Transfer of genetic material between the chloroplast and nucleus: how is it related to stress in plants?

BACKGROUND: The presence of chloroplast-related DNA sequences in the nuclear genome is generally regarded as a relic of the process by which genes have been transferred from the chloroplast to the nucleus. The remaining chloroplast encoded genes are not identical across the plant kingdom indicating an ongoing transfer of genes from the organelle to the nucleus. SCOPE: This review focuses on the active processes by which the nuclear genome might be acquiring or removing DNA sequences from the chloroplast genome. Present knowledge of the contribution to the nuclear genome of DNA originating from the chloroplast will be reviewed. In particular, the possible effects of stressful environments on the transfer of genetic material between the chloroplast and nucleus will be considered. The significance of this research and suggestions for the future research directions to identify drivers, such as stress, of the nuclear incorporation of plastid sequences are discussed. CONCLUSIONS: The transfer to the nuclear genome of most of the protein-encoding functions for chloroplast-located proteins facilitates the control of gene expression. The continual transfer of fragments, including complete functional genes, from the chloroplast to the nucleus has been observed. However, the mechanisms by which the loss of functions and physical DNA elimination from the chloroplast genome following the transfer of those functions to the nucleus remains obscure. The frequency of polymorphism across chloroplast-related DNA fragments within a species will indicate the rate at which these DNA fragments are incorporated and removed from the chromosomes.

RAPD polymorphisms detected among the flax genotrophs.

The occurrence of environmentally induced heritable changes in certain flax varieties has been shown to be accompanied by changes in the genomic DNA. A large difference in nuclear DNA contents has been characterized between the extreme types, termed genotrophs. The genomic variation between a series of genotrophs has been studied by the polymerase chain reaction using random arbitrary oligonucleotide primers. A total of 320 primers were used in the reactions and 253 polymorphic bands observed. The polymorphic bands were derived from all parts of the genome, namely the highly repetitive. middle-repetitive and low-copy-number sequences. They were also shown to be distributed throughout the genome. In one group of genotrophs, all of which were induced by temperature treatment, there was a clustering of the polymorphisms with a high degree of shared polymorphisms. These results are in agreement with earlier studies showing that a dispersed fraction of the genome is susceptible to variation when environmentally induced heritable changes occur.

The flax ribosomal RNA-encoding genes are arranged in tandem at a single locus interspersed by 'non-rDNA' sequences.

The ribosomal RNA (rRNA)-encoding genes (rDNA) in flax, estimated to be present in about 2400 copies per diploid nucleus, have been reported as a single homogeneous repeat unit of 8.6 kb. In situ hybridization analysis indicated that these genes were located at a single site on one pair of chromosomes. However, an analysis of a flax variety, CI 1303, has revealed heterogeneity in the intergenic spacer of the rDNA repeat unit. A genetic analysis of rDNA inheritance in two flax lines, Stormont Cirrus and CI 1303, has again supported the observation that there is a single rDNA locus in this plant species. Screening of four different genomic libraries made in methylation-sensitive and -insensitive systems, and the analysis of 40 phage clones, demonstrate a much higher number than that expected of junctions between rDNA and non-rDNA. Direct evidence of rRNA-encoding genes being present in tandem comes from a few phage clones that contain more than two rDNA repeats. The evidence presented here indicates that rDNA, although present at a single locus in tandem arrays, may be interrupted frequently by other non-rDNA sequences, thus giving rise to questions about their organization into long tandem arrays.

Producing a P1 bacteriophage library from pine: isolation and cloning of very high molecular weight DNA.

We have generated a genomic P1 bacteriophage library using Monterey pine (Pinus radiata) DNA. We first developed a method for isolating from pine tissue the very high molecular weight DNA necessary for the preparation of libraries requiring large inserts. The method involves protoplasting the cells, isolating nuclei and lysis in a high concentration of detergent. Fragments of greater than two megabases in size are produced in solution. Modifications introduced to the protocol for library preparation and for P1 plasmid isolation are described.

Sequence and organization of 5S ribosomal RNA-encoding genes of Arabidopsis thaliana.

We have isolated a genomic clone containing Arabidopsis thaliana 5S ribosomal RNA (rRNA)-encoding genes (rDNA) by screening an A. thaliana library with a 5S rDNA probe from flax. The clone isolated contains seven repeat units of 497 bp, plus 11 kb of flanking genomic sequence at one border. Sequencing of individual subcloned repeat units shows that the sequence of the 5S rRNA coding region is very similar to that reported for other flowering plants. Four A. thaliana ecotypes were found to contain approx. 1000 copies of 5S rDNA per haploid genome. Southern-blot analysis of genomic DNA indicates that 5S rDNA occurs in long tandem arrays, and shows the presence of numerous restriction-site polymorphisms among the six ecotypes studied.

Specific DNA alterations associated with the environmental induction of heritable changes in flax.

Several flax varieties have been shown to undergo environmentally induced heritable changes resulting in stable lines termed genotrophs. The most notable of these is the variety Stormont Cirrus, also termed "plastic" or Pl. A number of morphological, biochemical and genetic differences are associated with environmental induction of heritable changes in flax. We have studied 5S rDNA alterations as a model system for understanding environmental induction of heritable changes in flax. This paper reports the isolation of a flax 5S rRNA gene variant which identifies genotroph specific restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) in flax. Restriction fragment patterns for several enzymes were observed in both large and small genotrophs which consistently differed from the progenitor, Stormont Cirrus. Identical RFLP profiles for all restriction endonucleases tested were observed in four small genotrophs produced from separate environmental induction experiments. Comparison between Stormont Cirrus and these small genotrophs showed at least six differing bands in addition to several high molecular weight polymorphisms. Genetic data indicate that the polymorphisms were all produced from a repetitive 5S rRNA gene cluster at a single chromosomal locus. Similar, but not identical, polymorphisms are also detected in other flax varieties and Linum species suggesting that the induced variation is related to that which occurs naturally. The results are evidence that a specific set of DNA alterations occur in association with the induction of heritable changes in flax. This is the first genetic marker which is altered to an identical state in one type of genotroph. The results are discussed with respect to mechanisms for environmentally induced heritable change in plants.

The ubiquitin-encoding multigene family of flax, Linum usitatissimum.

Ubiquitin (Ubq), a 76-amino acid (aa) protein, is found in all eukaryotic organisms and is one of the most conserved proteins so far studied. It is implicated in many cellular processes. The Ubq-encoding genes (ubq) are generally present as a multigene family. In flax, we have estimated that this multigene family contains at the most ten members. The initial flax ubq sequences were isolated from a flax genomic library in lambda EMBL4 using a heterologous Arabidopsis thaliana ubq probe. An 916-bp fragment from one of the phage clones was subcloned and sequenced. The aa sequence derived from the nucleotide sequence of this fragment is identical to that of other plant Ubqs. This fragment was then used to isolate additional flax ubq clones. In all, eleven phage lambda clones, which represent six members of the gene family, were restriction-mapped and characterized. These six members are represented as three monomers, three poly-Ubqs, one hexamer and two tetramers. They can be present at either a single locus (two of the monomers and one of the poly-Ubqs) or at two loci (the remaining three genes). The other four members of the family are yet to be cloned and characterized.

Chromosomal and molecular analysis of 5S RNA gene organization in the flax, Linum usitatissimum.

The 5S rRNA genes (5S DNA) comprise up to 3% of the flax genome. Large copy-number changes in 5S DNA have been observed in flax genotrophs. We have characterized the chromosomal and molecular organization of this large gene family. In situ hybridization studies indicate the 5S DNA is distributed over many chromosomes, unlike most plants studied to date. Eleven genomic clones were isolated and characterized. All but one of the clones contain both 5S DNA and non-5S DNA. The homology of the 5S DNA of each clone, to a previously isolated flax 5S plasmid clone (pBG13), was determined. Five groups of 5S DNA were identified based on shared identity and repeat unit size. Group-1 and group-2 clones are the most abundant in terms of genomic representation. The remaining groups are significantly different from the previously described flax 5S DNA and are in low representation in comparison to group-1 and group-2 5S DNA. The results establish the presence of several groups of 5S DNA which are distributed over many chromosomes. The extent of identity shared among these groups to pBG13, indicates a high degree of divergence between the different groups.

Ribosomal DNA methylation in a flax genotroph and a crown gall tumour.

The methylation patterns of two flax lines are described. One, a genotroph S1, has 800 rNA genes per haploid cell while FT37/1, a crown gall tumour incited on S1, has only 300. Using the enzymes EcoRII, BstNI and ApyI to assess CXG methylation and HpaII and MspI for CG, we show that the methylation patterns of the rDNAs of both lines are identical. Both lines contain 3 fractions; the first contains repeats that are methylated at all sites examined and the second has some unmethylated sites. The third fraction contains repeats that are fully methylated but contain a discrete hypomethylated site at the 5' end of the pre-rRNA. The number of repeats which show these hypomethylated sites is constant in both lines despite the copy number difference. These may represent the active rRNA gene repeats.

Evaluating quantitative variation in the genome of Zea mays.

Genomic diversity within the species Zea mays has been examined by measuring the variation in the repetitive component of the nuclear genome among North American inbred lines and varieties. This was done by preparing a set of clones of repetitive maize sequences that differ in function, molecular arrangement and multiplicity and then using these as probes for quantitative hybridization to DNA from various maize genotypes. The comparison showed that the majority of repeated sequences are markedly variable in copy number among the ten maize strains tested. The clone sample contained the rDNA and 5S genes, the major repeat of the chromosome knobs, sequences functioning as origins of DNA replication in yeast (ARS sequences) and randomly cloned sequences of unknown function and chromosomal location. The sequences ranged in reiteration frequency from 200 to greater than 10(5) copies and included both tandemly arrayed and dispersed repeats. The copy numbers were measured by hybridizing labeled cloned sequences to aliquots of high molecular weight genomic DNA that were applied to nitrocellulose filters through a slotted template (slot blotting). The hybridization signal on an autoradiogram occurred in a narrow band that could be scored reliably with a densitometer. This provided a rapid method of determining the abundance of particular repeated sequences in individual plants and plant populations. Using this technique, we found that the copy number of repeated sequences of all types generally varied among the strains by two- to threefold, although at least one sequence showed no detectable variation. In contrast to the variability found between strains, individuals within an inbred line or variety were found to be indistinguishable in terms of specific sequence multiplicity. Each genotype has a different pattern of copy numbers for the set of repeated sequence clones, and this pattern is characteristic of all individuals of a particular genotype. The data also show that the copy number of each sequence varies independently. No strains had uniformly high or low copy numbers for the entire set of probes.

Unstable genes in plants.

The fluidity of the plant genome during development and reproduction has been considered. Although some cases of differential replication have been described there is little evidence for this process playing a large part in development. However the genome flexibility in response to 'shocks' to the genome observed in flax and maize suggest that this process may be important in the generation of rapid changes in genome. These rapid changes appear to occur in particular subsets of the genome which may allow a radical but limited reorganization of the genome in response to genomic challenge.

The chloroplast DNAs of flax genotrophs.

The chloroplast DNA of L. usitatissimum var. "Stormont Cirrus" has been mapped with respect to the recognition sites for the enzymes SalP1, Sst1 and SalG1. It is a circular molecule of about 160 kilobasepairs, with an inverted repeat containing the rDNA. Comparisons between chloroplast DNA of uninduced and induced flax genotrophs show there to be no major structural differences.

A simple plant polytene chromosome system, and its use for in situ hybridisation.

When the cotyledons of Pisum sativum are cultured in the presence of 2-4D, large populations of cells with polytene chromosomes are stimulated to enter prophase; the use of these chromosome for studies of in situ hybridisation with nucleic acids is described.

Organisation of the 5S RNA genes in flax.

The 5S RNA genes of flax [Linum usitatissimum] are arranged as tandem arrays of a 0.35 - 0.37kb repeating sequence. The 5S DNA is extensively methylated at CCGG and CCGG. In contrast to the rDNA, the 5S DNA sequences exhibit both length and sequence heterogeneity. The number of copies of this sequence varies between 117,000 and 49,600 per 2C nucleus in different lines of flax, and does not correlate with the number of rRNA genes.

Characterisation of the genes for ribosomal RNA in flax.

DNA coding for the 18S and 25S rRNAs in flax (Linum usitatissimum) has been purified and is arranged in tandem arrays with a repeat length of 8.6 kb. There is no detectable variation in the size of this repeat unit. Single repeat units have been cloned in the plasmid pAT 153. The coding sequences for the 25S, 18s and 5.85 rRNAs have been localised by hybridisation. The cloned rDNA has been used to compare two genotrophs, L1 ad S1, where the number of rRNA cistrons has been altered by growth under different environmental conditions. In terms of the size of the repeat unit and the position of a number of restriction enzyme sites the rDNAs from L1 and S1 were identical.

DNA sequence organization in the flax genome.

The complexity of the flax genome has been determined by reassociation kinetics. The total complexity of one constituent genome was 3.5 . 10(8) nucleotide pairs. The single copy sequences comprised 44% of the genome and showed a long period interspersion pattern with the repetitive sequences. The repetitive sequences occurred in clusters which stretched for at least 10 000 base pairs. Within these clusters the individual repetitive elements were about 650 base pairs. These elements themselves showed little interspersion of different frequency classes in lengths less than 3000 base pairs. The repetitive sequence duplexes formed on reassociation, except for the satellite DNA, showed a high thermal stability. The fold-back DNA comprised 1% of the total genome, and was itself clustered in a small fraction of the genome.

Segregation of the isozymes of flax genotrophs.

The segregation of isozymes of peroxidase and acid phosphatase in progenies of crosses between large (L) and small (S and L6) flax genotrophs has been determined. The peroxidase isozymes segregated as expected on a simple Mendelian model with a dominant and a recessive allele and with the L genotroph being a homozygous dominant. All the peroxidase isozymes which differed segregated together, so the isozymes are controlled by either a single locus or closely linked loci. The acid phosphatase isozymes in the F1 were all L type, but the segregations observed in the F2 were not always consistent with a simple Mendelian model.

Chromatin-bound DNA-dependent RNA polymarase in developing pea cotyledons : II. Polymerase activity and template availability under different growth conditions.

The chromatin-bound DNA-dependent RNA polymerase activity, and template availability to added homologous RNA polymerase, were determined for pea cotyledons which were allowed to develop in different environments. Both the maximum polymerase activity and the template availability were higher in cotyledons that were developing at the faster rate. The template availability was approximately constant within an environment throughout most of the development, but differed between environments. The extra DNA sythesised, that is that above the 2C level, during cytyledon development appeared to be more utilised for RNA synthesis in slowly developing cotyledons than in more rapidly developing ones.

Chromatin-bound DNA-dependent RNA polymerase in developing pea cotyledons.

The pattern of cotyledon development in three varieties of Pisum sativum has been defined in terms of cell number, DNA and RNA content and chromatin, bound RNA polymerase activity. Variation was observed in the relative periods of growth by cell division and cell expansion between the three varieties. The mean DNA content per cotyledon cell during growth by cell expansion increased to approximately 50C in one variety, 30C in the second variety and 15C in the third variety. The pattern of chromatin-bound RNA polymerase activity during development suggested that some of the DNA above the 2C level may contribute to RNA synthesis in two of the three varieties studied. In the third variety the RNA polymerase activity decreases throughout the phase of increase in DNA per cell. The chromatin-bound RNA polymerase activity per cell was correlated with the rate of RNA increase per cell.