Reference Protocol to Assess Analytical Performance of Higher Order Structural Analysis Measurements: Results from an Interlaboratory Comparison.

Measurements of protein higher order structure (HOS) provide important information on stability, potency, efficacy, immunogenicity, and biosimilarity of biopharmaceuticals, with a significant number of techniques and methods available to perform these measurements. The comparison of the analytical performance of HOS methods and the standardization of the results is, however, not a trivial task, due to the lack of reference protocols and reference measurement procedures. Here, we developed a protocol to structurally alter and compare samples of somatropin, a recombinant biotherapeutic, and describe the results obtained by using a number of techniques, methods and in different laboratories. This, with the final aim to provide tools and generate a pool of data to compare and benchmark analytical platforms and define method sensitivity to structural changes. Changes in somatropin HOS, induced by the presence of zinc at increasing concentrations, were observed, both globally and at more localized resolution, across many of the methods utilized in this study and with different sensitivities, suggesting the suitability of the protocol to improve understanding of inter- and cross-platform measurement comparability and assess analytical performance as appropriate.

Synthesis and chromatographic evaluation of molecularly imprinted polymers prepared by the substructure approach for the class-selective recognition of glucuronides.

Two series of molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) for the class-selective recognition of glucuronides have been prepared by using lipophilic substructures of the target analyte as template molecule and potent host monomers against oxyanions, that are expected to establish a strong stoichiometric interaction with the single carboxylic group of the template. The polymers were tested as stationary phases in liquid chromatography for specific recognition. A preliminary investigation of the imprinting properties of eleven MIPs was carried out, by comparing the retention time of the template and of structurally related compounds on the MIP column with that on the corresponding non-imprinted polymer (NIP). The two polymers showing the best performance were selected to further test cotinine, mycophenolic acid, testosterone and their respective glucuronides as model compounds. The high specificity obtained against glucuronides and the different chemical structure of the parent drug make the two MIPs class-selective imprinted receptors, also suitable for SPE application.

Chromatographic characterisation, under highly aqueous conditions, of a molecularly imprinted polymer binding the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid.

The affinity of a 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) molecularly imprinted polymer (MIP), which was synthesised directly in an aqueous organic solvent, for its template (2,4-D) was studied and compared with the affinity exhibited by two other reference (control) polymers, NIPA and NIPB, for the same analyte. Zonal chromatography was performed to establish the optimal selectivity, expressed as imprinting factor (IF), under chromatographic conditions more aqueous than those described so far in the literature. Frontal analysis (FA) was performed on columns packed with these polymers, using an optimized mobile phase composed of methanol/phosphate buffer (50/50, v/v), to extract adsorption isotherm data and retrieve binding parameters from the best isotherm model. Surprisingly, the template had comparable and strong affinity for both MIP (K = 3.8x10(4) M(-1)) and NIPA (K = 1.9x10(4) M(-1)), although there was a marked difference in the saturation capacities of selective and non-selective sites, as one would expect for an imprinted polymer. NIPB acts as a true control polymer in the sense that it has relatively low affinity for the template (K = 8.0x10(2) M(-1)). This work provides the first frontal chromatographic characterization of such a polymer in a water-rich environment over a wide concentration range. The significance of this work stems from the fact that the chromatographic approach used is generic and can be applied readily to other analytes, but also because there is an increasing demand for well-characterised imprinted materials that function effectively in aqueous media and are thus well-suited for analytical science applications involving, for example, biofluids and environmental water samples.

Validation of a RP-LC method for the simultaneous determination of isoniazid, pyrazinamide and rifampicin in a pharmaceutical formulation.

A simple and accurate liquid chromatographic method was developed and validated for estimation of isoniazid (ISN), pyrazinamide (PYR) and rifampicin (RIF) in combined dosage forms. Drugs were chromatographed on a reverse phase C18 column using a mobile phase gradient and monitored at the corresponding maximum of each compounds. Peaks were identified with retention time as compared with standards and confirmed with characteristic spectra using diode-array detector. Solution concentrations were measured on a weight basis to avoid the use of an internal standard. The method does not require any specific sample preparation except the use of a guard column. The method is linear (r(2)>0.999), precise (RSD%: 0.50% for ISN, 0.12% for PYR and 0.98% for RIF), accurate (overall average recovery yields: 98.55% for ISN, 98.51 for PYR and 98.56% for RIF) and selective. Due to its simplicity and accuracy the method is suitable for routine quality control analysis of antitubercolosis combination dosage form.

A partially structured species of beta 2-microglobulin is significantly populated under physiological conditions and involved in fibrillogenesis.

The folding of beta(2)-microglobulin (beta(2)-m), the protein forming amyloid deposits in dialysis-related amyloidosis, involves formation of a partially folded conformation named I(2), which slowly converts into the native fold, N. Here we show that the partially folded species I(2) can be separated from N by capillary electrophoresis. Data obtained with this technique and analysis of kinetic data obtained with intrinsic fluorescence indicate that the I(2) conformation is populated to approximately 14 +/- 8% at equilibrium under conditions of pH and temperature close to physiological. In the presence of fibrils extracted from patients, the I(2) conformer has a 5-fold higher propensity to aggregate than N, as indicated by the thioflavine T test and light scattering measurements. A mechanism of aggregation of beta(2)-m in vivo involving the association of the preformed fibrils with the fraction of I(2) existing at equilibrium is proposed from these results. The possibility of isolating and quantifying a partially folded conformer of beta(2)-m involved in the amyloidogenesis process provides new opportunities to monitor hemodialytic procedures aimed at the reduction of such species from the pool of circulating beta(2)-m but also to design new pharmaceutical approaches that consider such species as a putative molecular target.

Target analogue imprinted polymers with affinity for folic acid and related compounds.

Two approaches to synthesize molecularly imprinted polymers with affinity for folic acid and other substituted pteridines have been compared. In the first approach, the folic acid analogue methotrexate was used as template and functional monomers capable of generating selective binding sites were searched in a miniaturized screening system based on binding assessment in the batch mode. Highest selectivity was seen using 2-vinylpyridine as functional monomer, which was confirmed in the chromatographic mode for a batch synthesized on a gram scale. However, the retentivity and selectivity of this phase were insufficient for anticipated applications. In a second approach, using methacrylic acid as the functional monomer, organic soluble inhibitors for the enzyme dihydrofolate reductase were used to develop sites complementary toward the pteridine substructure. This resulted in materials showing enhanced selectivity for substituted pteridines when evaluated by HPLC. Thus, methotrexate and leucovorine were selectively retained in mobile phases of either low or high aqueous content, thus showing the typical bimodal retention behavior of previously reported MIPs. In organic mobile-phase systems, the inhibitor used as template had an influence on the retentivity and selectivity of the MIP. The polymer imprinted with trimethoprim retained all folic acid analogues strongly and showed the highest selectivity among the MIPs in an organic mobile-phase system. This was supported by Scatchard analysis resulting in biphasic plots and a quantitative yield of high-energy binding sites. All templates were shown to associate strongly with MAA in CDCl(3), the strength of association correlating roughly with the template basicity and the selectivity observed in chromatography. Nonparallel complexation-induced shifts indicated formation of 1:2 template monomer complexes at concentrations corresponding to those of the prepolymerization solutions.

Immobilized penicillin G acylase as reactor and chiral selector in liquid chromatography.

In this paper, the use of penicillin G acylase (PGA) as a biocatalyst and as a chiral selector is described. Penicillin G-acylase is an interesting enzyme used in the manufacture of semisynthetic antibiotics and, in particular, in the production of 6-APA by hydrolysis of penicillin G. Five PGA-based HPLC columns have been prepared by using two different silica supports by employing two immobilization methods, namely "in situ" and "in batch". The effects of the immobilization techniques and of different silica pore size on the catalytic properties of the enzyme as well as the applicability of the PGA-bonded stationary phases as chiral selectors for a number of chiral drugs have been investigated. The HPLC columns based on immobilized PGA combine the hydrolytic activity and the chiral recognition properties of PGA, therefore they have been used for the development of a combined reaction-separation system for chiral and achiral substrates.

Chiral capillary electrophoresis and nuclear magnetic resonance investigation on the structure-enantioselectivity relationship in synthetic cyclopeptides as chiral selectors.

In the present work, synthetic cyclohexa- and cycloheptapeptides previously singled out by a combinatorial chemistry approach have been evaluated as chiral selectors in capillary electrophoresis. By applying the countercurrent migration technique and employing a new adsorbed coating, a series of dinitrophenyl amino acids as well as some chiral compounds of pharmaceutical interest have been evaluated for enantiorecognition. The results thus obtained led to a deeper investigation of the chiral discrimination process, by carrying out nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies on selected cyclopeptide-analyte complexes. These studies shed light on the chemical groups involved in the analyte-selector interaction and provided useful information for a wider application of these cyclopeptides in the separation of other drug enantiomers.

Properties of a stationary phase based on immobilised chicken liver basic fatty acid-binding protein.

The fatty acid-binding proteins (FABPs) are a class of low-molecular-mass proteins that bind fatty acids and are thought to be involved in their intracellular transport. FABPs have been isolated and studied from several tissues, but their precise function and mechanism of action are still not clear. Chicken liver (basic) fatty acid-binding protein (bFABP) was immobilised on aminopropyl silica and the developed stationary phase was used to examine the enantioselective properties of this protein and to study the binding of drugs to bFABP. The retention and enantioselectivity of the new column for a large number of chiral drugs was investigated. The enantiomers of basic and neutral compounds were poorly retained and not resolved by the bFABP column. On the contrary the resolution of the enantiomers of some acidic compounds was obtained. Therefore the influence of the mobile phase pH and organic modifier on the chromatographic performance of acidic compounds was studied. In order to clarify the retention mechanism, competitive displacement studies were also carried out by adding short-chain fatty acids to the mobile phase as displacing agents and preliminary quantitative structure-retention relationship correlations were developed to describe the nature of the interactions between the chemical structures of the analytes and the observed chromatographic results.

Affinity capillary electrophoresis is a powerful tool to identify transthyretin binding drugs for potential therapeutic use in amyloidosis.

In this work we used affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE) to investigate the extent of interaction between a pool of drugs and wild-type transthyretin. After qualitative preliminary screening, attention was focused on the most promising molecules, flufenamic acid and flurbiprofen, which underwent a further stage of investigation, the determination of the binding constants, and, when possible, the assessment of the number of binding sites by ACE, frontal analysis (FA) capillary electrophoresis (CE) and parallel ultrafiltration (UF) experiments. Furthermore, our data demonstrate that FA CE is a suitable technique for identifying fibril ligands. This represents a novel CE application of pharmaceutical interest.

Evaluation of new adsorbed coatings in chiral capillary electrophoresis and the partial filling technique.

When using chiral selectors and the partial filling technique in capillary electrophoresis, a suitable and reproducible suppression of the electroosmotic flow is still a challenging issue, and there are a number of reasons to find alternatives to the use of covalently coated capillaries for such a particular application. In this paper, new achiral, neutral, and water-soluble polymers are evaluated as adsorbed polymers for the suppression of electroosmotic flow (EOF) when employing chiral capillary electrophoresis and the partial filling technique. Four chiral selectors, namely a cationic cyclopeptide, vancomycin, human serum albumin and riboflavin binding protein have been chosen for this study and some analytes such as derivatized amino acids, promethazine and prilocaine have been used as test compounds. Reproducibility of migration times, resolution, and selectivity as well as efficiency are reported to critically evaluate the performance of the adsorbed coatings. Results are compared to parallel data obtained with fused-silica and polyvinyl alcohol-coated capillaries.

Chromatographic investigation on the binding site characteristics of quail egg-white riboflavin binding protein as a chiral stationary phase.

Recently we described the use of riboflavin binding protein extracted from quail egg-white, as a new HPLC chiral stationary phase. In this study we show the further results obtained with the use of high-performance affinity chromatography to provide a better understanding of the chiral recognition mechanism for the observed enantioselectivity and to gain a deeper knowledge into the binding site that has been recently characterised by X-ray crystallography for chicken egg-white. High-performance affinity chromatography provides information on the potential protein structural changes occurring upon its immobilisation and enables competitive binding studies as well as the assessment of binding constants through frontal analysis experiments.

The impact of capillary electrophoresis in drug analysis and bioanalysis.

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) has penetrated a wide variety of areas of separation science during the last ten years. The relative strengths and weaknesses of this technique are here overviewed, by citing the most recent literature and updated Medline search, keeping an eye on technology news, as technology and the development of CE and its applicability progress in parallel. The issues discussed include micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC), which permits non-ionic solutes to be solubilized and separated. Enantioselective applications in CE exploit addition to the run buffer of cyclodextrins, macrocyclic antibiotics and proteins for analysis of chiral drugs and the state of the art of this field will be emphasized. CE has significant potential for drug metabolism studies, especially coupled with MS for high sensitivity detection and structural characterisation. Strategies for the analysis of drugs and metabolites in body fluids include on-capillary methods of sample concentration and single-step analyses with direct injection of body fluids on-column, where detection techniques other than conventional UV are essential to achieve adequate sensitivity. The potential contribution of the hybrid technique of capillary electrochromatography (CEC), which couples the separating power of reversed-phase HPLC and the high efficiency of CE, has recently attracted growing interest and is therefore discussed. Finally, validation issues which are peculiar to CE are illustrated.

Evaluation of quail egg white riboflavin binding protein as a chiral selector in capillary electrophoresis by applying a modified partial filling technique.

A preliminary evaluation of the enantioselective properties of quail egg yolk riboflavin binding protein (qRfBP) was carried out in capillary electrophoresis by using the complete filling technique. The most promising results obtained by this screening of nineteen chiral drugs were singled out with the aim of optimizing enantiomer separations by applying the partial filling technique, which allows operating at much higher protein concentrations without detection problems. The building of the separation zone in the partial filling technique has been modified in order to enable on-line monitoring, before each run, of the actual protein plug application velocity and, consequently, the building of a plug of the desired length. The electrophoretic conditions chosen gave opposite migration directions for the chiral selector and the analytes, with qRfBP migrating away from the detector. A polyvinyl alcohol-coated capillary was first totally filled with protein and the optimal plug length was obtained by further applying negative pressure together with positive voltage for the time needed. Separations of basic drugs were optimized by using protein concentrations ranging from 200 microM up to 900 microM and different plug lengths, while the running buffer pH (6.0), temperature (25 degrees C) and operating voltage (+20 kV) were kept constant. The enantioresolution of all solutes was affected by both the chiral selector concentration and protein plug length. Baseline separations were obtained for oxprenolol, prilocaine and bupivacaine.

Riboflavin binding proteins as chiral selectors in HPLC and CE.

The term riboflavin binding proteins (RfBPs) is applied to several molecular species that play the important role of vitamin delivery to the developing embryo, thus becoming essential for the survival of the fetus. In addition to this physiological significance, these proteins have recently been found to be successful chiral selectors. In this review, the authors address the use of such proteins, both as columns for high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and as additives in capillary electrophoresis (CE), for the enantioseparation of several racemic drugs.

Evaluation of beta-lactoglobulin as a stationary phase in high-performance liquid chromatography and as a buffer additive in capillary electrophoresis: observation of a surprising lack of stereoselectivity.

Previous studies have reported that alpha1-acid glycoprotein is quite similar in amino acid sequence and disulfide bond arrangements to members of a group of proteins which include beta-lactoglobulin (BLG). Since generally homologous proteins retain some similarity in function at the molecular level, we decided to evaluate the enantioselective properties of BLG as an high-performance liquid chromatographic chiral stationary phase (HPLC-CSP), and as an additive in capillary electrophoresis (CE). Two columns with differences in internal diameter and method of immobilisation on epoxide silica were prepared. Chiral acidic, basic and uncharged drugs were chromatographed and mobile phase parameters, namely pH and type of organic modifier, were varied in order to test the column performance. The CE approach has some advantages in that there is no need for immobilisation and only a small amount of protein is required. BLG was therefore tested as a CE buffer additive, using the same analytes as in the HPLC study. Although one would expect that a protein would display some enantioselectivity, BLG did not show any enantioselectivity whatsoever in either system; the protein has fairly weak interaction with the majority of the test solutes, as indicated by both techniques.

Selectivity in capillary electrophoresis: the use of proteins.

Proteins, by their very diverse nature, provide a wide variety of options for generating selectivity in capillary electrophoresis (CE). Their use in different modes of CE will be considered in this review. Proteins added in solution to the background electrolyte allow separations to be made in a similar fashion to other electrokinetic chromatography methods, e.g., micellar separations. Alternatively, different immobilization schemes can be used to secure proteins within the capillary; these have included capillary electrochromatography with the protein grafted onto a silica support, or immobilization of the protein within a gel structure. Compounds varying in size from small inorganic ions to biopolymers may be bound by proteins. There is the potential for any sort of intermolecular interaction to play a role in the binding process (e.g., hydrophobic interactions, electrostatic interactions, etc.). Very specific high-affinity binding often occurs, but also there is often weaker, non-selective binding. Frequently the interactions of chiral compounds with proteins are stereoselective. Obtaining chiral selectivity has been one of the main applications of protein selectors in CE, and this use will be emphasized here in a discussion structured by type of protein. As well as utilizing the selectivity of proteins to develop separations, the role of CE in investigating ligand-protein interactions will be emphasized.

Comparison of drug binding sites on rat and human serum albumins using immobilized-protein stationary phases as a tool for the selection of suitable animal models in pharmacological studies.

Immobilized serum albumins (rat and human) HPLC stationary phases have been used to investigate and to compare the binding sites of a number of analytes of pharmaceutical interest assessing the retention time as the chromatographic parameter which correlates the percentage of drug-binding of the corresponding free protein. Anti-inflammatory drugs with different molecular structure were chromatographed and the k' values were determined with a mobile phase based on 100 mM sodium phosphate buffer (pH 6.9) containing 6% n-propanol (v/v). The effect of the addition to the mobile phase of octanoic, decanoic and dodecanoic acids on the k' values enabled to elucidate the site of interaction between the solutes and the two albumins. The results indicate that there are some structural differences in the binding sites of the two albumins and also some quantitative differences with respect to the extent of drug-binding. Moreover the different stereoselective behaviour of the two albumins was studied by analysing some chiral anti-inflammatory drugs much as aryl-propionic acids.

Design of chiral LC separations for calcium antagonists on alpha 1-acid glycoprotein and ovomucoid columns.

Three chiral calcium antagonist drugs, gallopamil and two dihydropyridine derivatives, have been successfully separated within short retention times using both the alpha 1-acid glycoprotein chiral stationary phase (Chiral-AGP) and the ovomucoid column (Ultron ES-OVM). Aqueous buffer at defined pH is modified by the addition of an organic component, in order to modulate the retention properties of each system. Optimization of pH and organic modifier is carried out using the modified simplex method, with Kaiser's peak separation function as a criterion. The influence of pH and percentage of organic modifier on retention, selectivity, resolution and column performance are discussed for the two dihydropyridines analysed on Chiral-AGP and Ultron ES-OVM stationary phases. A new method is proposed as a new chiral system suitability test for these protein-based phases, utilizing a racemic mixture of closely eluting verapamil enantiomers as a probe.

High-performance liquid chromatographic determination of alpha-tocopheryl nicotinate in cosmetic preparations.

alpha-Tocopheryl nicotinate (alpha-TN) accelerates blood circulation and stimulates hair follicle cells, hence it is an active ingredient in a broad range of cosmetic products. A reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatographic method was developed to determine alpha-TN in cosmetic preparations with alpha-tocopheryl acetate as internal standard. The method was found to be rapid, precise and specific.