[Radiographs for the assessment of bone loss around implants. Exploring the potential]. / Röntgenopnamen voor het vaststellen van botverlies rond implantaten. Een exploratie van de mogelijkheden.

Twelve per cent of oral implants fail due to the loss of bone within 15 years after implantation. If bone loss is detected early, measures can be taken which increase the success rate of implants. To monitor implants, radiographs are made regularly. Generally, the loss of marginal bone level is measured on the radiographs. An alternative method is based on the subtraction ofradiographs. The authors applied subtraction to non-standardized panoramic radiographs of patients with implants. Bone loss around the implants could be rendered visible, at least on the level of patient groups. For individuals, no accurate method exists to render bone loss around implants visible. For the early recognition of bone loss around implants, intra-oral radiographs are preferred above panoramic radiographs. It is also important to maintain the same exposure time and projection geometry.

Sparseness of the trabecular pattern on dental radiographs: visual assessment compared with semi-automated measurements.

OBJECTIVE: In diagnostic imaging; human perception is the most prominent, yet least studied, source of error. A better understanding of image perception will help to improve diagnostic performance. This study focuses on the perception of coarseness of trabecular patterns on dental radiographs. Comparison of human vision with machine vision should yield knowledge on human perception. METHOD: In a study on identifying osteoporotic patients, dental radiographs were made from 505 post-menopausal women aged 45-70 years. Intra-oral radiographs of the lower and upper jaws were made. Five observers graded the trabecular pattern as dense, sparse or mixed. The five gradings were combined into a single averaged observer score per jaw. The radiographs were scanned and a region of interest (ROI) was indicated on each. The ROIs were processed with image analysis software measuring 25 image features. Pearson correlation and multiple linear regression were used to compare the averaged observer score with the image features. RESULTS: 14 image features correlated significantly with the observer judgement for both jaws. The strongest correlation was found for the average grey value in the ROI. Other features, describing that osteoporotic patients have fewer but bigger marrow spaces than controls, correlated less with the sparseness of the trabecular pattern than a rather crude measure for structure such as the average grey value. CONCLUSION: Human perception of the sparseness of trabecular patterns is based more on average grey values of the ROI than on geometric details within the ROI.

Prediction of osteoporosis with dental radiographs and age.

OBJECTIVES: In this study age and the trabecular pattern present on dental radiographs were used to predict the presence of osteoporosis. The objective was to evaluate the contribution of the trabecular pattern to the prediction. METHODS: In this project, 671 women between 45 and 71 years of age were recruited. Medical history was obtained and dental radiographs were made. Bone mineral density (BMD) was measured at three sites to assess the presence of osteoporosis according to the World Health Organization criteria. The radiographs were subjected to image analysis methods yielding measurements of the trabecular pattern. Thereafter, discriminant analysis was used to predict the presence of osteoporosis by means of the trabecular pattern and age. Sensitivity and specificity of age and the trabecular pattern were compared. Also, it was checked whether the inclusion of the trabecular pattern improved the sensitivity and specificity that were obtained when only age was used as the predictor. RESULTS: The sensitivity and specificity of the trabecular pattern present on dental radiographs were almost equal to those of age. However, combining age with the trabecular pattern increased the sensitivity from 0.71 to 0.75 and the specificity from 0.72 to 0.78; the latter increase was statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: The trabecular pattern predicts the presence of osteoporosis just as well as age does. When combining the trabecular pattern with age, the sensitivity and specificity increased. Only the latter increase was statistically significant.

Selecting regions of interest on intraoral radiographs for the prediction of bone mineral density.

OBJECTIVES: A previous study showed that the trabecular pattern on dental radiographs correlates with femoral and spinal bone mineral density (BMD). The objective of this study was to determine if the correlation is affected by the size and location of the region of interest (ROI). METHODS: In a European research project on osteoporosis, BMD was measured at the left hip and the lumbar spine of 525 women. From all subjects, intraoral radiographs were made of the premolar region in the upper and lower jaws. Two ROIs were indicated manually on each scanned image. The smallest region involved only trabecular bone and the largest also included parts of the neighbouring teeth. The ROIs were subjected to automatic image analysis, yielding 26 measurements per ROI. Stepwise linear regression was used to predict femoral and spinal BMD. RESULTS: Inner and outer regions predicted BMD equally well. The radiographs of lower and upper jaw also predicted BMD equally well. Combining inner and outer regions did not improve the prediction of femoral and spinal BMD, but combining lower and upper jaws did. CONCLUSIONS: This study shows that it is possible to include parts of neighbouring teeth in the ROI used to assess the trabecular pattern and predict BMD. This simplifies the process of selecting the ROIs because no efforts have to be made to exclude neighbouring teeth. Combining ROIs of lower and upper jaws significantly improves the prediction of BMD.

Spatial orientation in bone samples and Young's modulus.

Bone mass is the most important determinant of the mechanical strength of bones, and spatial structure is the second. In general, the spatial structure and mechanical properties of bones such as the breaking strength are direction dependent. The mean intercept length (MIL) and line frequency deviation (LFD) are two methods for quantifying directional aspects of the spatial structure of bone. Young's modulus is commonly used to describe the stiffness of bone, which is also a direction-dependent mechanical property. The aim of this article is to investigate the relation between MIL and LFD on one hand and Young's modulus on the other. From 11 human mandibular condyles, 44 samples were taken and scanned with high-resolution computer tomography equipment (micro-CT). For each sample the MIL and LFD were determined in 72602 directions distributed evenly in 3D space. In the same directions Young's modulus was determined by means of the stiffness tensor that had been determined for each sample by finite element analysis. To investigate the relation between the MIL and LFD on one hand and Young's modulus on the other, multiple regression was used. On average the MIL accounted for 69% of the variance in Young's modulus in the 44 samples and the LFD accounted for 72%. The average percentage of variance accounted for increased to 80% when the MIL was combined with the LFD to predict Young's modulus. Obviously MIL and LFD to some extent are complementary with respect to predicting Young's modulus. It is known that directional plots of the MIL tend to be ellipses or ellipsoids. It is speculated that ellipsoids are not always sufficient to describe Young's modulus of a bone sample and that the LFD partly compensates for this.

Osteoporosis and the general dental practitioner: reliability of some digital dental radiological measures.

OBJECTIVES: Dental radiographs are relatively inexpensive and are regularly made of a large fraction of the adult population; therefore, they represent an enormous potential as a screening tool for osteoporosis. Monitoring the population by means of dual X-ray absorptiometry (DXA), which is currently the most accepted method for diagnosing osteoporosis, involves enormous costs and facilities. In previous studies, it was shown that the radiographic trabecular pattern shows correlations with the bone mineral density (BMD) as measured by DXA. The objective of this study was to assess the reproducibility of the quantitative analysis of the trabecular pattern on dental radiographs. METHODS: Six regions of interest were selected manually on three digital radiographic images of 20 women. This process was performed 10 times resulting in 1200 image samples. For each image sample 26 parameters were measured. The reliability of the parameters was evaluated by means of Cronbach's alpha. RESULTS: Of the values of Cronbach's alpha 83% is at least 0.9 and 99% is at least 0.8. CONCLUSIONS: The measurements of the parameters used in this study are very reproducible. Therefore, the manual selection of the regions of interest does not introduce large amounts of noise. The imaging parameters potentially offer an accurate tool for the prediction of BMD values.

Prediction of bone mineral density with dental radiographs.

There is consensus to use the bone mineral density (BMD) for the operational definition of the degree of osteoporosis and the risk of osteoporotic fractures. Dual X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) is the common technique to determine BMD. Because of high costs and limited availability of DXA equipment it is worthwhile to look for alternative diagnostic techniques. As part of a larger study, the Osteodent project, we investigated if the trabecular pattern on dental radiographs can be used to predict BMD and to identify the subjects with osteoporosis and increased risk of osteoporotic fractures. In four clinical centers 671 women with an average age of 55 years were recruited. BMD values were measured by DXA equipment at the femoral neck, total hip, and spine. One panoramic and two intraoral radiographs were made. From 525 women a complete set of BMD values and radiographs was obtained. Four regions of interest on the radiographs were selected manually and then processed automatically. On all regions of interest mean and standard deviation of the gray values were measured and several features describing the shape of the binarized trabecular pattern. Multiple regression was used to predict BMD of total hip and spine by means of the radiographic measurements combined with age. It was found that age accounts for 10% of the variation in total hip BMD and 14% of the variation in spinal BMD. When all measurements on the dental radiographs are used the explained variation increases to 22% and 23%. The areas under the ROC curves are comparable to those of commonly used screening instruments for osteoporosis. It is concluded that prediction of DXA measurements of BMD by means of quantitative analysis of the trabecular pattern on dental radiographs is feasible.

A sensitive method for measuring spatial orientation in bone structures.

OBJECTIVES: This article introduces the newly developed line frequency deviation (LFD) method for measuring the orientation of the trabecular structure and shows that it is more sensitive than the mean intercept length (MIL) method that is commonly used. METHODS: The LFD method, which has been developed to measure the orientation of bone on two-dimensional X-ray images, was expanded to handle three-dimensional shapes. For the purpose of comparison, both the LFD and the MIL methods were applied to micro CT scans of 24 trabecular bone samples as well as to 24 simple synthetic samples. LFD and MIL values were calculated in various directions and collected in polar plots. Next, the anisotropy was quantified by calculating the coefficient of variation as well as by fitting ellipsoids through the plots. RESULTS: The MIL method yielded smooth rather spherical ellipsoidal polar plots with almost no sensitivity for changes in structure. The LFD method yielded more slender polar plots and more sensitivity for geometrical changes. The LFD method yielded significantly more anistropy and larger variation in anisotropy. CONCLUSIONS: The LFD method is a more sensitive descriptor of spatial orientation of bone structures than the MIL method.

An efficient filling algorithm for counting regions.

Region filling has many applications in computer graphics and image analysis. Some region filling tasks can be performed by fast scan line filling algorithms. Other region filling tasks require seed filling algorithms which are more general but slower. This paper introduces a seed filling algorithm that is designed to count regions irrespective of their shape. The method is described and its performance is compared with three alternative algorithms by applying them to a collection of 34 test images. The four methods showed complete agreement with respect to the counted numbers of regions. The proposed method was found to be fastest and requiring least memory.

Fractal properties of bone.

OBJECTIVE: To introduce the applications of fractal analysis of bone in medical imaging in general and dental radiographs in particular. RESULTS: Various methods for measuring fractal dimension have been used to compare normal with osteoporotic bone with contradictory results. This disparity may be attributed to differences in the anatomical sites studied and differences in methods used to obtain the 2D images. However, differences in methods used to measure fractal dimension can also be responsible. CONCLUSION: When fractal dimension is used to study bone it must be remembered that all stages in the analytical chain have an impact on the results. Thus, to obtain more conclusive results, studies on the fractal dimension of bone should be carefully designed and individual methods thoroughly evaluated.

Effect of noise on the compressibility and diagnostic accuracy for caries detection of digital bitewing radiographs.

OBJECTIVES: To determine the effect of noise on the compressibility and the diagnostic accuracy for caries detection of digital bitewing radiographs. METHODS: Bitewing radiographs of patients were obtained with a storage phosphor (Digora, Soredex, Helsinki, Finland) and compressed at different JPEG compression levels (2, 27, 53 and 128). A just noticeable difference study was performed to select a compression level to study the added noise effect. Gaussian noise was added at low, medium, and high levels to both the original and compressed images. Seven observers examined the selected approximal surfaces to identify the caries depth. ROC analysis was performed together with ANOVA at P = 0.05. RESULTS: The compressibility of the images decreased as the noise level increased. ROC analysis revealed no significant difference between the original and compressed images within the same noise level (P > 0.06). With added noise compressed/decompressed images had a higher Az than the corresponding original images. CONCLUSIONS: JPEG compression at level 27 can be used without a significant deterioration in diagnostic accuracy. Compression at this level seemed to reduce the effect of noise to some extent.

Agreement between radiographic and photographic trabecular patterns.

PURPOSE: It has been hypothesized that photographs can facilitate the interpretation of the radiographic characteristics of trabecular bone. The reliability of these photographic and radiographic approaches has been determined, as have various agreements between the two approaches and their correlations with biomechanical characteristics. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Fourteen vertebral bodies were obtained at autopsy from 6 women and 8 men aged 22-76 years. Photographs (n = 28) and radiographs (n = 28) were taken of midsagittal slices from the third lumbar vertebra. The radiographs and photographs were digitized and the geometric properties of the trabecular architecture were then determined with a digital image analysis technique. Information on the compressive strength and ash density of the vertebral body was also available. RESULTS: The geometric properties of both radiographs and photographs could be measured with a high degree of reliability (Cronbach's alpha > 0.85). Agreement between the radiographic and photographic approaches was mediocre as only the radiographic measurements showed significant correlations (p < 0.05) with the biomechanical characteristics. We suggest that optical phenomena may result in the insignificant correlations between the photographs and the biomechanical characteristics. CONCLUSION: For digital image processing, radiography offers a superior description of the architecture of trabecular bone to that offered by photography.

Radiographic assessment of changes in marginal bone around endosseous implants supporting mandibular overdentures.

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the reliability of a new method for quantification of radiographic changes in the marginal bone around implants. METHODS: Three groups of seven patients treated with an overdenture supported by two endosseous implants (Brnemark, n = 7 patients; IMZ, n = 7 patients; ITI Bonefit, n = 7 patients) were selected. Six weeks after loading the implants, radiographs were obtained using the long cone technique and an aiming device, scanned and digitized. Two observers measured the height and area of the peri-implant bone defects twice. The difference between measurements was statistically analysed using paired t-tests. RESULTS: There were small differences in interobserver error for the Brnemark implant system (P < 0.05), but no significant differences for the IMZ and ITI Bonefit. There were no significant difference in intraobserver error with any of the three implant systems (P > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The newly developed technique by measuring the area of the defect overcomes some drawbacks of existing techniques for quantification of peri-implant bone loss in the mandible.

Comparison of two methods for measuring orientation.

At the Department of Dental Radiology of ACTA, the line fraction deviation (LFD) method was developed to measure orientation on radiographic trabecular patterns. This article explains the measurement of the LFD index of orientation in a downscaled model. When investigations began to produce noteworthy results, the need for deeper understanding of the method and the resulting diagrams increased. Because it had previously been applied on rather complex patterns originating from bone it seemed worthwhile to study simpler images as well, which might yield a more intuitive understanding of the diagrams. Moreover, it seemed useful to compare the new LFD method with the well-accepted mean intercept length (MIL) method. Fifty images originating from cancellous bone structures and 25 drawings were analyzed. The results show that the MIL method tends to produce ellipses (not only on images originating from bone), and also that the LFD method is more sensitive to anisotropy.

The radiographic trabecular pattern of hips in patients with hip fractures and in elderly control subjects.

Due to the increasing number of osteoporotic fractures of hip, spine, and wrist there is a growing need for methods to track down the subjects with inferior bone structure and to monitor the effects of therapeutic measures. This study aims at a noninvasive diagnostic tool, deriving architectural properties of trabecular bone from in vivo measurements on plane radiographic films. Pelvic radiographs of the nonfractured hips of 81 patients with hip fractures and of the right hips of 74 controls were studied. The regions of interest, 2 x 2 cm2, located in the femoral neck, were sampled and digitized with a video camera connected to an image analysis system. Several geometrical and directional measurements were made. The measurements were evaluated by statistical comparison with fracture risk, gender, and Singh index. By discriminant analysis, type of fracture, as well as gender and Singh index could be predicted correctly for 58% of the subjects, whereas guessing would be correct in only 8%. It was found that the geometrical parameters discriminate between hips of controls and patients. With respect to the directional measurements associations were found with gender and Singh index. Although the new parameters assess fracture risk less accurately than bone density measurements, some parameters suggest by their behavior that they are relevant with respect to femoral bone architecture and its mechanical behavior. Although interpretation of the measurements in histological concepts requires methods that have been reported in literature only recently, it is concluded that digital analysis of the radiographic trabecular pattern is an interesting option to increase the diagnostic yield of plane film radiographs and to study the structure of bone in vivo.

A radiographic method for measuring radiation dose based on beam quality.

OBJECTIVES: To develop a radiographic method for measuring radiation dose based on beam quality for inexpensive postal surveys of general dental practitioners. METHODS: Different beam qualities were simulated to expose a commercially available film (X-Omat MA 18 x 22.4 cm, Ready Pack, Kodak Pathe, Paris, France). Density and contrast curves were fitted by means of 4th-degree polynomial functions. The curves were used to estimate beam quality (as the first HVL) and radiation dose in air for 22 different dental X-ray machines by means of linear interpolation. These estimations were compared with the measurements obtained with the NERO system and an ionization chamber (paired t-test). RESULTS: No significant differences were found between the radiographic and the conventional methods in determining beam quality and radiation dose. CONCLUSIONS: The radiographic method can be used to determine beam quality and radiation dose of dental X-ray machines from a single exposure. The radiographic method is simple and inexpensive and causes a minimum of disruption to the dental practice.

Reliability of an image analysis system for quantifying the radiographic trabecular pattern.

A reliability evaluation technique was used to examine the reliability of an image analysis system of the trabecular pattern and to determine the contribution of three possible sources of error variance. Two series of radiographs were taken of 14 lumbar vertebral slices (28 radiographs). Every radiograph was placed on a viewing box for digitization four times by a single operator (112 positions of radiographs) and from every position of a radiograph an area of 15 mm x 15 mm was digitized twice (224 samples for analysis). Ten geometrical characteristics of the trabecular pattern were studied and its orientation was analyzed in 12 directions. Reliability was determined by calculating Cronbach's alpha. This design enabled dividing the measurement error (1-alpha) into fractions associated with the X-ray procedure, the operator and the system. Using this reliability evaluation technique, it was found that the orientation variables are more reliable than the geometric variables. It was found that effort to increase the reliability should be directed toward improving the technical procedure of this image analysis system. Also, repeated measurements will increase the reliability. The number of repeated measurements based on a desired reliability can be calculated. This procedure of evaluation gives the opportunity to select a source of error variance which have to be reduced to increase reliability most effectively.

Orientation of the trabecular pattern of the distal radius around the menopause.

The trabecular pattern depicted on radiographs of the distal radius of women around the menopause is analysed by a new method to measure orientation. It is shown that the trabecular pattern on radiographs of the distal radius is aligned preferentially along the axial direction and to a lesser extent along the transverse direction. Two minima of orientation are found at 60 degrees off the axial direction. A significant correlation is found between the average value of the orientation in the radius and the average lumbar bone mineral density. It is known that the bone mineral content decreases around the menopause. Previous reports on the present images describe several features that were found to be related to bone mineral content and to time. The orientation of the trabecular pattern, however, is found to be independent of time, at least during the two years of the investigation. Therefore, it is concluded that the orientation of the radiographic trabecular pattern tends to remain stable even if some features of the pattern evolve. Previous studies on radiographs of the radius of children and elderly women and men provide evidence for the tendency of orientation to remain stable not only in women around the menopause, but also in men and women during the entire adult life.

Impact of scale standardization on images of digital radiography systems.

OBJECTIVES: To test the effect of altering image size on diagnostic quality. METHODS: Endodontic files, size 10 and 15 were prepared to full root length and 1.5 mm short, in upper and lower molars and premolars. Digital images of the Sidexis (S) and Visualix/Vixa (V) system were reduced in size to Digora (D) scale, and the D images were enlarged to S scale. ROC analysis was performed and data analysed with MANOVA statistics. RESULTS: Assessment of root canal length with file size 10 was less accurate for the S images reduced in size, compared with the original S images (P < 0.011). All other differences were not significant (P > 0.081). CONCLUSIONS: Relevant diagnostic information may be lost when images are reduced in size. Therefore, for optimal presentation, the smaller images should be enlarged rather than the larger ones reduced.

Relations between radiographic trabecular pattern and biomechanical characteristics of human vertebrae.

PURPOSE: Relations between the radiographic trabecular pattern and the biomechanical characteristics of bone were studied. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The material comprised L2 and L3 vertebral bodies of 14 individuals (aged 22-76 years; 6 women and 8 men). Compressive strength and ash density of the complete L2 vertebral body were determined. Of the L3 vertebral body, ash density and compressive strength in both horizontal and vertical directions were measured on cylinders of merely trabecular bone. Radiographs were taken of a midsagittal slice of L3 vertebrae. They were digitized to measure trabecular bone geometry and orientation. The procedure was repeated several times to obtain reliable measures. RESULTS: The radiographic trabecular pattern was significantly related to compressive strength, ash density and age. One of the radiographic geometric features in particular seems to offer information concerning the structural integrity of the trabecular architecture. CONCLUSION: Analysis of the radiographic trabecular pattern appears to be a promising technique for prediction of trabecular bone strength.