RESUMO
As an essential enzyme to SARS-CoV-2, main protease (MPro) is a viable target to develop antivirals for the treatment of COVID-19. By varying chemical compositions at both P2 and P3 sites and the N-terminal protection group, we synthesized a series of MPro inhibitors that contain {beta}-(S-2-oxopyrrolidin-3-yl)-alaninal at the P1 site. These inhibitors have a large variation of determined IC50 values that range from 4.8 to 650 nM. The determined IC50 values reveal that relatively small side chains at both P2 and P3 sites are favorable for achieving high in vitro MPro inhibition potency, the P3 site is tolerable toward unnatural amino acids with two alkyl substituents on the -carbon, and the inhibition potency is sensitive toward the N-terminal protection group. X-ray crystal structures of MPro bound with 16 inhibitors were determined. All structures show similar binding patterns of inhibitors at the MPro active site. A covalent interaction between the active site cysteine and a bound inhibitor was observed in all structures. In MPro, large structural variations were observed on residues N142 and Q189. All inhibitors were also characterized on their inhibition of MPro in 293T cells, which revealed their in cellulo potency that is drastically different from their in vitro enzyme inhibition potency. Inhibitors that showed high in cellulo potency all contain O-tert-butyl-threonine at the P3 site. Based on the current and a previous study, we conclude that O-tert-butyl-threonine at the P3 site is a key component to achieve high cellular and antiviral potency for peptidyl aldehyde inhibitors of MPro. This finding will be critical to the development of novel antivirals to address the current global emergency of concerning the COVID-19 pandemic.
RESUMO
Boceprevir is an HCV NSP3 inhibitor that has been explored as a repurposed drug for COVID-19. It inhibits the SARS-CoV-2 main protease (MPro) and contains an -ketoamide warhead, a P1 {beta}-cyclobutylalanyl moiety, a P2 dimethylcyclopropylproline, a P3 tert-butyl-glycine, and a P4 N-terminal tert-butylcarbamide. By introducing modifications at all four positions, we synthesized 20 boceprevir-based MPro inhibitors including PF-07321332 and characterized their MPro inhibition potency in test tubes (in vitro) and human host cells (in cellulo). Crystal structures of MPro bound with 10 inhibitors and antiviral potency of 4 inhibitors were characterized as well. Replacing the P1 site with a {beta}-(S-2-oxopyrrolidin-3-yl)-alanyl (opal) residue and the warhead with an aldehyde leads to high in vitro potency. The original moieties at P2, P3 and the P4 N-terminal cap positions in boceprevir are better than other tested chemical moieties for high in vitro potency. In crystal structures, all inhibitors form a covalent adduct with the MPro active site cysteine. The P1 opal residue, P2 dimethylcyclopropylproline and P4 N-terminal tert-butylcarbamide make strong hydrophobic interactions with MPro, explaining high in vitro potency of inhibitors that contain these moieties. A unique observation was made with an inhibitor that contains an P4 N-terminal isovaleramide. In its MPro complex structure, the P4 N-terminal isovaleramide is tucked deep in a small pocket of MPro that originally recognizes a P4 alanine side chain in a substrate. Although all inhibitors show high in vitro potency, they have drastically different in cellulo potency in inhibiting ectopically expressed MPro in human 293T cells. All inhibitors including PF-07321332 with a P4 N-terminal carbamide or amide have low in cellulo potency. This trend is reversed when the P4 N-terminal cap is changed to a carbamate. The installation of a P3 O-tert-butyl-threonine improves in cellulo potency. Three molecules that contain a P4 N-terminal carbamate were advanced to antiviral tests on three SARS-CoV-2 variants. They all have high potency with EC50 values around 1 M. A control compound with a nitrile warhead and a P4 N-terminal amide has undetectable antiviral potency. Based on all observations, we conclude that a P4 N-terminal carbamate in a boceprevir derivative is key for high antiviral potency against SARS-CoV-2.
RESUMO
As an essential enzyme of SARS-CoV-2, the pathogen of COVID-19, main protease (MPro) triggers acute toxicity to its human cell host, an effect that can be alleviated by an MPro inhibitor with cellular potency. By coupling this toxicity alleviation with the expression of an MPro-eGFP fusion protein in a human cell host for straightforward characterization with fluorescent flow cytometry, we developed an effective method that allows bulk analysis of cellular potency of MPro inhibitors. In comparison to an antiviral assay in which MPro inhibitors may target host proteases or other processes in the SARS-CoV-2 life cycle to convene strong antiviral effects, this novel assay is more advantageous in providing precise cellular MPro inhibition information for assessment and optimization of MPro inhibitors. We used this assay to analyze 30 literature reported MPro inhibitors including MPI1-9 that were newly developed aldehyde-based reversible covalent inhibitors of MPro, GC376 and 11a that are two investigational drugs undergoing clinical trials for the treatment of COVID-19 patients in United States, boceprevir, calpain inhibitor II, calpain inhibitor XII, ebselen, bepridil that is an antianginal drug with potent anti-SARS-CoV-2 activity, and chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine that were previously shown to inhibit MPro. Our results showed that most inhibitors displayed cellular potency much weaker than their potency in direct inhibition of the enzyme. Many inhibitors exhibited weak or undetectable cellular potency up to 10 M. On contrary to their strong antiviral effects, 11a, calpain inhibitor II, calpain XII, ebselen, and bepridil showed relatively weak to undetectable cellular MPro inhibition potency implicating their roles in interfering with key steps other than just the MPro catalysis in the SARS-CoV-2 life cycle to convene potent antiviral effects. characterization of these molecules on their antiviral mechanisms will likely reveal novel drug targets for COVID-19. Chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine showed close to undetectable cellular potency to inhibit MPro. Kinetic recharacterization of these two compounds rules out their possibility as MPro inhibitors. Our results also revealed that MPI5, 6, 7, and 8 have high cellular and antiviral potency with both IC50 and EC50 values respectively below 1 M. As the one with the highest cellular and antiviral potency among all tested compounds, MPI8 has a remarkable cellular MPro inhibition IC50 value of 31 nM that matches closely to its strong antiviral effect with an EC50 value of 30 nM. Given its strong cellular and antiviral potency, we cautiously suggest that MPI8 is ready for preclinical and clinical investigations for the treatment of COVID-19.
