Enhanced cardiac vagal efferent activity does not explain training-induced bradycardia.

Studies of heart rate variability (HRV) have so far produced contradictory evidence to support the common belief that endurance training enhances cardiac parasympathetic tone. This may be related to the fact that most studies failed to specifically isolate the vagally mediated influence of respiration. This study used a cross-sectional comparison of endurance athletes (n=20; ATHL) exhibiting resting bradycardia and age-matched nonathletes (n=12; CRTL) to indirectly assess training effects on amplitude and timing characteristics of respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA). Continuous electrocardiogram (ECG) and ventilatory flows were recorded during spontaneous breathing (SP), as well as during breathing at four cycles less than (M4) or more (P4) than SP, to also examine potential repercussions of training on the sensitivity of the cardiac vagal responses to breathing. A fast Fourier transform procedure was used to quantify the standard spectral high-frequency (HF) and low-frequency (LF) components and a respiratory-centered frequency (RCF) component of HRV. RSA was assessed using a breath-by-breath quantification of the amplitude and timing of the maximum change in instantaneous heart rate. Under baseline SP conditions, heart rate was lower in ATHL (62.6+/-6.5 vs. 75.2+/-9 beats/min; p<0.05) while blood pressure (BP), breath cycle duration, tidal volume, and ventilatory drive were similar in both groups. HRV total spectral power density, LF, HF, or RCF was not different between groups at either the SP, M4, or P4 conditions. Changes in total breath duration similarly affected RSA amplitude in all groups, while HR and BP remained unchanged from SP. RSA phase was not affected by training status or by changes in total breath duration. RSA amplitude was negatively related to breathing frequency in all groups (p<0.05), while the mean slope of the relationship (sensitivity) was not different between groups. In as much as RSA is an adequate marker of cardiac vagal efferent activity, these results add support to a contribution of a decrease in intrinsic heart rate to explain training-induced bradycardia.

Individual differences in respiratory sinus arrhythmia.

To investigate the interindividual differences in respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA), recordings of ventilation and electrocardiogram were obtained from 12 healthy subjects for five imposed breathing periods (T(TOT)) surrounding each individual's spontaneous breathing period. In addition to the spectral analysis of the R-R interval signal at each breathing period, RSA characteristics were quantified by using a breath-by-breath analysis where a sinusoid was fitted to the changes in instantaneous heart rate in each breath. The amplitude and phase (or delay = phase x T(TOT)) of this sinusoid were taken as the RSA characteristics for each breath. It was found that for each subject the RSA amplitude-T(TOT) relationship was linear, whereas the delay-T(TOT) relationship was parabolic. However, the parameters of these relationships differed between individuals. Linear correlation between the slopes of RSA amplitude versus T(TOT) regression lines and 1) mean breathing period and 2) mean R-R interval during spontaneous breathing were calculated. Only the correlation coefficient with breathing period was significantly different from zero, indicating that the longer the spontaneous breathing period the lesser the increase in RSA amplitude with increasing breathing period. Similarly, only the correlation coefficient between the curvature of the RSA delay-T(TOT) parabola and mean breathing period was significantly different from zero; the longer the spontaneous breathing period the larger the curvature of RSA delay. These results suggest that the changes in RSA characteristics induced by changing the breathing period may be explained partly by the spontaneous breathing period of each individual. Furthermore, a transfer function analysis performed on these data suggested interindividual differences in the autonomic modulation of the heart rate.