Developing As and Cu Tissue Residue Thresholds to Attain the Good Ecological Status of Rivers in Mining Areas.

The study was performed on residue-effects datasets from polluted and unpolluted sites in the Nalón River basin (northern Spain). The effects were measured in terms of alteration of field macroinvertebrate communities, and measured as ecological status scores, and number of families and abundance of Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera (EPT). Non-linear regression models of the field-measured tissue residues in 10 taxa related to the ecological status of the macroinvertebrate communities were used to derive effective tissue residues (ERs). These were estimated for the good/moderate boundary defined by the ecological quality ratio (EQRs) score and for the 50% reduction of EQR and EPT metrics. As, Cu, Hg and Se ERs were calculated for several macroinvertebrate taxa with different feeding styles. The ER dataset allowed us to estimate As and Cu hazardous concentrations (HC), using species sensitivity distribution models, and were interpreted as community thresholds. Further studies for Hg and Se are needed to complete the database required for HC estimation. The reliability and differences of the several thresholds were tested in a risk assessment using a tissue-residue approach (TRA) conducted with field organisms from Cauxa Creek, a tributary from the same basin exposed to high levels of metals in the sediments due to gold mining activities. This risk assessment identified that As and Cu tissue residues satisfactorily explained the reduction in the ecological status of the macroinvertebrate assemblages. Our results indicate that TRA can help in setting future environmental quality standards for the protection of aquatic biota.

Proposal of integrative scores and biomonitor selection for metal bioaccumulation risk assessment in mine-impacted rivers.

Development of sound criteria for metal and metalloid bioaccumulation risk assessment in river basins affected by mining activities is a necessary tool to protect the aquatic communities. The aim of this study is to propose integrative scores for tissue residues that are suitable for surveillance programs and readily interpreted in terms of risk assessment in mining impacted rivers. Tissue residues of 7 trace metals and 2 metalloids were measured in ten macroinvertebrate taxa from the Nalón River basin (Spain), affected by Hg, Cu and Au mining activities. Compared with reference sites, biomonitor taxa from Hg and Au mining districts showed the highest bioaccumulation. However, low or non-significant bioaccumulation was found in sites influenced by historical Cu mining. Multivariate analyses (ANOSIM) performed on individual taxa revealed significant differences in tissue residues between sites classified according to their ecological status. The bioaccumulation risk assessment was based on the average ratio of the actual metal tissue residues in each macroinvertebrate taxon to the corresponding Ecological Threshold tissue concentration (Tissue residue Ratio to Threshold, TRT). The suitability of the biomonitors was evaluated using linear regression models fitted to the relationships between TRT scores and site sediment pollution or ecological status scores. Biomonitor selection also considered differences in invertebrate functional traits, which can influence metal and metalloid bioavailability. Site bioaccumulation risk was assessed on an Integrated Tissue concentration score (INTISS), calculated over a selection of the most relevant chemicals (As, Cu and Hg) and 3 biomonitor taxa (Baetidae, Hydropsychidae, Microdrile oligochaetes) comprising a set of feeding styles. Based on INTISS, it was possible to predict community alteration scores, using linear regression models. A comparison of site bioaccumulation and ecological status assessments based on the departure from reference conditions showed that operational monitoring programs in basins impaired by mining can be optimized by combining both approaches.

Changes in invertebrate community composition allow for consistent interpretation of biodiversity loss in ecological status assessment.

Biological communities change in response to human alteration. The response of individual taxa and the community can be used to establish preventive criteria to halt further biodiversity deterioration. Here we explore how consistent are the boundaries between Good and Moderate ecological status derived from classification systems used in North-NW Spain: NORThern Spain Indicators system (NORTI), River type specific multimetric (METI) and Iberian Bio-monitoring Working Party (IBMWP), by using common interpretation of normative definitions of Water Framework Directive. We applied the three classifications to a monitoring dataset of Nalón River basin, comprising samples from different stream types and reference conditions. We applied Threshold Indicator Taxa ANalysis to the invertebrate community along the most relevant environmental pressures and biological impairment gradients represented by the Ecological Quality Ratio (EQR) scores of the classification systems. Only NORTI provided a true community ecological threshold and the change point (cp) 95% quantile (Q95%) range of 0.760 was assumed to be the boundary from Good to Moderate (G/M) status, used to standardize the number of taxa loss in all systems. Since the average number of taxa at reference sites was 34, the estimated loss of sensitive taxa was up to 97.1% in IBMWP, 73.5% in METI and 52.9% in NORTI when passing from Good to Moderate status, revealing very permissive boundaries. The loss of common sensitive taxa in NORTI at Q95% was used as G/M threshold and applied to the other classifications, resulting all in a common biodiversity loss of 21% of sensitive taxa richness at values of NORTI-EQR = 0.760, METI-EQR = 0.818 and IBMWP-EQR = 0.753. Results indicate that significant community changes along pressure gradients allow for establishing quantitative criteria consistent with normative definitions. This understanding derived from Directive monitoring programs can assess the risk that invertebrate communities face in terms of species loss derived from anthropogenic pressures.

Derivation of sediment Hg quality standards based on ecological assessment in river basins.

The Environmental Quality Standards (EQS) directive was an important improvement of long-term water quality monitoring at the European level, leading to the use of sediments and biota as relevant matrices for assessing priority substances under the European Water Framework directive. Currently, commonly accepted sediment EQS for Hg are missing in Europe. In this study we present a new, tiered approach to deriving sediment quality standards for Hg: the derivation of Predicted No-Effect Concentration (PNEC) from data in the literature, followed by adjusting values at regional scale, using ecological field data (macroinvertebrate community assessment) and field sediment ecotoxicity bioassays. The limited set of effect data available for Hg spiked-sediment ecotoxicity tests has resulted in unreliable PNEC values for sediment quality assessment. Field reference sites (n = 40) where the macroinvertebrate community status was assessed as High or Good were used to define the ecological background and threshold levels in sediments in northern Spain. Sediment QS developed in other areas were not suitable for specific basins in our study area, since they were within the range of our Hg background levels. Temporary sediment Quality Standards (QS) for Hg were developed for the Nalón River basin (where several mining districts occur), using field effect-based approaches such as sediment ecotoxicity data from Tubifex tubifex chronic bioassays and ecological assessment of macroinvertebrate communities. A proposal for Hg quality assessment in freshwater sediments of northern Spain is made based on ecologically relevant QS values, providing benchmark values for No-Effect and Effect Hg sediment concentrations.