Fibrillogenesis in dense collagen solutions: a physicochemical study.

Fibrillogenesis, the formation of collagen fibrils, is a key factor in connective tissue morphogenesis. To understand to what extent cells influence this process, we systematically studied the physicochemistry of the self-assembly of type I collagen molecules into fibrils in vitro. We report that fibrillogenesis in solutions of type I collagen, in a high concentration range close to that of living tissues (40-300 mg/ml), yields strong gels over wide pH and ionic strength ranges. Structures of gels were described by combining microscopic observations (transmission electron microscopy) with small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering analysis, and the influence of concentration, pH, and ionic strength on the fibril size and organization was evaluated. The typical cross-striated pattern and the corresponding small-angle X-ray scattering 67-nm diffraction peaks were visible in all conditions in the pH 6 to pH 12 range. In reference conditions (pH 7.4, ionic strength=150 mM, 20 degrees C), collagen concentration greatly influences the overall macroscopic structure of the resultant fibrillar gels, as well as the morphology and structure of the fibrils themselves. At a given collagen concentration, increasing the ionic strength from 24 to 261 mM produces larger fibrils until the system becomes biphasic. We also show that fibrils can form in acidic medium (pH approximately 2.5) at very high collagen concentrations, beyond 150 mg/ml, which suggests a possible cholesteric-to-smectic phase transition. This set of data demonstrates how simple physicochemical parameters determine the molecular organization of collagen. Such an in vitro model allows us to study the intricate process of fibrillogenesis in conditions of molecular packing close to that which occurs in biological tissue morphogenesis.

Cooperative ordering of collagen triple helices in the dense state.

Extracellular matrixes such as bone, skin, cornea, and tendon have ordered structures comprised for the most part of collagen, an elongated protein of well-defined dimensions and composition. Here we show how the cooperative ordering of collagen triple helices in the dense fluid state is exploited to produce dense ordered collagen matrixes. The spontaneous formation of a birefringent phase occurs at critical concentrations that increase from 50-60 to 80-85 mg/mL as the acetic acid concentration of the solvent increases from 5 to 500 mM. We studied by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) the local liquidlike positional order across the isotropic/anisotropic phase transition by unwinding the cholesteric phase with moderate shearing stress. Interparticle scattering gives rise to a broad interference peak. The average distance between triple helices, dav, is thus estimated and decreases linearly as a function of phi-1/2 from 12.7 +/- 0.9 nm (22.5 mg/mL) to 5.0 +/- 0.6 nm (166.4 mg/mL). Equilibrium concentrations and the order parameter of the nematic phase agree reasonably well with theoretical predictions for semiflexible macromolecules. Striated fibrils with a high degree of alignment were obtained by fine-tuning the delicately balanced electrostatic interactions, which yielded strong elastic gels with a hierarchical organization very similar to that of major biological tissues. Typical Bragg reflections corresponding to the 67 nm period characteristic of collagen fibrils in biological tissues were recorded by SAXS with ordered collagen matrixes reconstituted in vitro.

Liquid crystalline ordering of procollagen as a determinant of three-dimensional extracellular matrix architecture.

The precise molecular mechanisms that determine the three-dimensional architectures of tissues remain largely unknown. Within tissues rich in extracellular matrix, collagen fibrils are frequently arranged in a tissue-specific manner, as in certain liquid crystals. For example, the continuous twist between fibrils in compact bone osteons resembles a cholesteric mesophase, while in tendon, the regular, planar undulation, or "crimp", is akin to a precholesteric mesophase. Such analogies suggest that liquid crystalline organisation plays a role in the determination of tissue form, but it is hard to see how insoluble fibrils could spontaneously and specifically rearrange in this way. Collagen molecules, in dilute acid solution, are known to form nematic, precholesteric and cholesteric phases, but the relevance to physiological assembly mechanisms is unclear. In vivo, fibrillar collagens are synthesised in soluble precursor form, procollagens, with terminal propeptide extensions. Here, we show, by polarized light microscopy of highly concentrated (5-30 mg/ml) viscous drops, that procollagen molecules in physiological buffer conditions can also develop long-range nematic and precholesteric liquid crystalline ordering extending over 100 microm(2) domains, while remaining in true solution. These observations suggest the novel concept that supra-fibrillar tissue architecture is determined by the ability of soluble precursor molecules to form liquid crystalline arrays, prior to fibril assembly.

Structural aspects of fish skin collagen which forms ordered arrays via liquid crystalline states.

The ability of acid-soluble type I collagen extracts from Soleidae flat fish to form ordered arrays in condensed phases has been compared with data for calf skin collagen. Liquid crystalline assemblies in vitro are optimized by preliminary treatment of the molecular population with ultrasounds. This treatment requires the stability of the fish collagen triple helicity to be controlled by X-ray diffraction and differential scanning calorimetry and the effect of sonication to be evaluated by viscosity measurements and gel electrophoresis. The collagen solution in concentrations of at least 40 mg ml(-1) showed in polarized light microscopy birefringent patterns typical of precholesteric phases indicating long-range order within the fluid collagen phase. Ultrastructural data, obtained after stabilization of the liquid crystalline collagen into a gelated matrix, showed that neutralized acid-soluble fish collagen forms cross-striated fibrils, typical of type I collagen, following sine wave-like undulations in precholesteric domains. These ordered geometries, approximating in vivo situations, give interesting mechanical properties to the material.

Banded patterns in liquid crystalline phases of type I collagen: relationship with crimp morphology in connective tissue architecture.

Solutions of type I acid soluble collagen were studied in light and electron microscopy at concentrations over 40 mg/ml. Banded patterns spontaneously emerge in samples observed between crossed polars between slide and coverslip. The textures are interpreted as precholesteric, appearing at the transition between the isotropic phases, due to random molecular order, and the cholesteric phase corresponding to a highly organized three-dimensional structure. Type I collagen banded patterns correspond to regular undulations of the molecular directions with an observed periodicity in the range of 1 to 10 microm. This interpretation is verified by ultrastructural analysis of precholesteric samples gelled under ammonium vapors. Results are discussed in regard to banded patterns described either within synthetic polymer systems or within collagen extracellular matrices. Self-assembled liquid crystalline phases of collagen generate crimp morphologies. Their possible relationship with early secretion steps in the development of connective tissues is discussed.

Twisted liquid crystalline supramolecular arrangements in morphogenesis.

Supramolecular assemblies following liquid crystalline cholesteric geometries have been described in biological systems from optical properties observed in polarized-light microscopy and structural data obtained in electron microscopy. Major biological macromolecules are discussed, including structural polymers of the extracellular matrix, genetic material in nuclei and chromosomes, and proteins of the cytoplasm. The liquid crystalline assembly properties of biological polymers have been demonstrated by experiments in vitro with molecules at basic structural levels, such as molecular chains of cellulose and chitin, triple helices of collagen, and double helices of DNA, and also with entities at higher states of organization as they appear in cells and tissues, such as cellulose and chitin crystallites, and collagen fibrils. It appears that the building of cellular and extracellular edifices implies self-ordering processes of the liquid crystalline type and that the study of these mesomorphic states will help resolve basic questions about the structure and morphogenesis of densely packed biological structures.

Stabilization of fluid cholesteric phases of collagen to ordered gelated matrices.

Liquid crystalline assemblies occur spontaneously in highly concentrated solutions of type I acid-soluble calf skin collagen. The degree of order, identified by optical microscopy in polarized light, varies from a random distribution of molecules at low concentrations to highly organized structures as the concentration increases up to 80 mg/ml. Ultrastructural studies using classical techniques of chemical fixation are inappropriate for liquid crystalline phases due to the absence of stable links maintaining their three-dimensional order. In order to analyse the collagen liquid crystalline phases by electron microscopy the viscous preparations were stabilized under ammonia vapour. Observations of the gels in polarized light indicated that the liquid crystalline order, established at acidic pH in a sol state, persists at neutral pH in a gel state. Transmission electron microscopic observations allow us to validate the geometrical model interpreted from observations in polarizing microscopy, that is continuously twisting orientations in cholesteric phases characterized by typical series of arced patterns when viewed in oblique sections. A significant result is that the ultrastructure of the stabilized liquid crystalline collagen faithfully mimics fibrillar patterns described in vivo in extracellular matrices. This strongly supports the hypothesis that liquid crystalline properties are involved in the morphogenesis of collagen matrices.

Liquid crystalline order of biopolymers in cuticles and bones.

Microscopic studies at different scales have shown that in biological tissues the three-dimensional arrangement of chitin-protein or of collagen fibrillar networks can follow the same spatial distributions as those described in certain liquid crystals. The present work reviews the structural analogies established between the dense fibrillar organic matrix found in two materials: crab cuticles and compact bones. In both systems mobile fringes are described in polarizing microscopy, periodic cleavage aspects in scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and arched patterns in transmission electron microscopy (TEM). In parallel to these structural data, results obtained in vitro are recalled which corroborate the relationship established between ordered arrays of biopolymers and liquid crystalline assembly principles, highly concentrated solutions of purified collagen molecules spontaneously form ordered assemblies characterized in polarizing microscopy as cholesteric phases. This particular state of matter joins both fluidity and order and could correspond to a transient state of collagen or chitin secretion, before the stiffening of these skeletal structures, bone or cuticle, by molecular cross-links and crystalline deposition.

Liquid crystallinity in condensed type I collagen solutions. A clue to the packing of collagen in extracellular matrices.

We recently described a new type of assembly of collagen molecules, forming typical liquid crystalline phases in highly concentrated solutions after sonication. The present work shows that intact 300 nm long collagen molecules also form cholesteric liquid crystalline domains, but the time required is much longer, several weeks instead of several days. Differential calorimetry and X-ray diffraction show that sonication does not alter the triple-helical structure of the collagen fragments. In the viscous solutions, observed between crossed polars in optical microscopy, the textures vary as a function of the concentration. Molecules first align near the air interface at the coverslip edge, then as the concentration increases by slow evaporation of the solvent, the birefringence extends inwards and liquid crystalline domains progressively appear. For concentrations estimated to be above 100 mg/ml, typical textures and defects of cholesteric phases are obtained, at lower concentrations zig-zag extinction patterns and banded patterns are observed; all these textures are described and interpreted. The cholesteric packing of collagen fibrils in various extracellular matrices is known, and the relationship that can be made between the ordered phases obtained with collagen molecules in vitro and the related geometrical structures observed between fibrils in vivo is thoroughly discussed.

Liquid crystalline phases of sonicated type I collagen.

The assembly properties of concentrated solutions of type I collagen molecules are compared before and after a 5-min sonication, breaking the 300-nm triple helices into short segments of about 20 nm, with a strong polydispersity. The collagen concentration of these solutions, sonicated or not, was increased up to 100 mg/ml by slow evaporation of the solvent. Whereas the non-sonicated solutions remain isotropic, the sonicated solutions transform after a few hours into a twisted liquid crystalline phase, well recognizable in polarizing microscopy. The evidence of a twisted assembly of collagen triple helices in vitro is new and relevant in a biological context since it was reported in various collagen matrices.

Twisted plywood architecture of collagen fibrils in human compact bone osteons.

Ultrathin sections of decalcified human compact bone, observed by transmission electron microscopy, reveal that collagen fibrils can be distributed in the form of a superimposed series of nested arcs. This characteristic pattern has never been interpreted in previous works on compact bone structure. We demonstrate, by goniometric observations at the ultrastructural level, that such series of nested arcs are a consequence of the "twisted plywood" architecture of collagen fibrils in the compact bone matrix. In the same specimens, an "orthogonal plywood" disposition of collagen fibrils is also observed; a transition exists between these two types of orders. We show that the "twisted plywood structure" accounts well for certain optical properties of osteons, observed in polarizing microscopy, described as "intermediate osteons." The particular geometry of collagen fibrils, leading to nested arcs in oblique sections, is analogous to the distribution of molecules in certain liquid crystals (called cholesteric liquid crystals). The principle of a liquid crystalline self-assembly of the collagen matrix in bone is therefore discussed.

Direct visualization of microtomy artefacts in sections of twisted fibrous extracellular matrices.

Twisted fibrous extracellular matrices observed in section often show alternating clear and dark bands. Three different methods of observation (high voltage electron microscopy, shadowing of thin sections and stereoscopic views) show the presence of ruffling effects and relief at the surface of crab cuticle sections. These effects appear uneven on both sides of the sections. As shown in a series of diagrams, the localization of the microtomy artefact is a function of the orientation of the cuticle laminae relative to the knife direction, and this creates variations in the position and the extent of the microtomy effect over each lamina. Confirmation of this analysis is obtained in a particular geometrical situation which appears in sections of tubercles in the crab cuticle where the twisted plywood stratification is deformed into a dome. By shadowing thin sections, perpendicular to the tubercle axis, nested crescents are visualized on the surface of the samples. All observations demonstrate that the clear and dark lamellae are due to a microtomy artefact which is a three-dimensional process, and not, as usually considered, due to chemical or physical variations in the structure.

Fine structure of the chitin-protein system in the crab cuticle.

The fine structure of the organic matrix of the shore crab cuticle (Carcinus maenas L.), observed in transmission electron microscopy, reveals three different levels of organization of the chitin-protein complex. The highest level corresponds to the 'twisted plywood' organization described by Bouligand (1972). Horizontal microfibrils, parallel to the cuticle plane, rotate progressively from one level to another. When viewed in oblique section this structure gives superimposed series of nested arcs, visible in light microscopy or at the lowest magnifications of the electron microscope, in all the chitin-protein layers. At the highest magnifications of the electron microscope and with the best resolution, when the ultrathin sections are exactly transverse to the microfibril, a constant pattern can be observed which consists of rods transparent to electrons, which are embedded in an electron-opaque matrix. In cross-section, these rods often form more or less hexagonal arrays. We call a microfibril one rod and the adjacent opaque material, and question the usual interpretation of the microfibril molecular structure. Between these two levels of organization, there is an intermediate level, which corresponds to the grouping of microfibrils. Microfibrils form a dense structure, with few free spaces in the membranous layer, the deepest and non-calcified layer of the cuticle. In other parts of the cuticle, microfibrils are grouped into fibrils of various diameters or form a reticulate structure, the free spaces of the organic matrix being occupied by mineral.

Calcification initiation sites in the crab cuticle: the interprismatic septa. An ultrastructural cytochemical study.

In the crab cuticle the interprismatic septa (IS), which correspond to imprints left in the cuticle by the margins of the epidermal cells, penetrate the twisted structure of the chitin-protein matrix. The ultrastructure and geometric relationship between the fibrous architecture and the pattern of the prisms is described. The cytochemical characterization of the IS, by pronase treatment and ruthenium red staining, supports the hypothesis that this material corresponds to cell-coat glycoproteins released in the cuticle during secretion of the organic matrix. Calcification begins after ecdysis in the external laminae of the pigmented layer and along the IS. The presence of cation-binding glycoproteins in the sites where calcification is initiated could induce the nucleation of the mineral phase by concentrating calcium. The extracellular distribution of carbonic anhydrase, which favours carbonate deposition, is observed on ultrathin sections over the IS.