Assessing the Nasal Midline in Rhinoplasty: How Good Are We?

BACKGROUND: The challenge of assessing nasal alignment and asymmetry can contribute to high revision rates in rhinoplasty. Comparing to a validated computer algorithm for nasal alignment, the accuracy with which plastic surgeons can assess deviation of the nasal midline from the facial midline was measured. METHODS: Using 20 faces from the Binghamton University 3-dimensional face database, deviation was evaluated from facial midline of the middorsal line for the upper, middle, and lower thirds of the nose. Surgeons were asked to assess extent of deviation from facial midline for each third of the nose using a linear analog scale. Spearman correlations were performed comparing the surgeons' results to the algorithm measurements. Eleven residents and 9 consultant surgeons were tested. RESULTS: Surgeons' assessment of deviation correlated poorly with the algorithm in the upper third ( r =0.32, P <0.0001) and moderately in the middle third ( r =0.49, P <0.0001) and lower third ( r =0.41, P <0.0001) of the nose. No difference in accuracy was found between trainee and consultant surgeons ( P =0.51), and greater experience (>10 y performing nasal surgery) did not significantly affect performance ( P =0.15). The effect of fatigue on the accuracy of assessment was found to be significant ( P =0.0009). CONCLUSIONS: Surgeons have difficulty in visually assessing the 3-dimensional nasal midline irrespective of experience, and surgeon fatigue was found to be adversely affect the accuracy of assessments.

Radiation therapy for the treatment of skin Kaposi sarcoma.

OBJECTIVE: Kaposi sarcoma (KS) lesions are purplish, reddish blue or dark brown/black macules, plaques or nodules which involve the skin and occasionally internal organs. Most patients with KS have a long indolent chronic course. METHODS: A retrospective review was undertaken for all KS skin patients treated with radiotherapy at a tertiary cancer centre from Jan. 2, 1999 to Dec. 31, 2014 (inclusive). RESULTS: A total of 47 patients with KS (43 classical, 0 African, 1 iatrogenic, 3 AIDS related) were seen in the multidisciplinary clinic. Out of this group, 17 patients (5 females and 12 males, 14 classical, 0 African, 0 iatrogenic, 3 AIDS related) with 97 KS skin sites were treated with local external beam radiotherapy. An additional 18 skin sites were treated with repeat radiotherapy. The radiotherapy dose ranged from 6 Gy in 1 fraction to 30 Gy in 10 fractions with the most common dose fractionation scheme being 8 Gy in 1 fraction or 20 Gy in 5 daily fractions. For the previously untreated KS sites, 87% responded to radiation [30% complete response (CR) and 57% partial response (PR)]. Thirteen percent of KS sites treated with radiation progressed. For the skin sites which were treated with repeat radiotherapy, 0% showed CRs, 50% PRs and 50% had continued progression. CONCLUSIONS: The majority of KS skin lesions (87%) responded to radiotherapy. Patients experience minimal side effects from the palliative radiation regimens used. KS skin lesions which progress despite radiation are unlikely to show CR with repeat radiotherapy. In our experience 50% of skin KS will have partial regression with repeat radiotherapy and 50% will have continued progression.