Computation of the fracture probability and lifetime of all ceramic anterior crowns under cyclic loading - An FEA study.

OBJECTIVES: To predict the lifetime and fracture probability of anterior crowns made of a lithium disilicate glass-ceramic (IPS e.max CAD, LD, Ivoclar Vivadent, Liechtenstein) and a zirconia-containing lithium silicate glass-ceramic (Celtra Duo, ZLS, Dentsply Sirona, USA) under cycling loading. METHODS: Three-point bending tests were conducted to measure the viscoelastic parameters. These parameters are used to compute the residual stresses of the anterior crown after crystallization. In the next analysis, the cyclic loading on the anterior crown was calculated. Based on this combined stress state (residual stress and stress state due to external cyclic loading), the life cycle and fracture probability of the anterior crown was calculated using the CARES/Life software. Finally, fatigue experiments were carried out to compare and validate the results of the computations. RESULTS: Although a sound qualitative comparison of the lifetime of both materials can be done using this methodology, the calculated fracture probability of the anterior crown for both materials was very low in comparison with the fatigue test results using the fatigue parameters determined from the experiments. In order to achieve good correspondence with the experimental results, the SCG exponent n for both materials should be modified by a correlation factor of 0.38. SIGNIFICANCE: Using this modified computational strategy, the results of the time-consuming fatigue tests for dental glass-ceramics can be closely predicted. This methodology can be integrated into the development process of new glass-ceramic materials in order to save time and costs.

Strength characterization and lifetime prediction of dental ceramic materials.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the Weibull modulus m, the characteristic strength σ0,the subcritical crack growth (SCG) parameters (n &A*) as well as the lifetime durability of three dental ceramic materials in water: a polycrystalline yttria-stabilized zirconia (Zenostar MT O, YSZ, Ivoclar Vivadent/Wieland, Germany), a lithium disilicate glass ceramic (IPS e.max CAD, LD, Ivoclar Vivadent, Liechtenstein), and a zirconia-containing lithium silicate glass ceramic (Celtra Duo, ZLS, Dentsply Sirona Inc, USA). METHODS: 30 specimens (Ø12 mm × 0.9 mm thickness) of each material were fabricated. The biaxial ring-on-ring bending tests at four stress rates σ˙ (100, 10, 1, 0.1 MPa/s) were performed in water for all three ceramics. The results were used to determine the Weibull and SCG parameters, and to plot the Strength-Probability-Time (SPT) diagram. RESULTS: YSZ showed the highest m (12.5) and highest σ0 (542 MPa), while the values for the glass ceramic materials were lower: for LD m = 4.7, σ0 = 407 MPa, and for ZLS m = 2.7, σ0 = 279 MPa. The n for YSZ, LD and ZLS in water were 31.1, 13.7 and 16.6, respectively. The strength of YSZ decreased by 50% within a simulated period of 10 years, and for the glass ceramic materials the decrease was up to 80%. SIGNIFICANCE: Determining the Weibull and SCG parameters from the constant stress rate testing is an efficient methodology for ranking materials in terms of durability and longevity.

Numerical assessment of bone remodeling around conventionally and early loaded titanium and titanium-zirconium alloy dental implants.

The aim of this study was to investigate conventionally and early loaded titanium and titanium-zirconium alloy implants by three-dimensional finite element stress analysis. Three-dimensional model of a dental implant was created and a thread area was established as a region of interest in trabecular bone to study a localized part of the global model with a refined mesh. The peri-implant tissues around conventionally loaded (model 1) and early loaded (model 2) implants were implemented and were used to explore principal stresses, displacement values, and equivalent strains in the peri-implant region of titanium and titanium-zirconium implants under static load of 300 N with or without 30° inclination applied on top of the abutment surface. Under axial loading, principal stresses in both models were comparable for both implants and models. Under oblique loading, principal stresses around titanium-zirconium implants were slightly higher in both models. Comparable stress magnitudes were observed in both models. The displacement values and equivalent strain amplitudes around both implants and models were similar. Peri-implant bone around titanium and titanium-zirconium implants experiences similar stress magnitudes coupled with intraosseous implant displacement values under conventional loading and early loading simulations. Titanium-zirconium implants have biomechanical outcome comparable to conventional titanium implants under conventional loading and early loading.

Predicting bone remodeling around tissue- and bone-level dental implants used in reduced bone width.

The objective of this study was to predict time-dependent bone remodeling around tissue- and bone-level dental implants used in patients with reduced bone width. The remodeling of bone around titanium tissue-level, and titanium and titanium-zirconium alloy bone-level implants was studied under 100 N oblique load for one month by implementing the Stanford theory into three-dimensional finite element models. Maximum principal stress, minimum principal stress, and strain energy density in peri-implant bone and displacement in x- and y- axes of the implant were evaluated. Maximum and minimum principal stresses around tissue-level implant were higher than bone-level implants and both bone-level implants experienced comparable stresses. Total strain energy density in bone around titanium implants slightly decreased during the first two weeks of loading followed by a recovery, and the titanium-zirconium implant showed minor changes in the axial plane. Total strain energy density changes in the loading and contralateral sides were higher in tissue-level implant than other implants in the cortical bone at the horizontal plane. The displacement values of the implants were almost constant over time. Tissue-level implants were associated with higher stresses than bone-level implants. The time-dependent biomechanical outcome of titanium-zirconium alloy bone-level implant was comparable to the titanium implant.

Immediate versus conventional loading of implant-supported maxillary overdentures: a finite element stress analysis.

PURPOSE: To compare biomechanical outcomes of immediately and conventionally loaded bar-retained implant-supported maxillary overdentures using finite element stress analysis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Finite element models were created to replicate the spatial positioning of four 4.1 × 12-mm implants in the completely edentulous maxillae of four cadavers to support bar-retained overdentures with 7-mm distal extension cantilevers. To simulate the bone-implant interface of immediately loaded implants, a contact situation was defined at the interface; conventional loading was simulated by "bonding" the implants to the surrounding bone. The prostheses were loaded with 100 N in the projected molar regions bilaterally, and strain magnitudes were measured at the buccal aspect of bone. RESULTS: The amplitude of axial and lateral strains, the overall strain magnitudes, and the strain magnitudes around anterior and posterior implants in the immediate loading group were comparable to those seen in the conventional loading group, suggesting that the loading regimens created similar stress/strain fields (P > .05). CONCLUSIONS: Conventional and immediate loading of maxillary implants supporting bar-retained overdentures resulted in similar bone strains.

Finite element analysis of stress distribution with splinted and nonsplinted maxillary anterior fixed prostheses supported by zirconia or titanium implants.

PURPOSE: The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of splinting titanium (Ti) or zirconia (Zr) implants supporting maxillary anterior fixed prostheses on the stress levels and patterns in the implants, prostheses, and the surrounding bone; and to compare the effects of Zr and Ti implant materials on the stress distribution in splinted and nonsplinted designs via finite element modeling. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Zr and Ti dental implants and the anterior maxilla were modeled. In the nonsplinted design (D1), implants were placed into the maxillary left central incisor and canine regions, and a three-unit zirconia fixed prosthesis was modeled. In the splinted design (D2), a symmetric model of D1 was generated and the two prostheses were splinted together to create a six-unit prosthesis. Loading was applied horizontally and obliquely. Von Mises, tensile, and compressive stresses were evaluated in the implants, prostheses, and surrounding bone. RESULTS: Under both loading conditions, the stresses on the D2 implants were lower than those in the D1 implants. Stresses were concentrated on the neck of the implant and decreased through the apex. All of the stress values in cortical bone in D1 were slightly higher than in D2 for both implant materials under both loading conditions. CONCLUSION: When the implants were splinted together, stresses were reduced in the supporting bone and implants in both loading conditions, but increased stress was observed in the prostheses under oblique loading. Intense stress concentrations were found in the connector of the splinted prosthesis and the cervical region of the nonsplinted prosthesis. Zr and Ti implants showed very similar stress distributions in all materials. Under oblique loading, lower stresses occurred in implants and the prosthesis core material when Ti implants were used.

Biomechanical comparison of two different collar structured implants supporting 3-unit fixed partial denture: a 3-D FEM study.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of the study was to compare the effects of two distinct collar geometries of implants on stress distribution in the bone as well as in the fixture-abutment complex, in the framework and in the veneering material of 3-unit fixed partial denture (FPD). MATERIAL AND METHODS: The 3-dimensional finite element analysis method was selected to evaluate the stress distribution in the system composed of 3-unit FPD supported by two different dental implant systems with two distinct collar geometries; microthread collar structure (MCS) and non-microthread collar structure (NMCS). In separate load cases, 300 N vertical, 150 N oblique and 60 N horizontal, forces were utilized to simulate the multidirectional chewing forces. Tensile and compressive stress values in the cortical and cancellous bone and von Mises stresses in the fixture-abutment complex, in the framework and veneering material, were simulated as a body and investigated separately. RESULTS: In the cortical bone lower stress values were found in the MCS model, when compared with NMCS. In the cancellous bone, lower stress values were observed in the NMCS model when compared with MCS. In the implant-abutment complex, highest von Mises stress values were noted in the NMCS model; however, in the framework and veneering material, highest stress values were calculated in MCS model. CONCLUSIONS: MCS implants when compared with NMCS implants supporting 3-unit FPDs decrease the stress values in the cortical bone and implant-abutment complex. The results of the present study will be evaluated as a base for our ongoing FEA studies focused on stress distribution around the microthread and non-microthread collar geometries with various prosthesis design.

Biomechanical effects of two different collar implant structures on stress distribution under cantilever fixed partial dentures.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of the study was to compare the effects of two distinct collar geometries of implants on stress distribution in the bone around the implants supporting cantilever fixed partial dentures (CFPDs) as well as in the implant-abutment complex and superstructures. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The three-dimensional finite element method was selected to evaluate the stress distribution. CFPDs which was supported by microthread collar structured (MCS) and non-microthread collar structured (NMCS) implants was modeled; 300 N vertical, 150 N oblique and 60 N horizontal forces were applied to the models separately. The stress values in the bone, implant-abutment complex and superstructures were calculated. RESULTS: In the MCS model, higher stresses were located in the cortical bone and implant-abutment complex in the case of vertical load while decreased stresses in cortical bone and implant-abutment complex were noted within horizontal and oblique loading. In the case of vertical load, decreased stresses have been noted in cancellous bone and framework. Upon horizontal and oblique loading, a MCS model had higher stress in cancellous bone and framework than the NMCS model. Higher von Mises stresses have been noted in veneering material for NMCS models. CONCLUSION: It has been concluded that stress distribution in implant-supported CFPDs correlated with the macro design of the implant collar and the direction of applied force.

Biomechanical comparison of implant retained fixed partial dentures with fiber reinforced composite versus conventional metal frameworks: a 3D FEA study.

Fiber reinforced composite (FRC) materials have been successfully used in a variety of commercial applications. These materials have also been widely used in dentistry. The use of fiber composite technology in implant prostheses has been previously presented, since they may solve many problems associated with metal alloy frameworks such as corrosion, complexity of fabrication and high cost. The hypothesis of this study was that an FRC framework with lower flexural modulus provides more even stress distribution throughout the implant retained fixed partial dentures (FPDs) than a metal framework does. A 3-dimensional finite element analysis was conducted to evaluate the stress distribution in bone, implant-abutment complex and prosthetic structures. Hence, two distinctly different models of implant retained 3-unit fixed partial dentures, composed of Cr-Co and porcelain (M-FPD model) or FRC and particulate composite (FRC-FPD model) were utilized. In separate load cases, 300 N vertical, 150 N oblique and 60 N horizontal forces were simulated. When the FRC-FPD and M-FPD models were compared, it was found that all investigated stress values in the M-FPD model were higher than the values in the FRC-FPD model except for the stress values in the implant-abutment complex. It can be concluded that the implant supported FRC-FPD could eliminate the excessive stresses in the bone-implant interface and maintain normal physiological loading of the surrounding bone, therefore minimizing the risk of peri-implant bone loss due to stress-shielding.

Effects of different fixture geometries on the stress distribution in mandibular peri-implant structures: a 3-dimensional finite element analysis.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare 3 different solid screw implant fixture designs of stepped cylindric tapered, straight cylindric nontapered, and cylindric with vertical groove tapered on stress distribution in the posterior mandible at a fixed interimplant distance of 1.0 cm. STUDY DESIGN: Three-dimensional finite element analysis was used to compare stress distribution around the endosseous titanium implants using 3 different implant fixture geometries. Two identical dental implants of 3 commercially available fixture designs were embedded in each model with a fixed interimplant distance of 1.0 cm. Loads were applied to each of these fixtures: vertically 70 N, with an inclination of 60 degrees obliquely (buccolingually) 35 N, and horizontally (mesiodistally) 14 N. Tensile and compressive stresses on each simulated mandible were calculated using finite element analysis software. Finally, evaluation of the stress around 3 different implant fixtures was performed. RESULTS: In the vertical and buccolingual directions, the highest tensile stresses (P(max)) and compression stresses (P(min)) mostly occurred around the cylindric with vertical groove tapered fixture design in both cortical and cancellous bone. In mesiodistal direction, the highest P(max) and P(min) values in cortical and cancellous bone mostly occurred around the straight cylindric nontapered fixture design. CONCLUSION: On the basis of the knowledge of deterioration of osseointegration under undesirable stresses within the surrounding bone, the implant fixture design should be chosen carefully. The results of this study reveal that in a clinical situation of molar edentulism, 2 identical stepped cylindric fixture designs which were embedded at a fixed distance of 1.0 cm were the most desirable choice of stress distribution in the surrounding bone.

Numerical simulation of the effect of time-to-loading on peri-implant bone.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the effect of time-to-loading on trabecular bone around single-tooth dental implants using numerical solutions based on computer models. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A global model with a coarse mesh carrying a Straumann dental implant (043.033S; Institut Straumann, Basel, Switzerland) was created. A region of interest in trabecular bone was defined to study a localized part of the global model with a refined mesh. Time-to-loading submodels to simulate 2h, 4 days, 1, 4, 6 and 12 wks of trabecular bone-healing status were designed and created. Bone types were considered in the simulation by different elastic bone properties. A 100-N oblique static load was applied. Maximum and minimum principal stresses were calculated and visualized. RESULTS: Bone types with higher elastic moduli experienced higher stress levels. Changes in the quality and quantity of bone at the bone-implant interface did not affect the overall stress distribution. Peri-implant bone with a higher elastic modulus preserved the stress increase at the implant-bone interface. DISCUSSION: Reduced bone contact may not have a prevailing effect over bone quality and quantity on stress generation at the peri-implant bone. CONCLUSION: Time-to-loading of single-tooth implants may not differ in terms of load distributions in neighboring peri-implant bone.

Predicting time-dependent remodeling of bone around immediately loaded dental implants with different designs.

The purpose of this study was to predict time-dependent biomechanics of bone around cylindrical screw dental implants with different macrogeometric designs under simulated immediate loading condition. The remodeling of bone around a parallel-sided and a tapered dental implant of same length was studied under 100N oblique load by implementing the Stanford theory into three-dimensional finite element models. The results of the analyses were examined in five time intervals consisting loading immediately after implant placement, and after 1, 2, 3 and 4 weeks following implantation. Maximum principal stress, minimum principal stress, and strain energy density in peri-implant bone and displacement in x-(implant lateral direction with a projection of the oblique force) and y-(implant longitudinal direction) axes of the implant were evaluated. The highest value of the maximum and minimum principal stresses around both implants increased in cortical bone and decreased in trabecular bone. The maximum and minimum principal stresses in cortical bone were higher around the tapered cylindrical implant, but stresses in the trabecular bone were higher around the parallel-sided cylindrical implant. Strain energy density around both implants increased in cortical bone, slightly decreased in trabecular bone, and higher values were obtained for the parallel-sided cylindrical implant. Displacement values slightly decreased in time in x-axis, and an initial decrease followed by a slight increase was observed in the y-axis. Bone responded differently in remodeling for the two implant designs under immediate loading, where the cortical bone carried the highest load. Application of oblique loading resulted in increase of stiffness in the peri-implant bone.

Numeric simulation of time-dependent remodeling of bone around loaded oral implants.

PURPOSE: The objective of this study was to investigate the time-dependent biomechanics of marginal bone around osseointegrated dental implants within physiologic loading conditions. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The remodeling of marginal bone around a 4.1-mm-diameter, 10-mm-long implant was studied by implementing the Stanford theory into axisymmetric mathematical models simulating different bone support at the implant neck: 1-mm-thick cortical bone (model 1), 0.5-mm-thick cortical bone (model 2), absence of cortical bone (model 3), and absence of cortical bone with 0.5 mm of resorption of marginal trabecular bone (model 4). The results were examined separately for all models at five time intervals: the first loading after osseointegration and 3, 6, 9, and 12 months after osseointegration. Minimum principal stress, maximum principal stress, strain energy, total equivalent strain, displacement, average elastic modulus, and bone density were evaluated. RESULTS: In models 1 and 2, the magnitude of the stresses increased during the 1-year period. The distributions of stresses in models 3 and 4 were less variable and lower than models with cortical bone. The region of high stresses enlarged during the first 3 months and then decreased over time. There was a time-dependent increase in strain energy density around the neck of the implant in models 1 and 2. The time-dependent displacement values of implants were almost constant over time (maximum 1 Mum change). The lowest implant displacement values were observed in model 1. There was a slight increase in the elastic modulus of cortical bone and a decrease in trabecular bone (maximum 1% change). CONCLUSION: The time-dependent increase in stresses in the marginal zone of the implants with cortical bone support was higher than that of the implants supported solely by trabecular bone in the first year of function. Higher strain energy density around the implants with cortical bone support might indicate apposition and increase in interface stiffness, whereas lower strain energy density around implants supported solely by trabecular bone could be associated with skeletal tissue loss.

Nonlinear finite element analysis versus ex vivo strain gauge measurements on immediately loaded implants.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the level of agreement between nonlinear finite element stress analysis (NL-FEA) and ex vivo strain gauge analysis (EV-SGA) on immediately loaded implants. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Four 4.1-mm-diameter, 12-mm-long implants were placed bilaterally into the lateral and first premolar regions of completely edentulous maxillae of four human cadavers. Two-element 90-degree rosette strain gauges were bonded to the labial cortical bone around the implants, and 100 N maximal load was applied over two miniature load cells on bar-retained overdentures while simultaneous data acquisition from load cells and strain gauges was performed at a sample rate of 10 KHz. Individualized numeric models of the cadavers were constructed, and contact analysis with normal contact detection and separation behavior was performed between the implants and bone. Upon simulation of the loading regimen, axial and lateral strains were recorded. The NL-FEA data and EV-SGA data were compared. RESULTS: There was a high level of agreement regarding the quality of strains, as determined by both techniques, although the mean values obtained with EV-SGA were higher than those found with NL-FEA. However, the strains recorded by NL-FEA did not differ significantly (P<.05) from the strains recorded by EV-SGA. CONCLUSION: Considering the complex biomechanical behavior of human hard and soft tissues, EV-SGA and NL-FEA did not suggest inconsistency in the detection of the quality of strains. Further, the methods provided comparable values for the quantification of strains on implants supporting maxillary overdentures.

Stability of locking and conventional 2.0-mm miniplate/screw systems after sagittal split ramus osteotomy: finite element analysis.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the mechanical stresses over the bone and hardware after sagittal split ramus osteotomy (SSRO) fixed with standard titanium or locking plate/screws using finite element analysis. STUDY DESIGN: A 3-dimensional finite element model of the mandible was created, and SSRO and 5 mm advancement was simulated on a computer model. The model was fixed with either 2.0-mm titanium conventional miniplate/screw or 2.0-mm titanium locking miniplate/screw system, and oblique 200 N bite force was applied. RESULTS: The values of von Mises stresses in the cortical layer of the distal segment using the locking plate system was higher. However, in the cortical layer of the proximal segment the stresses were higher at conventional plate system. In the spongiosa layers of both segments, stresses were higher with the conventional plate system. CONCLUSION: The locking miniplate/screw system spreads the load over the plate and screws and diminishes the amount of force transfered to each unit.

Effects of different inter-implant distances on the stress distribution around endosseous implants in posterior mandible: a 3D finite element analysis.

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of different inter-implant distances on stress distribution in the bone around the endosseous titanium implants under vertical, oblique and horizontal loads in the posterior mandibular edentulousim by finite element analysis (3D FEA). MATERIALS AND METHODS: 3D FEA models representing mandible and ITI implant (Straumann, Waldenburg, Switzerland) were simulated. The distances in-between the units were set at 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 cm. Vertical (V) 70 degrees N, 60 degrees oblique (BL) 35 degrees N in buccolingual direction and horizontal (MD) 14 degrees N in mesiodistal direction loads were applied to each of these designs. The principal stresses (tensile and compressive stress) on each model were calculated using MSC MARC finite element analyze solver software. RESULTS: The tensile stress (P(max)) values have been evaluated that they rose at the cervical region of buccal side when the inter-implant distances increased under V and BL loads and they diminished while the inter-implant distances decreased. In short inter-implant distances the compressive stress (P(min)) has been presented with increased values and found at the lingual surface of the cervical region. DISCUSSION: The results of this study indicated that the magnitude of the stress was influenced by complex factors such as the direction of loads and the distance between adjacent fixtures. The stress occurring around fixtures differs significantly with various types of inter-implant distance. CONCLUSION: The evaluation of tensile and compressive stresses for cortical and cancellous bone under V, MD and BL loading conditions in aspect of inter-implant distance shows; the 1.0 cm of inter-implant distance is the optimum distance for two fixture implantation.