Second surgery for progressive glioblastoma: a multi-centre questionnaire and cohort-based review of clinical decision-making and patient outcomes in current practice.

PURPOSE: Glioblastoma prognosis is poor. Treatment options are limited at progression. Surgery may benefit, but no quality guidelines exist to inform patient selection. We sought to describe variations in surgical management at progression, highlight where further evidence is needed, and build towards a consensus strategy. METHODS: Current practice in selection of patients with progressive GBM for second surgery was surveyed online amongst specialists in the UK and Europe. We complemented this with an assessment of practice in a retrospective cohort study from six United Kingdom neurosurgical units. We used descriptive statistics to analyse the data. RESULTS: 234 questionnaire responses were received. Maintaining or improving patient quality of life was key to decision making, with variation as to whether patient age, performance status or intended extent of resection was relevant. MGMT methylation status was not important. Half considered no minimum time after first surgery. 288 patients were reported in the cohort analysis. Median time to second surgery from first surgery 390 days. Median overall survival 815 days, with no association between time to second surgery and time to death (p = 0.874). CONCLUSIONS: This is the most wide-ranging examination of contemporaneous practice in management of GBM progression. Without evidence-based guidelines, the variation is unsurprising. We propose consensus guidelines for consideration, to reduce heterogeneity in decision making, support data collection and analysis of factors influencing outcomes, and to inform clinical trials to establish whether second surgery improves patient outcomes, or simply selects to patients already performing well.

How much can be concluded from the International Subarachnoid Aneurysm Trial (ISAT)?

Recently published data from the International Subarachnoid Aneurysm Trial (ISAT) shows that for patients enrolled in the trial there is a 7.4% reduction in the incidence of death or dependency at 1 year if they undergo coiling, rather than clipping. Furthermore, extrapolation of longer-term follow-up data for patient mortality appears to suggest that this advantage will be maintained in the longer term. Based on a reassessment of the published data, the authors note: (1) the incidence of rebleeding following treatment is approximately three times higher in the coiled group (p<0.001); (2) the need for aneurysm retreatment is likely to be higher in the coiled group; (3) trends in longer-term mortality data are not a reliable basis for predicting future outcomes of the trial; (4) trends in longer-term morbidity data are more reliable and suggest that the advantage of coiling diminishes with time; (5) The absence of up-to-date published rates of aneurysm retreatment and of longer-term rates of death or dependence makes ISAT extremely hard to interpret. It is far from clear that the early advantage of coiling will be maintained in the future and, hence, longer follow-up is required. Treatment of aneurysms is a continually evolving field and there is currently no other major source of information concerning management of aneurysms. For these reasons the authors recommend the instigation of a national aneurysm registry to prospectively collect data.

Angiography postclipping and coiling of cerebral aneurysms.

Postclipping cerebral angiography is generally not practised in the UK. The International Subarachnoid Trial (ISAT) data show that coiling compared favourably with clipping in the early posttreatment phase. We present a 4-year, single unit experience comparing cerebral angiography at 6 months postclipping and postcoiling, defining the proportion of aneurysms in either group, which were incompletely excluded from the cerebral circulation after treatment. There were 4 'dog-ear' remnants (4.6%) in the clipping group of 86 aneurysms, one of which required further surgery. Thirty-one out of 82 (37.8%) coiled aneurysms that underwent check angiography were inadequately excluded from the cerebral circulation at 6 months. Of these, to date, four patients have undergone re-coiling. Although the immediate complications of coiling may be less than those of clipping (ISAT), it seems that the degree and permanence of exclusion of an aneurysm from the cerebral circulation may be more secure with surgery. In summary, the rates of incomplete aneurysmal exclusion from the cerebral circulation, the requirement for reintervention and the requirement for continuing surveillance were all higher in the coiled population than in the clipped population.

Injury rates in Shotokan karate.

OBJECTIVE: To document the injury rate in three British Shotokan karate championships in consecutive years. In these tournaments strict rules governed contact, with only "light" or "touch" contact allowed. Protective padding for the head, hands, or feet was prohibited. METHODS: Prospective recording of injuries resulting from 1770 bouts in three national competitions of 1996, 1997, and 1998. Details of ages and years of karate experience were also obtained. RESULTS: 160 injuries were sustained in 1770 bouts. The overall rate of injury was 0.09 per bout and 0.13 per competitor. 91 (57%) injuries were to the head. The average age of those injured was 22 years, with an average of nine years of experience in karate. CONCLUSIONS: The absence of protective padding does not result in higher injury rates than in most other series of Shotokan karate injuries. Strict refereeing is essential, however, to maintain control and minimise contact.

Cerebral blood flow and tissue oxygenation monitoring during aneurysm surgery.

Regional cerebral blood flow may be compromised during aneurysm surgery. This may occur during vessel occlusion by temporary clips or result from malposition of the definitive aneurysm clip. Post-operative cerebral vasospasm may also compromise cerebral blood flow and is an important cause of morbidity. This study addresses the need for a sensitive indicator of compromised cerebral function during aneurysm surgery by measuring brain tissue oxygenation and laser Doppler flow. Four patients were studied, all of whom had ruptured middle cerebral artery aneurysms. Brain tissue oxygenation measurements were made with a closed polarographic sensor placed in the ipsilateral cerebral hemisphere to the aneurysm. A laser Doppler flow probe and intracranial pressure monitor were similarly placed. The data were simultaneously processed using multimodality recording monitoring. The monitoring was continued during the post-operative period and totalled over 190 hours. Data were analysed as specific events and as trends. Initial tissue oxygen levels were low but improved in all cases as the intracranial pressure was reduced. This effect was independent of the cerebral perfusion pressure. Laser Doppler flow provided an indicator of compromised brain function and tissue oxygenation an indicator of established ischemia.

Vim thalamotomy for the relief of the intention tremor of multiple sclerosis.

We have reviewed the outcome of patients who have undergone thalamotomy for the intention tremor of multiple sclerosis (MS). Twenty-four patients underwent 29 procedures between 1988 and 1995. These patients were assessed for the degree of disability due to MS and for the impairment of arm function due to the tremor. Preoperative, postoperative and last follow-up score (mean 2.2 years) were determined for arm function following thalamotomy. Patient satisfaction, where expressed, was recorded. Twenty-three procedures (79%) resulted in immediate improvement in arm function. Thirteen complications were recorded. Postoperative fatigue was demonstrated after seven procedures. Sustained benefit was seen after 18 procedures (62%). Out of 23 patients whose opinions are recorded four were enthusiastic and 10 satisfied with the outcome. We conclude that, despite severe disability, a majority of patients with intention tremor of MS may still benefit from thalamotomy and are satisfied with the results.

Granular cell tumour of the spinal cord: case report.

A granular cell tumour presenting within the spinal cord of a 17-year-old woman is described. This distinctive tumour has a widespread distribution, but has been reported only rarely in the central nervous system. The literature is reviewed.

Intralobular variations in barrier thickness in the mature human placenta.

Following perfusion fixation, the harmonic mean thickness of the villous membrane was measured for terminal villi sampled at various sites within a single lobule. Comparisons were made between central and peripheral regions of the lobule at the levels of the basal plate, the mid-zone and just under the chorionic plate. Ten placentae were examined, and in each case the centre of a lobule was identified by the presence of a villus-free cavity. At each level the harmonic mean thickness was significantly reduced in the peripheral regions compared to the central regions. By contrast, no change was found in the arithmetic mean thickness, the volume fraction of the fetal capillary lumina, or the mean capillary diameter. This variation in harmonic mean barrier thickness may be related to the pattern of maternal blood flow through the lobule and any PO2 gradient that results therefrom. It is clear that changes in the thickness of vasculosyncytial membranes can take place independently of any alterations in the calibre of the underlying fetal capillary network.