombinant monoclonal antibody.

Deamidation of glutamine (Gln) proceeds at a much slower rate than deamidation of asparagine (Asn) residues at peptide level. However, deamidation of Gln residues in native proteins may occur faster because of the impact of protein structure and thus plays a significant role in affecting protein stability. Gln deamidation of a recombinant monoclonal IgG1 antibody was investigated in the current study. Deamidation was determined by a molecular weight increase of 1 Da, a retention time shift on reversed-phase chromatography and tandem mass spectrometric (MS/MS) analysis of the peptides. As expected, Gln residues at different locations in the three-dimensional structure had different susceptibilities to deamidation. Gln deamidation was highly pH dependent with the highest level detected in the sample incubated at pH 9, and lowest level at pH 6 in the pH range from 5 to 9. The detection of significant levels of Gln deamidation suggested that it may play an important role in affecting heterogeneity and stability of recombinant monoclonal antibodies.

Effect of methionine oxidation of a recombinant monoclonal antibody on the binding affinity to protein A and protein G.

Oxidation of methionine (Met) residues is one of the most common protein degradation pathways. Two Met residues, Met256 and Met432, of a recombinant fully human monoclonal IgG1 antibody have been shown to be susceptible to oxidation. Met256 and Met432 are located in the antibody CH2-CH3 interface and in close proximity to protein A and protein G binding sites. The effect of oxidation of these susceptible Met residues on the binding to protein A and protein G was investigated in the current study. Incubation of the antibody with 5% tert-butyl hydroperoxide (tBHP) resulted in a nearly complete oxidation of Met256 and Met432, while incubation with 1% tBHP resulted in mixed populations of the antibody with different degrees of Met oxidation. Oxidation of Met256 and Met432 resulted in earlier elution of the antibody from protein A and protein G columns when eluted with a gradient of decreasing pH. Analysis by ELISA and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) revealed decreased binding affinity of the oxidized antibody to protein A and protein G. It is therefore concluded that oxidation of the Met256 and Met432 residues of the recombinant monoclonal antibody altered its interaction with protein A and protein G resulting in a decrease in binding affinity.