Affinity ranking of antibodies using flow cytometry: application in antibody phage display-based target discovery.

Application of antibody phage display to the identification of cell surface antigens with restricted expression patterns is often complicated by the inability to demonstrate specific binding to a certain cell type. The specificity of an antibody can only be properly assessed when the antibody is of sufficient high affinity to detect low-density antigens on cell surfaces. Therefore, a robust and simple assay for the prediction of relative antibody affinities was developed and compared to data obtained using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) technology. A panel of eight anti-CD46 antibody fragments with different affinities was selected from phage display libraries and reformatted into complete human IgG1 molecules. SPR was used to determine K(D) values for these antibodies. The association and dissociation of the antibodies for binding to CD46 expressed on cell surfaces were analysed using FACS-based assays. We show that ranking of the antibodies based on FACS data correlates well with ranking based on K(D) values as measured by SPR and can therefore be used to discriminate between high- and low-affinity antibodies. Finally, we show that a low-affinity antibody may only detect high expression levels of a surface marker while failing to detect lower expression levels of this molecule, which may lead to a false interpretation of antibody specificity.

A proteomic approach to tumour target identification using phage display, affinity purification and mass spectrometry.

Tumour-associated cell surface markers are potential targets for antibody-based therapies. We have obtained a panel of myeloid cell binding single chain variable fragments (scFv) by applying phage display selection on myeloid cell lines followed by a selection round on freshly isolated acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) blasts using flow cytometry. To identify the target antigens, the scFv were recloned and expressed in an IgG(1) format and tested for their ability to immunoprecipitate cell surface proteins. The IgGs that reacted with distinct cell membrane extractable proteins were used in large-scale affinity purification of the target antigen followed by mass-spectrometry-based identification. Well-characterised cell surface antigens, such as leukocyte antigen-related receptor protein tyrosine phosphatase (LAR PTP) and activated leukocyte adhesion molecule (ALCAM) in addition to several unknown proteins, like ATAD3A, were identified. These experiments demonstrate that phage antibody selection in combination with affinity chromatography and mass spectrometry can be exploited successfully to identify novel antibody target molecules on malignant cells.

C-type lectin-like molecule-1: a novel myeloid cell surface marker associated with acute myeloid leukemia.

Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) has a poor prognosis due to treatment-resistant relapses. A humanized anti-CD33 antibody (Mylotarg) showed a limited response rate in relapsed AML. To discover novel AML antibody targets, we selected a panel of single chain Fv fragments using phage display technology combined with flow cytometry on AML tumor samples. One selected single chain Fv fragment broadly reacted with AML samples and with myeloid cell lineages within peripheral blood. Expression cloning identified the antigen recognized as C-type lectin-like molecule-1 (CLL-1), a previously undescribed transmembrane glycoprotein. CLL-1 expression was analyzed with a human anti-CLL-1 antibody that was generated from the single chain Fv fragment. CLL-1 is restricted to the hematopoietic lineage, in particular to myeloid cells present in peripheral blood and bone marrow. CLL-1 is absent on uncommitted CD34(+)/CD38(-) or CD34(+)/CD33(-) stem cells and present on subsets of CD34(+)/CD38(+) or CD34(+)/CD33(+) progenitor cells. CLL-1 is not expressed in any other tissue. In contrast, analysis of primary AMLs demonstrated CLL-1 expression in 92% (68 of 74) of the samples. As an AML marker, CLL-1 was able to complement CD33, because 67% (8 of 12) of the CD33(-) AMLs expressed CLL-1. CLL-1 showed variable expression (10-60%) in CD34(+) cells in chronic myelogenous leukemia and myelodysplastic syndrome but was absent in 12 of 13 cases of acute lymphoblastic leukemia. The AML reactivity combined with the restricted expression on normal cells identifies CLL-1 as a novel potential target for AML treatment.