Estimation of wound surface area: an evaluation of medical professionals' assessment in a plastic surgery unit.

The percentage of skin graft take following the resurfacing of burn injuries is routinely calculated in a subjective fashion, in order to make management decisions. Given the gravity of decisions made based on this clinical assessment of graft check, it is notable that limited research has been carried out on this subject. No standardised subjective assessment tools exist to measure surface area of graft take in a manner similar to that of Wallace's Rule of Nines or Lund and Browder. This study set out to examine the accuracy of visual assessments of graft take within the multidisciplinary team regularly making assessments of newly grafted burn wounds. A total of 15 digitally drawn images were used to assess 36 staff members' estimations of percentage of surface area. The results showed a wide variation in estimation in all staff types, including senior burns surgeons, who were found to underestimate surface area by as much as 30%. The British Burns Association has removed 'healing time' as an outcome measurement from its guidance, as it recognises how hard it is to make a standardised assessment of wound healing. This study demonstrates the difficulty in subjectively assessing surface area and makes some suggestions for further research and clinical applications of technology to aid assessment.

A simple computerised technique for estimating resting lip position and symmetry.

The angle between the commisure-commisure and the endocantus-commisure lines (CCE angle) is approximately equal to the contralateral angle. A computerised technique for assessing the gross symmetry and position of the lips by comparing left- and right-sided CCE angles was developed. This study established (1) the repeatability of computerized CCE angle measurement; (2) mean CCE angle magnitudes in healthy controls and suggest a "normal" reference range. Two authors independently measured CCE angles on frontal repose facial photographs of 104 volunteers on three separate occasions using facial analysis software. Twenty right-sided hemifaces with the largest CCE differences were then mirrored in the sagittal plane to produce symmetrical photographs. Measurements were repeated by a single author. There was high agreement of angle measurements between authors (inter-rater ICC of 0.89) and within each authors' repeated measurements (intra-raters ICCs of 0.85 and 0.77). Differences in the mean right and left-sided CCE angles in controls were small but statistically significant (82.4° and 81.7°, respectively, mean absolute difference 2.2 ± 1.7°, p < 0.05). The mean absolute differences had a skewed distribution. The 2.5th and 97.5th centiles were therefore set as limits of the range of asymmetries which could be regarded as "normal" (95% reference range, or 95% reference interval): 0.2°-6.2°. Measurements of opposing CCE angles in symmetrical mirrored images were similar (82.4° versus 82.3°, mean absolute difference 0.6°, p > 0.05). In conclusion, computerised CCE angle measurement is highly repeatable and may be a useful tool with which to assess gross resting lip symmetry.

Meta-analysis on the comparative efficacy of drains, progressive tension sutures and subscarpal fat preservation in reducing complications of abdominoplasty.

INTRODUCTION: Abdominoplasty is a popular aesthetic operation. Complication rates vary from 4-80%. To date, there is a lack of evidence for complication-reducing techniques. The aim of this meta-analysis was to summarise and quantify the effects of these techniques on complication rates and determine the safest combination. METHODS: A literature search was undertaken from MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials databases. Two authors assessed the abstracts and evaluated their suitability for inclusion in the review. For each complication (including overall), a random effects meta-analysis was conducted to investigate the average number of complications. The log rate and associated variance is calculated in R using the "escalc" function from the metafor R package. For the forest plots the model output is back-transformed to the original scale. RESULTS: 4295 patients were included in the meta-analysis. Overall complication rates ranged from 9.3-33.8%. Revision rates were 3-21.9%. Forest plots of data extracted from observational studies demonstrated summary measures favouring the sub-scarpal fat preservation and drains, and drains only groups for overall complications. There were no significant differences between groups for seroma, haematoma, infection/abscess, skin/fat necrosis, dehiscence, surgical revision rate and VTE rate. CONCLUSIONS: The rates of individual complications are no different with or without the use of PTS, drain or sub-Scarpal fat preservation in different combinations.

Low-Dose Insulin as an Antiscarring Therapy in Breast Surgery: A Randomized Controlled Trial.

BACKGROUND: The role of insulin in expediting wound healing is firmly established within the context of major trauma and burns; however, only limited clinical evidence exists as to its effects on scar formation. This study aims to build on previous laboratory work to examine the potential antiscarring properties of insulin in a clinical environment. METHODS: Ninety-one patients undergoing bilateral aesthetic breast operations were recruited to receive low-dose insulin and placebo injections to the medial 3 cm of their submammary incisions within the context of a randomized, intrapatient, placebo-controlled trial, and scar quality was assessed at 3-, 6-, and 12-month reviews using the Manchester Scar Scale. RESULTS: Across the cohort at 12-month review, the insulin-treated scars had lower scar scores (p = 0.055) compared with placebo. Subgroup analysis of individuals with heavier scars showed that median scar scores were significantly lower for the insulin-treated scars with regard to both scar contour (p = 0.048) and scar distortion (p = 0.045). CONCLUSIONS: Subcutaneous insulin injections reduced the appearance of scarring in this study compared with placebo. The greatest effect was seen in those participants who showed heavier scars and, as such, insulin has a role as an antiscarring therapy in individuals likely to be affected by heavier scarring. Further research is required to more precisely delineate which subjects may benefit most from this treatment. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, II.

The importance of early flap coverage in deep sternal wounds.

BACKGROUND: Chronic or persistent wound infection is one of the key outcome measures after flap reconstruction in deep sternal wound infection (DSWI). This study aimed to assess potentially modifiable factors associated with chronic infection in patients undergoing flap reconstruction. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An analysis of a prospective database of 5239 median sternotomies performed during a 5-year period was carried out. Seventy-seven cases of DSWI were recorded, of which 23 cases proceeded to flap reconstruction. The flap-reconstructed patients were placed into groups according to the primary outcome measure of those who experienced chronic infection and those who remained infection free. RESULTS: Of the flap-reconstructed patients, 22% experienced subsequent chronic infection, whereas 78% remained infection free. The only 2 variables that were associated with chronic infection were the timing of flap reconstruction; median time 29.5 days (vs 12 days in the infection-free group), P=0.011 and time taken from diagnosis of wound infection/dehiscence to referral to the plastic surgical team; median 21 days (vs median 8 days in the infection free group), P=0.02. Each day of delay from the diagnosis of clinical infection to flap cover equated to an increase in risk of chronic infection of 1.2 times per day (OR=1.205, P=0.039). CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that chronic infection after flap reconstruction in DSWI is associated with late flap cover. We suggest the need for a consensus agreement on the combined care and early management of DSWI.

A case of persistent hemifacial weakness.

Hemifacial weakness, or palsy, results from disruption of communication between cortical motor centres and the facial musculature along the course of the facial nerve. Bell's palsy has a typical presentation of sudden onset, mild otalgia, altered facial sensation and/or taste, with no obvious prodrome. It represents over half of hemifacial weakness cases in primary care. However, as a diagnosis of exclusion, there are a number of key clinical features of more sinister diagnoses that must be considered. Acute hemifacial weakness secondary to isolated facial nerve palsy must be differentiated from acute cerebrovascular accident. The latter results in sparing of the brow musculature due to the bilateral innervation of the frontalis. Altered facial sensation and mild otalgia are common in Bell's palsy, however severe pain is suggestive of Ramsay Hunt syndrome. Recent facial or head trauma and surgery should also be excluded in causation. Patients with the following conditions should be referred: lagophthalmos if the weakness persists beyond a few days or ocular damage is suspected; Ramsay Hunt syndrome (immunocompromised patients, those with significant pain, and where intraoral vesicles prohibit oral intake); and palsy secondary to trauma or surgery. A parotid mass with facial palsy implies malignant change and must be referred within the two-week wait pathway. A history of progressive hearing loss and tinnitus with palsy also requires urgent referral to neuro-otology for assessment of cerebellopontine angle tumours. All cases of facial palsy associated with infective otological symptoms should be discussed with ENT.

Implications of rationing and the European Working Time Directive on aesthetic breast surgery: a study of trainee exposure in 2005 and 2011.

BACKGROUND: There are concerns that current trainees may be lacking operative experience in aesthetic and functional breast surgeries. Reduced exposure to such cases during training may stem from rationing, EWTD compliance, and an increasingly consultant-led service. These issues are examined in a single NHS hospital, with analysis of trends over time, and are contrasted with the changes that have occurred in a related private hospital. METHODS: A single NHS hospital trusts database was retrospectively analysed for all aesthetic breast surgeries from 2005 to 2011, noting the total number of cases and the grade of the principal surgeon. The analysis was repeated in a related private sector hospital in the same catchment area. RESULTS: A statistically significant drop of 55% of NHS aesthetic breast surgeries performed in 2011 compared to 2005 was demonstrated with an increasing trend for consultant led procedures. The NHS caseload decline was matched by a corresponding increase of 57% within the private sector. CONCLUSIONS: Current trainees in plastic surgery face a significant reduction in operative exposure to aesthetic breast surgeries compared to their predecessors due to the EWTD working hours, surgical rationing policies, and an increasingly consultant led service. Approaches to maintaining training standards are discussed.

Is home monitoring of international normalised ratio safer than clinic-based monitoring?

A best evidence topic was written according to a structured protocol, to answer the question: 'In patients taking warfarin, is home self-monitoring of international normalized ratio (INR) safer than clinic-based testing in reducing bleeding, thrombotic events and death?' Altogether, 268 papers were found using the reported search. Five papers represented the highest level of evidence to answer the clinical question (four systematic reviews with meta-analysis and one meta-analysis). The authors, journal, date and country of publication, patient group studied, study type, relevant outcomes and results of these papers are tabulated. The principal outcomes of interest were death, major haemorrhage, major thromboembolism, and time (or percentage time) spent within the therapeutic range, compared between self-monitoring/self-management and conventional management. Self-monitoring/self-management was associated with a significantly reduced risk of all-cause mortality of 26-42%. All meta-analyses reported on major thromboembolism, finding significant reductions in risk of ~50%. One meta-analysis found a 35% reduction in the risk of major haemorrhage, with the other four studies finding no significant difference. Only one study found self-monitoring/self-management to be associated with a significantly greater proportion of time within range, with another finding no significant difference in either the percentage of therapeutic results or in the time within range. The remaining two could not combine data for meta-analysis owing to methodological heterogeneity. We conclude that self-monitoring/self-management appears to be safer than conventional management. It is associated with consistently lower rates of thromboembolism and may also be associated with reduced risk of bleeding and death. This supports the updated guidance from the American College of Chest Physicians, recommending self-management of INR for patients who are both competent and motivated.

Refinements in smile reanimation: 10-year experience with the lengthening Temporalis Myoplasty.

The lengthening Temporalis Myoplasty (LTM) is an innovative dynamic facial reanimation procedure that has been used to great effect following its conception during the early 1990s by the senior author. Since its first description in the literature the technique has been refined and it has become clear from correspondence that certain technical aspects of the procedure require particular attention to detail. We discuss from experience of more than a hundred cases and highlight not only the important technical aspects of the procedure but also the importance of pre-operative assessment and the avoidance of complications.