Differential effects of Notch ligands Delta-1 and Jagged-1 in human lymphoid differentiation.

Notch signaling is known to differentially affect the development of lymphoid B and T cell lineages, but it remains unclear whether such effects are specifically dependent on distinct Notch ligands. Using a cell coculture assay we observed that the Notch ligand Delta-1 completely inhibits the differentiation of human hematopoietic progenitors into the B cell lineage while promoting the emergence of cells with a phenotype of T cell/natural killer (NK) precursors. In contrast, Jagged-1 did not disturb either B or T cell/NK development. Furthermore, cells cultured in the presence of either Delta-1 or Jagged-1 can acquire a phenotype of NK cells, and Delta-1, but not Jagged-1, permits the emergence of a de novo cell population coexpressing CD4 and CD8. Our results thus indicate that distinct Notch ligands can mediate differential effects of Notch signaling and provide a useful system to further address cell-fate decision processes in lymphopoiesis.

Individual variations in the murine T cell response to a specific peptide reflect variability in naive repertoires.

Previous studies have analyzed the diversity of T cell responses upon immunization. Little is known, however, about the individual variability of naive repertoires and its influence on immune responses. In the present study, T cells specific for a Kd-restricted epitope derived from HLA-A2 were purified from individual immunized mice using tetramers of MHC-peptide. Their TCRbeta chains were sequenced revealing strong biases but large variations in BJ usage and clonal composition. Most importantly, sequence analysis from nonimmunized mice demonstrated the preexistence of a small set of splenic precursors, distinct in each mouse and comprising less than 200 cells. Therefore, differences in precursor pools appear to be the major source of individual variability in antigen-selected repertoires.

Functional diversity and clonal frequencies of reactivity in the available antibody repertoire.

The present experiments address functional antibody diversity and clonal distribution in murine available repertoires. IgM-containing supernatants were prepared by unbiased, polyclonal stimulation of resting splenic B cells from C57BL/6 mice, to ensure similar numbers of responding clones/culture and equivalent growth and maturation of all clones. The repertoires of clones and clonal mixtures were quantitatively assayed by limiting dilution analysis (LDA) on immunoblots of sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of homologous liver extracts, allowing to determine specific clonal frequencies towards the many hundred blotted antigens. The clonal frequency of reactivity of B cells with the extract was shown to be a bi-modal distribution of specific frequencies between 1/220 and 1/100,000. Cross-correlation analysis of reactivity to different bands in individual supernatants revealed low levels of cross-reactivity, suggesting that the blotted extract provides a very diverse set of antigens. Investigation of the affinity/concentration thresholds for detection of antigen-antibody interactions of our assay supports the notion that global repertoire analyses on immunoblots were highly discriminative and non-degenerate. Furthermore, reactivity patterns obtained with complex antibody mixtures correlated with the frequency of clonal reactivities as determined by LDA. The results demonstrate a large functional diversity of resting B lymphocytes, indicating a minimal repertoire size that is orders of magnitude higher than previous theoretical proposals suggested, and extensively heterogeneous in the size of clonal specificities.

Genetic control of natural antibody repertoires: I. IgH, MHC and TCR beta loci.

Global analysis of natural antibody repertoires has revealed a marked conservation of reactivity patterns within inbred mouse strains, and characteristic strain-specific differences. We have now analyzed the genetic control of reactivity repertoires, aiming at identifying the respective selection mechanisms. Multiparametric statistics of a large number of serum antibody reactivities scored by quantitative Western blot analyses using extracts from homologous tissues and bacteria readily distinguish the reactivity patterns of C57BL/6 and BALB/c, revealing homogeneity among genetically identical individuals. Antibody repertoires in the prototype strains can also be segregated from those expressed by the respective IgH congenics, BC.8 and CB.20, demonstrating that IgH-linked genes contribute to determining natural antibody repertoires. Conversely, strains sharing IgH haplotype also express distinct reactivity patterns, indicating that other genes participate in the selection of serum IgM repertoires. Two such non-IgH loci were now identified. Thus, analysis of four MHC-congenic strains demonstrated that MHC-linked control of natural antibody repertoires is likely to operate through differential selection of T cell repertoires, since (1) mice that are congenic at the TCR beta locus, and (2) BALB/c nude mice grafted at birth with pure thymic epithelium from either C57BL/6 or BALB/c also differ in their natural antibody repertoires.

Regulation of B lymphocyte development by the truncated immunoglobulin heavy chain protein Dmu.

The development of B lymphocytes from progenitor cells is dependent on the expression of a pre-B cell-specific receptor made up by a mu heavy chain associated with the surrogate light chains, immunoglobulin (Ig)alpha, and Igbeta. A variant pre-B cell receptor can be formed in which the mu heavy chain is exchanged for a truncated mu chain denoted Dmu. To investigate the role of this receptor in the development of B cells, we have generated transgenic mice that express the Dmu protein in cells of the B lineage. Analysis of these mice reveal that Dmu expression leads to a partial block in B cell development at the early pre-B cell stage, probably by inhibiting VH to DHJH rearrangement. Furthermore, we provide evidence that Dmu induces VL to JL rearrangements.

The repertoire of serum IgM in normal mice is largely independent of external antigenic contact.

Antigen-free (AGF) and germ-free (GF) mice, although essentially free of serum IgG, maintain normal levels of circulating IgM. Using a quantitative immunoblot assay, we have now analyzed the repertoire of serum IgM from AGF, GF, and specific pathogen-free (SPF) BALB/c mice, on large panels of natural antigens from homologous tissues and bacteria. The reactivity profiles were very similar in the three groups of mice. Multiparametric statistic evaluation of the data showed that BALB/c animals, SPF, GF, and AGF mice constitute an homogeneous group with similar immunoreactivity profiles when compared to C57BL/6. Differences between immunoreactivity profiles of GF and AGF mice were observed, but were not statistically significant. These results suggest that the serum IgM repertoire of normal mice is strictly regulated and selected by endogenous ligands.

Characteristic generated alterations of autoantibody patterns in idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura.

Using a Western blot technique that allows quantitative detection of antibody reactivities to a large number of antigens, serum IgG and IgM antibody repertoires were compared in a group of 19 patients with a diagnosis of idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP) and respective healthy controls. The results show that, irrespective of the duration of thrombocytopenia, age of the patients, and type of therapy, all ITP donors share characteristic alterations of serum antibody reactivity patterns on homologous erythrocyte and liver antigens. Multiparametric analyses of the immunoreactivity data readily segregated the groups of ITP and healthy donors. Similar analyses also distinguished ITP sera from those of a group of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). We conclude that ITP is an autoimmune disease associated with generalized alterations of antibody repertoires, that may be characteristic enough to allow for diagnosis.

Instability of natural antibody repertoires in systemic lupus erythematosus patients, revealed by multiparametric analysis of serum antibody reactivities.

Recent views on autoimmune diseases invoke generalized but specific perturbations in antibody repertoires, rather than the clonally restricted or non-specific polyclonal alterations proposed thus far. The present experiments analyse serum antibody reactivities in 24 systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients and 17 healthy controls, using a method that quantitatively scores a large number of antibody reactivities and allows for multiparametric statistical analyses. The results show global but relatively specific perturbations in SLE antibody repertoires, and identify novel disease-associated reactivity patterns. Furthermore, a time series analysis of serum antibodies over 3 months demonstrates instability of natural antibody repertoires in individual SLE patients, contrasting with their remarkable conservation in healthy donors. Moreover, the method used clusters controls and patients independently, and might prove of diagnostic value, once large data bases are established.

The age-associated increase in autoreactive immunoglobulins reflects a quantitative increase in specificities detectable at lower concentrations in young mice.

Serum immunoglobulins reactive with several autoantigens have been reported to increase with age. The authors have studied the reactivity of serum immunoglobulins from mice between 2 and 24 months of age with antigens present in lysates of syngeneic tissue extracts from young mice. The profile of immunoglobulin binding with the immunoblots of spleen and brain tissue increased progressively with age, showing only minor differences from mouse to mouse and, with one exception, revealing that the age-associated increase in binding of immunoglobulins occurred with antigens with the same migratory position in the immunoblots detectable, at lower concentration, in sera from young mice. Not all sera from older mice had increased immunoglobulin binding when tested with extracts of skin, muscle and liver but those that did expressed increased binding with antigens in all three lysates and with the same profile shown by sera from young mice. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the age-associated increase in autoreactive immunoglobulins represents a selective increase in autoreactive specificities expressed by serum immunoglobulins from young animals at lower levels.

Analysis of the normal human IgG antibody repertoire. Evidence that IgG autoantibodies of healthy adults recognize a limited and conserved set of protein antigens in homologous tissues.

We have used a quantitative immunoblot technique to analyze the Ab repertoire of IgG in the serum of healthy adults with a large panel of homologous and foreign Ags in tissue extracts. Densitometric patterns of reactivity of purified IgG with self-Ags exhibited striking homogeneity among individuals with regard to the protein bands that were recognized. Purified IgG showed higher levels of reactivity with self-Ags than IgG in whole serum. Reactivity with self-Ags of IgG in whole serum was restricted to a small number of protein bands (fewer than 10). There were significant inter-individual differences in the intensity and nature of immunoreactivities. Purified IgG of different individuals exhibited heterogeneous patterns of immunoreactivity with Ags in bacterial extracts. Comparative analysis of repertoires of IgG and IgM indicated that all protein Ags recognized by IgM were also reactive with purified IgG. Some proteins in homologous and in foreign tissue extracts reacted solely with IgG. Our observations provide direct evidence for the restricted and conserved character of the antiself-repertoire of IgG of healthy adults and suggest that natural IgG Ab repertoires in serum are specifically selected for reactivity with a limited set of self-Ags. In addition, IgG autoreactivity in whole serum is controlled by non-IgG factors that determine the unique reactivity pattern of each individual.

Analysis of natural and disease-associated autoantibody repertoires: anti-endothelial cell IgG autoantibody activity in the serum of healthy individuals and patients with systemic lupus erythematosus.

The present study demonstrates that natural IgG with anti-endothelial cell activity is present in the serum of healthy individuals and in pooled normal human Ig. By using a novel method that allows for the simultaneous and quantitative assessment of reactivities of antibodies with a large number of antigens in tissues, we observed that natural anti-endothelial cell antibody (AECA) recognizes a restricted set of self antigens in endothelial cells that is conserved among healthy individuals. The extent to which natural AECA activity is expressed in serum and the pattern of reactivity of AECA with endothelial cell antigens showed little variability between individuals. Analysis of AECA in the serum of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) revealed a higher amount of activity and a wider spectrum of antigenic specificities than that recognized by natural antibodies in endothelial cell extracts. AECA activity of IgG in whole serum was lower than that of purified IgG in the case of healthy individuals and showed little variation among individuals. In contrast, no difference was found between AECA activity of purified IgG and that of IgG in patients' serum suggesting that SLE sera lack the factors that control expression of AECA activity in the serum of healthy individuals. Our results indicate that natural autoantibodies recognize a restricted and conserved set of self antigens. Our observations further suggest that defective regulation of the expressed autoreactive B cell repertoire is the basis for expansion of novel clonal specificities and enhanced autoantibody activity in serum of patients with autoimmune disease.

Selectivity of recognition of variable (V) regions of autoantibodies by intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg).

In the present study, we demonstrate that intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) is capable of binding to variable (V) regions of anti-endothelial cell antibodies (AECA) of healthy donors and patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Among V regions of AECAs, IVIg selectively recognized certain idiotypes expressed by the autoantibodies of a given individual, in the case of both natural and SLE-associated AECAs. These observations provide new and direct evidence that IVIg interacts idiotypically with V regions of autoantibodies and that the efficacy of such interaction depends on individual autoantibody specificity. Our findings may be relevant for the understanding of the mechanisms that control expression of natural autoantibody activity in serum and for that of the differences in response to IVIg therapy that are seen between patients with autoimmune disease.

Global analysis of antibody repertoires. 1. An immunoblot method for the quantitative screening of a large number of reactivities.

This paper describes a procedure for analysing multiple antibody reactivities that explores a commercially available immunoblot system, and is based on a double staining of nitrocellulose membranes, revealing both antibody reactivities and the migration position of the blotted proteins in the membrane. Quantification of both stainings by densitometry allowed the accurate superposition of the immunoreactivity and total protein profiles of each lane. Moreover, the protein stainings of the different lanes could be adjusted with a simple-scale transformation algorithm, correcting for possible distortions during electrophoretic migration, and allowing for the precise comparison of the immunoreactivity profiles in different lanes. The procedure is discriminatory enough to identify unique reactivity patterns in random pools of 10(4) activated B cells, and to define strain-specific natural antibody repertoires. The utility of this immunoblot method as an assay for simultaneously scoring multiple reactivities to hundreds of antigens in complex mixtures of antibodies, and thus defining antibody repertoires in a global manner, is discussed.

Signaling of programmed cell death induction in WEHI-231 B lymphoma cells.

The murine WEHI-231 B lymphoma is highly sensitive to membrane immunoglobulin ligation which leads to programmed cell death (PCD) in this cell line. To study the molecular pathways involved in PCD induction in these cells, we derived two variants of WEHI-231 resistant to anti-Ig treatment. The level of bcl-2 mRNA was identical in the wild type and the variants, either untreated or anti-Ig treated, suggesting that PCD is not under the control of bcl-2 in WEHI-231 cells. In contrast, c-myc gene expression was markedly different in the wild type and the variants, both in the unstimulated and anti-Ig-stimulated state. Our findings are interpreted in the context of the dual capacity of c-myc to promote cell growth or cell death, in conjunction with other growth regulatory signals.

Global analysis of antibody repertoires. II. Evidence for specificity, self-selection and the immunological "homunculus" of antibodies in normal serum.

The serum IgM repertoires of C57BL/6, DBA/2 and BALB/c mouse strains were analyzed using a recently developed global and quantitative assay that measures antibody reactivities to a very large number of antigens. A characteristic repertoire could be assigned to each strain. The different repertoires could be successfully classified with multivariate statistics. Many common reactivities were also observed among the different strains, which allows the definition of a mouse-specific repertoire. Analysis of human sera support this notion. To investigate the impact of minor genetic differences on the serum IgM repertoire, the congenic strains B10.D2/oSn and B10.D2/nSn, which differ in the expression of the C5 component of complement, were analyzed. The two strains could be separated based on the reactivity profiles obtained. The analysis of the results reveals that many antigenic proteins are not recognized at all by natural antibodies, while others are disproportionately reactive, the resulting patterns giving rise to what could be the definition of an "immunological homunculus". The relevance of this type of analysis for clinical applications is discussed.

The physiology of bcl-2 expression in murine B lymphocytes.

Quantitation of bcl-2 gene expression in B-lineage lymphocytes from normal adult mice allows the identification of four cell populations, characterized by successive three- to fivefold increases in average mRNA levels: bone marrow pre-B cells, bone marrow B cells, splenic B cells and long-lived splenic B cells. Thus, in line with previous experiments using overexpression systems, a correlation between longevity and levels of bcl-2 mRNA exists also in the physiology of B-lineage cells. The data are compatible with a quantitative regulation of expression, possibly determined at selective differentiation steps. No difference in bcl-2 expression was detected by comparing splenic IgD+ with IgD- B cells, while distinctly low levels of bcl-2 mRNA were scored in peritoneal CD5+ and CD5- B cells. These observations indicate that the reported persistence of peritoneal B cells may be controlled by mechanisms other than bcl-2 gene expression.

Intestinal T lymphocytes in the chicken express an integrin-like antigen.

We report the characterization of a molecule recognized on chicken T cells by the murine A19 monoclonal antibody that was generated by immunization with intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes. Immunofluorescence analysis indicated that both alpha beta and gamma delta T cell subpopulations in the intestine express the A19 antigen, but natural killer cells and B cells do not. The A19-marked T cells were preferentially localized in the intestinal epithelium and less frequently in the underlying lamina propria. T cells appearing in the intestine during embryonic life were A19 negative but acquired the antigen within the first few days after hatching. Although rarely found on cells in non-intestinal tissues at any age, very late expression of the A19 antigen could be induced by concanavalin A stimulation of splenic and circulating T cells. Transforming growth factor beta 1 enhanced this induction of A19 expression. The A19 molecules expressed by intestinal T cells and activated splenic T cells were biochemically identical, consisting of a multi-molecular complex of proteins with approximate M(r) of 205, 145 and 75 kDa under nonreducing conditions and 120, 90 and 28 kDa under reducing conditions. The characteristics of this multimolecular complex and its differential expression suggest that the A19 antigen is a member of the integrin family which may function in the retention of intestinal lymphocytes.