Weakly Internalized Receptors Use Coated Vesicle Heterogeneity to Evade Competition during Endocytosis.

The uptake of receptors by clathrin-mediated endocytosis underlies signaling, nutrient import, and recycling of transmembrane proteins and lipids. In the complex, crowded environment of the plasma membrane, receptors are internalized when they bind to components of the clathrin coat, such as the major adaptor protein, AP2. Receptors with higher affinity for AP2 are known to be more strongly internalized compared to receptors with lower affinity. However, it remains unclear how receptors with different affinities compete for space within crowded endocytic structures. To address this question, we constructed receptors with varying affinities for AP2 and allowed them to compete against one another during internalization. As expected, the internalization of a receptor with high affinity for AP2 was reduced when it was coexpressed with a competing receptor of similar affinity. However, receptors of low affinity for AP2 were surprisingly difficult to displace from endocytic structures, even when expressed alongside receptors with much higher affinity. To understand how these low-affinity receptors are protected from competition, we looked at AP2 heterogeneity across clathrin-coated structures. When we examined structures with lower-than-average AP2 content, we found that they were relatively enriched in cargo of low affinity for AP2 and depleted of cargo with high affinity. These findings suggest that the heterogeneity of adaptor protein content across the population of endocytic structures enables the internalization of diverse receptors. Given the critical role that internalization plays in signaling, this effect may help to prevent strongly internalized receptors from interfering with the cell's ability to process signals from weakly internalized receptors.

Molecular thermodynamics of receptor competition for endocytic uptake.

Endocytic uptake of receptors from the cell surface plays an important role in diverse processes from cell signaling to nutrient internalization. Understanding the mechanisms by which endocytic structures select receptors for internalization is of fundamental importance to our understanding of cellular physiology. Binding of receptors to the endocytic protein machinery is known to facilitate receptor loading into endocytic structures. However, many receptor species use the same small set of biochemical motifs to interact with the endocytic machinery, suggesting that receptors may compete for a limited number of binding sites within endocytic structures. Previous studies have shown that such competition can substantially modify receptor uptake. However, a predictive biophysical understanding of this phenomenon is currently lacking. Toward addressing this gap, here we employ quantitative imaging and statistical thermodynamics to measure and predict the competition between two distinct receptor species that are internalized simultaneously from the cell surface. Our studies demonstrate that when receptors compete for the same interactions with the endocytic machinery, their uptake is fundamentally coupled. Importantly, we find that these trends can be quantitatively predicted by a simple thermodynamic analysis. These results suggest that multiple receptor species reach an equilibrium partitioning between endocytic structures and the surrounding plasma membrane as the receptors compete for occupancy within dynamic endocytic structures. More broadly, this work provides a quantitative framework for predicting the impact of competition on receptor uptake, an effect which has the potential to physically couple signaling pathways that impact diverse aspects of cellular physiology.

Receptor Heterodimerization Modulates Endocytosis through Collaborative and Competitive Mechanisms.

Recruitment of receptors into clathrin-coated structures is essential to signal transduction and nutrient uptake. Among the many receptors involved in these processes, a significant fraction forms dimers. Dimerization of identical partners has generally been thought to promote receptor recruitment for uptake because of increased affinity of the dimer for the endocytic machinery. But what happens when receptors with substantially different affinities for the endocytic machinery come together to form a heterodimer? Evidence from diverse receptor classes, including G-protein-coupled receptors and receptor tyrosine kinases, suggests that heterodimerization with a strongly recruited receptor can drive significant recruitment of a receptor that lacks direct interactions with the endocytic machinery. However, a systematic biophysical understanding of this effect has yet to be established. Motivated by the potential of such events to influence cell signaling, here, we investigate the impact of receptor heterodimerization on endocytic recruitment using a family of engineered model receptors. As expected, we find that dimerization of a weakly recruited receptor with a strongly recruited receptor promotes incorporation of the weakly recruited receptor to endocytic structures. However, the effectiveness of this collaborative mechanism depends heavily on the relative strengths of endocytic recruitment of the two receptors that make up the dimer. Specifically, as the strength of endocytic recruitment of the weakly recruited receptor approaches that of the strongly recruited receptor, monomers of each receptor compete with heterodimers for space within endocytic structures. In this regime, the presence of the strongly recruited receptor drives a reduction in incorporation of the weakly recruited receptor into clathrin-coated structures. Similarly, as the strength of the dimer bond between the two receptors is progressively weakened, competition begins to dominate over collaboration. Collectively, these results demonstrate that the impact of receptor heterodimerization on endocytic recruitment is controlled by a delicate balance between collaborative and competitive mechanisms.

Synergy between intrinsically disordered domains and structured proteins amplifies membrane curvature sensing.

The ability of proteins to sense membrane curvature is essential to cellular function. All known sensing mechanisms rely on protein domains with specific structural features such as wedge-like amphipathic helices and crescent-shaped BAR domains. Yet many proteins that contain these domains also contain large intrinsically disordered regions. Here we report that disordered domains are themselves potent sensors of membrane curvature. Comparison of Monte Carlo simulations with in vitro and live-cell measurements demonstrates that the polymer-like behavior of disordered domains found in endocytic proteins drives them to partition preferentially to convex membrane surfaces, which place fewer geometric constraints on their conformational entropy. Further, proteins containing both structured curvature sensors and disordered regions are more than twice as curvature sensitive as their respective structured domains alone. These findings demonstrate an entropic mechanism of curvature sensing that is independent of protein structure and illustrate how structured and disordered domains can synergistically enhance curvature sensitivity.

Entropic Control of Receptor Recycling Using Engineered Ligands.

Receptor internalization by endocytosis regulates diverse cellular processes, from the rate of nutrient uptake to the timescale of essential signaling events. The established view is that internalization is tightly controlled by specific protein-binding interactions. However, recent work suggests that physical aspects of receptors influence the process in ways that cannot be explained by biochemistry alone. Specifically, work from several groups suggests that increasing the steric bulk of receptors may inhibit their uptake by multiple types of trafficking vesicles. How do biochemical and biophysical factors work together to control internalization? Here, we show that receptor uptake is well described by a thermodynamic trade-off between receptor-vesicle binding energy and the entropic cost of confining receptors within endocytic vesicles. Specifically, using large ligands to acutely increase the size of engineered variants of the transferrin receptor, we demonstrate that an increase in the steric bulk of a receptor dramatically decreases its probability of uptake by clathrin-coated structures. Further, in agreement with a simple thermodynamic analysis, all data collapse onto a single trend relating fractional occupancy of the endocytic structure to fractional occupancy of the surrounding plasma membrane, independent of receptor size. This fundamental scaling law provides a simple tool for predicting the impact of receptor expression level, steric bulk, and the size of endocytic structures on receptor uptake. More broadly, this work suggests that bulky ligands could be used to drive the accumulation of specific receptors at the plasma membrane surface, providing a biophysical tool for targeted modulation of signaling and metabolism from outside the cell.