Monitoring the kinetics of the pH-driven transition of the anthrax toxin prepore to the pore by biolayer interferometry and surface plasmon resonance.

Domain 2 of the anthrax protective antigen (PA) prepore heptamer unfolds and refolds during endosome acidification to generate an extended 100 Å ß barrel pore that inserts into the endosomal membrane. The PA pore facilitates the pH-dependent unfolding and translocation of bound toxin enzymic components, lethal factor (LF) and/or edema factor, from the endosome to the cytoplasm. We constructed immobilized complexes of the prepore with the PA-binding domain of LF (LFN) to monitor the real-time prepore to pore kinetic transition using surface plasmon resonance and biolayer interferometry (BLI). The kinetics of this transition increased as the solution pH was decreased from 7.5 to 5.0, mirroring acidification of the endosome. Once it had undergone the transition, the LFN-PA pore complex was removed from the BLI biosensor tip and deposited onto electron microscopy grids, where PA pore formation was confirmed by negative stain electron microscopy. When the soluble receptor domain (ANTRX2/CMG2) binds the immobilized PA prepore, the transition to the pore state was observed only after the pH was lowered to early (pH 5.5) or late (pH 5.0) endosomal pH conditions. Once the pore formed, the soluble receptor readily dissociated from the PA pore. Separate binding experiments with immobilized PA pores and the soluble receptor indicate that the receptor has a weakened propensity to bind to the transitioned pore. This immobilized anthrax toxin platform can be used to identify or validate potential antimicrobial lead compounds capable of regulating and/or inhibiting anthrax toxin complex formation or pore transitions.

Three dimensional structure of the anthrax toxin translocon-lethal factor complex by cryo-electron microscopy.

We have visualized by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) the complex of the anthrax protective antigen (PA) translocon and the N-terminal domain of anthrax lethal factor (LF(N) inserted into a nanodisc model lipid bilayer. We have determined the structure of this complex at a nominal resolution of 16 Å by single-particle analysis and three-dimensional reconstruction. Consistent with our previous analysis of negatively stained unliganded PA, the translocon comprises a globular structure (cap) separated from the nanodisc bilayer by a narrow stalk that terminates in a transmembrane channel (incompletely distinguished in this reconstruction). The globular cap is larger than the unliganded PA pore, probably due to distortions introduced in the previous negatively stained structures. The cap exhibits larger, more distinct radial protrusions, previously identified with PA domain three, fitted by elements of the NMFF PA prepore crystal structure. The presence of LF(N), though not distinguished due to the seven-fold averaging used in the reconstruction, contributes to the distinct protrusions on the cap rim volume distal to the membrane. Furthermore, the lumen of the cap region is less resolved than the unliganded negatively stained PA, due to the low contrast obtained in our images of this specimen. Presence of the LF(N) extended helix and N terminal unstructured regions may also contribute to this additional internal density within the interior of the cap. Initial NMFF fitting of the cryoEM-defined PA pore cap region positions the Phe clamp region of the PA pore translocon directly above an internal vestibule, consistent with its role in toxin translocation.

Assembly of anthrax toxin pore: lethal-factor complexes into lipid nanodiscs.

We have devised a procedure to incorporate the anthrax protective antigen (PA) pore complexed with the N-terminal domain of anthrax lethal factor (LFN ) into lipid nanodiscs and analyzed the resulting complexes by negative-stain electron microscopy. Insertion into nanodiscs was performed without relying on primary and secondary detergent screens. The preparations were relatively pure, and the percentage of PA pore inserted into nanodiscs on EM grids was high (∼43%). Three-dimensional analysis of negatively stained single particles revealed the LFN -PA nanodisc complex mirroring the previous unliganded PA pore nanodisc structure, but with additional protein density consistent with multiple bound LFN molecules on the PA cap region. The assembly procedure will facilitate collection of higher resolution cryo-EM LFN -PA nanodisc structures and use of advanced automated particle selection methods.

Three-dimensional structure of the anthrax toxin pore inserted into lipid nanodiscs and lipid vesicles.

A major goal in understanding the pathogenesis of the anthrax bacillus is to determine how the protective antigen (PA) pore mediates translocation of the enzymatic components of anthrax toxin across membranes. To obtain structural insights into this mechanism, we constructed PA-pore membrane complexes and visualized them by using negative-stain electron microscopy. Two populations of PA pores were visualized in membranes, vesicle-inserted and nanodisc-inserted, allowing us to reconstruct two virtually identical PA-pore structures at 22-A resolution. Reconstruction of a domain 4-truncated PA pore inserted into nanodiscs showed that this domain does not significantly influence pore structure. Normal mode flexible fitting of the x-ray crystallographic coordinates of the PA prepore indicated that a prominent flange observed within the pore lumen is formed by the convergence of mobile loops carrying Phe427, a residue known to catalyze protein translocation. Our results have identified the location of a crucial functional element of the PA pore and documented the value of combining nanodisc technology with electron microscopy to examine the structures of membrane-interactive proteins.

Classification and reconstruction of a heterogeneous set of electron microscopic images: a case study of GroEL-substrate complexes.

Image analysis methods were used to separate images of a large macromolecular complex, the chaperonin GroEL, in a preparation in which it is partially liganded to a nonnative protein substrate, glutamine synthetase. The relatively small difference ( approximately 6%) in size between the chaperonin in its free and complexed forms, and the absence of gross changes in overall conformation, made separation of the two types of particles challenging. Different approaches were evaluated and used for alignment and classification of images, both in two common projections and in three dimensions, yielding 2D averages and a 3D reconstruction. The results of 3D analysis describe the conformational changes effected by binding of this particular protein substrate and demonstrate the utility of 2D analysis as an indicator of structural change in this system.

Structural changes in GroEL effected by binding a denatured protein substrate.

In the absence of nucleotides or cofactors, the Escherichia coli chaperonin GroEL binds select proteins in non-native conformations, such as denatured glutamine synthetase (GS) monomers, preventing their aggregation and spontaneous renaturation. The nature of the GroEL-GS complexes thus formed, specifically the effect on the conformation of the GroEL tetradecamer, has been examined by electron microscopy. We find that specimens of GroEL-GS are visibly heterogeneous, due to incomplete loading of GroEL with GS. Images contain particles indistinguishable from GroEL alone, and also those with consistent identifiable differences. Side-views of the modified particles reveal additional protein density at one end of the GroEL-GS complex, and end-views display chirality in the heptameric projection not seen in the unliganded GroEL. The coordinate appearance of these two projection differences suggests that binding of GS, as representative of a class of protein substrates, induces or stabilizes a conformation of GroEL that differs from the unliganded chaperonin. Three-dimensional reconstruction of the GroEL-GS complex reveals the location of the bound protein substrate, as well as complex conformational changes in GroEL itself, both cis and trans with respect to the bound GS. The most apparent structural alterations are inward movements of the apical domains of both GroEL heptamers, protrusion of the substrate protein from the cavity of the cis ring, and a narrowing of the unoccupied opening of the trans ring.

Formation of proteasome-PA700 complexes directly correlates with activation of peptidase activity.

The proteolytic activity of the eukaryotic 20S proteasome is stimulated by a multisubunit activator, PA700, which forms both 1:1 and 2:1 complexes with the proteasome. Formation of the complexes is enhanced by an additional protein assembly called modulator, which also stimulates the enzymatic activity of the proteasome only in the presence of PA700. Here we show that the binding of PA700 to the proteasome is cooperative, as is the activation of the proteasome's intrinsic peptidase activity. Modulator increases the extent of complex formation and peptidase activation, while preserving the cooperative kinetics. Furthermore, the increase in activity is not linear with the number of PA700 assemblies bound to the proteasome, but rather with the number of proteasome-PA700 complexes, regardless of the PA700:proteasome stoichiometry. Hence the stimulation of peptidase activity is fully (or almost fully) effected by the binding of a single PA700 to the 20S proteasome. The stimulation of peptidase by modulator is explained entirely by the increased number of proteasome-PA700 complexes formed in its presence, rather than by any substantial direct stimulation of catalysis. These observations are consistent with a model in which PA700, either alone or assisted by modulator, promotes conformational changes in the proteasome that activate the catalytic sites and/or facilitate access of peptide substrates to these sites.

Structural and functional effects of PA700 and modulator protein on proteasomes.

Control and targeting of the proteolytic activity of the major intracellular protease, the proteasome, is accomplished by various regulatory protein complexes that may form higher-order assemblies with the proteasome. An activator of proteolytic activity, PA700, has been shown to have an ATP-dependent stimulatory effect on the peptidase activities of the proteasome, and another protein factor, the modulator, further enhances the effect of PA700. Here we show that the addition of PA700 endows the proteasome with the ability to cleave ubiquitinated proteins, a property associated with the previously isolated 26 S form of the proteasome. The modulator further stimulates this specific activity, without having any such effect on the proteasome alone. Using electron microscopy, we show that addition of PA700 causes the appearance of protein "caps" at one or both ends of proteasomes, forming structures that are indistinguishable from 26 S proteasomes. Quantitation of the numbers of uncapped, singly capped and doubly capped complexes indicates cooperativity in the association of PA700 with the two ends of the proteasome. Addition of modulator protein makes no further structural modification that is detectable by electron microscopy, but does cause an increase in the number of capped complexes visible at subsaturating concentrations of PA700. Hence PA700 converts the proteasome both functionally and structurally to the 26 S form, and the modulator promotes this transformation, apparently without stable association with the resulting complex.

The phage T4-coded DNA replication helicase (gp41) forms a hexamer upon activation by nucleoside triphosphate.

Sedimentation and high performance liquid chromatography studies show that the functional DNA replication helicase of bacteriophage T4 (gp41) exists primarily as a dimer at physiological protein concentrations, assembling from gp41 monomers with an association constant of approximately 10(6) M-1. Cryoelectron microscopy, analytical ultracentrifugation, and protein-protein cross-linking studies demonstrate that the binding of ATP or GTP drives the assembly of these dimers into monodisperse hexameric complexes, which redissociate following depletion of the purine nucleotide triphosphatase (PuTP) substrates by the DNA-stimulated PuTPase activity of the helicase. The hexameric state of gp41 can be stabilized for detailed study by the addition of the nonhydrolyzable PuTP analogs ATP gamma S and GTP gamma S and is not significantly affected by the presence of ADP, GDP, or single-stranded or forked DNA template constructs, although some structural details of the hexameric complex may be altered by DNA binding. Our results also indicate that the active gp41 helicase exists as a hexagonal trimer of asymmetric dimers, and that the hexamer is probably characterized by D3 symmetry. The assembly pathway of the gp41 helicase has been analyzed, and its structure and properties compared with those of other helicases involved in a variety of cellular processes. Functional implications of such structural organization are also considered.

Electron microscopy of the F1F0 ATP synthase: from structure to function.

The F1F0 ATP synthase is the large multisubunit complex which uses the proton gradient of energetically active membranes to synthesize ATP. While biochemical and genetic approaches have characterized the composition of the enzyme and elucidated many details of its mechanism and assembly, electron microscopy has been the tool of primary importance in determining the arrangement of the many subunits which comprise the F1F0. The highly cooperative catalytic mechanism is tightly coupled to transmembrane proton translocation in a separate and rather distant sector of the complex. An understanding of this intricate process and its control requires an appreciation of subunit interactions, starting with their locations relative to one another. Electron microscopy has provided most of the available structural information on the F1F0, and recent applications of cryo-electron microscopy have captured different functionally relevant configurations which may finally address longstanding questions about subunit rearrangements during the catalytic cycle.

Structure of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase and role of the gamma and epsilon subunits in coupling catalytic site and proton channeling functions.

The structure of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase has been studied by electron microscopy and a model developed in which the alpha and beta subunits of the F1 part are arranged hexagonally (in top view) alternating with one another and surrounding a central cavity of around 35 A at its widest point. The alpha and beta subunits are interdigitated in side view for around 60 A of the 90 A length of the molecule. The F1 narrows and has three-fold symmetry at the end furthest from the F0 part. The F1 is linked to F0 by a stalk approximately 45 A long and 25-30 A in diameter. The F0 part is mostly buried in the lipid bilayer. The gamma subunit provides a domain that extends into the central cavity of the F1 part. The gamma and epsilon subunits are in a different conformation when ATP + Mg2+ are present in catalytic sites than when ATP + EDTA are present. This is consistent with these two small subunits switching conformations as a function of whether or not phosphate is bound to the enzyme at the position of the gamma phosphate of ATP. We suggest that this switching is the key to the coupling of catalytic site events with proton translocation in the F0 part of the complex.

Epitope mapping of monoclonal antibodies to the Escherichia coli F1 ATPase alpha subunit in relation to activity effects and location in the enzyme complex based on cryoelectron microscopy.

The interaction of Escherichia coli F1 ATPase (ECF1) with several different monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) specific for the alpha subunit has been examined. The epitopes for each of the mAbs have been localized by using molecular biological approaches to generate fragments of the alpha subunit. The binding of several of the mAbs has also been examined by cryoelectron microscopy of ECF1 Fab complexes. One of the mAbs, alpha II, bound in the region Asn 109-Val 153 without affecting ATPase activity. Most of the mAbs bound in the C-terminal third of the alpha subunit. MAb alpha 1 bound between residues Gln 443 and Trp 513. This mAb activated ATPase activity and was visualized in cryoelectron microscopy, superimposed on the alpha subunit, indicating that the epitope was on the top or bottom of ECF1 in the hexagonal projection. Other mAbs to the C-terminus, including alpha D which also activated the enzyme, reacted between Gly 371 and Trp 513 but failed to bind to small overlapping fragments within this sequence. The epitopes for these mAbs are probably formed by the folded polypeptide which occurs only in Western analysis when long stretches of the alpha subunit are present, suggesting that the C-terminus of alpha is a self-folding domain. In cryoelectron microscopy, Fab fragments for alpha D were seen extending from the sides of the ECF1 complex in hexagonal projection.

Cryoelectron microscopic visualization of functional subassemblies of the bacteriophage T4 DNA replication complex.

A specific complex of proteins involved in bacteriophage T4 replication has been visualized by cryoelectron microscopy as distinctive structures in association with DNA. Formation of these structures, which we term "hash-marks" for their characteristic appearance in association with DNA, requires the presence of the T4 polymerase accessory proteins (the products of T4 genes 44, 45 and 62), ATP and appropriate DNA cofactors. ATP hydrolysis by the DNA-stimulated ATPase activity of the accessory proteins is required for visualization of the hash-mark structures. If ATP hydrolysis is stopped by chelation of Mg2+, by dilution with a non-hydrolyzable ATP analogue, or by exhaustion of the ATP supply, the DNA-associated structures disappear within seconds to minutes, indicating that they have a finite and relatively short lifetime. The labile nature of the structures makes their study by more conventional methods of electron microscopy, as well as by most other structural approaches, difficult if not impossible. Addition of T4 gene 32 protein increases the number of hash-mark structures, as well as increasing the rate of ATP hydrolysis. Using plasmid DNA in either a native (supercoiled) or enzymatically modified state, we have shown that nicked or gapped DNA is required as a cofactor for hash-mark formation. Stimulation of the ATPase activity of the accessory proteins has a similar cofactor requirement. These conditions for the formation and visualization of the structures parallel those required for the action of these complexes in promoting the enzymatic activity of the T4 DNA polymerase, as well as the transcription of late T4 genes. Substructure in the hash-marks has been examined by image analysis, which reveals a variation in the projected density of the subunits comprising the structures. The three-dimensional size of the hash-marks, modeled as a solid ellipsoid, is consistent with that of the gene 44/62 protein subcomplex. Density variations suggest an arrangement of subunits, either tetragonal or trigonal, viewed from a variety of angles about the DNA axis. The hash-mark structures often appear in clusters, even in DNA that has a single nick. We interpret this distribution as the result of one-dimensional translocation of the hash-marks along the DNA after their ATP-dependent initial association with, and injection into, the DNA at nicks or gaps.

Structure and assembly of the Escherichia coli transcription termination factor rho and its interaction with RNA. I. Cryoelectron microscopic studies.

Cryoelectron microscopy has been used to visualize the Escherichia coli transcription termination protein rho in a vitreously frozen state, without the use of strains, fixatives or other chemical perturbants. In the absence of RNA cofactor, a variety of structures are observed, reflecting the heterogeneity of complexes formed by rho at protein concentrations near the physiological range (3 to 10 microM). One of the most common structural motifs we see is a six-membered ring of rho subunits (present as either a closed or "notched" circle), which corresponds to the predominant hexameric association state of the protein. Also visible are smaller oligomeric structures, present as curved lines of rho subunits, which probably represent the lower association states of the protein that coexist with the hexamer at these protein concentrations. Addition of oligomers of ribocytosine (rC) of defined lengths (23-mers and 100-mers) results in the generation of more homogeneous populations of rho oligomers. In the presence of (rC)23, all identifiable particles appear either as closed or as notched hexameric circles. A small fraction of these particles are of visibly higher density, and are identified with the dodecamers expected as a subpopulation of rho under these conditions. Binding of (rC)100, an oligomer of length greater than that needed to span the entire hexamer binding site, results in a uniform population of closed circular hexamers. In some images additional features are visible at either the centers or the peripheries of the particles. These features may correspond to the excess length of the rC strands bound to the hexamers. The distributions of particles observed under the various experimental conditions used correlate well to those deduced from physical biochemical studies Seifried et al., accompanying paper).

Ligand-dependent structural variations in Escherichia coli F1 ATPase revealed by cryoelectron microscopy.

The Escherichia coli F1 ATPase, ECF1, has been examined by cryoelectron microscopy after reaction with Fab' fragments generated from monoclonal antibodies to the alpha and epsilon subunits. The enzyme-antibody complexes appeared triangular due to the superposition of three anti-alpha Fab' fragments on alternating densities of the hexagonally arranged alpha and beta subunits. The Fab' to the epsilon subunit superimposed on a beta subunit. A density was observed near the center of the structure in the internal cavity. The position of this central density with respect to peripheral sites was not fixed. Sorting of images of ECF1 labeled with the combination of three anti-alpha Fab' fragments plus an Fab' directed to the epsilon subunit gave three classes in each of which the central density was closest to a different beta subunit. The distribution of the central density among the three classes was measured for different ligand-binding conditions. When ATP was present in catalytic sites under conditions where there was no enzyme turnover (i.e., without Mg2+ present), there were approximately equal numbers of images in each of three classes. When ATP and Mg2+ were added and ATP hydrolysis was allowed to proceed, almost two-thirds of the images were in the class in which the central density was closest to the beta subunit superimposed by the epsilon subunit. We conclude that domains within the ECF1 structure, either the central mass or a domain including the epsilon subunit, move in the enzyme in response to ligand binding. We suggest that this movement is involved in coupling catalytic sites to the proton channel in the F0 part of the ATP synthase.

Structure of the ATP synthase complex (ECF1F0) of Escherichia coli from cryoelectron microscopy.

The structural relationship of the catalytic portion (ECF1) of the Escherichia coli F1F0 ATP synthase (ECF1F0) to the intact, membrane-bound complex has been determined by cryoelectron microscopy and image analysis of single, unordered particles. ECF1F0, reconstituted into membrane structures, has been preserved and examined in its native state in a layer of amorphous ice. Side views of the ECF1F0 show the same elongated bilobed and trilobed projection of the ECF1 views shown previously to be normal to the hexagonal projection. The elongated aqueous cavity of the ECF1 is perpendicular to the membrane bilayer profile in the bilobed view. ECF1 is separated from the membrane-embedded F0 by a narrow stalk approximately 40 A long and approximately 25-30 A thick. The F0 part extends from the lipid bilayer by approximately 10 A on the side facing the ECF1. There is no clear extension of the protein on the opposite side of the membrane.

Molecular architecture of Escherichia coli F1 adenosinetriphosphatase.

The structure of the E. coli F1 ATPase (ECF1) has been studied by a novel combination of two specimen preparation and image analysis techniques. The molecular outline of the ECF1 was determined by three-dimensional reconstruction of images of negatively stained two-dimensional crystals of ECF1. Internal features were revealed by analysis of single particles of ECF1, preserved in their native state in a thin layer of amorphous ice, and examined by cryoelectron microscopy. Various projections of the unstained ECF1 were interpreted consistently with the three-dimensional structure in negative stain, yielding a more informative description of the enzyme than otherwise possible. Results show that the ECF1 is a roughly spherical complex approximately 90-100 A in diameter. Six elongated protein densities (the alpha and beta subunits, each approximately 90 A X approximately 30 A in size) comprise its hexagonally modulated periphery. At the center of the ECF1 is an aqueous cavity which extends nearly or entirely through the length of the complex. A compact protein density, located at one end of the hexagonal barrel and closely associated with one of the peripheral subunits, partially obstructs the central cavity.

Cryoelectron microscopy of Escherichia coli F1 adenosinetriphosphatase decorated with monoclonal antibodies to individual subunits of the complex.

Monoclonal antibodies directed against epitopes on each of the five subunits (alpha, beta, gamma, delta, and epsilon) of the Escherichia coli F1 ATPase (ECF1) have been prepared and used to localize the subunits in the enzyme complex. Fab' fragments, prepared by pepsin digestion of the antibodies, were bound to ECF1 and visualized by cryoelectron microscopy of the unstained, frozen hydrated ECF1-Fab' complexes. Besides aiding in the identification of the ECF1 subunits, addition of Fab's to the specimen fortuitously offers additional advantages in this technique. ECF1 labeled with anti-alpha Fab' is uniformly oriented in the amorphous ice layer, in contrast to unlabeled ECF1, which exhibits a multitude of projection views when examined in ice. Almost all complexes display a triangular projection, which image averaging reveals to be a hexagonal view of ECF1 with Fab' fragments labeling every other peripheral subunit, confirming the alternating arrangement of alpha and beta subunits in the enzyme. A density in the interior of the structure is positioned asymmetrically, adjacent to an unlabeled peripheral mass, indicating that its primary linkage is to a beta rather than an alpha subunit. The composition of the asymmetric density was explored by examining the trypsin-treated ECF1, taking advantage of the unique orientation induced by the binding of anti-alpha Fab'. Trypsin treatment releases the delta and epsilon subunits and cleaves the gamma subunit; the internal density is reduced but not eliminated, showing the contribution of the gamma subunit to the residual structure, and suggesting that the loss of the delta and epsilon subunits, or a structural rearrangement of the gamma subunit, is responsible for its smaller size.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The stalk connecting the F1 and F0 domains of ATP synthase visualized by electron microscopy of unstained specimens.

E. coli F1F0 ATP synthase has been reconstituted into membranes and visualized by electron microscopy of unstained samples preserved in thin layers of amorphous ice. Unlike previous observations in negative stain, these specimens are not exposed to potentially denaturing or perturbing conditions, having been rapidly frozen from well-defined conditions in which the enzyme is fully active. The structures visualized in views normal to the lipid bilayer clearly show the presence of a narrow stalk approx. 45 A long, connecting the F1 to the membrane-embedded F0.

Neutron scattering shows that cytochrome b5 penetrates deeply into the lipid bilayer.

Cytochrome b5 was asymmetrically reconstituted into small lipid vesicles made of a highly deuterated phospholipid. Small-angle neutron diffraction patterns were collected in a series of H2O-D2O mixtures from vesicles consisting of lipid and native or trypsinized cytochrome b5. The second moment of the radial distribution of scattering density in the vesicles was derived from these data and was compared to values calculated from three proposed models, which differ by the degree that cytochrome b5 penetrates the lipid bilayer. The model in which the hydrophobic domain of the protein is distributed across the bilayer agreed most closely with the data.