Human-specific phages infecting Enterococcus host strain MW47: are they reliable microbial source tracking markers?

AIM: The aim of this study was to determine the morphological diversity and environmental survival of human-specific phages infecting Enterococcus faecium host strain MW47, to support their use as microbial source tracking (MST) markers. METHODS AND RESULTS: Twenty phages capable of infecting strain MW47 were propagated and their morphologies were determined using transmission electron microscopy (TEM), which revealed that a heterogeneous group of phages was able to infect strain MW47. Three distinct morphologies from two different families (Myoviridae and Siphoviridae) were observed. In situ inactivation experiments were subsequently conducted to determine their environmental persistence. CONCLUSION: The findings revealed a statistically significant link between morphology and the rate of inactivation, with phages belonging to the Myoviridae family demonstrating more rapid inactivation in comparison to those belonging to the Siphoviridae family. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF STUDY: The results suggest that while Enterococcus MW47 phages appear to be a potentially valuable MST tools, significant variations in the persistence of the different phages mean that the approach should be used with caution, as this may adversely affect the reliability of the approach, especially when comparing MW47 phage levels or the presence across different matrices (e.g. levels in sediments or shellfish). This highlights the importance of elucidating the ecological characteristics of newly proposed MST markers before they are used in full-scale MST investigations.

The effect of UV-C radiation (254 nm) on candidate microbial source tracking phages infecting a human-specific strain of Bacteroides fragilis (GB-124).

The enumeration of phages infecting host-specific strains of Bacteroides has been widely recognised as an effective and low-cost method of microbial source tracking (MST). A recently described human-specific Bacteroides host strain (GB-124) has been shown to detect bacteriophages exclusively in human-impacted waters and is emerging as a useful MST tool. However, a better understanding of the morphology and ecological behaviour of the phages, especially in wastewater disinfection processes, is now required in order to validate their role as MST markers. Bacteriophages infecting Bacteroides fragilis GB-124 (n = 21) were isolated from wastewater effluent and irradiated using laboratory-based UV-C (254 nm) collimated beam experiments. Bacteriophages were found to be both a morphologically and ecologically homogeneous group, with all specimens showing highly similar first order log-linear inactivation profiles (mean fluence required to inactivate phages by 4-log(10) was 36 mJ/cm(2)). These findings present the first evidence that phages infecting GB-124 are inactivated by the levels of UV-C radiation routinely delivered during tertiary wastewater treatment processes. More importantly, comparison with previously published inactivation data suggests that their response to UV-C radiation makes GB-124 phages more suitable surrogates for selected enteric viruses in UV disinfection processes than traditional faecal indicator bacteria or human-specific molecular markers.

Geographical stability of enterococcal antibiotic resistance profiles in Europe and its implications for the identification of fecal sources.

This manuscript describes the use of a recently developed microbial source tracking (MST) technique to determine sources of fecal bacteria (enterococci) from four separate European countries. The investigation aimed to evaluate whether the origin of bacterial populations from France, Spain, and Sweden (n = 456) could be predicted using a library of antibiotic resistance patterns of enterococci of known origin assembled in the United Kingdom (n = 2739). Bacterial isolates were exposed to a battery of 31 antibiotic tests and classified into source groups using discriminant function analysis (DFA). Results showed that while on average 72% of the U.K. isolates could be correctly classified as originating from either municipal wastewater (MW), livestock, or wild birds, only 43% of non-U.K. isolates could be successfully classified into the same source categories. The results suggested that patterns of resistance amongst isolates contained in the U.K. library were not representative of those found in the other locations and that it may not be possible to share libraries over large distances, such as those in this study. Future MST studies using antibiotic resistance analysis (ARA) in Europe may therefore require the assembly of watershed specific libraries, increasing the cost of such studies.

A simplified low-cost approach to antibiotic resistance profiling for faecal source tracking.

Antibiotic resistance profiling (ARP) is a potentially useful method for distinguishing faecal bacteria according to host source. This phenotypic approach has cost benefits over genotypic methods, but existing protocols are time-consuming and manual data handling is open to human error. A simplified, low-cost approach to the ARP technique was developed that used automated data recording techniques combined with simple statistical analyses to compare isolates of the genus Enterococcus from various faecal sources. An initial battery of 21 antibiotics (at up to four concentrations) was chosen for source discrimination. Images of growth or non-growth in microplate wells were stored as bitmaps and converted to binary data to form a database of known antibiotic resistance profiles. Discriminant function analysis (DFA) showed that the average rate of isolates correctly classified by the database (wastewater vs non-wastewater) was 86%. Once the more discriminating antibiotics and their concentrations had been identified, it was possible to reduce the number of tests from 80 to 18 whilst increasing the number of correctly classified human isolates. ARP could offer a low-cost and rapid means of identifying sources of faecal pollution. As such, the technique may be of particular benefit to developing countries, where water quality may have a significant impact on health and where cost is a major factor when choosing environmental management technology.