The Global Contributions of Working Equids to Sustainable Agriculture and Livelihoods in Agenda 2030.

Small farmers produce most food in low- and middle-income countries and most small farmers rely on directly or indirectly working equids (WE). The lack of methods and metrics for assessing the role of WE hampers realisation of WE contributions. Based on literature review and a survey of WE welfare experts, we propose a framework for optimising WE potential based on two axes of sustainable development goals (SDGs) and value chains. WE contribute especially to earning and sparing income (largely in food production) (SDG 1), but also have roles in accessing health and hygiene services and products (SDG 3 and 5), providing edible products (SDG 2), and benefiting women (SDG 6), with lesser contributions to other SDGs, notably climate action (SDG 13). Experts identified barriers to appropriate appreciation of WE contributions, in order to target actions to overcome them. They found WE are neglected because they belong to farmers who are themselves neglected; because information on WE is inadequate; and, because the unique nature and roles of WE means systems, policies, investors, markets and service providers struggle to cater for them. Harnessing WE to optimally contribute to sustainable development will require generating better evidence on their contributions to SDGs, ensuring better integration into ongoing efforts to attain SDGs, and building the WE capacity among development actors.

Multiple host feeding in Glossina palpalis gambiensis and Glossina tachinoides in southeast Mali.

Changes in agricultural practices and the resulting extinction of wildlife have led to the reduction or disappearance of savannah tsetse species. Riparian tsetse such as Glossina palpalis gambiensis Vanderplank 1949 and Glossina tachinoides Westwood 1850 (Diptera: Glossinidae) continue to persist in peridomestic sites, transmitting trypanosomiasis. At present, little is known about interspecies differences in feeding behaviour in these two species in southeast Mali, or of the phenomenon of multiple bloodmeals. To study these topics, 279 samples of G. p. gambiensis and G. tachinoides containing host DNA, caught in the Sikasso region between November 2008 and April 2009, were analysed by applying host species-specific primers and sequencing. Human accounted for > 66% of G. p. gambiensis bloodmeals, whereas G. tachinoides contained in equal parts DNA of human, cattle or both, showing a significantly higher proportion of multiple host use. Further, the trypanosome infection rate was found to be three-fold higher in G. tachinoides. Logistic regression analysis revealed double-feeding and infection to be independent of one another, but showed infection to be correlated with engorgement in G. p. gambiensis and female sex in G. tachinoides. Enhanced host-seeking activities paired with the high trypanosome infection rate found in G. tachinoides would indicate that this species has a higher vectorial capacity than G. p. gambiensis.

Preventing and containing trypanocide resistance in the cotton zone of West Africa.

Trypanocidal drugs are the most commonly purchased and used livestock input by resource-poor farmers in sub-Saharan Africa. The effective use of trypanocidal drugs by smallholder farmers is threatened by the development of widespread resistance. This is a particular concern for smallholder crop-livestock farmers in the cotton zone of West Africa. A recent project funded by the Germany Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ) confirmed significant resistance to trypanocidal drugs in villages with high trypanosomosis risk in Burkina Faso and Mali. Strategies for resistance prevention were investigated. Keeping trypanotolerant cattle was found to be an effective disease management strategy, but farmers' preference for trypano-susceptible breeds, for reasons unrelated to animal health, suggest that the intromission of zebu genotype will continue. Community vector control was found to be effective in managing trypanosomosis in the presence of resistance and the high-level participatory approach tested was found to be more sustainable than low-level approaches previously used in the region. This suggests that participatory vector control with appropriate external support is likely to be a viable option for implementing resistance 'clean-up'. Promoting rational drug use (RDU) emerged as a promising prevention strategy, with clear improvements in farmer knowledge, farmer practice and animal health outcomes. However, policy studies showed low understanding of the problem of resistance and the absence of an enabling environment for RDU. Engagement was initiated with actors involved in the problem of resistance and for its solution, including manufacturers, sellers and users of drugs, regulators and extension providers.

African bovine trypanosomiasis: the problem of drug resistance.

The three trypanocides used to control tsetse-transmitted trypanosomiasis in domestic animals in Africa have been in use for over 40 years and, not surprisingly, resistance of trypanosomes to these drugs has emerged. Because of the relatively limited market in Africa and the high costs of developing and licensing new drugs, international pharmaceutical companies have shown little interest in the development of new trypanocides for use in either animals or humans. Therefore, the current challenge is to achieve optimal use of the relatively old existing drugs, and it is in this context that the problem of drug resistance has to be quantified--as discussed here by Stanny Geerts, Peter Holmes, Oumar Diall and Mark Eisler.

Extension of the prophylactic effect of isometamidium against trypanosome infections in cattle using a biodegradable copolymer.

Two trials were carried out in order to compare the prophylactic effect of a subcutaneously implanted sustained release device (SRD) containing a mixture of a biodegradable copolymer, poly(caprolactone-co-L-lactide), and isometamidium (ISMM) with that obtained after intramuscular injection of the drug. In a first experiment under controlled conditions, two groups of cattle were treated with 0.5 mg/kg isometamidium either as a SRD or intramuscularly (i.m.), and exposed at monthly intervals to Glossina morsitans morsitans infected with Trypanosoma congolense. The average protection period was at least 24 months in the SRD treated against 5.7 months in the i.m. treated group. Using an ISMM enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, the drug could be detected until 140 days post-treatment in the latter group, whereas in the former group, traces of the drug were detectable until 330 days after treatment. Furthermore, a field trial was carried out at the Madina Diassa ranch in Mali involving three groups of N'Dama cattle, each containing 23 or 24 animals. Two groups were treated with 1 mg/kg ISMM either as a SRD or i.m. and a third group served as untreated control. Twelve months after treatment, the cumulative infection rates were 56.5, 87.8 and 91.6% in the SRD implanted, the i.m. treated and the control groups, respectively. The ISMM concentrations were slightly lower than in the laboratory trial, but the overall pattern of drug disappearance from the sera of the SRD treated cattle was very similar in both trials. Statistical analysis showed that the incidence of trypanosomiasis was significantly lower in the SRD treated than in the i.m. treated group.

Biodegradable polyesters for controlled release of trypanocidal drugs: in vitro and in vivo studies.

Copolymers of epsilon-caprolactone and L-lactide P(CL-LLA), epsilon-caprolactone and D,L-lactide P(CL-DLLA) and epsilon-caprolactone and trimethylene carbonate P(CL-TMC) were synthesized. The composition of comonomers and their sequence lengths were determined by means of 1H and 13C NMR measurements. The effect of the comonomer on the thermal properties was investigated by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) analysis. The in vitro degradation of the rods obtained by melt extrusion of the synthesized copolymers and the commercial homopolymers poly(epsilon-caprolactone) P(CL) and poly(D,L-lactide) P(DLLA) was carried out in phosphate buffer (PB) pH 7.4 at 37 degrees C. The rate of degradation depends on comonomers and polymer composition. The in vitro release of the selected drugs, isometamidium chloride (IMM) and ethidium bromide (EtBr), from such devices was carried out under the same conditions as used for the in vitro degradation. The release experiments show that the release of IMM is faster than for EtBr. During the first stage, for IMM the release is governed by osmotic pressure whereas for EtBr the release is mainly diffusion-controlled. The in vitro release of these drugs is governed by polymer matrix degradation at the later stage of the release process. Comparative in vitro release study from the different polymers showed that the release depends mainly on the physical properties of the polymer. The in vivo experiments carried out in the field on cattle and in the laboratory on rabbits using the classical treatment (intramuscular injection) and the sustained release devices (SRD) subcutaneously implanted, showed that the prophylactic period is significantly enhanced in the case of SRD as compared to intramuscular injection. The comparative efficacy of SRD containing IMM and EtBr evaluated in the case of rabbits showed that, the SRD (IMM) prophylactic period is much longer than for SRD (EtBr).

Field evaluation of the prophylactic effect of an isometamidium sustained-release device against trypanosomiasis in cattle.

In order to compare the prophylactic effect provided by a poly(D,L-lactide) sustained-release device (SRD) containing isometamidium (ISMM) with that provided by the classical intramuscular injection of the drug, a field trial was carried out at the Madina Diassa Ranch in Mali. One- to 3-year-old N'Dama cattle were randomly divided into three groups. The first group (n = 42) was treated with ISMM at a dose of 1 mg/kg of body weight, the second group (n = 44) received the same dose of the drug via an SRD, which was subcutaneously implanted in the shoulder region, and the third group (n = 36) was kept as an untreated control group. All animals were treated with diminazene aceturate (7 mg/kg of body weight) 2 weeks before the start of the experiment and were tested monthly by the buffy coat technique for a period of 8 months. Glossina morsitans submorsitans was the most important tsetse species, with apparent densities (number of catches/trap/day) varying between 11.9 and 38.7 over the experimental period. Eight months after treatment the cumulative infection rates were 27.7, 58.5, and 77.4% in the group with the SRD implant, the group receiving the intramuscular injection, and the control group, respectively. Statistical analysis showed that the incidence of trypanosomiasis was significantly lower (P = 0.006) in the group which received ISMM via the SRD than in the one which was treated with ISMM intramuscularly.

[Evaluation of a direct serologic card agglutination test for the diagnosis of camel trypanosomiasis caused by Trypanosoma evansi]. / Evaluation d'un test sérologique d'agglutination directe sur carte dans le diagnostic de la trypanosomose caméline à Trypanosoma evansi.

The results of a novel direct serological card agglutination test for the diagnosis of camel trypanosomosis due to Trypanosoma evansi (CATT/T. evansi) were compared with those obtained by direct detection of parasites in a study using 1,093 sera from camels raised in northern Mali. A good correlation was revealed between the percentage of positive results obtained by CATT and the presence of trypanosomes (89%), as well as a good coincidence between the percentage of positive results obtained by CATT and low haematocrit values (packed cell volume). CATT revealed a global serological prevalence of 30.6%, whereas trypanosomes were found in only 5.85% of the corresponding animals. CATT/T. evansi is a quick and easy-to-read test, which merits further evaluation in camel-rearing countries.

[Epidemiology of trypanosomiasis caused by T. evansi in camels in mali: results of parasitological and clinical survey]. / Epidémiologie de la trypanosomose à T. evansi chez le dromadaire au Mali: résultats d'enquêtes parasitologiques et cliniques.

An epidemiological study of trypanosomiasis was conducted in the rearing areas of dromedary camels in Mali. According to the parasitological and clinical surveys performed, the overall infection rates were 9.5% (29/305) in Western Sahel (region I) and 4.5% (28/627) in the areas of Tombouctou and Gao (region II). The proportion of contaminated herds was 55% in region I and 68% in region II and in some herds the infection rate exceeded 50%. The surveys showed a trend for increasing parasitological prevalence with age. While it was almost nonexistent in young camels less than one year old, it increased with age and reached a maximum in 2 to 5-year old camels. The authors showed that the infection has a significantly negative effect on PCV and on the overall status of the animals, confirming the pathogenicity of Trypanosoma evansi in dromedary camels. This trypanosome is almost the only species detected in the dromedary camel in Mali and it does not seem to cause infections in other animals reared in the same environment.

Evaluation of mono- and polyclonal antibody-based antigen detection immunoassays for diagnosis of Trypanosoma evansi infection in the dromedary camel.

Two enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA), one based on a mouse anti-Trypanosoma brucei group-specific monoclonal antibody and the other on rabbit anti-Trypanosoma evansi polyclonal antibodies, have been evaluated for their ability to detect circulating trypanosome antigens in camel sera as a means for the diagnosis of T. evansi infections. All 91 sera from a negative control camel herd from Kenya gave negative antigen-ELISA results in the monoclonal antibody-based ELISA and only 2 of them (2.2%) gave false positive results in the polyclonal antibody-based ELISA. In subsequent analyses of sera from infected camels (as determined by mouse inoculation), the monoclonal antibody-based ELISA detected antigens in 90 (83.3%) out of the 108 sera tested. This percentage was lower for the polyclonal antibody-based ELISA which was able to detect antigens in 67 (60.9%) out of the 110 sera tested. The two tests detected probably different antigens and when the results were combined, 99 out of 107 (92.5%) sera were shown to be ELISA positive. In a survey involving 316 camels from the Gao and Nara areas, in Mali, a high proportion of animals tested were antigen positive (43.5 and 42.9%, respectively for the mono- and polyclonal antibody-based ELISA) compared to only 22 (7.0%) diagnosed by the parasite detection techniques. Thus, these immunoassays were at least six times more sensitive than the haematocrit centrifugation technique. As a large proportion of cases may be antigen positive but parasite negative, these two of "surra" immunoassays should be used in routine diagnosis in addition to the parasite detection techniques in the dromedary camel.

[Trypanosomiasis and trypanocidal treatments in Ndama calves in a glossina infected area (the ranch of Madina-Diassa in Mali)]. / Trypanosomose et traitements trypanocides chez le veau Ndama en milieu fortement infesté de glossines (ranch de Madina-Diassa au Mali).

This work aims at contributing to the knowledge of trypanosomiasis epidemiology in calves of trypanotolerant breeds and at defining an appropriate treatment to improve the survival of such calves in a tsetse infested area. The first study was a parasitological survey of 100 calves from the day of birth to the age of one year. According to the results of this survey, the period from birth to three months is a "critical" moment in the life of the calves, due to a high infection rate and mortality related to trypanosomiasis. The purpose of the second study was to investigate the possible interference of early trypanocidal treatments with the further expression of trypanotolerance. For this purpose three groups of over one-year old animals were established. The groups had different trypanosomiasis history due to the different treatments they had undergone during their first year of life. All the animals had been exposed to trypanosomiasis without treatment and followed up parasitologically and clinically during the second year. The results showed no interference of early trypanocidal treatments (including preventive ones) with the expression of resistance in potentially trypanotolerant animals.

Two simple antigen-detection enzyme immunoassays for the diagnosis of Trypanosoma evansi infections in the dromedary camel (Camelus dromedarius).

A monoclonal antibody against a plasma membrane antigen of Trypanosoma rhodesiense was used in a microplate- and a tube-ELISA for the detection of T. evansi circulating antigen in camel sera from endemic areas in Mali and Kenya. The colour reactions could be read visually and the results obtained for both assays were identical. The sera from the control herd of 30 camels from a farm in a non-endemic area in Kenya were all negative for antigen, while 18 out of 20 sera from infected camels in an endemic area in Kenya and 16 out of 17 parasitaemic camels from a different endemic area in Mali were antigen-positive. More importantly, the antigen-detection assay gave positive results with 9 out of 20 and 13 out of 20 field sera from the two endemic areas in Kenya and Mali, respectively, collected from camels which had negative parasitological findings. The ease with which the tube-ELISA can be carried out makes it a potentially suitable tool for the diagnosis of T. evansi infections in the field.

Serological prevalence of bovine babesiosis in Mali.

A serological survey of cattle in Mali was carried out to determine the prevalence of antibody activity to Babesia bovis and B. bigemina. It was found that the level of B. bovis infection as indicated by antibody activities was too low to be of immediate concern. However, the serological prevalence of B. bigemina was high and this may indicate a potential disease problem. It was also found that when zebu and N'Dama cattle grazed together the N'Dama were twice as likely to have positive titres to Babesia as were the zebus.