Mechanism of activation of the chloroplast ATP synthase. A kinetic study of the thiol modulation of isolated ATPase and membrane-bound ATP synthase from spinach by Eschericia coli thioredoxin.

The mechanism of thiol modulation of the chloroplast ATP synthase by Escherichia coli thioredoxin was investigated in the isolated ATPase subcomplex and in the ATP synthase complex reconstituted in bacteriorhodopsin proteoliposomes. Thiol modulation was resolved kinetically by continuously monitoring ATP hydrolysis by the isolated subcomplex and ATP synthesis by proteoliposomes. The binding rate constant of reduced thioredoxin to the oxidized ATPase subcomplex devoid of its epsilon subunit could be determined. It did not depend on the catalytic turnover. Reciprocically, the catalytic turnover did not seem to depend on thioredoxin binding. Thiol modulation by Trx of the epsilon-bearing ATPase subcomplex was slow and favored the release of epsilon. The rate constant of thioredoxin binding to the membrane-bound ATP synthase increased with the protonmotive force. It was lower in the presence of ADP than in its absence, revealing a specific effect of the ATP synthase turnover on thioredoxin-gamma subunit interaction. These findings, and more especially the comparisons between the isolated ATPase subcomplex and the ATP synthase complex, can be interpreted in the frame of the rotational catalysis hypothesis. Finally, thiol modulation changed the catalytic properties of the ATP synthase, the kinetics of which became non-Michaelian. This questions the common view about the nature of changes induced by ATP synthase thiol modulation.

Activation and deactivation of F0F1-ATPase in yeast mitochondria.

The regulation of membrane-bound proton F0F1 ATPase by the protonmotive force and nucleotides was studied in yeast mitochondria. Activation occurred in whole mitochondria and the ATPase activity was measured just after disrupting the membranes with Triton X-100. Deactivation occurred either in whole mitochondria uncoupled with FCCP, or in disrupted membranes. No effect of Triton X-100 on the ATPase was observed, except a slow reactivation observed only in the absence of MgADP. Both AMPPNP and ATP increased the ATPase deactivation rate, thus indicating that occupancy of nucleotidic sites by ATP is more decisive than catalytic turnover for this process. ADP was found to stimulate the energy-dependent ATPase activation. ATPase deactivated at the same rate in uncoupled and disrupted mitochondria This suggests that deactivation is not controlled by rebinding of some soluble factor, like IF1, but rather by the conversion of the F1.IF1 complex into an inactive form.

Kinetic analysis of tentoxin binding to chloroplast F1-ATPase. A model for the overactivation process.

The mechanism of action of tentoxin on the soluble part (chloroplast F1 H+-ATPase; CF1) of chloroplast ATP synthase was analyzed in the light of new kinetic and equilibrium experiments. Investigations were done regarding the functional state of the enzyme (activation, bound nucleotide, catalytic turnover). Dialysis and binding data, obtained with 14C-tentoxin, fully confirmed the existence of two tentoxin binding sites of distinct dissociation constants consistent with the observed Kinhibition and Koveractivation. This strongly supports a two-site model of tentoxin action on CF1. Kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of tentoxin binding to the first site (Ki = 10 nM; kon = 4.7 x 10(4) s-1.M-1) were determined from time-resolved activity assays. Tentoxin binding to the high affinity site was found independent on the catalytic state of the enzyme. The analysis of the kinetics of tentoxin binding on the low affinity site of the enzyme showed strong evidence for an interaction between this site and the nucleotide binding sites and revealed a complex relationship between the catalytic state and the reactivation process. New catalytic states of CF1 devoid of epsilon-subunit were detected: a transient overstimulated state, and a dead end complex unable to bind a second tentoxin molecule. Our experiments led to a kinetic model for the reactivation phenomenon for which rate constants were determined. The implications of this model are discussed in relation to the previous mechanistic hypotheses on the effect of tentoxin.

Interrelation between high and low affinity tentoxin binding sites in chloroplast F1-ATPase revealed by synthetic analogues.

Eight synthetic analogues of tentoxin (cyclo-(L-N-MeGlu1-L-Leu2-N-MeDeltaZPhe3-Gly4)) modified in residues 1, 2, and 3 were checked for their ability to inhibit and reactivate the ATPase activity of the activated soluble part of chloroplast ATP synthase. The data were consistent with a model involving two binding sites of different affinities for the toxins. The occupancy of the high affinity site (or tight site) gave rise to an inactive complex, whereas filling both sites (tight + loose) gave rise to a complex of variable activity, dependent on the toxin analogue. Competition experiments between tentoxin and nonreactivating analogues allowed discrimination between the absence of binding and a nonproductive binding to the site of lower affinity (or loose site). The affinity for the loose site was not affected significantly by the modifications of the tentoxin molecule, whereas the affinity for the tight site was found notably changed. Increasing the size of side chain 1 or 2 and introducing a net electrical charge both resulted in a decrease of affinity for the tight site, but the second change dominated the first one. The activity of different ternary complexes enzyme-tentoxin-analogue depended on the nature of the toxin bound on each site and not only on that bound on the loose site. This demonstrates that the reactivation process results from an interaction, direct or not, between these two binding sites. Possible molecular mechanisms are discussed.

Synthesis, structure, and properties of MeSer1-tentoxin, a new cyclic tetrapeptide which interacts specifically with chloroplast F1 H(+)-ATPase differentiation of inhibitory and stimulating effects.

A new tentoxin analogue, in which the L-methyl alanine residue is substituted by L-methylserine, has been prepared following the synthetic pathway recently described for the synthesis of tentoxin [Cavelier, F., & Verducci, J. (1995) Tetrahedron Lett. 36, 4425-4428]. Using two-dimensional homonuclear proton nuclear magnetic resonance and structural analysis, we observed that MeSer1-tentoxin, like tentoxin, adopts several conformations in aqueous solution and presents self-aggregative properties. This analogue was found to be conformationally similar to the natural toxin. It showed the same efficiency as tentoxin in inhibition of ATPase activity of the isolated chloroplast F1 proton ATPase (CF1) as well as in inhibition of the ATP synthase activity of the membrane-bound enzyme (CF0CF1) in thylakoids and proteoliposomes. At concentrations above 10 microM, MeSer1-tentoxin did not reactivate CF1 to a high extent, contrary to tentoxin. It appeared, however, to bind in the same way, since the reactivating effect of tentoxin was inhibited by MeSer1-tentoxin. These results show that it is possible, using tentoxin analogues, to separate inhibitory and activating effects on the chloroplast ATPase, despite the limited chemical difference between the two toxins.

Proton coupling is preserved in membrane-bound chloroplast ATPase activated by high concentrations of tentoxin.

The effect of tentoxin at high concentrations was investigated in thylakoids and proteoliposomes containing bacteriorhodopsin and CF0CF1. Venturicidin-sensitive ATP hydrolysis, ATP-generated delta pH and ATP synthesis were practically 100% inhibited at 2 microM tentoxin, and restored to various extents beyond 50 microM. With respect to the native enzyme, tentoxin-reactivated ATPase had the following properties: (i) a higher delta pH requirement to synthetise ATP; (ii) a decreased futile proton flow through CF0CF1 (without ADP), which remains 100% blocked by ADP. It is concluded that despite its altered kinetic performances, tentoxin-modified CF0CF1 preserves its mechanism and remains a tightly coupled proton pump.

Deactivation of F0F1 ATPase in intact plant mitochondria. Effect of pH and inhibitors.

By using a method especially adapted to intact (pea leaf) mitochondria, we studied the regulation of the F0F1 ATPase by the electrochemical proton gradient (delta mu H+) and by the matricial pH. The kinetics of decay of the ATP hydrolase activity was studied immediately after the collapse of the electrochemical proton gradient by an uncoupler. At pH 7.5, three inhibitors of the ATPase (venturicidin, tri-n-butyl tin and aurovertin), used at non-saturating concentrations, inhibited ATP hydrolysis to the same extent throughout the decay. This showed that the activity was totally controlled by the ATPase during all the decay and rules out any involvement of the phosphate or nucleotide carriers. This interpretation was confirmed by the fact that carboxyatractyloside, an inhibitor of the ATP/ADP antiporter, had a strong effect only on the initial rate of ATP hydrolysis, but not on the rate measured after some tens of seconds of decay. Oligomycin, at variance with the other ATPase inhibitors, interfered with the deactivation process, suggesting that its effect depends on the conformational state of the enzyme. Between pH 6.5 and 7.5, the hydrolase activity rose continuously and was still kinetically controlled by the ATPase. At higher pH value, the activity slightly decreased and appeared limited by at least one of the carriers. The activity of the ATPase itself, free of any transport process, seemed to increase monotonously with pH from 6.5 to 8. The electrochemical proton gradient is required to maintain the ATPase active, whereas no effect can be observed on transport processes. Matricial pH, while modulating the apparent catalytic turnover, has no marked effect on the rate of deactivation. These results, obtained with intact mitochondria, extend previous observations on the isolated enzyme and question the binding of IF1 as a rate-limiting step for ATPase deactivation.

Catalytic and activating protons follow different pathways in the H(+)-ATPase of potato tuber mitochondria.

The effect of some F0F1 inhibitors on the activation of the H(+)-ATPase by the electrochemical proton gradient was investigated in mitochondria extracted from potato tubers. Transient activated state of the ATPase was revealed by addition of ATP and of the detergent lauryldimethylamine oxide (LDAO) to energized mitochondria. Venturicidin, tri-n-butyltin and aurovertin at high concentrations did not affect the process of delta mu H(+)-activation, whereas oligomycin fully blocked it. The results support the idea of separate pathways or binding sites for catalytic and activating protons.

Flow-force relationships in lettuce thylakoids. 1. Strict control of electron flow by internal pH.

The regulation by the proton gradient of the electron flow from water to ferricyanide was investigated in thylakoids extracted from lettuce leaves. When the transmembrane proton current was varied by an uncoupler or by the ATP synthase activity, a unique relationship was found between the rate of ferricyanide reduction and the proton gradient, restricted here to its delta pH component. This behavior was conserved in CF1-depleted thylakoids where the passive proton flow was varied by the concentration of an Fo inhibitor or by the concentration of an uncoupler after 100% inhibition of Fo. This shows that under our experimental conditions no direct proton transfer exists in steady state between the site of regulation of the redox chain and the ATPase. Studies at two different pH's indicate that the internal pH, and not the transmembrane pH difference, controls the electron transfer between PS2 and PS1. Modeling the data suggests that a single deprotonation step is kinetically limiting.

Flow-force relationships in lettuce thylakoids. 2. Effect of the uncoupler FCCP on local proton resistances at the ATPase level.

The relationship between the steady-state proton gradient (delta pH) and the rate of phosphorylation was investigated in thylakoids under various conditions. Under partial uncoupling by carbonyl cyanide p-(trifluoromethoxy)phenylhydrazone (FCCP), the rate of ATP synthesis was reduced by less than expected from the decrease of delta pH. This was observed in the case of the pyocyanine-mediated cyclic electron flow around photosystem 1, but not with the H2O-->photosystem 2-->cytochrome b6f-->photosystem 1-->methyl viologen system. In state 4, a unique relation was found between delta pH and the "phosphate potential", delta Gp, regardless of whether the energy level was controlled by light input or FCCP. The anomalous effect of FCCP on the rate of ATP synthesis disappeared when the ATPase was partially blocked by the reversible inhibitor venturicidin, but not in the presence of tentoxin, an irreversible inhibitor. These results are consistent with the existence of a small kinetic barrier for protons, limiting their access to the ATPase. This resistance would be collapsed by FCCP.

The electrochemical-proton-gradient-activated states of F0F1 ATPase in plant mitochondria as revealed by detergents.

ATP hydrolysis, triggered by the addition of polyoxyethylene-9-lauryl ether (Lubrol) or lauryldimethylamine oxide (LDAO) to energized plant mitochondria was studied in some details. The membrane disruption was quasi-instantaneous (2-3 s) with both detergents, as shown by the decrease of turbidity and the stopping of respiration. In pea leaf mitochondria, Lubrol triggered ATP hydrolysis in almost the same way as valinomycin plus nigericin, except that the activity was slightly stimulated and became insensitive to carboxyatractyloside. This allowed investigations of ATP hydrolysis without any interference of the ATP/ADP antiporter or the phosphate carrier. Lubrol did not prevent the ATPase from deactivating in pea leaf mitochondria, and did not trigger any ATP hydrolysis in potato tuber mitochondria. At variance with Lubrol, LDAO changed the properties of the F0F1 ATPase. It made the enzyme oligomycin insensitive and froze it in an activated state. The activity was also 5-8-times stimulated in pea leaf mitochondria. Moreover, LDAO revealed an important ATP hydrolase activity when added to energized potato tuber mitochondria. Despite the specific effect of LDAO, the activity triggered by this detergent strongly depended on the energized state of the organelles before detergent addition. From this study, it is concluded that the electrochemical proton gradient is completely necessary to activate the F0F1-ATPase in intact plant mitochondria, as known in chloroplasts and suggested by some reports in animal mitochondria. Moreover, it is suggested that the main difference between the enzymes of pea leaf and potato tuber mitochondria is their rate of deactivation after the collapse of the transmembrane electrochemical potential difference. Finally, when properly used, detergents appear to be a powerful tool to probe the state of the ATPase in intact mitochondria, and maybe in more integrated systems.

Tissue specificity of the regulation of ATP hydrolysis by isolated plant mitochondria.

Pea leaf mitochondria had a high ATP hydrolase activity following the collapse of the membrane potential by addition of valinomycin in state 4. In mitochondria isolated from potato tubers such ATP hydrolase activity was not observed. Pea leaf mitochondria also had a delta pH, in contrast to what was previously found for potato tuber mitochondria. This delta pH could, however, not explain the different results on ATP hydrolysis since this activity was also observed in the presence of nigericin. The results suggest a tissue-specific regulation of ATP hydrolysis in resting organs (potato tubers) as compared to active organs (leaves).

An attempt to discriminate catalytic and regulatory proton binding sites in membrane-bound, thiol-reduced chloroplast ATPase.

The question of the possible identity of catalytic and regulatory proton pathways in the chloroplast FoF1 ATPase has been studied using different energy-transfer inhibitors. Venturicidin, a reversible inhibitor of Fo, affects neither the delta mu H(+)-dependent thiol reduction of the membrane-bound chloroplast ATPase nor its ability to be activated by the proton gradient. It seems therefore to block only the proton flow required by the catalytic function of the enzymes. Venturicidin, however, also slows down the deactivation of the thiol-reduced ATPases during uncoupled ATP hydrolysis, following a delta mu H+ activation, but phloridzin, a reversible F1 inhibitor, has the same effect. Tentoxin, an irreversible F1 inhibitor, decreases the rate of ATP hydrolysis but does not affect the rate of deactivation. These findings suggest that catalytic and regulatory H(+)-binding sites are different. No distinction can be made, if any, between protons involved in unmasking the thiol-sensitive groups of F1 and in activating the enzyme. The effect of venturicidin and phloridzin on the deactivation is consistent with an inhibitory effect of newly formed--by ATP hydrolysis--ADP molecules, which might affect the enzyme without passing through the medium. Phosphate at millimolar concentration has an effect similar to low concentrations of phloridzin and venturicidin, probably by a simple back-reaction effect.

Dependence of kinetic parameters of chloroplast ATP synthase on external pH, internal pH, and delta pH.

ATP synthesis by the membrane-bound chloroplast ATPase in the oxidized state of its gamma disulfide bridge was studied as a function of the ADP concentration, delta pH, and external pH values, under conditions where delta pH was clamped and delocalized. At a given pH, the rate of phosphorylation at saturating ADP concentration (Vmax) and the Michaelis constant Km (ADP) depend strictly on delta pH, irrespective of the way the delta pH is generated: there evidently is no specific interaction between the redox carriers and the ATPase. It was also shown that both Km (ADP) and Vmax depend on delta pH, not on the external or internal pH. This suggests that internal proton binding and external proton release are concerted, so that net proton translocation is an elementary step of the phosphorylation process. These results appear to be consistent with a modified "proton substrate" model, provided the delta G0 of the condensation reaction within the catalytic site is low. At least one additional assumption, such as a shift in the pK of bound phosphate or the existence of an additional group transferring protons from or to reactants, is nevertheless required to account for the strict delta pH dependence of the rate of ATP synthesis. A purely "conformational" model, chemically less explicit, only requires constraints on the pK's of the groups involved in proton translocation.

Integrated functioning of the chloroplast coupling factor.

This review is focused on some functional characteristics of the chloroplast coupling factor. The structure of the enzyme and the putative role of its subunits are recalled. An attempt is made to discriminate the driving force and the activator effects of the electrochemical proton gradient. Respective roles of delta pH, delta phi, external and internal pH are discussed with regard to mechanistic implications. The hypothesis of a functional switch of the enzyme between two states with better efficiency either in ATP synthesis or in ATP hydrolysis is also examined. A brief survey is made on some problems complicating quantitative studies of energy coupling, such as localized chemiosmosis, delta pH and delta phi computations, and scalar ATPases. The main data on the enzyme activation and the energy-dependent release of tightly bound nucleotides are summarized. The arguments for and against the catalytic competence of theses nucleotides are reviewed. Lastly, some prevailing models of the catalytic mechanism are presented. The relevance of nucleotides binding change events in this process is discussed.

Measurement of chloroplast internal protons with 9-aminoacridine. Probe binding, dark proton gradient, and salt effects.

A defined ratio, gamma, of the total proton uptake to the concentration change of free internal H+ is observed for illuminated envelope-free chloroplasts (Haraux, F. and de Kouchkovsky, Y. (1979) Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 546, 455-471). Proton uptake is measured by the external pH shift, free internal H+ by 9-aminoacridine fluorescence quenching. Extension of this work leads to the following conclusions, which, in the case of 9-aminoacridine behaviour, should apply to any kind of diffusible protonizable delta pH probe: 1. The gamma constancy is preserved when the internal volume (Vi) is modulated by chlorophyll and osmolarity changes: thus, 9-aminoacridine behaves as expected from the delta pH distribution of an amine of high pK; previous doubts on this point are attributed to the lack of control of the external proton uptake. 2. With variable 9-aminoacridine concentration, however, some variation of gamma confirms the existence of slight light-induced probe-membrane interactions. 3. According to the diffuse layer theory, salts decrease the negative potential at the 'plane of closest approach' of the thylakoids, thereby releasing the excess 9-aminoacridine in this diffuse layer, which increases its fluorescence. Although of equal valency, NH4+ is more potent than K+, suggesting competition between amines for specific anionic binding sites. 4. Two categories of membrane modifications are induced by salts: in addition to the above-mentioned electrical effect, mono- and divalent cations at high concentration increase the chloroplast proton binding capacity. La3+ is only able to release the excess dye in the diffuse layer and leaves gamma unchanged. Therefore the probe-membrane interactions should have limited importance for steady-state delta pH measurement. 5. A Donnan-type dark pH difference, which could seriously bias these delta pH estimates, is found experimentally to be less than 2 (no significant gamma change when Vi varies) and even theoretically less than 1 (on the basis of the concentration of the non-diffusible internal protonizable groups). Similarly, the predictable errors of Vi and its possible light-induced variations must have a small effect on delta pH under present experimental conditions.

Quantitative estimation of the photosynthetic proton binding inside the thylakoids by correlating internal acidification to external alkalinisation and to oxygen evolution in chloroplasts.

The external alkalinisation delta pHe, or the rate of oxygen evolution vO2, of a suspension of envelope-free chlorplasts was correlated with their internal acidification, estimated from the transmembrane delta pHei. Knowing the external buffer value, the concentration of the total protons moved Hi was calculated from the delta pHe, measured with a glass electrode ([Hi] was also obtained from vO2), and the free proton concentration [Hi+] was determined from delta pHei, measured with 9-aminoacridine. This gives a ratio gamma i = theta [Hi]/theta [Hi+], which is independent of the thylakoids internal volume. Within a large pHi range, scanned by varying the light intensity, gamma i was kept reasonably constant; it was hardly sensitive to pHi. This apparent invariability implies a continuous change of the internal buffer value beta i with pHi, since beta i/gamma i = -2.3.....10pHi, a relationship which inlcudes neither the total concentration of protonizable groups [Ai] nor pKi. As gamma i approximately Ki[Ai]/(Ki + [Hi+i]2, to keep gamma i constant when pHi drops, pKi and [Ai] must increase. This may be achieved by a progressive unmasking of anionic functions, initially inaccessible in the membrane. The relative slowness of this process may explain why gamma i calculated from the initial kinetics was sometimes smaller in high than in low light, where it always equalled that measured from the steady-state amplitude at all intensities. A small deficit of [Hi+] deduced from what could have been expected from delta pHe may reflect a limited binding of protons in the membrane itself, about 1 H+ for 30--130 chlorophylls (gamma i could be between 70 and 240, more frequently around 100); these numbers varied depending on the samples, but were constant for a given preparation.