Frequent, quantitative bone planar scintigraphy for determination of bone anabolism in growing mice.

BACKGROUND: To provide insight into bone turnover, quantitative measurements of bone remodeling are required. Radionuclide studies are widely used in clinical care, but have been rarely used in the exploration of the bone in preclinical studies. We describe a bone planar scintigraphy method for frequent assessment of bone activity in mice across the growing period. Since repeated venous radiotracer injections are hardly feasible in mice, we investigated the subcutaneous route. METHODS: Repeated 99mTc-hydroxymethylene diphosphonate (HMDP) tracer bone planar scintigraphy studies of the knee region and µCT to measure femur growth rate were performed in eight mice between week 6 and week 27 of life, i.e., during their growth period. Three independent investigators assessed the regions of interest (ROI). An index was calculated based on the counts in knees ROI (normalized by pixels and seconds), corrected for the activity administered, the decay between administration and imaging, and individual weights. RESULTS: A total of 93 scintigraphy studies and 85 µCT were performed. Repeated subcutaneous tracer injections were well tolerated and allowed for adequate radionuclide studies. Mean scintigraphic indexes in the knees ROI decreased from 87.4 ± 2.6 × 10-6 counts s-1 pixel-1 MBq-1 g-1 at week 6 to 15.0 ± 3.3 × 10-6 counts s-1 pixel-1 MBq-1 g-1 at week 27. The time constant of the fitted exponential decay was equal to 23.5 days. As control mean femur length assessed by µCT increased from 12.2 ± 0.8 mm at week 6 to 15.8 ± 0.2 mm at week 22. The time constant of the fitted Gompertz law was equal to 26.7 days. A correlation index of -0.97 was found between femur growth and decrease of bone tracer activity count between week 6 and 24. CONCLUSION: This methodological study demonstrates the potential of repeated bone planar scintigraphy in growing mice, with subcutaneous route for tracer administration, for quantitative assessment of bone remodeling.

Estimation of subject coregistration errors during multimodal preclinical imaging using separate instruments: origins and avoidance of artifacts.

We use high-resolution [Formula: see text] data in multiple experiments to estimate the sources of error during coregistration of images acquired on separate preclinical instruments. In combination with experiments with phantoms, we completed in vivo imaging on mice, aimed at identifying the possible sources of registration errors, caused either by transport of the animal, movement of the animal itself, or methods of coregistration. The same imaging cell was used as a holder for phantoms and animals. For all procedures, rigid coregistration was carried out using a common landmark coregistration system, placed inside the imaging cell. We used the fiducial registration error and the target registration error to analyze the coregistration accuracy. We found that moving an imaging cell between two preclinical devices during a multimodal procedure gives an error of about [Formula: see text] at most. Therefore, it could not be considered a source of coregistration errors. Errors linked to spontaneous movements of the animal increased with time, to nearly 1 mm at most, excepted for body parts that were properly restrained. This work highlights the importance of animal intrinsic movements during a multiacquisition procedure and demonstrates a simple method to identify and quantify the sources of error during coregistration.

Influence of Animal Heating on PET Imaging Quantification and Kinetics: Biodistribution of 18F-Tetrafluoroborate and 18F-FDG in Mice.

Different environmental conditions under anesthesia may lead to unstable homeostatic conditions in rodents and therefore may alter kinetics. In this study, the impact of different heating conditions on PET imaging quantification was evaluated. Methods: Two groups of 6 adult female BALB/c nude mice with subcutaneously implanted tumors underwent microPET imaging after injection of 18F-labeled tetrafluoroborate or 18F-FDG. Dynamic scans were acquired under optimal and suboptimal heating conditions. Time-activity curves were analyzed to calculate uptake and washout time constants. Results: With 18F-labeled tetrafluoroborate, optimal animal heating led to a stable heart rate during acquisition (515 ± 35 [mean ± SD] beats/min), whereas suboptimal heating led to a lower heart rate and a higher SD (470 ± 84 beats/min). Both uptake and washout time constants were faster (P < 0.01) in animals maintained with optimal heating. Conclusion: Although the difference in heart rates was slight, optimal heating yielded significantly faster uptake and washout kinetics than suboptimal heating in all organs for both tracers.

Image quality evaluation of small FOV and large FOV CBCT devices for oral and maxillofacial radiology.

OBJECTIVES: Quantitative and qualitative image quality evaluation of two different dental CBCT scanners. METHODS: Two CBCT systems were evaluated in this study: one small field-of-view (FOV) (50-mm diameter) system that also allows two-dimensional (2D) dental panoramic imaging and one large FOV CBCT system (60-180-mm diameter). These devices were all tested with installed acquisition default modes and proprietary reconstruction software, enabling high-resolution bone imaging. Quantitative analyses were carried out to measure spatial resolution, linearity and homogeneity. Small-size phantoms and a human dry skull were used to evaluate intrinsic performances. Visual qualitative analyses of specific anatomical parts were blindly performed by 10 operators. RESULTS: Concerning spatial resolution, small-voxel size protocols provide equivalent results on the two apparatus. In terms of linearity, all systems are highly linear (0.98 < r2 < 0.99) over the range of signal intensities encountered. Our results, coming from either phantoms or the dry skull, demonstrate that the small FOV CBCT suffers from a lack of homogeneity. CONCLUSIONS: For limited oral and maxillofacial volume imaging (diameter < 50 mm), the polyvalent small FOV CBCT (2D and three-dimensional imaging) system used in this study could reach performances similar to those of the large FOV CBCT.

MSCT versus CBCT: evaluation of high-resolution acquisition modes for dento-maxillary and skull-base imaging.

OBJECTIVES: Our aim was to conduct a quantitative and qualitative evaluation of high-resolution skull-bone imaging for dentistry and otolaryngology using different architectures of recent X-ray computed tomography systems. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Three multi-slice computed tomography (MSCT) systems and one Cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) system were used in this study. All apparatuses were tested with installed acquisition modes and proprietary reconstruction software enabling high-resolution bone imaging. Quantitative analyses were performed with small fields of view with the preclinical vmCT phantom, which permits to measure spatial resolution, geometrical accuracy, linearity and homogeneity. Ten operators performed visual qualitative analyses on the vmCT phantom images, and on dry human skull images. RESULTS: Quantitative analysis showed no significant differences between protocols in terms of linearity and geometric accuracy. All MSCT systems present a better homogeneity than the CBCT. Both quantitative and visual analyses demonstrate that CBCT acquisitions are not better than the collimated helical MSCT mode. CONCLUSION: Our results demonstrate that current high-resolution MSCT protocols could exceed the performance of a previous generation CBCT system for spatial resolution and image homogeneity. KEY POINTS: • Quantitative evaluation is a prerequisite for comparison of imaging equipment. • Bone imaging quality could be objectively assessed with a phantom and dry skull. • The current MSCT shows better image quality than a dental CBCT system. • CBCT remains a work-in-progress technology.

RSK2 is a modulator of craniofacial development.

BACKGROUND: The RSK2 gene is responsible for Coffin-Lowry syndrome, an X-linked dominant genetic disorder causing mental retardation, skeletal growth delays, with craniofacial and digital abnormalities typically associated with this syndrome. Craniofacial and dental anomalies encountered in this rare disease have been poorly characterized. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: We examined, using X-Ray microtomographic analysis, the variable craniofacial dysmorphism and dental anomalies present in Rsk2 knockout mice, a model of Coffin-Lowry syndrome, as well as in triple Rsk1,2,3 knockout mutants. We report Rsk mutation produces surpernumerary teeth midline/mesial to the first molar. This highly penetrant phenotype recapitulates more ancestral tooth structures lost with evolution. Most likely this leads to a reduction of the maxillary diastema. Abnormalities of molar shape were generally restricted to the mesial part of both upper and lower first molars (M1). Expression analysis of the four Rsk genes (Rsk1, 2, 3 and 4) was performed at various stages of odontogenesis in wild-type (WT) mice. Rsk2 is expressed in the mesenchymal, neural crest-derived compartment, correlating with proliferative areas of the developing teeth. This is consistent with RSK2 functioning in cell cycle control and growth regulation, functions potentially responsible for severe dental phenotypes. To uncover molecular pathways involved in the etiology of these defects, we performed a comparative transcriptomic (DNA microarray) analysis of mandibular wild-type versus Rsk2-/Y molars. We further demonstrated a misregulation of several critical genes, using a Rsk2 shRNA knock-down strategy in molar tooth germs cultured in vitro. CONCLUSIONS: This study reveals RSK2 regulates craniofacial development including tooth development and patterning via novel transcriptional targets.

Comparing respiratory gated with delayed scans in the detection of colorectal carcinoma hepatic and pulmonary metastases with 18F-FDG PET-CT.

PURPOSE: In patients experiencing colorectal carcinoma, exhaustive analysis of indicates extent of hepatic and pulmonary surgery that prolongs survival of patients. PATIENTS AND METHODS: To localize metastasis, we compared 2 F-FDG PET-CT imaging protocols, early respiratory gated scan, and delayed scan, to standard PET imaging procedure. SUVmax and lesion-to-healthy tissue ratio were measured in 60 pulmonary and 21 hepatic lesions by each of the 2 imaging protocols. RESULTS: In the liver, metastatic lesion-to-healthy tissue ratios significantly increased on delayed scans as compared with early scans (P < 0.001). Better ratios could not be obtained when using respiratory gated scans, whereas more lesions were detected on delayed scans. In the lungs, metastatic lesion- to-healthy tissue ratio increased significantly on delayed scans for largest lesions (P < 0.001). Ratios were not better when exploring smallest metastatic lesions or when using respiratory gated scans. Factors interfering with F-FDG PET-CT sensitivity are discussed, such as respiratory motion and high FDG physiological uptake in healthy liver parenchyma. CONCLUSIONS: Our studies indicate that routine acquisitions should use delayed hepatic scans for all patients referred for evaluation, recurrence check, or monitoring of colorectal adenocarcinoma. Delayed pulmonary scans are useful for the largest metastatic lesions and should be used in addition to early scan. In our experience, respiratory gated scans seem to be less convenient because of a low sensitivity in detection, as compared with the delayed technique; in addition, this technique is currently complicated by some technical issues, although these might be overcome with new gated protocols.

Dual-isotope 99mTc-MIBI/123I parathyroid scintigraphy in primary hyperparathyroidism: comparison of subtraction SPECT/CT and pinhole planar scan.

PURPOSE: In patients with primary hyperparathyroidism, the preoperative imaging objective is to locate accurately and reliably uniglandular or multiglandular hyperfunctioning parathyroid, to guide surgery, particularly for minimally invasive method. Subtraction planar scintigraphy with dual-isotope (I/Tc-MIBI) is an efficient examination to specify abnormal parathyroid location, but without accurate anatomic reference. This lack should be avoided by a hybrid SPECT/CT image acquisition. METHODS: We compared planar scans (neck and mediastinum parallel-hole, associated with anterior neck pinhole) to neck and mediastinum SPECT/CT, all with subtraction (I/Tc-MIBI) method, in exact location of abnormal parathyroid in 50 patients with sporadic primary hyperparathyroidism. Surgical and histological findings were used as the standard of comparison. RESULTS: Sensitivity is equivalent for the 2 protocols (86% and 75% for SPECT/CT and planar protocol, respectively, P = 0.15), but SPECT/CT was highly specific (specificity 100% and 90% for SPECT/CT and planar protocol, respectively, P = 0.04). In patients with concomitant thyroid disease, subtraction SPECT/CT appeared to be more sensitive than planar protocol (88% and 62% for SPECT/CT and planar protocol, respectively, P = 0.04). CONCLUSIONS: In preoperative assessment of primary hyperparathyroidism and to guide surgery, we propose to perform first subtraction SPECT/CT and to complete it with neck pinhole, only if tomoscintigraphy is negative.

Elliptical Fourier descriptors for contours in three dimensions: a new tool for morphometrical analysis in biology.

Elliptical Fourier descriptor analysis is a method for the morphometric study of curves. It has been used in the two-dimensional plane for closed contours, but rarely for lines in the three-dimensional space. The method consists of an expansion of a contour as a sum of ellipses. In this article, we study three-dimensional contours, i.e. lines embedded in the three-dimensional space. We compute for the first time the relations between the Fourier coefficients and its geometric parameters. We then use these relations for normalization and reorientation of three-dimensional contours. Such an algorithm can be used to perform inter-individual comparisons between contours, regardless of differences in viewpoint or global size. Human and small animal illustrative examples using biomedical X-ray CT imaging data of open bone structures demonstrate the interest and potential of the method for morphological analysis.

The impact of dialysis solution biocompatibility on ultrafiltration and on free water transport in rats.

This study compares different peritoneal dialysis fluids (PDF) in rats over a short contact time. For greater accuracy, net ultrafiltration (UF) and peritoneal transport indices, mass transfer area coefficient (MTAC) were scaled for the in vivo peritoneal surface area recruited (ivPSA) measured by microcomputerized tomography. Wistar rats underwent nephrectomy (5/6ths), were randomized into two groups and given 1.5% glucose PDF, either conventional acidic lactate (n = 14) or pH neutral bicarbonate (BicaVera) (n = 13); MTAC and UF were measured using a 90-min peritoneal equilibrium test (PET), fill volume (IPV) of 10 ml/100 g; small pore fluid transport was determined from sodium balance and used to calculate free water transport (FWT). Each ivPSA value was significantly correlated with the actual IPV, which varied from one rat to another. At 90 min of contact, there was no difference in recruited ivPSA in relation to PDFs. There was a difference (p < 0.01) in net UF/ivPSA 0.45 vs. 1.41 cm(2)/ml for bicarbonate versus lactate, as there was in the proportion of FWT with bicarbonate (42 ± 5% of net UF) compared to lactate (29 ± 4% of net UF). Net UF for individual values of ivPSA differs between conventional PDF and more biocompatible solutions, such as bicarbonate PDF. This observed change in UF cannot be fully explained by differences in glucose transport. The changes in FWT may be explained by the impact of the PDF biocompatibility on aquaporin function.

PET, SPECT, CT, and MRI in Mouse Cardiac Phenotyping: An Overview.

This overview first summarizes the last decade of continuous developments and improvements in pre-clinical imaging methods that are now essential tools for in vivo evaluation of cardiac morphology and function in living mice, involving nuclear emission of labeled molecules (micro-PET and micro-SPECT) and electromagnetic wave interactions with biological tissues (micro-CT and micro-MRI). In the following, and for better understanding, the basic physical principles and specific technical innovations of the aforementioned imaging methods are reviewed. Specificity, sensitivity, and spatial and temporal resolutions, together with the corresponding advantages and weaknesses of each method are then discussed, and cardiac image-acquisition protocols and illustrative examples are given for each modality. Emerging hybrid cardiac imaging is also presented and illustrated. Then, recent biological insights provided by mouse cardiac imaging are presented. Finally, imaging strategies in mouse cardiac phenotyping involving the aforementioned methods, adding metabolic and molecular information to morphological data, are emphasized and discussed. Curr. Protoc. Mouse Biol. 2:129-144 © 2012 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Subtle Morphological Changes in the Mandible of Tabby Mice Revealed by Micro-CT Imaging and Elliptical Fourier Quantification.

X-linked hypohidrotic ectodermal dysplasia (XLHED) is a genetic disorder due to a mutation of the EDA gene and is mainly characterized by an impaired formation of hair, teeth and sweat glands, and craniofacial dysmorphologies. Although tooth abnormalities in Tabby (Ta) mutant mice - the murine model of XLHED - have been extensively studied, characterization of the craniofacial complex, and more specifically the mandibular morphology has received less attention. From 3D micro-CT reconstructions of the left mandible, the mandibular outline observed in lateral view, was quantified using 2D elliptical Fourier analysis. Comparisons between Ta specimens and their wild-type controls were carried out showing significant shape differences between mouse strains enabling a clear distinction between hemizygous Ta specimens and the other mouse groups (WT and heterozygous Eda(Ta/+) specimens). Morphological differences associated with HED correspond not only to global mandibular features (restrained development of that bone along dorsoventral axis), but also to subtle aspects such as the marked backward projection of the coronoid process or the narrowing of the mandibular condylar neck. These modifications provide for the first time, evidence of a predominant effect of the Ta mutation on the mandibular morphology. These findings parallel the well described abnormalities of jugal tooth row and skeletal defects in Ta mice, and underline the role played by EDA-A in the reciprocal epithelial-mesenchymal interactions that are of critical importance in normal dental and craniofacial development.

Carbon tube electrodes for electrocardiography-gated cardiac multimodality imaging in mice.

This report describes a simple design of noninvasive carbon tube electrodes that facilitates electrocardiography (ECG) in mice during cardiac multimodality preclinical imaging. Both forepaws and the left hindpaw, covered by conductive gel, of mice were placed into the openings of small carbon tubes. Cardiac ECG-gated single-photon emission CT, X-ray CT, and MRI were tested (n = 60) in 20 mice. For all applications, electrodes were used in a warmed multimodality imaging cell. A heart rate of 563 ± 48 bpm was recorded from anesthetized mice regardless of the imaging technique used, with acquisition times ranging from 1 to 2 h.

Targeted apc;twist double-mutant mice: a new model of spontaneous osteosarcoma that mimics the human disease.

TWIST and adenomatosis polyposis coli (APC) are critical signaling factors in normal bone development. In previous studies examining a homogeneously treated cohort of pediatric osteosarcoma patients, we reported the frequent and concurrent loss of both TWIST and APC genes. On these bases, we created a related animal model to further explore the oncogenic cooperation between these two genes. We performed intercrosses between twist-null/+ and Apc1638N/+ mice and studied their progeny. The Apc1638N/+;twistnull/+ mice developed bone abnormalities observed by macroscopic skeletal analyses and in vivo imaging. Complementary histologic, cellular, and molecular analyses were used to characterize the identified bone tumors, including cell culture and immunofluorescence of bone differentiation markers. Spontaneous localized malignant bone tumors were frequently identified in Apc1638N/+;twist-null/+ mice by in vivo imaging evaluation and histologic analyses. These tumors possessed several features similar to those observed in human localized osteosarcomas. In particular, the murine tumors presented with fibroblastic, chondroblastic, and osteoblastic osteosarcoma histologies, as well as mixtures of these subtypes. In addition, cellular analyses and bone differentiation markers detected by immunofluorescence on tumor sections reproduced most murine and human osteosarcoma characteristics. For example, the early bone differentiation marker Runx2, interacting physically with hypophosphorylated pRb, was undetectable in these murine osteosarcomas, whereas phosphorylated retinoblastoma was abundant in the osteoblastic and chondroblastic tumor subtypes. These characteristics, similar to those observed in human osteosarcomas, indicated that our animal model may be a powerful tool to further understand the development of localized osteosarcoma.

Iodinated blood pool contrast media for preclinical X-ray imaging applications--a review.

The in vivo X-ray micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) is a very powerful and non-invasive tool used to establish high-resolution images with isotropic voxels in typical scan times ranging from minutes to tenths of minutes. This preclinical imaging technology is primarily adapted to visualize bones. X-ray imaging of soft tissues is made possible by using opaque compounds, providing contrast through tissue vascularization. Thus, using control agents with a long-lasting time in the blood, active or passive targeting of soft tissue is made possible in small animals. In this respect, the use of hydrophilic iodinated X-ray contrast media remains limited due to their rapid blood clearance, albeit at a slightly slower pace in humans as compared with rodents. The development of an iodinated contrast medium with increased vascular residence time is thus necessary. This is precisely the scope of the present paper, which will review and compare in detail the different vectors used as long-circulating iodinated contrast agents for micro-CT, i.e. liposomes, nanoemulsions, micelles, dendrimers and other polymeric particles. The discussion is focused, for each of these nanoparticulate systems, on their method of formulation and production, their stability properties, encapsulation properties, release properties, pharmacokinetics, and toxicology. The different aspects relative to the adaptation of these properties and physico-chemical characteristics for blood pool contrast agents aimed at angiographic micro-CT applications are also discussed. The aim of this review is to propose an overview into the formulation and properties of iodinated micro-CT contrast agents for preclinical applications.

In vivo preclinical low-field MRI monitoring of tumor growth following a suicide-gene therapy in an orthotopic mice model of human glioblastoma.

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to monitor in vivo with low field MRI growth of a murine orthotopic glioma model following a suicide gene therapy. METHODS: The gene therapy consisted in the stereotactic injection in the mice brain of a modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) vector encoding for a suicide gene (FCU1) that transforms a non toxic prodrug 5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) to its highly cytotoxic derivatives 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) and 5'-fluorouridine-5'monophosphate (5'-FUMP). Using a warmed-up imaging cell, sequential 3D T1 and T2 0.1T MRI brain examinations were performed on 16 Swiss female nu/nu mice bearing orthotopic human glioblastoma (U87-MG cells). The 6-week in vivo MRI follow-up consisted in a weekly measurement of the intracerebral tumor volume leading to a total of 65 examinations. Mice were divided in four groups: sham group (n=4), sham group treated with 5-FC only (n=4), sham group with injection of MVA-FCU1 vector only (n=4), therapy group administered with MVA-FCU1 vector and 5-FC (n=4). Measurements of tumor volumes were obtained after manual segmentation of T1- and T2-weighted images. RESULTS: Intra-observer and inter-observer tumor volume measurements show no significant differences. No differences were found between T1 and T2 volume tumor doubling times between the three sham groups. A significant statistical difference (p<0.05) in T1 and T2 volume tumor doubling times between the three sham groups and the animals treated with the intratumoral injection of MVA-FCU1 vector in combination with 2 weeks per os 5-FC administration was demonstrated. CONCLUSION: Preclinical low field MRI was able to monitor efficacy of suicide gene therapy in delaying the tumor growth in an in vivo mouse model of orthotopic glioblastoma.

Fifty years of brain tissue mechanical testing: from in vitro to in vivo investigations.

Beginning in the 1960s many studies have been performed to investigate the mechanical properties of brain. In this paper we point out the difficulties linked with in vitro experimental protocols as well as the advantages of using recently developed non-invasive in vivo techniques, such as magnetic resonance elastography. Results of in vitro and in vivo work are compared, emphasizing the specificities and disparities of the in vitro as well as the in vivo results. In particular, a detailed discussion of the results obtained from dynamic shear experiments and magnetic resonance elastography is given before arriving at a tentative conclusion on the state of knowledge of the mechanical properties of brain.

Transient left ventricular dysfunction syndrome: patho-physiological bases through nuclear medicine imaging.

BACKGROUND: Takotsubo cardiomyopathy (TTC) is a novel heart disease, mimicking acute myocardial infarction. The term "transient left ventricular dysfunction syndrome" (TLVDS) seems to be more appropriate since variant forms of TTC sparing apical segments (mid-ventricular ballooning syndrome (MVBS) and inverted TTC) have been described. Patho-physiological bases of TLVDS remain poorly understood and its optimal management is until now empirical. Our aim was to characterize patho-physiological mechanisms of TLVDS by means of nuclear medicine procedures and to discuss the clinical usefulness of isotopic imaging for a non-invasive diagnosis of TLVDS. METHODS AND RESULTS: During the sub acute phase, eighteen patients with TLVDS (13 TTC and 5 MVBS) underwent myocardial (99m)Tc-tetrofosmin or (201)Thallium Gated Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography (G-SPECT) (n=11), (123)I-mIBG SPECT (n=8) and (18)F-FDG Gated Positron Emission Tomography (G-PET) (n=15), assessing respectively LV perfusion, sympathetic innervation and glucose metabolism. Hypocontractile LV segments were characterized by normal perfusion but reduced uptake of (18)F-FDG and (123)I-mIBG. Topography and extent of metabolic defects and innervation abnormalities were largely overlapping. Follow-up (123)I-mIBG SPECT and (18)F-FDG G-PET were performed in selected patients showing rapid normalization of LV motion and progressive improvement of both glucose metabolism and sympathetic innervation. DISCUSSION: With the hypothesis of neurogenic stunned myocardium as the central causative mechanism of TLVDS, (123)I-mIBG SPECT seems to be the most specific diagnostic technique. Sympathetic function and glucose metabolism seem to be strictly correlated in the hypocontractile LV segments. Finally, our results underline the role of nuclear imaging in the setting of patho-physiological mechanisms of TLVDS.

Ultrasound-based transient elastography compared to magnetic resonance elastography in soft tissue-mimicking gels.

Ultrasound-based transient elastography (TE) and magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) are increasingly used methods for the clinical evaluation of soft tissue mechanical properties and their alteration under diseased conditions. This study proposes a comparison between magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) and ultrasound-based transient elastography (TE). Both methods were tested on the same soft tissue-mimicking gels in a common frequency range in order to allow for direct quantitative comparison. For the four gels tested, relatively good agreement was found between the shear moduli measured by both methods, with an averaged relative difference of 23%. This study demonstrates that under the assumption of homogeneous media that are significantly more elastic than viscous, quantitative results obtained by both methods are comparable.