Comparison of Usefulness of Four Chelating Agents (EDTA, NTA, ODA and IDA) for the Chromatographic Separation of Micro and Macro Amounts of Rare Earth Elements.

Literature on the use of four chelating agents namely: ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, nitrilotriacetic acid, diglycolic acid and iminodiacetic acid for the chromatographic separation of micro and macro amounts of rare earth elements was critically reviewed and supplemented with some new unpublished data from our Laboratory. Advantages and disadvantages of ion exchange chromatography both in cation and anion mode as well as ion interaction chromatography techniques, which were used for rare earth elements separation, are discussed. The usefulness of some of the chromatographic systems for micro-macro separations was discussed and demonstrated. The importance of resilience of the separation method to column overloading in some analytical and larger scale separations was emphasized. The methods described in this article might suit well for recovering of individual lanthanides and yttrium from e-waste and other industrial wastes which were fast accumulating in recent years.

New reversed phase-high performance liquid chromatographic method for selective separation of yttrium from all rare earth elements employing nitrilotriacetate complexes in anion exchange mode.

Separation of Y from other rare earth elements (REE) is difficult because of similarity of its ionic radius to ionic radii of Tb, Dy and Ho. In the new RP-HPLC system with C18 column, tetra-n-butyl ammonium hydroxide (TBAOH) as an ion interaction reagent (IIR), nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) as a complexing agent at pH=2.8-3.5, and post column derivatization with Arsenazo III, yttrium is eluted in the region of light REE, between Nd and Sm and is base line separated from Nd and Sm and even from promethium. Simple model employing literature data on complex formation of REE with NTA and based on anion exchange mechanism was developed to foresee the order of elution of individual REE. The model correctly predicted that lanthanides up to Tb will be eluted in the order of increasing Atomic Number (At.No.) but all heavier REE will show smaller retention factors than Tb. Concurrent UV/VIS detection at 658nm and the use of radioactive tracers together with γ-ray spectrometric measurements made possible to establish an unique elution order of elution of REE: La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Pm, Y, Sm, Er, Ho, Tm, Yb, Eu, Lu, Dy+Gd, Tb, Sc. The real place of Y however, in this elution series differs from that predicted by the model (Y between Sm and Eu). The method described in this work enables selective separation of Y from La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Pm, Sm and all heavier REE treated as a group.

Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry in comparison with neutron activation and ion chromatography with UV/VIS detection for the determination of lanthanides in plant materials.

Analytical performance of inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) for determination of lanthanides in plant materials was investigated and compared with neutron activation analysis (NAA) as well as ion chromatography (IC) with UV-VIS detection. Two sample preparation protocols were tested: (i) microwave assisted digestion by concentrated nitric acid; (ii) microwave digestion involving silica and fluoride removal, followed by the selective and quantitative lanthanides group separation from the plant matrix. Several Certified Reference Materials (CRM) of plant origin were used for the evaluation of the accuracy of the applied analytical procedures. The consistency of results, obtained by various methods, enabled to establish the tentative recommended values (TRV) for several missing elements in one of CRMs. The ICP-MS, due to its very high sensitivity, has the potential to contribute to this aim. The discrepancy of the results obtained by various methods was discussed in a view of possible matrix effects related to the composition of investigated materials.

Two new reference materials based on tobacco leaves: certification for over a dozen of toxic and essential elements.

The preparation, certification, and characterization of two new biological certified reference materials for inorganic trace analysis have been presented. They are based on two different varieties of tobacco leaves, namely, Oriental Basma Tobacco Leaves (INCT-OBTL-5), grown in Greece, and Polish Virginia Tobacco Leaves (INCT-PVTL-6), grown in Poland. Certification of the materials was based on the statistical evaluation of results obtained in a worldwide interlaboratory comparison, in which 87 laboratories from 18 countries participated, providing 2568 laboratory averages on nearly 80 elements. It was possible to establish the certified values of concentration for many elements in the new materials, that is, 37 in INCT-OBTL-5 and 36 in INCT-PVTL-6, including several toxic ones like As, Cd, Hg, Pb, and so forth. The share and the role of instrumental analytical techniques used in the process of certification of the new CRMs are discussed.

Comparison of performance of INAA, RNAA and ion chromatography for the determination of individual lanthanides.

Lanthanides represent an interesting group of elements which are steadily gaining importance in science and in industry. Literature data suggest that they may have a role in regulating cellular processes and also in agriculture enhancing plant growth. Only few instrumental methods like NAA, ICP-OES and ICP-MS have potential for the determination of low levels of all lanthanides, but in practice they often have to be combined with suitable separation/preconcentration methods to achieve maximum number of elements being determined and to assure good accuracy and precision. In this work an attempt has been made to compare the performance of both variants of NAA: purely instrumental activation analysis (INAA) and radiochemical mode (RNAA) with pre- and post-irradiation group separation for the determination of individual lanthanides with the special emphasis on rarely determined elements (Gd, Ho, Er, Tm, Lu). This has been done by the analysis of two reference materials with different matrices viz. biological (CTA-OTL-1) and mineral (CTA-FFA-1). The results are compared with those obtained by ion chromatography (IC) employing the same lanthanide group preseparation scheme as in the case of RNAA.

RNAA in metrology: A highly accurate (definitive) method.

The idea of highly accurate (definitive) methods by radiochemical neutron activation analysis (RNAA) is presented and illustrated with several examples of methods worked out in this Laboratory over the past several years. Definitive methods by RNAA are constructed by combining reactor neutron activation with very selective and quantitative post-irradiation separation of the indicator radionuclide by column chromatography followed by gamma-ray spectrometric measurement. All conditions for the determination of the individual element are optimized and uncertainties associated with every step of the analytical procedure are minimized. Even after the method has been thoroughly elaborated and validated through the analysis of appropriate certified reference materials (CRMs), the results obtained in each series of measurements are acknowledged as obtained by definitive method only when a series of previously formulated criteria is simultaneously fulfilled. The examples of definitive methods for the determination of cadmium, cobalt and molybdenum, respectively, in biological materials are presented. Each of these methods has detection limit of the order of ng g(-1) or better, and yields accurate and precise results. The expanded standard uncertainty is of the order of 2.6% for the case of single-element determination (Co) and 3.4-5.2% for the less favourable case (Mo) where there is necessity for simultaneous determination of uranium to correct for interference due to fission reaction. Definitive methods by RNAA may constitute an option or alternative with respect to ID-MS as methods of "guaranteed accuracy" being also a perspective solution in the case of monoisotopic elements, for which ID-MS cannot be used.