The effect of surface defects in early caries assessment using quantitative light-induced fluorescence (QLF) and micro-digital-photography (MDP).

OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to consider the impact of surface defects on quantitative light-induced fluorescence (QLF) and micro-digital-photography (MDP) measures, in relationship to lesion depth. METHODS: Simulated enamel carious lesions were developed on 45 extracted human teeth. Images of each tooth were captured with both QLF and MDP. The teeth were sectioned and lesion depth was measured with polarized light microscopy (PLM). Pearson correlations were computed using data from the 27 lesions which did not have surface loss, and then separately based upon the 18 lesions which did display surface loss. MDP variables ΔR and ΔX measure reflected light, whereas QLF variables ΔF and ΔQ measure fluorescence. RESULTS: A strong correlation was identified between lesion depth and ΔF (r=-0.765, p<0.0001), and ΔQ (r=-0.827, p<0.0001) on intact lesions while a weak but suggestive, although non-significant, correlation was identified between average lesion depth and ΔR (r=0.369, p=0.059) and ΔX (r=0.595, p=0.0011). However, the corresponding correlation was not statistically significant, when lesions with surface loss were considered for QLF and MDP measures. CONCLUSIONS: QLF measures ΔF and ΔQ were strongly correlated with lesion depth in lab-simulated lesions with no surface loss, but not among lesions with surface defects. The two MDP-associated measures, ΔR and ΔX, could not be said to differ significantly when lesions with and without surface defects were compared with lesion depth. Because intact lesions can be remineralized, accurate assessment of their status is imperative for caries treatment. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Dental caries is still widely prevalent today. We now know that with early stage detection, remineralization can be accomplished. Being able to identify dental caries in its reversible stage (before physical surface loss) is paramount for the clinician to be able to treat the disease non-invasively.

Effect of an alcohol-free, 1% chlorhexidine gel as an adjunct to a fluoridated dentifrice using an intraoral crown model.

BACKGROUND/AIMS: The use of chlorhexidine as a topically applied oral antiseptic is well documented; however, clinical studies examining the effects of chlorhexidine gel on in situ dental caries are limited. This study utilized an in situ caries model and a modified crossover design to examine whether the addition of a biweekly topical, alcohol-free, 1% chlorhexidine digluconate gel to a daily fluoridated dentifrice inhibited artificial caries in dental tissues better than the fluoridated dentifrice alone when compared to a nonfluoridated placebo dentifrice. METHODS: Thirty patients were recruited based on their need for a mandibular, full crown. Artificial caries lesions were created in extracted human teeth and enamel and root tissue sections 100 mum in thickness were characterized using polarized light microscopy. The sections were fixed in the crown and placed on the prepared tooth. The participants were assigned a placebo toothpaste, a toothpaste with 1,100 ppm F or a 1,100 ppm F toothpaste followed by 1 ml of 1% chlorhexidine gel at day 1 and day 14 (chlorhexidine+). Patients were instructed to brush twice daily for 4 weeks. Following each round, the sections in the crown were replaced with new sections. The sections were recharacterized and the mean changes were compared using ANOVA at alpha = 0.05. RESULTS: The chlorhexidine + Fdentifrice and the F dentifrice alone significantly reduced lesion area in enamel tissue when compared to the placebo dentifrice. Both treatments also inhibited lesion progression and initiation in root tissue better than control in this model system. Although the chlorhexidine+ group enhanced remineralization and inhibited lesion progression better than the F(-) dentifrice alone for all outcomes measured, the differences were not significant. CONCLUSIONS: The chlorhexidine, in conjunction with a fluoride dentifrice, was no more effective than the fluoride dentifrice alone. Further study is needed before this 1% alcohol-free chlorhexidine gel should be recommended as an adjunct to a fluoride dentifrice in the treatment of dental caries.

Effect of fluoridated milk on progression of root surface lesions in vitro under pH cycling conditions.

The aim of this study was to assess the effect of milk with 0, 2.5 or 5 ppm F on progression and remineralization of caries-like root surface lesions using a pH cycling model. The root surface lesions were created utilizing a partially saturated lactic acid buffer at pH 4.6. Longitudinal sections were cut through the lesion and analyzed using polarized light microscopy (PLM) and microradiography (MRG). The sections were then coated with an acid resistant varnish, except the outer natural surface that would be exposed to water, milk or fluoridated milk and cycled in a de- and remineralizing system for 2 weeks. The lesions were characterized again by PLM and MRG after treatment. A significant reduction in lesion progression was found by PLM and MRG after treatment with either non-fluoridated or fluoridated milk when compared to the control group. Using quantitative MRG, mineral change and distribution in the lesions were recorded. A possible protective effect of fluoridated milk on root surface caries was supported by a reduction in the progression of the lesions and an increase in the mineral within the lesion.

In situ evaluation of sodium hexametaphosphate-containing dentifrices.

The purpose of this investigator-blinded, five-treatment, crossover human intraoral study was to evaluate the effects of two experimental dentifrice formulations containing either stannous fluoride (SnF(2)) or sodium fluoride (NaF) packaged with sodium hexametaphosphate in a dual-phase delivery system on demineralization-remineralization using an in situ model system. The experimental dentifrice formulations' ability to alter demineralization-remineralization was compared to a series of three controls: SnF(2)-positive control, NaF-positive control and no-fluoride placebo-negative control. The single-section crown model, developed at the University of Iowa, was used to assess the fluoride efficacy of two experimental products versus the placebo containing no fluoride and positive controls. The results of the current in situ study suggest a clinical level of anticaries activity for the experimental SnF(2) and NaF dentifrice formulations that was as good as either of the positive controls, when evaluated using polarized light microscopy. This supports the conclusion that the use of the sodium hexametaphosphate ingredient does not interfere with the normal fluoride activity of these toothpastes. In addition, the experimental SnF(2) product was numerically better than both the NaF and placebo controls at preventing demineralization of sound root surfaces.

The use of saturated DCPD in remineralization of artificial caries lesions in vitro.

Dicalcium phosphate dihydrate (DCPD) may play a significant role in the caries lesion since it is a stable calcium phosphate phase under acidic conditions. The reaction of DCPD and fluoride, forming fluorapatite (FAP), may provide a potentially promising treatment regimen for remineralization of caries lesions in vivo. The purpose of this study was to determine whether a two-step DCPD and inorganic wash with fluoride can remineralize artificial caries-like lesions in vitro. We used the single-section technique to facilitate quantitation of the same tissue before and after the experimental regimen. The two-step remineralizing treatment was repeated three times and consisted of a two-minute saturated DCPD treatment (pH 2.1) followed by a 24-hour inorganic wash. Lesion parameters were recorded before and after treatment by the taking of polarized light photomicrographs of each section after imbibition in several media. The changes in the tissue following treatment were expressed as a percent change in the area of the initial pre-treatment lesion. Significant reductions (p < 0.02) in lesion pore volume were observed in all aqueous media examined. In the lesions after imbibition in quinoline, remineralization was also apparent from the significant increase in the area of the dark zone following treatment. This two-step DCPD treatment appears to remineralize artificial caries-like lesions effectively, but additional work is needed to determine whether it affords any protection against subsequent cariogenic challenges.

Development of an intra-oral single-section remineralization model.

An intra-oral model system has been developed which uses a single-section technique for before-and-after measurements on the same tissue. This model allows for placement of sections of enamel at both buccal and approximal sites. These sections may be sound or possess white-spot lesions. This allows for the evaluation of lesion initiation, lesion progression, and/or lesion remineralization. The sections are appropriate for measurement by polarized light microscopy, and, although not included in this study, they are also suitable for microradiographic evaluation. With ten human volunteers, the model system was evaluated by means of three rinse regimens in a cross-over design. The distilled water rinse showed the whole range of possible changes (e.g., demineralization, no change, and remineralization). More consistent remineralization was observed when a fluoride rinse or a remineralizing fluid was used. This model system should prove to be quite useful in evaluation of demineralization and remineralization phenomena in the oral environment.

Topical fluoride application and lesion progression in vitro.

The objectives of this investigation were to study the effects of topical fluoride application on white spot enamel and the effect that this application would have on a second acid exposure (lesion progression). Artificial white spot lesions of approximately 200 micron were created with an acidified gel technique, central control sections were removed, and the remaining tooth halves were randomly paired, with one half serving as an untreated control while the other received a single four-minute application of 1.23% (w/v) fluoride solution of either NH4F, Na2SnF6, APF, or TiF4. Both tooth halves were sectioned following progression and examined with polarized light microscopy. Lesion depth, internal pore volume, and presence, size and shape of dark zones were determined. The considerable variation among progressed lesions revealed no significant benefit from any topical fluoride treatment.

Comparison of artificial white spots by microradiography and polarized light microscopy.

This work compared lesions produced by three artificial caries systems with natural white spot lesions using both polarized light microscopy and microradiography. The three systems employed were the acidified gelatin gel, diphosphonate surface dissolution inhibitor, and a partially saturated buffer system. When we compared the natural white spot lesions with the artificial caries-like lesions, we found that the acidified gel system reproduced the classical histological zones most frequently. All systems showed a radiopaque surface layer overlying a radiolucent body of the lesion. This radiopaque layer could not be equated with the negatively birefringent surface zone seen in polarized light.