5,6-Dihydropyran-2-ones possessing various sulfonyl functionalities: potent nonpeptidic inhibitors of HIV protease.

On the basis of previous SAR findings and molecular modeling studies, a series of compounds were synthesized which possessed various sulfonyl moieties substituted at the 4-position of the C-3 phenyl ring substituent of the dihydropyran-2-one ring system. The sulfonyl substituents were added in an attempt to fill the additional S(3)' pocket and thereby produce increasingly potent inhibitors of the target enzyme. Racemic and enantiomerically resolved varieties of selected compounds were synthesized. All analogues in the study displayed decent binding affinity to HIV protease, and several compounds were shown to possess very good antiviral efficacy and safety margins. X-ray crystallographic structures confirmed that the sulfonamide and sulfonate moieties were filling the S(3)' pocket of the enzyme. However, the additional substituent did not provide improved enzymatic inhibitory or antiviral activity as compared to the resolved unsubstituted aniline. The addition of the sulfonyl moiety substitution does not appear to provide favorable pharamacokinectic parameters. Selected inhibitors were tested for antiviral activity in clinical isolates and exhibited similar antiviral activity against all of the HIV-1 strains tested as they did against the wild-type HIV-1. In addition, the inhibitors exhibited good antiviral efficacies against HIV-1 strains that displayed resistance to the currently marketed protease inhibitors.

Functional characterization of the protease of human endogenous retrovirus, K10: can it complement HIV-1 protease?

To investigate the biochemical properties of the protease encoded by the human endogenous retrovirus, K10 (HERV-K), 213 amino acids of the 3'-end of the HERV-K protease (PR) open reading frame were expressed in Escherichia coli. Autocatalytic cleavage of the expressed polypeptide resulted in an 18.2 kDa protein which was shown to be proteolytically active against a fluorogenic peptide used as a substrate for HIV-1 protease. On the basis of sequence homology and molecular modeling, the 106 N-terminal amino acids of HERV-K PR were predicted to comprise a retroviral protease core domain. An 11.6 kDa protein corresponding to this region was expressed and shown to be a fully functional enzyme. The 11.6 kDa domain of HERV-K PR is unusually stable over a wide pH range, exhibits optimal catalytic activity between pH 4.0 and 5.0, and exists as a dimer at pH 7.0 with a Kd of 50 microM. Like HIV-1 PR, the HERV-K PR core domain is activated by high salt concentrations and processes HIV-1 matrix-capsid polyprotein at the authentic HIV-1 PR recognition site. However, both the 18.2 and 11.6 kDa forms of HERV-K PR were highly resistant to a number of clinically useful HIV-1 PR inhibitors, including ritonavir, indinavir, and saquinavir. This raises the possibility that HERV-K PR may complement HIV-1 PR during infection, and could have implications for protease inhibitor therapy and drug resistance.

Conformational switching in an aspartic proteinase.

The crystal structure of a catalytically inactive form of cathepsin D (CatDhi) has been obtained at pH 7.5. The N-terminal strand relocates by 30 A from its position in the interdomain beta-sheet and inserts into the active site cleft, effectively blocking substrate access. CatDhi has a five-stranded interdomain beta-sheet and resembles Intermediate 3, a hypothetical structure proposed to be transiently formed during proteolytic activation of the proenzyme precursor. Interconversion between active and inactive forms of CatD is reversible and may be regulated by an ionizable switch involving the carboxylate side chains of Glu 5, Glu 180, and Asp 187. Our findings provide a structural basis for the pH-dependent regulation of aspartic proteinase activity and suggest a novel mechanism for pH-dependent modulation of substrate specificity.

Cyclopropane-derived peptidomimetics. Design, synthesis, evaluation, and structure of novel HIV-1 protease inhibitors.

Toward establishing the general efficacy of using trisubstituted cyclopropanes as peptide mimics to stabilize extended peptide structures, the cyclopropanes 20a-d were incorporated as replacements into 9-13, which are analogues of the known HIV-1 protease inhibitors 14 and 15. The syntheses of 20a-d commenced with the Rh2[5(S)-MEPY]4-catalyzed cyclization of the allylic diazoesters 16a-d to give the cyclopropyl lactones 17a-d in high enantiomeric excess. Opening of the lactone moiety using the Weinreb protocol and straightforward refunctionalization of the intermediate amides 18a-d gave 20a-d. A similar sequence of reactions was used to prepare the N-methyl-2-pyridyl analogue 28. Coupling of 20a-d and 28 with the known diamino diol 22 delivered 9-13. Pseudopeptides 9-12 were found to be competitive inhibitors of wild-type HIV-1 protease in biological assays having Kis of 0.31-0.35 nM for 9, 0.16-0.21 nM for 10, 0.47 nM for 11, and 0.17 nM for 12; these inhibitors were thus approximately equipotent to the known inhibitor 14(IC50 = 0.22 nM) from which they were derived. On the other hand 13 (Ki = 80 nM) was a weaker inhibitor than its analogue 15 (Ki = 0.11 nM). The solution structures of 9 and 10 were analyzed by NMR spectroscopy and simulated annealing procedures that included restraints derived from homo- and heteronuclear coupling constants and NOEs; because of the molecular symmetry of9 and 10, a special protocol to treat the NOE data was used. The final structure was checked by restrained and free molecular dynamic calculations using an explicit DMSO solvent box. The preferred solution conformations of 9 and 10 are extended structures that closely resemble the three-dimensional structure of 10 bound to HIV-1 protease as determined by X-ray crystallographic analysis of the complex. This work convincingly demonstrates that extended structures of peptides may be stabilized by the presence of substituted cyclopropanes that serve as peptide replacements. Moreover, the linear structure enforced in solution by the two cyclopropane rings in the pseudopeptides 9-12 appears to correspond closely to the biologically active conformation of the more flexible inhibitors 14 and 15. The present work, which is a combination of medicinal, structural, and quantum chemistry, thus clearly establishes that cyclopropanes may be used as structural constraints to reduce the flexibility of linear pseudopeptides and to help enforce the biologically active conformation of such ligands in solution.

Unsymmetric nonpeptidic HIV protease inhibitors containing anthranilamide as a P2' ligand.

A series of novel unsymmetrical anthranilamide-containing HIV protease inhibitors was designed. The structure-activity studies revealed a series of potent P2-P3' inhibitors that incorporate an anthranilamide group at the P2' position. A reduction in molecular weight and lipophilicity is achieved by a judicious choice of P2 ligands (i.e., aromatic, heteroaromatic, carbamate, and peptidic). A systematic investigation led to the 5-thiazolyl carbamate analog 8 m, which exhibited a favorable Cmax/EC50 ratio (> 30), plasma half-life (> 8 h), and potent in vitro antiviral activity (EC50 = 0.2 microM).

4-hydroxy-5,6-dihydropyrones. 2. Potent non-peptide inhibitors of HIV protease.

The 4-hydroxy-5,6-dihydropyrone template was utilized as a flexible scaffolding from which to build potent active site inhibitors of HIV protease. Dihydropyrone 1c (5,6-dihydro-4-hydroxy-6-phenyl-3-[(2-phenylethyl)thio]-2H-pyran-2-one) was modeled in the active site of HIV protease utilizing a similar binding mode found for the previously reported 4-hydroxybenzopyran-2-ones. Our model led us to pursue the synthesis of 6,6-disubstituted dihydropyrones with the aim of filling S1 and S2 and thereby increasing the potency of the parent dihydropyrone 1c which did not fill S2. Toward this end we attached various hydrophobic and hydrophilic side chains at the 6-position of the dihydropyrone to mimic the natural and unnatural amino acids known to be effective substrates at P2 and P2'. Parent dihydropyrone 1c (IC50 = 2100 nM) was elaborated into compounds with greater than a 100-fold increase in potency [18c, IC50 = 5 nM, 5-(3,6-dihydro-4-hydroxy-6-oxo-2-phenyl-5-[2-phenylethyl)thio] -2H-pyran-2-yl)pentanoic acid and 12c, IC50 = 51 nM, 5,6-dihydro-4-hydroxy-6-phenyl-6-(2-phenylethyl)-3- [(2-phenyl-ethyl)thio]-2H-pyran-2-one]. Optimization of the 3-position fragment to fill S1' and S2' afforded potent HIV protease inhibitor 49 [IC50 = 10 nM, 3-[(2-tert-butyl-5-methylphenyl)sulfanyl]-5,6-dihydro-4 -hydroxy-6-phenyl-6-(2-phenylethyl)-2H-pyran-2-one]. The resulting low molecular weight compounds (< 475) have one or no chiral centers and are readily synthesized.

Design of sensitive fluorogenic substrates for human cathepsin D.

Cathepsin D is a lysosomal aspartic proteinase that has been implicated in several pathological processes such as breast cancer and Alzheimer's disease. We designed and synthesized a number of quenched fluorogenic substrates with P2 variations in the series AcEE(EDANS)KPIXFFRLGK(DABCYL)E-NH2, where X=cysteine, methylcysteine, ethylcysteine, tert-butylcysteine, carboxymethylcysteine, methionine, valine or isoleucine. Most of the fluorogenic substrates exhibited greater k(cat)/Km ratios than the best cathepsin D substrates described so far. Differences in kinetic constants, which were rationalized using structure-based modeling, might make certain substrates useful for particular applications, such as active site titrations or initial velocity determination using a fluorescent plate reader.

Structure-based subsite specificity mapping of human cathepsin D using statine-based inhibitors.

Human cathepsin D is a lysosomal aspartic protease that has been implicated in breast cancer metastasis and Alzheimer's disease. Based on a crystal structure of a human cathepsin D-pepstatin A complex, a series of statine-containing inhibitors was designed, synthesized, and tested for inhibitory activity toward the enzyme in vitro. The compounds were modified systematically at individual positions (P4, P3, P2, P1, and P2t) with the aim of mapping the cathepsin D subsite preferences. The experimentally obtained SAR data were correlated on the basis of molecular modeling. Side-chain preferences for the peptidomimetic inhibitors differed from those found previously using peptide substrates (Scarborough PE et al., 1993, Protein Sci 2:264-276). In addition, the effects of single side-chain modifications were often nonadditive. Structure-activity relationships, modeling, and thermodynamic analysis indicated that entropy plays a major stabilizing role in inhibitor binding to cathepsin D.

Escape mutants of HIV-1 proteinase: enzymic efficiency and susceptibility to inhibition.

Genes encoding a number of mutants of HIV-1 proteinase were sub-cloned and expressed in E. coli. The proteinases containing mutations of single residues (e.g., G48V, V82F, I84V and L90M) were purified and their catalytic efficiencies relative to that of wild-type proteinase were examined using a polyprotein (recombinant HIV-1 gag) substrate and several series of synthetic peptides based on the -Hydrophobic * Hydrophobic-, -Aromatic * Pro- and pseudo-symmetrical types of cleavage junction. The L90M proteinase showed only small changes, whereas the activity of the other mutant enzymes was compromised more severely, particularly towards substrates of the -Aromatic * Pro- and pseudo-symmetrical types. The susceptibility of the mutants and the wild-type proteinase to inhibition by eleven different compounds was compared. The L90M proteinase again showed only marginal changes in its susceptibility to all except one of the inhibitors examined. The K(i) values determined for one inhibitor (Ro31-8959) showed that its potency towards the V82F, L90M, I84V and G48V mutant proteinases respectively was 2-, 3-, 17- and 27-fold less than against the wild-type proteinase. Several of the other inhibitors examined form a systematic series with Ro31-8959. The inhibition constants derived with these and a number of other inhibitors, including ABT-538 and L-735,524, are used in conjunction with the data on enzymic efficiency to assess whether each mutation in the proteinase confers an advantage for viral replication in the presence of any given inhibitor.

Structure and inhibition of plasmepsin II, a hemoglobin-degrading enzyme from Plasmodium falciparum.

Plasmodium falciparum is the major causative agent of malaria, a disease of worldwide importance. Resistance to current drugs such as chloroquine and mefloquine is spreading at an alarming rate, and our antimalarial armamentarium is almost depleted. The malarial parasite encodes two homologous aspartic proteases, plasmepsins I and II, which are essential components of its hemoglobin-degradation pathway and are novel targets for antimalarial drug development. We have determined the crystal structure of recombinant plasmepsin II complexed with pepstatin A. This represents the first reported crystal structure of a protein from P. falciparum. The crystals contain molecules in two different conformations, revealing a remarkable degree of interdomain flexibility of the enzyme. The structure was used to design a series of selective low molecular weight compounds that inhibit both plasmepsin II and the growth of P. falciparum in culture.

Structure-based design of achiral, nonpeptidic hydroxybenzamide as a novel P2/P2' replacement for the symmetry-based HIV protease inhibitors.

A combination of structure-activity studies, kinetic analysis, X-ray crystallographic analysis, and modeling were employed in the design of a novel series of HIV-1 protease (HIV PR) inhibitors. The crystal structure of a complex of HIV PR with SRSS-2,5-bis[N-(tert-butyloxycarbonyl)amino]-3,4-dihydroxy-1, 6-diphenylhexane (1) delineated a crucial water-mediated hydrogen bond between the tert-butyloxy group of the inhibitor and the amide hydrogen of Asp29 of the enzyme. Achiral, nonpeptidic 2-hydroxyphenylacetamide and 3-hydroxybenzamide groups were modeled as novel P2/P2' ligands to replace the crystallographic water molecules and to provide direct interactions with the NH groups of the Asp29/129 residues. Indeed, the symmetry-based inhibitors 7 and 19, possessing 3-hydroxy and 3-aminobenzamide, respectively, as a P2/P2' ligand, were potent inhibitors of HIV PR. The benzamides were superior in potency to the phenylacetamides and have four fewer rotatable bonds. An X-ray crystal structure of the HIV PR/7 complex at 2.1 A resolution revealed an asymmetric mode of binding, in which the 3-hydroxy group of the benzamide ring makes the predicted interaction with the backbone NH of Asp29 on one side of the active site only. An unexpected hydrogen bond with the Gly148 carbonyl group, resulting from rotation of the aromatic ring out of the amide plane, was observed on the other side. The inhibitory potencies of the benzamide compounds were found to be sensitive to the nature and position of substituents on the benzamide ring, and can be rationalized on the basis of the structure of the HIV PR/7 complex. These results partly confirm our initial hypothesis and suggest that optimal inhibitor designs should satisfy a requirement for providing polar interactions with Asp29 NH, and should minimize the conformational entropy loss on binding by reducing the number of freely rotatable bonds in inhibitors.

Design, synthesis, and resistance patterns of MP-134 and MP-167, two novel inhibitors of HIV type 1 protease.

Inhibitors of HIV-1 protease represent a new class of antiretroviral compounds. Here, we report the design and synthesis of two novel C2 symmetry-based inhibitors, MP-134 and MP-167, specifically targeted against HIV-1 variants with reduced sensitivity to another related protease inhibitor, A-77003. In addition, we describe the in vitro selection of viral variants with reduced sensitivity of these two protease inhibitors. An isoleucine-to-valine substitution at residue 84 (I84V) of the HIV-1 protease confers resistance to MP-134, whereas a glycine-to-valine substitution at residue 48 (G48V) confers resistance to MP-167. Testing other protease inhibitors against these variants has revealed specific overlapping patterns of resistance among these agents. These findings have important implications in the design of combination regimens using multiple protease inhibitors and underscore the need to develop non-cross-resistant compounds to be used toward this goal.

Kinetic characterization and cross-resistance patterns of HIV-1 protease mutants selected under drug pressure.

Eleven different recombinant, drug-resistant HIV-1 protease (HIV PR) mutants--R8Q, V32I, M46I, V82A, V82F, V82I, I84V, V32I/I84V, M46I/V82F, M46I/I84V, and V32I/K45I/F53L/A71V/I84V/L89M--were generated on the basis of results of in vitro selection experiments using the inhibitors A-77003, A-84538, and KNI-272. Kinetic parameters of mutant and wild-type (WT) enzymes were measured along with inhibition constants (Ki) toward the inhibitors A-77003, A-84538, KNI-272, L-735,524, and Ro31-8959. The catalytic efficiency, kcat/Km, for the mutants decreased relative to WT by a factor of 1.2-14.8 and was mainly due to the elevation of Km. The effects of specific mutations on Ki values were unique with respect to both inhibitor and mutant enzyme. A new property, termed vitality, defined as the ratio (Kikcat/Km)mutant/(Kikcat/Km)WT was introduced to compare the selective advantage of different mutants in the presence of a given inhibitor. High vitality values were generally observed with mutations that emerged during in vitro selection studies. The kinetic model along with the panel of mutants described here should be useful for evaluating and predicting patterns of resistance for HIV PR inhibitors and may aid in the selection of inhibitor combinations to combat drug resistance.