Comparative accuracy and resolution assessment of two prototype proton computed tomography scanners.

BACKGROUND: Improving the accuracy of relative stopping power (RSP) in proton therapy may allow reducing range margins. Proton computed tomography (pCT) has been shown to provide state-of-the-art RSP accuracy estimation, and various scanner prototypes have recently been built. The different approaches used in scanner design are expected to impact spatial resolution and RSP accuracy. PURPOSE: The goal of this study was to perform the first direct comparison, in terms of spatial resolution and RSP accuracy, of two pCT prototype scanners installed at the same facility and by using the same image reconstruction algorithm. METHODS: A phantom containing cylindrical inserts of known RSP was scanned at the phase-II pCT prototype of the U.S. pCT collaboration and at the commercially oriented ProtonVDA scanner. Following distance-driven binning filtered backprojection reconstruction, the radial edge spread function of high-density inserts was used to estimate the spatial resolution. RSP accuracy was evaluated by the mean absolute percent error (MAPE) over the inserts. No direct imaging dose estimation was possible, which prevented a comparison of the two scanners in terms of RSP noise. RESULTS: In terms of RSP accuracy, both scanners achieved the same MAPE of 0.72% when excluding the porous sinus insert from the evaluation. The ProtonVDA scanner reached a better overall MAPE when all inserts and the body of the phantom were accounted for (0.81%), compared to the phase-II scanner (1.14%). The spatial resolution with the phase-II scanner was found to be 0.61 lp/mm, while for the ProtonVDA scanner somewhat lower at 0.46 lp/mm. CONCLUSIONS: The comparison between two prototype pCT scanners operated in the same clinical facility showed that they both fulfill the requirement of an RSP accuracy of about 1%. Their spatial resolution performance reflects the different design choices of either a scanner with full tracking capabilities (phase-II) or of a more compact tracker system, which only provides the positions of protons but not their directions (ProtonVDA).

The role of Monte Carlo simulation in understanding the performance of proton computed tomography.

Proton computed tomography (pCT) is a promising tomographic imaging modality allowing direct reconstruction of proton relative stopping power (RSP) required for proton therapy dose calculation. In this review article, we aim at highlighting the role of Monte Carlo (MC) simulation in pCT studies. After describing the requirements for performing proton computed tomography and the various pCT scanners actively used in recent research projects, we present an overview of available MC simulation platforms. The use of MC simulations in the scope of investigations of image reconstruction, and for the evaluation of optimal RSP accuracy, precision and spatial resolution omitting detector effects is then described. In the final sections of the review article, we present specific applications of realistic MC simulations of an existing pCT scanner prototype, which we describe in detail.

An empirical artifact correction for proton computed tomography.

PURPOSE: To reduce image artifacts of proton computed tomography (pCT) from a preclinical scanner, for imaging of the relative stopping power (RSP) needed for particle therapy treatment planning using a simple empirical artifact correction method. METHODS: We adapted and employed a correction method previously used for beam-hardening correction in x-ray CT which makes use of a single scan of a custom-built homogeneous phantom with known RSP. Exploiting the linearity of the filtered backprojection operation, a function was found which corrects water-equivalent path lengths (RSP line integrals) in experimental scans using a prototype pCT scanner. The correction function was applied to projection values of subsequent scans of a homogeneous water phantom, a sensitometric phantom with various inserts and an anthropomorphic head phantom. Data were acquired at two different incident proton energies to test the robustness of the method. RESULTS: Inaccuracies in the detection process caused an offset and known ring artifacts in the water phantom which were considerably reduced using the proposed method. The mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of mean RSP values of all inserts of the sensitometric phantom and the water phantom was reduced from 0.87% to 0.44% and from 0.86% to 0.48% for the two incident energies respectively. In the head phantom a clear reduction of artifacts was observed. CONCLUSIONS: Image artifacts of experimental pCT scans with a prototype scanner could substantially be reduced both in homogeneous, heterogeneous and anthropomorphic phantoms. RSP accuracy was also improved.

Proof of concept image artifact reduction by energy-modulated proton computed tomography (EMpCT).

PURPOSE: To reduce imaging artifacts and improve image quality of a specific proton computed tomography (pCT) prototype scanner by combining pCT data acquired at two different incident proton energies to avoid protons stopping in sub-optimal detector sections. METHODS: Image artifacts of a prototype pCT scanner are linked to protons stopping close to internal structures of the scanner's multi-stage energy detector. We aimed at avoiding such protons by acquiring pCT data at two different incident energies and combining the data in post-processing from which artifact-reduced images of the relative stopping power (RSP) were calculated. Energy-modulated pCT (EMpCT) images were assessed visually and quantitatively and compared to the original mono-energetic images in terms of RSP accuracy and noise. Data were acquired for a homogeneous water phantom. RESULTS: RSP images reconstructed from the mono-energetic datasets displayed local image artifacts which were ring-shaped due to the homogeneity of the phantom. The merged EMpCT dataset achieved a superior visual image quality with reduced artifacts and only minor remaining rings. The inter-quartile range (25/75) of RSP values was reduced from 0.7% with the current standard acquisition to 0.2% with EMpCT due to the reduction of ring artifacts. In this study, dose was doubled compared to a standard scan, but we discuss strategies to reduce excess dose. CONCLUSIONS: EMpCT allows to effectively avoid regions of the energy detector that cause image artifacts. Thereby, image quality is improved.

Experimental comparison of proton CT and dual energy x-ray CT for relative stopping power estimation in proton therapy.

Proton computed tomography (pCT) has been proposed as an alternative to x-ray computed tomography (CT) for acquiring relative to water stopping power (RSP) maps used for proton treatment planning dose calculations. In parallel, it has been shown that dual energy x-ray CT (DECT) improves RSP accuracy when compared to conventional single energy x-ray CT. This study aimed at directly comparing the RSP accuracy of both modalities using phantoms scanned at an advanced prototype pCT scanner and a state-of-the-art DECT scanner. Two phantoms containing 13 tissue-mimicking inserts of known RSP were scanned at the pCT phase II prototype and a latest generation dual-source DECT scanner (Siemens SOMATOM Definition FORCE). RSP accuracy was compared by mean absolute percent error (MAPE) over all inserts. A highly realistic Monte Carlo (MC) simulation was used to gain insight on pCT image artifacts which degraded MAPE. MAPE was 0.55% for pCT and 0.67% for DECT. The realistic MC simulation agreed well with pCT measurements ([Formula: see text]). Both simulation and experimental results showed ring artifacts in pCT images which degraded the MAPE compared to an ideal pCT simulation ([Formula: see text]). Using the realistic simulation, we could identify sources of artifacts, which are attributed to the interfaces in the five-stage plastic scintillator energy detector and calibration curve interpolation regions. Secondary artifacts stemming from the proton tracker geometry were also identified. The pCT prototype scanner outperformed a state-of-the-art DECT scanner in terms of RSP accuracy (MAPE) for plastic tissue mimicking inserts. Since artifacts tended to concentrate in the inserts, their mitigation may lead to further improvements in the reported pCT accuracy.

Moiré method for nanometer instability investigation of scanning hard x-ray microscopes.

We present a Moiré method that can be used to investigate positional instabilities in a scanning hard x-ray microscope with nanometer precision. The development of diffraction-limited storage rings offering highly-brilliant synchrotron radiation and improvements of nanofocusing x-ray optics paves the way towards 3D nanotomography with 10 nm resolution or below. However, this trend demands improved designs of x-ray microscope instruments which should offer few-nm beam stabilities with respect to the sample. Our technique can measure the position of optics and sample stage relative to each other in the two directions perpendicular to the beam propagation in a scanning x-ray microscope using simple optical components and visible light. The usefulness of the method was proven by measuring short and long term instabilities of a zone-plate-optics-based prototype microscope. We think it can become an important tool for the characterization of scanning x-ray microscopes, especially prior to experiments with an actual x-ray beam.